Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quran School Incident

318 replies

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 13:05

The reaction to this non-incident is shameful. We're effectively charging this poor autistic boy with blasphemy and his mother is begging for his life.

OP posts:
Quveas · 01/03/2023 08:12

Ofcourseshecan · 28/02/2023 18:25

UdoU, anyone should be free to make fun of anyone without 'consequences'. Free speech includes having the right to offend other people, and they have the right to offend you and me. Every alternative to free speech is worse than free speech itself.

It's funny how bigots always turn to "free speech" to defend the indefensible. There is no such thing in the UK as free speech. There is no law that defends it. We have laws that curtail speech and actions in all sorts of ways. Hate speech, for example, is specifically outlawed.

Section 4 of the Public Order Act 1986 makes it an offence for a person to use “threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviours that causes, or is likely to cause, another person harassment, alarm or distress”. Deliberate disrespect of someone's holy book is behaviour likely to cause another person distress, and in the right circumstances may also constitute racial harassment. These children obviously knew that making a Quran the subject of a dare would be very likley to cause distress to Muslims. They did not bring it in to read or to show their peers how respectful they could be. Yes, they are idiots, but being an idiots doesn't mean that actions are defensible. The school dealt with this in a measured and sensible way. Suspend and educate.

I am a Christian, but I have no similar attachment to the Bible, and would not personally get upset if it was subject to similar treatment. But I would expect a school to respond to the same actions with a Bible in a similar way because it is not the book, but the deliberately disrepectful behaviour that underlies the actions that is the issue.

I do wonder what the reaction here would be if a bunch of Muslims publically and deliberately set out to disrespect the Bible. Outrage I would imagine, and just as much from non-Christians I will bet. Because they would be attacking our "culture". "heritage" or "British values". Those lines are trotted out often enough, but only when it refers to doubling down on someone else - it's funny how many of those "British values" don't apply to the British.

It may be just a book to you, whether the Quran or the Bible - but it isn't to others, and basic human decency would argue that deliberate provocation designed to distress others in not the kind of behaviour we want in society.

Overthinkingnotdrinking · 01/03/2023 08:05

It’s a weird situation on mumsnet where a lot of posters are ok with death threats to teachers and children for disrespecting Islam, but at the same time get upset about anyone not accepting trans women in women’s spaces and think the snp leader who has traditional Christian views on marriage is a bigot. The same ‘be kind’ brigade. Do you think if we start pandering to the religious beliefs of a group who’s e views on women/faith/homosexuality are so at odds with the culture of tolerance is a good idea. It is a slippery slope once you start involving the police for a book being accidentally damaged.

VestaTilley · 01/03/2023 08:02

YANBU. It’s completely unacceptable, and as usual the cowardly MPs on the left and right have absolutely nothing to say about this.

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 07:54

Emmmie · 28/02/2023 22:13

What picture is that? There are no portraits of Prophet Mohammed and his face is never shown anywhere.

You must mean the teacher was sharing a vile, disrespectful cartoon with his students for some reason. I struggle to imagine what reason that could be other than deliberately aiming to offend and hurt.

But sure...minimise it.

I can’t comment on what picture it was, I don’t know. But quite frankly at the end of the day it’s a picture of a bloke. Not even a photo, just some drawing out of someone’s imagination, now I’m assuming Islam doesn’t actually call for death threats for a teacher who shows that picture to a bunch of kids (if it does it’s fucked up and have no idea why anyone would follow that). But why don’t Muslims call it out. Why isn’t every Iman in the news condemning it. Why isn’t every Nudkim condemning it in here as taking their religion in vain?

What other reason? Maybe to show how ludicrous being offended by a picture is- if a picture leads to death threats the meaning of that picture needs minimising. It’s ridiculous. Are you happy with death threats? Maybe you need to stop minimising the effects on the teacher. Even if he set out to offend, that’s a disciplinary matter not something to make him in fear of his life. Anyone who thinks otherwise is seriously fucked in the head, and only a couple of flying lessons away from flying a packed passenger plane into a building..

Islam seems to be operating as Christianity did 500 -1000 years ago (which prob makes sense given the differing ages of religion so different stages of evolution)

HermioneWeasley · 01/03/2023 06:22

Emmmie · 28/02/2023 22:13

What picture is that? There are no portraits of Prophet Mohammed and his face is never shown anywhere.

You must mean the teacher was sharing a vile, disrespectful cartoon with his students for some reason. I struggle to imagine what reason that could be other than deliberately aiming to offend and hurt.

But sure...minimise it.

Not true that the only images are “vile cartoons”. He also gave Muslim students the option to leave the room before he showed it to the class.

but even if it were the case that he forced Muslim students to view a “vile cartoon”, you think that justifies death threats and him living in fear for his life? Absolutely bonkers.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/03/2023 04:40

I wonder what truly happened here. Including the death threats.

Northernsouloldies · 01/03/2023 02:08

UdoU · 01/03/2023 01:57

Anti-Muslim fervour never ends well either.

Not sure what you're getting at, my comment definitely had no racist intent.

UdoU · 01/03/2023 01:57

Anti-Muslim fervour never ends well either.

Northernsouloldies · 01/03/2023 01:35

Religious fervour of any kind never ends well.

UdoU · 01/03/2023 00:57

Justanotherlurker · 28/02/2023 22:24

That is such a bad faith comparison, I am not going to go into why and will repost a link but this is your mindset.

twitter.com/jessgill03/status/1630312286190542851?s=20

So only poppy burning is vile? Hypocrisy, no?

