Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider driving kids 120 miles (3 hours) round trip mom-fri for a year?

137 replies

Helpmegetajob · 28/02/2023 17:53

We are hopefully moving to a new place in the next couple of months but year 5 DS really wants to finish primary at his current school. This would mean doing this journey each week day for 9 months until July 24 …So …

yes you are being unreasonable to keep his current schools and commute

no you are not being unreasonable to keep his current school.

any ideas on if the school would object?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedChooChoo · 01/03/2023 10:06

I wouldn't. We moved a few weeks ago and DS wanted to finish the year at his current school. So we have been doing the 50 mile round trip twice a day. It's meant to be 37 minutes each way, but sometimes takes an hour or more in the morning. It's a killer and we have a visit with the local school today because it's just not sustainable.

You'd literally be spending half your day taking them to and from school. I'd think very carefully about what the reality would actually be like.

Couldyounot · 01/03/2023 10:03

I did a 140-mile round trip commute for work about 15 months just over a decade ago, coastal West Sussex to Berkshire, mostly A-roads. It was pretty hard on the car - fuel £500+ a month, servicing and tyres needed more often because of the mileage - and that's before taking into account just how exhausting it was spending 3-4 hours a day behind a steering wheel. I wouldn't recommend it at all.

MarshaBradyo · 01/03/2023 09:55

Move..

MarshaBradyo · 01/03/2023 09:55

No I’d love him

mindutopia · 01/03/2023 09:52

No, I wouldn't do it. Mine moved to a new school around the same age (and same distance from old house) and she absolutely loves the new school, settled so easily, etc. It will be such an advantage to him to start to make local friends and go into secondary having some mates, even if it's only 1 or 2 who end up at the same school with him.

TangledUpInDreams · 01/03/2023 09:49

(A good way to avoid a promise is to say ‘I will do everything I can to make sure X, Y or Z happens - or doesn’t happen - but it might not be possible.’ That is the truth.)

TangledUpInDreams · 01/03/2023 09:42

Stay strong. It’s really, really hard to see your children sad/distressed. A lot of it will be anxiety at the prospect of change. But he will be okay. It’s very important that as the adult, you make grown-up decisions and then fix it for your child to be as comfortable with and secure within those changes as possible.

Do what’s most right for everyone all round, which is to make a clean break, get settled in your new place, and embrace the future; lead and guide him to feeling strong and being resilient.

I agree with pp - you sound like a fantastic mother. He will be okay.

Lesson for the future: don’t make promises to your children that you cannot possibly know you can keep.

MisgenderedSwan · 01/03/2023 09:33

My dd has just moved for y6 and is loving her new school. In some of the holidays we have met old friends from her old school and she has loved those days. She also made some great new friends who she enjoys after school play dates and clubs with and they are going to the same secondary school on the same bus as her. She has the best of both worlds.

You're making far too big a deal of this with him. Moving is always scary but also exciting. Take some weekend trips to scope out the new area, look into scouts for him maybe? And maybe get on the wait list for a club he would enjoy. 120 miles a day in snow/rain/gales/dark is frankly not a risk I would be taking with my children just so they didn't have to make new friends.

BeachBlondey · 01/03/2023 09:22

I did something similar, when a house came up for sale in a different town. My kids were in High School, and the youngest had 3 more years to do. The house was much nearer to my DH work, and I was WFH, but the biggest thing was that it was a house right on the seafront - the kind of which is rarely available. We did go for it, and I kept them in their old High School, and just took the commute on the chin for 3 years (it was a 60 minute round trip, twice a day).

It was a royal pain in the hoop, but it was worth it to get our dream home. This was 10 years ago - the kids are now grown up, and have left home. And in the last 10 years, nothing similar has come on to the market. It wasn't easy though at the time. Had plenty of days stuck in traffic jams and we had to leave really early to get to school on time. Also, it was very hard for the kids to socialise outside of school when they lived in a different town. We just tried our best, but felt like I was always in the bloody car, because I didn't want them to miss things! I spent a fortune on petrol!

With all of that said, re your son, I would have thought that he would be better moving schools now, so that when he moves up to High School he knows a lot of the other kids.

FiveGoMadInDorset · 01/03/2023 08:34

it is so much easier transitioning to secondary school when you have friends, you really can’t do this to yourself, him and your youngest

Seeline · 01/03/2023 08:31

If you've got the house now, I'd move them after Easter. They've got a whole term to get to know new classmates. You can work on establishing new friendships over the Summer holidays. Your eldest will start Y6 at least knowing his classmates and by the end of the year will be able to finish the primary years with friends. He will also go to secondary at least knowing some other students. They can also both join in with activities outside of their new school and get to know other local children that way.

