Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quran School Incident

318 replies

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 13:05

The reaction to this non-incident is shameful. We're effectively charging this poor autistic boy with blasphemy and his mother is begging for his life.

OP posts:
potniatheron · 28/02/2023 15:53

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:35

Absolutely about black males yes.

i think rather than hypersexualised I meant sexually aggressive

But it is about Muslim men also, it was a feature of colonialism how sexual certain aspect of Muslim culture were and you can see it in how the western media presents discourses around Muslim men, they are often presented as sexual predators unable to help themselves and preying on white women.

Again, that's an imprecise characterisation. The Islamophobic trope is specifically that Muslim men prey sexually on white (usually female) children.

Interestingly this was an anti-Semitic, rather than Islamophobic, trope for many centuries and related to the so-called 'blood libel'. It probably reached its apogee in the UK in 1290 with the Edict of Expulsion. But one can still see traces of it in the characterisation of Fagin in Oliver Twist, which has marked peadophilic undertones.

Some Q-Anon types still occasionally try to breathe life into the old blood libel trope although now they characterise it in terms of Epstein and his 'party yacht'.

GyozaGuiting · 28/02/2023 15:52

The thing is, it’s just a book. The bible is just a book, the Quran is just a book. If you don’t believe what is written within it, it may be a fairytale for all you care.

The attachment humans place on the books is the issue. I say this as a Christian, who does read the bible.

theworldhas · 28/02/2023 15:50

That article is so biased. So four white boys brought the Quran as a dare into a West Yorkshire school that has Muslim kids and the Humanist is expecting us to believe they treated it respectfully?

yeah, I’ve know major bones with humanism as a creed (except for being so human centric which is a pretty irrational outlook for a belief system which prides itself on rationality above all else) - but I do however I find that some humanists are more of the anti religion crusader types of the Dawkins variety. They claim to espouse a live and let live philosophy but actually enjoy exaggerating the “crimes” of religious people and stirring shit up. Their beliefs are very different to the religious groups but the mentality is remarkably similar.

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:49

Well that’s true! @Lesschubtolove <cynical emoticon>

You cannot compel people to be respectful of religious texts “or else”. The “or else” is where the blasphemy laws come in, and our judiciary has long decided they are complete nonsense.

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:46

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:41

@Lesschubtolove I think that’s spectacularly naive tbh, human behaviour being the shitshow that it is!

What if that doesn’t work?

Then if it doesn’t work, it doesn’t work does it and idiots will always be idiots

Quveas · 28/02/2023 15:46

I just don't get why people get so angry , you cannot force others to respect and believe or you are imposing blasphemy laws.

I think that people are very confused and more than a little two faced here. I am not suggesting that there should be blasphemy laws, nor would I support them. I am not saying that people must respect what others believe or that they should be forced to believe it too. I DO believe that people should not show or act in deliberately disrespectful ways which is something entirely different. And that principle is established in law time and time again - in laws that say that there are consequences for being racist for example. We do, as a society, expect a certain standard of behaviour from the collective that enables us to "rub along" without a chaotic descent into everyone doing what the hell they want. But sometimes around here is seems that only applies to everyone else and not "us".

Serrassi · 28/02/2023 15:46

Isn’t it weird how someone can make a death threat against an autistic child and then pat themselves on the back for being moral.

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:41

@Lesschubtolove I think that’s spectacularly naive tbh, human behaviour being the shitshow that it is!

What if that doesn’t work?

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:40

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:29

@Lesschubtolove you think people should be prevented from destroying holy texts. How are you going to stop them?

Asking nicely probably won’t work.

I have no interest personally in defacing any books (maybe that shitrag the DM) but if someone else wants to, it’s nowt to do with me. Unless you’re going to “encourage” me otherwise, using the law.

it’s the obvious consequence of what you are advocating (and in fact the only way it will have any effect).

Well I’d hope we’d start with good education and interfaith dialogue and remove the want from people to denigrate things that matter to others.

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:38

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:28

You don't have to get upset about what others say if you have confidence and faith in your religion. You believe she married and consummated at 16 and 19 cool. Mary supposedly got pregnant with Jesus at 12 things were different at the time. People are always going to pick apart and debate religion that's human nature. A violent reaction and offense shows a lack of confidence in your faith.

