Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quran School Incident

318 replies

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 13:05

The reaction to this non-incident is shameful. We're effectively charging this poor autistic boy with blasphemy and his mother is begging for his life.

OP posts:
HermioneWeasley · 28/02/2023 20:09

Whereas @MadamArcati99 using a version of the R word to describe the actions of others, shows how enlightened you are.

I’ve reported your post.

Comefromaway · 28/02/2023 20:03

It was not immediate nor ostentatious and it was more akin to being given a promotional booklet than a gift.

MadamArcati99 · 28/02/2023 19:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 19:28

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 18:30

I’m sorry but no. No part of your post responded to what I said and every part implied that I had said something I hadn’t said.

My point was that people here are only pretending to not understand why it’s offensive. Your post doesn’t respond or relate to that.

Really? Now who's making things up?

Let's have a quick recap. You listed a bunch one-off culturally / historically significant works of literature or art, talked about damaging those specifc works deliberately and likened it to damaging a mass produced copy of the Quran.

I disagreed with this and instead said it was more akin damaging a mass produced copy of one of those works of art / literature and that a similar level of offense should be taken.

You countered and said that all Quran's are significant to Muslims and so damaging any old Quran is equally offensive and will provoke or offend.

I countered again saying I don't believe any old Quran is as significant as a truly sacred one off item (or at least shouldn't be), you got sidetracked by my use of the word "you" at the end of a post and here we are.

To bring us back on topic. I do not believe that damaging or disrespecting a Quran should provoke the same level of offense or anger as damaging a truly significant item. For example, if I were to damage the Shroud of Turin I would expect backlash (but not violence), if I were to damage a tea towel copy of the Shroud of Turin I would expect people be non-plussed.

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 19:04

I remember the state the bibles were in back when I took religious studies at school. Graffiti and pages ripped

The pages about tits in the Song of Solomon were quite well-thumbed at ours. A herd of gazelles iirc - load of guff, but titillating to teen boys apparently.

Lovinmyblanket · 28/02/2023 18:51

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 18:34

Not a chance

I remember the state the bibles were in back when I took religious studies at school. Graffiti and pages ripped.

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 18:34

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 18:31

Yes, of course it bloody well would.

Not a chance

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 18:31

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 18:30

I'm not aware of anyone making fun of Muslim kids. Ultimately it's a book, would the same thing have happened if something happened to a Bible or Torah?

Yes, of course it bloody well would.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 28/02/2023 18:30

No one deserves death threats over incidents like this.

That being said, the story doesn't add up. I seriously doubt the incident is as innocent and small as the school are trying to make it sound. It probably isn't as bad as to actually need police involvement either, unless they were only there because of the threats and tensions building up.

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 18:30

UdoU · 28/02/2023 17:55

Yes, our kids should be free to make fun of Muslim kids without consequences. They are just brown kids after all, who cares? 🙄

I'm not aware of anyone making fun of Muslim kids. Ultimately it's a book, would the same thing have happened if something happened to a Bible or Torah?

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 18:30

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 18:25

The first part of the post was in response to your previous post. The final part was a more broad point in general.

When I said if "you" believe X, Y or Z you can fuck off I was using "you" as a general term and not trying to imply that "you - the poster Sqqueeeeeeee" believed X, Y or Z.

I should have said if "anybody believes X, Y, or Z they can fuck off.

I’m sorry but no. No part of your post responded to what I said and every part implied that I had said something I hadn’t said.

My point was that people here are only pretending to not understand why it’s offensive. Your post doesn’t respond or relate to that.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 18:28

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 18:25

The first part of the post was in response to your previous post. The final part was a more broad point in general.

When I said if "you" believe X, Y or Z you can fuck off I was using "you" as a general term and not trying to imply that "you - the poster Sqqueeeeeeee" believed X, Y or Z.

I should have said if "anybody believes X, Y, or Z they can fuck off.

I’m sorry but no. No part of your post responded to what I said and every part implied that I had said something I hadn’t said.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 18:25

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 18:10

If your post wasn’t a response to me then why did you reply to my post in order to say it?

The first part of the post was in response to your previous post. The final part was a more broad point in general.

When I said if "you" believe X, Y or Z you can fuck off I was using "you" as a general term and not trying to imply that "you - the poster Sqqueeeeeeee" believed X, Y or Z.

I should have said if "anybody believes X, Y, or Z they can fuck off.

