Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is zero benefit to telling people who are lonely that this is bad for their health

71 replies

salutsandy · 28/02/2023 13:52

Just heard a smug thing on the radio about how having no social contacts is the worst thing for your health. I've heard this before but it made me think, what if you're listening to that and you are lonely, what on earth is the point of this? A lot of people who are lonely do try to make friends, there are often threads about this on MN.

OP posts:
TennisWithDeborah · 28/02/2023 15:19

Good point above about the importance of “weak ties”. Nigella Lawson wrote about this topic during lockdown. It’s behind a paywall unfortunately but here is the link :

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/nigella-lawson-makes-a-strong-case-for-weak-ties-vlszg3mpv

tattygrl · 28/02/2023 15:12

I think people are taking the 3am thing literally. It's obviously meant to be an expression of, if you had an inconvenient yet personally urgent situation, do you have someone in your life who you're close enough with to contact and get help/love/care from. Sometimes that might be ringing at 3am with an emergency or turmoil in extremis, other times it might be "I'm stranded in a strange city, who can I turn to, even just for comfort and empathy?".

Also I think, knowledge is power. Scaremongering is one thing, and I don't agree with that - headlines like "loneliness takes years off your life" or whatever. That's just shaming and scary, unnecessarily. However, the knowledge that social connections, sense of community (and that can look different for different people), a the knowledge that people are watching out for you even in just a basic sense, all are so beneficial to humans that they enhance our health and prolong our lives, is a good thing. It's a fact, and people can be empowered by knowing these things. Problem is there's not the resources out there for many people affected by loneliness.

megletthesecond · 28/02/2023 15:09

I don't have anyone to call at 3am. If I didn't work and have a child with MH issues I'd have time for a support network.

gogohmm · 28/02/2023 15:09

I suppose my mum would not mind me calling at 3am but it would need to be a lot more than upset and/or worried - we are talking someone is in resuscitation or dead. But what can anyone do at 3am? Very little, even in a life threatening situation I would wait until 8am to bother her.

weaseleyes · 28/02/2023 15:08

I don't know the specifics of this study, but most studies of loneliness use scales which distinguish between isolation (seeing no one) and loneliness (perceived deficit in the quality of one's relationships). So yes, it's possible to be isolated but not lonely or surrounded by people and lonely. It's the perception of loneliness that is usually seen as detrimental to health. Most studies find a mix of situational loneliness, which comes about through difficult circumstance such as bereavement, and a more chronic loneliness, which may spring from difficulties forming/sustaining relationships over a long period of time.

And I think the 3am thing is that sense that you know you could ring someone, not that you actually would!

I agree it must be hard to hear these findings if you are lonely, but it's perhaps a good message to others who may be dismissive if they don't experience loneliness themselves.

Hollyhocksandlarkspur · 28/02/2023 15:08

Great thread OP. The report on radio 4 I heard today was maybe connected. A longitudinal study in US has followed two cohorts for decades and found that the main predictors of health and happiness were not economic (the two groups were privileged/poorer) but good relationships and feeling belonging. The interviewee also emphasised the good effect of weak social relationships as PP mentioned (postie, neighbours, people on commute).

There was a fantastic interview in another R4 prog this morning (one to one I think) with a woman who grew up on Park Estate, Sheffield (council) where sense of community and belonging was amazing and moved to another so called nicer area where lots of neighbour rows and fighting. Instead of moaning she started getting kids together to mend bikes, cooked them all chips and do community stuff together weekly. She was an inspiration.

salutsandy · 28/02/2023 15:06

If you are not prepared to be someone someone calls in an emergency then don't be surprised when you have no one you can call in an emergency

Again it depends on circumstances. Some people will have a car, some people will be single parents, some people are disabled and can't physically help. It's one thing to meet people and try to enlarge friendship groups, but those kind of very close ties, outside of family, are likely to take decades to build up I'd have thought?