BaroldFromEastenders · 01/03/2023 07:49

I moved to a new area for the start of secondary and knew nobody - it was really hard to make friends. You need to present this as an adventure and move him as soon as possible. Be matter of fact about it and don’t indulge the crying for too long. You might have promised he could finish y6 which was quite a silly thing to do but things change in life and it’ll do wonders for his resilience.

kljk78 · 01/03/2023 07:45

No he's better off moving to the new primary so he hopefully makes friends that'll go to secondary with him??

Quitelikeacatslife · 01/03/2023 07:26

At this age they can be really sentimental about school and home. Please now you've told him get him involved in the move, and focus on positives of new school, go look round (assuming you have one?( get stories of people who went to new school. And put your energy into setting him in instead of clinging on when he will have to go through that anyway later.

MamOfFive · 01/03/2023 07:11

I moved before starting year seven and knew nobody it was horrific. I'd of preferred to have moved for year six and gotten to know kids.

That said 1.5 hours school run is ridiculous, you'd be paying £100s out in petrol not to mention how shattered you'd be.

LlynTegid · 01/03/2023 07:11

I might consider it were it A level year, maybe GCSE, but not for year 5.

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 01/03/2023 07:08

I did it with my child for a term when we moved 20 miles away so he could finish infant school. And it nearly killed me. The petrol costs alone were astronomical and I was working at the time and trying to fit in school runs, work and my other child going to nursery. Honestly I wouldn't.

rainbowstardrops · 01/03/2023 07:07

Absolute madness! It's just simply not practical.

Like other posters have said, what about hours of driving in filthy winter weather, or traffic jams, car issues, environmental issues etc etc etc?

Also, you're toying with the idea of staying in old area M-F and coming back for the weekend but what about your other child?

Is the new house worth all this?

If the new house is worth all this palaver then you need to step up and be a parent and tell your son it's unavoidable that he moves.

I can't believe you only told him about the move. He's going to have a double whammy now!

Funkyblues101 · 01/03/2023 06:46

Helpmegetajob · 28/02/2023 18:24

Yes I’ve deducted the holidays as we would be at home and not travelling.

my sense is that they won’t really know anyone at secondary hence my thoughts about starting fresh in year 7

other dc is 5 so reception and I’m less worried about them moving as they seem fine with it

Your child won't have any friends in your new area to play with during the holidays...

Bellavida99 · 01/03/2023 06:42

I couldn’t do it. I’m thinking of winter icy mornings when it takes me 40 minutes to clear car and do 3 mile school run. Switch now. Short term pain for long term gain. He’ll be fine and at least can do after school clubs and matches and have school friends over

Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 01/03/2023 06:29

Sorry but this is a ridiculous idea. It’s actually quite baffling. You’d be letting a 9 year old dictate your entire families lives for over a year. And he thinks it’s what he wants but what about when he gets to secondary and knows no one and then is annoyed about it !

BackT · 01/03/2023 06:26

Far far worse to start secondary not knowing anyone than to move now.

I'd move him straight away with the "promise" to make sure that he gets a lift to see his current friends regularly at weekends and in holidays.

I'd probably sweeten the deal with something he really wants. You shouldn't have promised and now you have to make that good. I know bribery is bad etc etc but think of something her really wants and add that.

"As you are being so grown up about this, we'll bring forward getting you an... iPhone/Xbox/new bike/puppy etc etc"

Squidlydoo · 01/03/2023 06:22

have you considered where there are places for both primary and secondary and whether you would get in?
parents often assume they can move and get into their first choices but often this is not the case as a huge number of schools are over subscribed.

for me this would be the bigger factor. And yes I would look to move now so your child can establish themself before secondary.

you are delaying the inevitable by postponing but please be aware that finding a school may be more challenging that you anticipate

Alaimo · 01/03/2023 06:20

No. Your son might think going to his old school will mean life continue as normal, but it won't. He won't be able to play with other kids after school or weekends, so his existing friendships will probably be negatively affected. At the same time he won't be able to start forming friendships in his new place, because he's barely there. It really is the worst of both worlds.

bluechameleon · 01/03/2023 06:20

I moved school at the Easter of what is now Y5. I didn't enjoy the rest of primary school as much as I would have done but it was OK. I'm sure it was better starting school with some familiar people, even if they weren't lifetime best friends.