Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quran School Incident

318 replies

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 13:05

The reaction to this non-incident is shameful. We're effectively charging this poor autistic boy with blasphemy and his mother is begging for his life.

OP posts:
Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 13:56

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 13:41

Well as I said the Sufis did add a lot to philosophy- but yes Islam does need reformation from where isn’t is currently to fit into western society.

you clearly don’t understand the Protestant reformation or how it came about, maybe look into that. It came about because the likes of Martin Luther were sick to the decadence of the Catholic Church and believed they had innovated many things in their doctorine so it was intiallt incredibly conservative, puritans for one. Salafism is a reformation of sorts, aiming to strip Islam of innovative practices.

also who the f are you to say my religion needs changing when you are actively demonstrating you know nothing about it. There is nothing about Islam that doesn’t fit into western society. Most religious groups, including the Church of England believe homosexuality is a sin, but that’s the physical act not the desire. Women can wear what they want here, so if someone wears a head covering who cares. There are shura councils that deal with internal politics issues and Islamic divorces but minority every religious group has them (Jews do as well) but the overarching principle in Islam is you abide by the law of the land.

this narrative of Islam compatible with western lifestyles is straight from the daily mail and Sun and is just tedious.

ScholesPanda · 01/03/2023 13:41

I'm inclined to agree with you OP that this has been blown out of all proportion. It could be solved so simply- teens are admonished and apologise, maybe do something practical like donate another copy of the Koran to the local mosque. Job done.
However, people quickly pile in with their own agendas, wanting to shoehorn this minor local incident into their wider narratives- that Islam is incompatible with British life, that Islamophobia is rife and Muslims are under attack, that Islam is under threat from infidels, that British values are under threat from Islam etc. etc.
I grew up in a town which had a race riot, and even in pre-internet days it was amazing how all these groups piled in and wound everyone up further.
And of course, it's the local people who have to stick their lives and community back together again, long after the professional campaigners and rubberneckers move on to the next supposed outrage.

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 13:41

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 13:01

It’s a stupid observation and embarrassing on your behalf.

you cannot compare Western European Christianity to Islam, remember the centre of Western European Christianity is in Europe and the centre of Sunni Islam is Saudi Arabia. Most Muslim majority countries are developing and third world countries and third world countries do not have a great track record on human rights regardless of religion, nor education.

sunni Islam did take a more conservative turn after the formation of Saudi Arabia which was, shock horror, supported by the Brits. Prior to that under the ottomans it was far more pluralistic, homosexuality was decriminalised for instance. The conservative nature of mainstream Islam has a lot of geopolitical factors, islamicization of Malaysia post colonialism for instance, the propping up of the Saudi state, arming of the taliban for instance.

islam Doesn’t need to be forced to modernised nor does it need a reformation, we need more scholars and to remember our past

Well as I said the Sufis did add a lot to philosophy- but yes Islam does need reformation from where isn’t is currently to fit into western society.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/03/2023 13:01

MamOfFive · 01/03/2023 12:37

Honestly religion should be banned, the amount of hate, wars, terrorism, poor lack of judgement and understanding it causes is beyond me.

I wouldn't go that far, MamOfFive, even if it was possible; I've the greatest respect for individual faith - as opposed to organised religion - providing that any actions which result from it stay within the law

I'd ban all forms of practice from schools and anything else that's publicly funded though. By all means exercise any faith at a personal level if it's legal, but please don't expect the rest of us to support its promotion, far less to bend the knee to its demands on the basis of threats

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 13:01

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 12:52

Ooh I don’t know!

Position on homosexuality
Stoning for sex

it’s a shame the sufis have added quite a lot to philosophy

but trying to force Islam into modern western society does involve big compromises. Unless compromises are made there will be continued clashes - the question is who should be doing the compromises and why?

It’s a stupid observation and embarrassing on your behalf.

you cannot compare Western European Christianity to Islam, remember the centre of Western European Christianity is in Europe and the centre of Sunni Islam is Saudi Arabia. Most Muslim majority countries are developing and third world countries and third world countries do not have a great track record on human rights regardless of religion, nor education.

sunni Islam did take a more conservative turn after the formation of Saudi Arabia which was, shock horror, supported by the Brits. Prior to that under the ottomans it was far more pluralistic, homosexuality was decriminalised for instance. The conservative nature of mainstream Islam has a lot of geopolitical factors, islamicization of Malaysia post colonialism for instance, the propping up of the Saudi state, arming of the taliban for instance.

islam Doesn’t need to be forced to modernised nor does it need a reformation, we need more scholars and to remember our past

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 12:52

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 12:35

You know why people don’t say it? Because it’s a stupid and ignorant observation

Ooh I don’t know!

Position on homosexuality
Stoning for sex

it’s a shame the sufis have added quite a lot to philosophy

but trying to force Islam into modern western society does involve big compromises. Unless compromises are made there will be continued clashes - the question is who should be doing the compromises and why?

UdoU · 01/03/2023 12:44

Notaflippinclue · 01/03/2023 12:00

100s protesting outside the Batley school which one was the oddball.

