Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quran School Incident

318 replies

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 13:05

The reaction to this non-incident is shameful. We're effectively charging this poor autistic boy with blasphemy and his mother is begging for his life.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 28/02/2023 14:55

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 14:41

I don't buy the faux-ignorance of people on these threads. Everyone with a brain cell knows why it's unacceptable.

  • I have no interest in art. If I damaged a Picasso painting on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in art, I understand why.
  • I have no interest in the Beatles. If someone damaged a Beatles master record on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in the Beatles, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in football. If someone damaged the 1966 World Cup Final ball on purpose, people would be offended and, despite no interest in football, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in Jane Austen. If someone damaged a Jane Austen manuscript on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in Jane Austen, I would understand why.
It's not difficult to understand that sometimes things matter to other people even if they don't matter to you. Five year olds understand that concept. It's unacceptable to damage things that are significant to other people just because you don't care about them and, frankly, more often because they matter to other people but not to you. I don't believe anyone here genuinely doesn't understand that concept - you're not fooling anyone.

In all of those examples the person is damaging something that does not belong to them.

If I owned a rare Beatles Master record and damaged it on purpose then it would be no-one else's business.

The book belonged to the boy. He was free to do to it as he wished.

UdoU · 28/02/2023 14:54

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:44

Exactly. We all know it’s the same religion again and again. But nobody really wants to acknowledge it.

So 4 white kids kick around the Quran to upset Muslim boys and the fault lies with. Muslims. Can you say gaslighting?

FlumpyLump · 28/02/2023 14:52

Way back in 2002 when I was 16 and at college, another young girl had her crucifix ripped from her neck and thrown on the floor where it was then spat on by a boy of another religion and she was called “Christian scum”.
Do you know what was done?
Absolutely nothing.
No investigations, no suspensions, no uproar.

I know this was over 20 years ago, but I can’t see the outcome being any different today.

potniatheron · 28/02/2023 14:52

Islamophobia is a huge problem in this country and this kind of hysterical reporting just fans the flames. The media has been in faux outrage about it for a few days. If everyone involved had responded like adults and the media had not incited outrage, we would probably not be at the point of death threats.

UdoU · 28/02/2023 14:51

Even if you exclude the fact they were behaving like little shits (no one dares someone else to bring in a Qaran unless they're being a little shit) and ignore any religious factor, the punishment isn't unreasonable. No child innocently dares someone else to bring a religious text into school. When I was in Y9, a guy in Y11 brought in a bible and made a video of him eating it.

I agree with this. Death threats are deplorable, but I can see why you would bring in the police to talk to the little shits.

My husband was a Pakistani kid in a West Yorkshire school. He was so inured to being called a 'P*' that he even hung out with the white kids who called him this.

Fifi0102 · 28/02/2023 14:51

Oh for god's sake we don't have blasphemy laws in the UK. Anyone sending death threats to a child over a book needs to be thrown in jail. The Qur'an pictured is in English not Arabic.

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 14:50

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:44

Exactly. We all know it’s the same religion again and again. But nobody really wants to acknowledge it.

Tell me you’re a racist without telling me you’re a racist

Zippidydoda · 28/02/2023 14:49

I don’t understand why this is national news. Of course they shouldn’t treat a holy book from any religion with a lack of
respect but the school could have dealt with this without outside (media /community groups) involvement.

If there was no malicious intent then surely it’s a case of education and working with the children to ensure it doesn’t happen again (whatever even happened as it’s not that clear- but certainly nothing that sounds significant).

TallulahBetty · 28/02/2023 14:48

Lockheart · 28/02/2023 13:24

Yeah, because the mother doesn't want to press charges.

Appearing to apologise isn't "begging for her son's life".

It would be difficult, seeing as you don't 'press charges' in the UK.

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 14:45

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 14:41

I don't buy the faux-ignorance of people on these threads. Everyone with a brain cell knows why it's unacceptable.

  • I have no interest in art. If I damaged a Picasso painting on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in art, I understand why.
  • I have no interest in the Beatles. If someone damaged a Beatles master record on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in the Beatles, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in football. If someone damaged the 1966 World Cup Final ball on purpose, people would be offended and, despite no interest in football, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in Jane Austen. If someone damaged a Jane Austen manuscript on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in Jane Austen, I would understand why.
It's not difficult to understand that sometimes things matter to other people even if they don't matter to you. Five year olds understand that concept. It's unacceptable to damage things that are significant to other people just because you don't care about them and, frankly, more often because they matter to other people but not to you. I don't believe anyone here genuinely doesn't understand that concept - you're not fooling anyone.