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 28/02/2023 15:04

Cornelious2011 · 28/02/2023 14:21

If someone is motivated then (with some exceptions) people can create networks of support/ friends. It isn't always easy and you have to put the effort in, but it's rarely impossible. It's sad to think that people think there are no options- neighbours, family, work colleagues, support groups, baby groups, hobbies, church etc. Friends don't become friends overnight. It takes time.

The 3am thing though- my phones on silent at night so I wouldn't hear a call even if someone wanted me.

And they need to be reasonable. To develop a wide variety of contacts, and not expect the exclusive attention of one person/family.

It's as much about quantity as quality. If you need a favour every week, then you need a few people to share it about.

It helps if you are prepared to go the extra mile for someone else, too.

LaurieFairyCake · 28/02/2023 14:58

I don't have my phone on at 3am and no landline

Nor would I EVER call anyone at that time

What a load of SHASH

Ragwort · 28/02/2023 14:54

That's such an important point pickle it is vital that couples maintain independent friendships and their own hobbies etc. My DM was recently widowed after 60 years of marriage... of course she is sad but she already had a wide circle of her 'own' friends and she is getting out and about with her hobbies, meeting friends and making new ones.
I've been married myself over 30 years but I wouldn't say my DH is my 'best' friend and neither would he say that about me. We have our own, separate friends and don't live in each other's pockets.

FourTeaFallOut · 28/02/2023 14:53

I think it's an important public message. It's something that people should include when weighing up the pros and cons of moving out of an area for whatever reason or 'going low contact's for trivial umbrages or when deciding how to spend their spare time. Family and friendship groups are an important part of our wellbeing but they are often treated as disposable 'nice to haves'.

Somebodiesmother · 28/02/2023 14:53

If you are not prepared to be someone someone calls in an emergency then don't be surprised when you have no one you can call in an emergency.

EdithWeston · 28/02/2023 14:53

I think YABU as it's a radio programme, so is speaking to all people (not just those who are lonely)

And it's worth knowing about. So perhaps when you're in good shape, you remember to stay in touch with people who might fade if you don't make an effort, or perhaps embolden someone who's beginning to miss events that they really need to stick with it, or encourage someone to volunteer for a service that provides befrienders, or perhaps it'll lodge in the mind of a policy-maker who will think about what services should be funded (keeping things like lunch clubs going, or funding the odd excursion)

Tinypetunia · 28/02/2023 14:52

Many lonely people are victims of their particular circumstances. People may have moved away or died, they may have small families, or simply lost touch with former friends.
I agree it's counter productive to tell lonely people that it's bad for their health. If they could do something about it, they would.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 28/02/2023 14:50

@TheYearOfSmallThings
and can I add - being alone is not the same thing as being lonely. Far too often they are classed as being the same. They are not. It is perfectly possible to be alone and happy/content. It’s also possible to be surrounded by lots of friends/acquaintances/colleagues/family and yet be totally ignored and become very lonely.

picklemewalnuts · 28/02/2023 14:49

It's helpful if it encourages people to prioritise social contact. Those couples who 'only need each other', the men who don't bother because their wife does then she dies.

The men who let the family women do all the work of staying in touch, until they die and there are only men left.

If it helps people prioritise the time and energy involved in building relationships, then it's helpful.

My mum is suddenly interested in friendships now her husband has died. She's clueless. Thinks her friends should do what she wants all the time.
But at least she's trying.

salutsandy · 28/02/2023 14:48

You can have lots of friends but still feel excruciatingly lonely. So do they actually mean alone? Or the emotional experience of feeling lonely?

Yes that's not clear either

Also, we get stuck in this idea that friends only count if they tick a bunch of boxes
Yes, there's a lot of confusion around expectations I think. Most people wouldn't phone their friends at 3am or the like.