OMG12 · 28/02/2023 22:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Justanotherlurker · 28/02/2023 22:33

Eleganz · 28/02/2023 22:24

This is simply untrue. There are images and portraits of the prophet Muhammed that are not cartoons.

For example there is a painting from 19th century in the Met collection:

www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/841475

There are examples of Muhammed being depicted by islamic artists for private use by wealthy individuals in the Ottoman empire, for example.

I was going to cite those as well, the teacher from bately is essentially now under government protection.

It's a schrödinger situation, where it doesn't happen but if it does it is somehow acceptable because even though no one really wants blasphemy laws implanted, the edge cases are perfectly justifiable.

Eleganz · 28/02/2023 22:24

Emmmie · 28/02/2023 22:13

What picture is that? There are no portraits of Prophet Mohammed and his face is never shown anywhere.

You must mean the teacher was sharing a vile, disrespectful cartoon with his students for some reason. I struggle to imagine what reason that could be other than deliberately aiming to offend and hurt.

But sure...minimise it.

This is simply untrue. There are images and portraits of the prophet Muhammed that are not cartoons.

For example there is a painting from 19th century in the Met collection:

www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/841475

There are examples of Muhammed being depicted by islamic artists for private use by wealthy individuals in the Ottoman empire, for example.

Justanotherlurker · 28/02/2023 22:24

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 22:11

You only have to look at the reaction of some (many) people when a bunch of nutters start burning poppies to tell you all you need to know about Western attitudes to desecration of what is considered sacred

That is such a bad faith comparison, I am not going to go into why and will repost a link but this is your mindset.

twitter.com/jessgill03/status/1630312286190542851?s=20

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 22:23

Lovinmyblanket · 28/02/2023 22:02

Why not though? In Arabic, it is the literal words of Allah. In English it is a human's interpretation of what they think Allah said.

A Quran in English isn’t of lesser value, let’s put it that way, so it’s not less offensive to destroy and English quran

Emmmie · 28/02/2023 22:13

HermioneWeasley · 28/02/2023 13:21

This case has reminded me that a teacher is still living in hiding for fear of his life after showing pupils a picture of Mohammed.

What picture is that? There are no portraits of Prophet Mohammed and his face is never shown anywhere.

You must mean the teacher was sharing a vile, disrespectful cartoon with his students for some reason. I struggle to imagine what reason that could be other than deliberately aiming to offend and hurt.

But sure...minimise it.

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 22:11

You only have to look at the reaction of some (many) people when a bunch of nutters start burning poppies to tell you all you need to know about Western attitudes to desecration of what is considered sacred

Lovinmyblanket · 28/02/2023 22:02

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 21:07

Something along the lines of the Quran being less significant when not in Arabic?

that’s not a thing

Why not though? In Arabic, it is the literal words of Allah. In English it is a human's interpretation of what they think Allah said.

UdoU · 28/02/2023 22:00

Notaflippinclue · 28/02/2023 21:49

I was ashamed and angry at what they did to the poor mum making her wear a scarf and begging for forgiveness, just downright humiliation and bullying, detective inspector, councillor, Iman and
headmaster, as someone on TV tonight said they all need binning, shariah law by the back door - what's going on in British schools - grrrrr

No one made her do anything. It’s customary to wear a scarf at the mosque, there is no force involved.

Stop causing division and hate.

Yes, I’m sure the Muslim kids felt really supported when the Quran was kicked around in front of them by white kids.

Justanotherlurker · 28/02/2023 21:51

I think this is quite the moral framework for a lot of users on this site.

twitter.com/jessgill03/status/1630312286190542851?s=20

And as a brown, ex Muslim (even though I should not need to do that qualifier), I do not believe in in any way this was an appropriate response, anyone even trying to justify or downplay it is a reason to why the teacher from Batley has had to basically go into hiding, but knowing MN that will be justified.

Notaflippinclue · 28/02/2023 21:49

I was ashamed and angry at what they did to the poor mum making her wear a scarf and begging for forgiveness, just downright humiliation and bullying, detective inspector, councillor, Iman and
headmaster, as someone on TV tonight said they all need binning, shariah law by the back door - what's going on in British schools - grrrrr

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 21:07

Lovinmyblanket · 28/02/2023 17:44

If you disagree with something I've said, could you maybe explain it rather than writing "what?"

Something along the lines of the Quran being less significant when not in Arabic?

that’s not a thing

Kendodd · 28/02/2023 21:05

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 18:31

Yes, of course it bloody well would.

Really?
You think that?
They publish children's editions of the bible with cartoon illustrations, children then scribble all over them.

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 20:32

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/02/2023 19:28

Really? Now who's making things up?

Let's have a quick recap. You listed a bunch one-off culturally / historically significant works of literature or art, talked about damaging those specifc works deliberately and likened it to damaging a mass produced copy of the Quran.

I disagreed with this and instead said it was more akin damaging a mass produced copy of one of those works of art / literature and that a similar level of offense should be taken.

You countered and said that all Quran's are significant to Muslims and so damaging any old Quran is equally offensive and will provoke or offend.

I countered again saying I don't believe any old Quran is as significant as a truly sacred one off item (or at least shouldn't be), you got sidetracked by my use of the word "you" at the end of a post and here we are.

To bring us back on topic. I do not believe that damaging or disrespecting a Quran should provoke the same level of offense or anger as damaging a truly significant item. For example, if I were to damage the Shroud of Turin I would expect backlash (but not violence), if I were to damage a tea towel copy of the Shroud of Turin I would expect people be non-plussed.

You do realise that’s not an accurate representation of the conversation that took place.

Comefromaway · 28/02/2023 20:11

Thank you Hermione. Dd & Ds have both had the r word used at them as have many autistic people.