Ofcourseshecan · 28/02/2023 18:25

UdoU · 28/02/2023 17:55

Yes, our kids should be free to make fun of Muslim kids without consequences. They are just brown kids after all, who cares? 🙄

UdoU, anyone should be free to make fun of anyone without 'consequences'. Free speech includes having the right to offend other people, and they have the right to offend you and me. Every alternative to free speech is worse than free speech itself.

Ofcourseshecan · 28/02/2023 18:20

Lockheart · 28/02/2023 13:24

Yeah, because the mother doesn't want to press charges.

Appearing to apologise isn't "begging for her son's life".

the mother doesn't want to press charges or make a complaint.

Presumably because she is already terrified by the death threats against her son, and doesn't dare do anything that will further enrage his attackers.

And anyone who thinks this doesn't matter is helping religious zealots bring back the law against blasphemy by the back door.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 18:10

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 17:57

I didn't say you did, at least not intentionally. The "you" in my final paragraph was a collective you i.e., if anyone thinks they can harass or attack someone for offending them they can fuck off. Apologies if that was not clear.

I think we are broadly arguing the same point tbh, the only difference appears to be around significance. I don't see mass produced copies of the Quran as anymore significant than a mass produced print of the Mona Lisa and don't believe any Muslim should be offended if one is damaged deliberately or otherwise (unless it's their own personal copy).

If your post wasn’t a response to me then why did you reply to my post in order to say it?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/02/2023 18:02

It's obvious they brought it in to kick around in front of Muslim kids to upset them

Is It? Were you there?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 17:57

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 17:18

Ah, I see you’ve resorted to inventing things.

Point out where I said “damaging or disrespecting a book / flag / replica / random whatever is worthy of physically harming a person”. I didn’t, did I?

I said that I don’t believe the PP on here who are pretending that they don’t understand why it’s offensive to damage a Quran. I’m glad you now agree. Everyone does, in fact, recognise why it’s offensive.

That doesn’t mean that it’s acceptable to be a dick about it or behave like a violent thug - I never made any such assertion. I simply stated that everyone here does actually, in reality, understand why destroying things that matter to other people on purpose is offensive to other people.

I didn't say you did, at least not intentionally. The "you" in my final paragraph was a collective you i.e., if anyone thinks they can harass or attack someone for offending them they can fuck off. Apologies if that was not clear.

I think we are broadly arguing the same point tbh, the only difference appears to be around significance. I don't see mass produced copies of the Quran as anymore significant than a mass produced print of the Mona Lisa and don't believe any Muslim should be offended if one is damaged deliberately or otherwise (unless it's their own personal copy).

UdoU · 28/02/2023 17:55

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 17:53

It's awful we are not an Islamic state and I hope we never will be.

Yes, our kids should be free to make fun of Muslim kids without consequences. They are just brown kids after all, who cares? 🙄

ACynicalDad · 28/02/2023 17:53

It's awful we are not an Islamic state and I hope we never will be.

UdoU · 28/02/2023 17:52

Youreastar · 28/02/2023 17:09

Interesting that people on MN don't realise schools, especially secondary schools, often involve the police to talk to children involved in serious incidents in school (damage property, threats etc) This decision is not taken lightly but surprisingly common. Normally the police are better placed to talk to the children and they see the seriousness of the issue.
I'd imagine the local mosques leaders were involved by the school to diffuse the situation and restore calm. As like any story it can quickly become distorted.
Personallly I think the school dealt with it well. Any threats made to the children involved and their families should be investigated by the police.

Another voice of reason, amidst the bigotry.

Conkersinautumn · 28/02/2023 17:52

Anyone issuing a death threat should deal with the legal consequences. It should be taken seriously as a crime. Its funny how many would be violent people hide behind faith

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/02/2023 17:50

Impossible to comment on the detail without having been there, but two thoughts occur: firstly why, if it's true there was "no malicious intent", it was deemed necessary to suspend the pupils

And secondly, that this is a good example of why it may be wise to keep all religious practice well away from schools

Lovinmyblanket · 28/02/2023 17:44

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 13:53

What?

If you disagree with something I've said, could you maybe explain it rather than writing "what?"

potniatheron · 28/02/2023 17:29

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 17:27

I don’t think phenotypes or anti semitism was akala’s point it was something along the lines of the race of a black or non white person is the first piece about them that is seen.

have you read the price of whiteness? I believe that talks about the transformation in European consciousness that led Jews to be considered white.

i fear we are derailing here but it’s really interesting to chat with you! But I do still stand by my point That islamaphobia is tied up with racism

Agree to disagree then but it's been lovely to chat with you too and has enlivened rather a dull Tuesday afternoon :-)

Swipe left for the next trending thread