Because if Muslims don't protest racist/islamophobic attacks, then the rate at which pig heads are lobbed into Mosques and other racist attacks just increases.

MamOfFive · 01/03/2023 12:37

Honestly religion should be banned, the amount of hate, wars, terrorism, poor lack of judgement and understanding it causes is beyond me.

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 12:36

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/03/2023 12:32

So who is the arbiter of when criticism is valid and when it is not?

We could fill entire threads with that, but in practice it appears to be those who shout loudest and pose the greatest potential threat to the wider community if they don't get their way - which may well explain why some spouters of hate face consequences and others have a blind eye turned

I'll add that this certainly doesn't just apply to race and religion; as a PP identified, it's fascinating to see posters - sometimes the same ones - hammering away in defence of a preferred minority group while damning others, clearly ignoring that legal protections belong to us all

Interesting, though, to see death threats described as "absurd" and "laughable"; personally I'd choose other adjectives, but it's illuminating all the same

Assume that’s a reference to my comments, ie. Laughable Ie it’s a totally absurd reaction, disproportionate, against what Islam teaches and frankly weird

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 12:35

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 12:28

Well I guess that’s what I’m saying - because Islam is lagging a few hundred years behind Christianity is also lagging behind societies built round Christianity. The attitudes would have probably fitted in better round 1500 Europe. Today it’s totally incongruent.

People won’t say it, but that’s the situation, unless one or both of the stances changes there will be tension.

this is yet another example of so called diversity causing conflicts without anyone realistically trying to sort it out.

You know why people don’t say it? Because it’s a stupid and ignorant observation

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/03/2023 12:32

So who is the arbiter of when criticism is valid and when it is not?

We could fill entire threads with that, but in practice it appears to be those who shout loudest and pose the greatest potential threat to the wider community if they don't get their way - which may well explain why some spouters of hate face consequences and others have a blind eye turned

I'll add that this certainly doesn't just apply to race and religion; as a PP identified, it's fascinating to see posters - sometimes the same ones - hammering away in defence of a preferred minority group while damning others, clearly ignoring that legal protections belong to us all

Interesting, though, to see death threats described as "absurd" and "laughable"; personally I'd choose other adjectives, but it's illuminating all the same

User8646382 · 01/03/2023 12:32

In what universe is it right that a local councillor should carry out an investigation about something involving a child that happened in a school and then report back to the community while ignoring death threats made by that community?

It’s a publicly elected official representing the UK government (albeit at a local level) condoning the death threats and turning the criminals (the ones making the death threats) into victims. You don’t think that’s wrong? Great, but the rest of us who pay taxes should not have to put up with this.

OMG12 · 01/03/2023 12:28

Ponoka7 · 01/03/2023 09:32

"Islam seems to be operating as Christianity did 500 -1000 years ago (which prob makes sense given the differing ages of religion so different stages of evolution)"

Well yes, but we've got to ignore that. Religious rights don't trump mine and anyone else who has a vagina, to the degree that we can be classed as second class citizens. We don't have the death penalty in this country and it isn't ok to make death threats.

"it’s about a small section of nasty men who see an opportunity to be relevant."

I think that how small that group is needs to be disputed. If abusive/radical Muslim men are in the minority, why when Islam takes hold of a region do women's and children's rights, even the right to life, disappear? Why does it get more and more radical including men carrying sticks and beating women in public who drive cars and show their wrists? We accept the murder of Catholics across Africa and the stealing of land. We are accepting that areas are Muslim, which has actually only happened in the last ten years and have happened because of murder. There's parts of the Muslim faith, such as the right to rape and impregnate your wife yearly, even if you are selling your daughters to survive, that we have the right to find problematic. Go onto the Vicky McClure DV video on FB and read the comments from the Muslim men living in the UK. There's an issue of feeling as though men own women and it's up to us to not make them angry. It's dangerous to declare not liking parts of Islam as Islamophobia. The Christian Churches have changed many stances and as bad as the sexism is still in the UK it is nowhere near on a par as it is in predominantly Muslim countries. That's without going into attitudes towards gay etc people.

Well I guess that’s what I’m saying - because Islam is lagging a few hundred years behind Christianity is also lagging behind societies built round Christianity. The attitudes would have probably fitted in better round 1500 Europe. Today it’s totally incongruent.

People won’t say it, but that’s the situation, unless one or both of the stances changes there will be tension.

this is yet another example of so called diversity causing conflicts without anyone realistically trying to sort it out.

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 12:02

Notaflippinclue · 01/03/2023 12:00

100s protesting outside the Batley school which one was the oddball.

Protesting isn’t the same as calling for the death of someone. It’s within someone’s right to protest if they felt that their faith was being attacked. I myself wouldn’t have but I’d have gone to the head and aired my concerns, perhaps this happened and they felt they weren’t taken seriously.

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 12:01

User8646382 · 01/03/2023 11:54

But if that’s the case, why did the teacher and his family have to go into witness protection?