OP posts:
Ragwort · 28/02/2023 14:47

Totally agree with Beatley. ... communities need people to engage with them and become part of the 'community' .. and that might involve stepping out of your comfort zone. And as another PP said, so many people on Mumsnet seem to love being in their 'little family' <boak>, refuse to answer the door, take in parcels for a neighbour etc etc .. so no wonder there is no sense of community and friendships formed. I felt sad for a recent poster who was trying to organise a street party for the Coronation but got lots of sneery comments.
FWIW I find it easy to make friends ... but I join things ... from helping to start up a Toddler and Baby group when we moved to a new village and knew no one, delivering meals on wheels, PTA, going to church, joining the WI, volunteering etc etc ... there are so many ways to meet people and make friends. The people I meet who say 'they don't have friends' just don't seem to be prepared to make the effort and only want a friendship on their terms or to meet clones of themselves.

salutsandy · 28/02/2023 14:45

I'm not saying there isn't a real effect, just that a person who has nobody they would call at 3am but eats well, exercises daily, has a fulfilling well paid job, rewarding hobbies and a spaniel probably isn't who they are really looking at

Yes. Also is it better to be in bad relationships than no relationships? I'm sure before I'd read that things like saying hello to people in the street counted, but today's thing was different and said it was close relationships. I think there could be class elements as well, and surely people who are single are generally less financially well off. Plus men on their own might be less likely to go to the doctors or take as good care of their health.

OP posts:
Strongboat · 28/02/2023 14:39

You can have lots of friends but still feel excruciatingly lonely. So do they actually mean alone? Or the emotional experience of feeling lonely?

SusiePevensie · 28/02/2023 14:34

Agreed. On the other hand, there is maybe value in telling people about the value of weak ties.

That saying hello to people you meet dogwalking, waving to neighbours when you see them on the stairwell or over the fence, smiling at the person who serves you coffee, 5 secs about the weather to the librarian, chatting with someone over a video game, all those tiny unnoticed interactions matter a lot.

Also, we get stuck in this idea that friends only count if they tick a bunch of boxes.

You have to be able to call them at 2am, they have to invite you to their birthday parties (God forbid they ask you to replace a mate who dropped out), there can't be any money involved (why shouldn't a hairdresser count her clients as friends?). It's stifling and stressful and makes it so much harder to reach out.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/02/2023 14:33

I always wonder how clean the research is on this. I imagine people who have poor physical or mental health will find it more difficult to be social, but also more difficult to exercise, quit smoking, earn a good salary etc. So the correlation is not straightforward, even before you take into account self assessment of social support (two people may perceive the same number and closeness of social contacts to be satisfactory or inadequate). And as someone above said, elderly people are not just dealing with loneliness but also grief and loss, which is a separate issue.

I'm not saying there isn't a real effect, just that a person who has nobody they would call at 3am but eats well, exercises daily, has a fulfilling well paid job, rewarding hobbies and a spaniel probably isn't who they are really looking at.

salutsandy · 28/02/2023 14:32

OP, I agree. Similarly, there is no point telling insomniacs that getting less than X hours sleep a night is bad for their health, because it's just one more worry to keep them awake at night

Yes! so true

OP posts:
BeetleyCarapace · 28/02/2023 14:30

Well the 3am aspect is obviously for dire emergencies, isn't it? I have one of those friends. If you're calling someone at 3am it's going to be because you're in trouble, or someone's been taken critically ill, or you're locked out of your house, or similar.

The thing about community and support is more interesting to me. I think a lot of people have got quite a dysfunctional idea of community. You see it a lot on the moving threads on here — people want to move locations 'for community'.

Community isn't a kind of on-demand social teat that people can latch themselves onto as soon as the final moving box has been collapsed. True community is as much about what you bring as it is about the other person/people.

It strikes me that many people expect community to be there for them, in the way they expect hot water to be there for them. Like package deals of ready-made friends that occur in certain areas. But they don't consider what they might bring to that community. It comes across as all take and no give. (I know it isn't always like that. But I do think it can be telling in terms of how people view friendship, social connections, and community.)

bringandby · 28/02/2023 14:29

OP, I agree. Similarly, there is no point telling insomniacs that getting less than X hours sleep a night is bad for their health, because it's just one more worry to keep them awake at night.

Swipe left for the next trending thread