I think it’s often quite complicated and the radicals have exploited that, exploited people feeling like they are being attacked and never fitting in into rallying people into defending, often aggressively ‘their way of life’ from what they feel is constant criticism.

often these people are actually not very well educated on their faith but they’ve been told xyz xyz and that they should do such and such, it’s why isis recruited people who were often ‘born again’ and had commit a lot of ‘sins’ prior to their new found religion

Justanotherlurker · 28/02/2023 15:36

Here is an interesting thread on the whole situation and follow up meetings

twitter.com/adrian_hilton/status/1629546651730706433

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:35

potniatheron · 28/02/2023 15:26

LOL what are you talking about? The trope of the hypersexual Black male can be almost wholly and precisely located within white supremacist narratives of the Antebellum and post Reconstruction Deep South.

It has never been applied to Muslims. It was applied to Ottomans and Ancient Persians to some extent, often by other non-Western peoples. And rooted in different tropes.

Modern Islamophobia is rooted in the 19th - 20th century European trope of 'Moslems' as being warlike, fanatical, and contemptuous of females. This in itself was drawn from myths and narratives around the so-called Crusades and the Ottoman Empire.

Islamophobia is a huge problem but let's be analytical in the way that we approach the problem please!

Absolutely about black males yes.

i think rather than hypersexualised I meant sexually aggressive

But it is about Muslim men also, it was a feature of colonialism how sexual certain aspect of Muslim culture were and you can see it in how the western media presents discourses around Muslim men, they are often presented as sexual predators unable to help themselves and preying on white women.

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:30

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 15:25

The Christian King Richard, in a comparable period of history had a 11 year concubine

And ? I don't worship King Richard , I don't worship anyone I'm now agnostic.

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:29

@Lesschubtolove you think people should be prevented from destroying holy texts. How are you going to stop them?

Asking nicely probably won’t work.

I have no interest personally in defacing any books (maybe that shitrag the DM) but if someone else wants to, it’s nowt to do with me. Unless you’re going to “encourage” me otherwise, using the law.

it’s the obvious consequence of what you are advocating (and in fact the only way it will have any effect).

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:28

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:21

But that’s actually a hugely debated issue, firstly there is a belief that she was 16 and 19 not 6 and 9

but regardless until the 20th century that has never been a point of contention of critics of Islam because it was so common place in communities of the time, it’s something in Arabic defined as ‘Urf a custom of the people. Christian and Jewish criticism of the time (7th c ad) never mentioned Aisha’s age or supposed age as it was common place in their community also. Puberty was a sign of readiness for marriage, whenever that occurred. The huge problem is when people directly transplant that onto the present day.

You don't have to get upset about what others say if you have confidence and faith in your religion. You believe she married and consummated at 16 and 19 cool. Mary supposedly got pregnant with Jesus at 12 things were different at the time. People are always going to pick apart and debate religion that's human nature. A violent reaction and offense shows a lack of confidence in your faith.

Toddlerteaplease · 28/02/2023 15:28

I went to a Catholic scuba's you should have seen what state the schools copies of the Bible were in.

potniatheron · 28/02/2023 15:26

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:05

Precisely, islamaphobia is intrinsically tied up with the fear of ‘the big scary (often hypersexual) brown man’. White Muslims are racialised as non White, i know this from my many many white Muslim friends, who have people congratulate them on how good their English is or grill them on where their parents are from’. Islam is viewed as a brown person/ Arab/ a religion of the Other. Islamaphobia is routed in racism and to pretend otherwise is well outrageous

LOL what are you talking about? The trope of the hypersexual Black male can be almost wholly and precisely located within white supremacist narratives of the Antebellum and post Reconstruction Deep South.

It has never been applied to Muslims. It was applied to Ottomans and Ancient Persians to some extent, often by other non-Western peoples. And rooted in different tropes.

Modern Islamophobia is rooted in the 19th - 20th century European trope of 'Moslems' as being warlike, fanatical, and contemptuous of females. This in itself was drawn from myths and narratives around the so-called Crusades and the Ottoman Empire.

Islamophobia is a huge problem but let's be analytical in the way that we approach the problem please!

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 15:25

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:16

But in some hadith it does say he married a 6 year old and consummated at 9. That's not false , If you feel confident in your beliefs and religion , you don't need to impose your views on others or send death threats.