Because on threat is enough right, even if it’s by an absolute nutter, it’s erring on the side of caution. If it was a straight forward as a prominent Muslim figure calling for the execution of some teacher then that person would be arrested but that’s not what happens, it’s key board warriors, who even knows if they are UK based.

is he in witness protection like actually though? Or has it just been reported that he’s in hiding? Because the latter is what I’ve read. I know this is old Ie from 2021 but I’d not even heard anyone mention this it was such a non event and I’m Muslim, and attend a conservative mosque. The general thought there is don’t rise to the bait, don’t associate yourself with people who seek to offend you and use appropriate channels to report such behaviour.

Notaflippinclue · 01/03/2023 12:00

100s protesting outside the Batley school which one was the oddball.

User8646382 · 01/03/2023 11:54

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 11:41

Wow lot of people have a lot of problems with Muslims here.

death threats are obviously absurd but it’s incredibly unlikely they’ve come from community leaders because if they have why haven’t they been arrested. More than likely it’s from an over zealous troll who is more than Likely not really all there himself.

99.9% of Muslims would also think death threats are absurd and laughable but the problem is this is held up as ‘look at how backwards Muslims are, one of them has done this’ and that is being dragged out here, again.

But if that’s the case, why did the teacher and his family have to go into witness protection?

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 11:51

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 28/02/2023 14:15

Actually the Christians would, I believe, be turning the other cheek, as instructed by their faith.

I can’t speak for any of the others you refer to, though the militant wing of Buddhism doesn’t seem to make the headlines often.

Except in Myanmar where they were slaughtering Muslims by the hundreds right? But doesn’t really count because they were only killing Muslims right.

actually turn the other cheek IS a central part of Islam, forgiveness and clemency are huge! So many hadith on this and ayats on forgiveness but it doesn’t suit the narrative of the violent Muslim does it?

Notaflippinclue · 01/03/2023 11:45

It's a book that was dropped or knocked to the floor- be respectful to all books - fairytales? probably

Hotpinkangel19 · 01/03/2023 11:42

Not all people with Autism are clueless you know! This 'poor autistic boy' may have been fully aware that what he was doing was wrong.

Surplus2requirements · 01/03/2023 11:42

@zara223 all kids are susceptible to peer pressure to some degree, it's difficult to resist when a group is collectively trying to persuade one to do something. I certainly wouldn't try and place blame on one child.

The threats are obviously abhorrent and the police should act on them.

Sadly extremists on both sides try to twist things like this to suit their agenda and it makes perfect sense to involve community leaders to calm fears and counter false narratives some of which may well originate from outside the UK as happened in Leicester.

There's also a lot being stirred up by the far right and there's comments here that appear to be lifted straight from their rantings.

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 11:42

Kendodd · 01/03/2023 11:28

Honestly, I think these grown men Muslim 'leaders' are the worse thing to ever happen to Islam. They make Islam look like a hate filled ideology populatied by nutcases. Why don't the people around them tell the to shut the fuck up, why do you let these people drag your religion through the mud with death threats against children.

Did you study or work at the University of Birmingham?

Lesschubtolove · 01/03/2023 11:41

Wow lot of people have a lot of problems with Muslims here.

death threats are obviously absurd but it’s incredibly unlikely they’ve come from community leaders because if they have why haven’t they been arrested. More than likely it’s from an over zealous troll who is more than Likely not really all there himself.

99.9% of Muslims would also think death threats are absurd and laughable but the problem is this is held up as ‘look at how backwards Muslims are, one of them has done this’ and that is being dragged out here, again.

User8646382 · 01/03/2023 11:33

zara223 · 01/03/2023 11:10

Only heard about this just now from MN so haven't been following this story but If the boy has autism/SEN then I do really feel for him and his mother.
Autism is a spectrum so some children may grasp the importance of religions/boundaries etc but some may not so easily.
Some autistic kids MIGHT have behaviour challenges and be impulsive or easily led by peer pressure and are vulnerable.
I'm not saying what he did was OK as I'm a Muslim myself and do not like to see my holy book disrespected in anyway but I do feel for the mother receiving threats.
I hope things de escalate for the boy and he can be given some support/education on the topic.

I think it’s up to the police to ensure that things deescalate by doing their jobs properly and arresting the individuals who are making death threats. They are ones who are committing a crime under UK law.

The child has not committed any crime and his need for education on the topic should be dealt with by his parents and the school, not community ‘elders’ or the local councillor, and certainly not the police.

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/03/2023 11:29

creamwitheverything · 01/03/2023 10:45

Total over reaction by all involved. My pet hate is religion in schools. Teach friendships,teach kindness,teach inclusion dont teach about fairy tales. Take religion out of schools this wouldnt happen. We have to find a better way to go on. Seperate communities cause seperation.Let kids be kids, punish kids who are mean,punish kids who dont do the right thing by all means have rules that provide a clear understanding of how the school is run for everyone but get rid of religion.

So is kicking a holy book allowed or not? It is obviously not kind to the Faithful, but then, on the other hand you ate dismissing religion as fairytales