The Christian King Richard, in a comparable period of history had a 11 year concubine

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:25

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:22

@Lesschubtolove it is genuinely challenging to apply a law according to people’s motivation - it’s subjective, lacks clarity and is ripe for abuse. All the things a law shouldn’t be.

The last person punished for blasphemy was (iirc) at the beginning of the last century. Why on earth would we want to reverse ferret and undo a century of far bigger brains than ours deciding it had no place in our society?

Lets accept that provocative little shits looking for a reaction will always be among us, but FGS let’s try and be proportionate as well!

question: who is bringing in blasphemy laws? Especially for a religion that isn’t this country’s state religion?

you get no Muslims really want this right?

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:25

Most cinemas refused to show The Life Of Brian when it was released because Christian groups threatened blockades

That is appalling. I was introduced to it by a Jewish friend, who laughed his head off at the scene when Brian explains why he can’t possibly be a Roman. I felt really uncomfortable watching it with him as a teen, I think that is (partially) the point.

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:23

Quveas · 28/02/2023 15:14

You see that's the issue. It's all made up - like your post! No Muslim child brought the Quran to school. A non-Muslim child was dared by three others to to bring it to school where they proceeded to treat it with disrespect. There is no evidence of any death threats and I doubt the police would consider it not worthy of attention if there were. It was not an accident. It was deliberate, and done by a group of four secondary aged children who damned well knew that they were treating someones holy book disrespectfully - because it wouldn't have been a "dare" if they didn't.

FFS I knew that manhandling a holy book was disrespectful when I was in PRIMARY school, never mind a teenager in secondary school. And that was in the 1960's. So lets not do all this faux concern on the thread about blasphemy laws and call this out as it is - racism and islamophobia. If these young people didn't know that disrespecting someone's holy book is wrong in this day and age, then I am more bothered about the lack of education in the school than their suspension.

And while we are at it, lets not assume that children with autism are stupid or incapable either - the patronising tone here suggest that it's all a storm in a teacup if the child had autism, because "obviously" he wouldn't understand what he was doing. Bullshit.

I was quite a strict Christian as a teenager not so much anymore a friend of mine started tearing out pages of the bible to use as roach in a roll up cigarette. I was mildly offended and said so I didn't feel the need to phone the police or send death threats. She didn't believe and that's fine it didn't personally affect my faith.

I just don't get why people get so angry , you cannot force others to respect and believe or you are imposing blasphemy laws.

TallulahBetty · 28/02/2023 15:23

UdoU · 28/02/2023 15:00

So that means you can treat all Muslims like shit? Righttttttt.

Islamophobia is also racism.

You got THAT from what I said? LOL

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 15:22

@Lesschubtolove it is genuinely challenging to apply a law according to people’s motivation - it’s subjective, lacks clarity and is ripe for abuse. All the things a law shouldn’t be.

The last person punished for blasphemy was (iirc) at the beginning of the last century. Why on earth would we want to reverse ferret and undo a century of far bigger brains than ours deciding it had no place in our society?

Lets accept that provocative little shits looking for a reaction will always be among us, but FGS let’s try and be proportionate as well!

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 15:21

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 15:16

But in some hadith it does say he married a 6 year old and consummated at 9. That's not false , If you feel confident in your beliefs and religion , you don't need to impose your views on others or send death threats.

But that’s actually a hugely debated issue, firstly there is a belief that she was 16 and 19 not 6 and 9

but regardless until the 20th century that has never been a point of contention of critics of Islam because it was so common place in communities of the time, it’s something in Arabic defined as ‘Urf a custom of the people. Christian and Jewish criticism of the time (7th c ad) never mentioned Aisha’s age or supposed age as it was common place in their community also. Puberty was a sign of readiness for marriage, whenever that occurred. The huge problem is when people directly transplant that onto the present day.

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 15:20

Comefromaway · 28/02/2023 15:10

You have the choice not to (say) watch the Life of Brian, but you don’t get to impose that choice on others.

Totally.

The Mormons had the right reaction, they advertise in the programme of The Book of Mormon, they don't issue death threats to the writers or actors. (in the show a Book of Mormon gets shoved up a characters backside)

Most cinemas refused to show The Life Of Brian when it was released because Christian groups threatened blockades.

It was rated AA (14) but the independent cinemas that did show it rated it as X (18)

I was 15 and my choice to watch it was taken away by others.