I am not questioning whether it could potentially offend or why it was offensive. I am well aware of muslim teachings in this regards and it is not a behaviour I would take part in.

My issue is the overreaction to stupid school child stuff, and how that overreaction is not based on sensitivity, but fear.

OP posts:
Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 14:45

OhmygodDont · 28/02/2023 14:42

The only time I ever hear of anger over anything religious is always the same religion.

Don’t see Buddhists or Sikhs or Christians tending to be up in arms about most things.

You don't see many deliberately trying to offend the others either

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:44

OhmygodDont · 28/02/2023 14:42

The only time I ever hear of anger over anything religious is always the same religion.

Don’t see Buddhists or Sikhs or Christians tending to be up in arms about most things.

Exactly. We all know it’s the same religion again and again. But nobody really wants to acknowledge it.

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 14:43

OhmygodDont · 28/02/2023 14:42

The only time I ever hear of anger over anything religious is always the same religion.

Don’t see Buddhists or Sikhs or Christians tending to be up in arms about most things.

I'm part-Jewish. You need to pay more attention to the news.

OhmygodDont · 28/02/2023 14:42

The only time I ever hear of anger over anything religious is always the same religion.

Don’t see Buddhists or Sikhs or Christians tending to be up in arms about most things.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 28/02/2023 14:41

I don't buy the faux-ignorance of people on these threads. Everyone with a brain cell knows why it's unacceptable.

  • I have no interest in art. If I damaged a Picasso painting on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in art, I understand why.
  • I have no interest in the Beatles. If someone damaged a Beatles master record on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in the Beatles, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in football. If someone damaged the 1966 World Cup Final ball on purpose, people would be offended and, despite no interest in football, I would understand why.
  • I have no interest in Jane Austen. If someone damaged a Jane Austen manuscript on purpose then people would be offended and, despite no interest in Jane Austen, I would understand why.
It's not difficult to understand that sometimes things matter to other people even if they don't matter to you. Five year olds understand that concept. It's unacceptable to damage things that are significant to other people just because you don't care about them and, frankly, more often because they matter to other people but not to you. I don't believe anyone here genuinely doesn't understand that concept - you're not fooling anyone.
Overthinkingnotdrinking · 28/02/2023 14:38

@Chickenly we’re the police called? Did her mum have to apologise to a council of Christian community leaders to de-escalate the situation? Hardly comparable.

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:36

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 14:35

That's not true. Someone on this exact thread has already said their DD was disciplined for binning a Bible at school.

Yeah disciplined at school! They didn’t involve police and local churches, it’s bloody barmy 😂

Overthinkingnotdrinking · 28/02/2023 14:35

The head teacher is quoted as saying “no malicious intent” and the mother of the boy speaking with the Islamic community leaders says her child is autistic. It does not seem like an act of religious hate, just kids being kids. But as predicted, mumsnet is up for special punishments for those who offend religious minorities. Can’t imagine anyone getting upset about a bible being smudged with no malicious intent.

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 14:35

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:32

What madness!! If it was any other religion whose book got slightly damaged at a school, nobody would care. Why must we all tolerate this insanity 🙄

That's not true. Someone on this exact thread has already said their DD was disciplined for binning a Bible at school.

Lesschubtolove · 28/02/2023 14:33

Vinvertebrate · 28/02/2023 14:06

@Lesschubtolove I'm married to a Muslim who is ashamed of the kind of lunatics that make death threats to disabled kids, as I believe all sane people should be.

It’s like any moral issue - views are personal to the holder. Calling it Jewish or Christian or Zoroastrian or frigging Jedi does not automatically confer respect, nor should it. Don’t believe in mistreating certain books? Don’t do it. Let others live according to their own beliefs, or none.

Erm I disagree on the last part, whether you believe it or not holy books (not sure about any Jedi texts) do hold significance to people and to destroy it or to denigrate one in anyway is an act of antagonism or prejudice or even racism and those things shouldn’t really be tolerated or let slide under the guise of live and let live. Religious texts, artefacts and places should be treated with respect, even if it means nothing to you, it does to others and that should be enough and the underlying principle of those who stoke the fires of hatred by drawing cartoons of Muhammad or ripping apart Qurans can’t be ignored. So I actually do think religious texts should be respected. That doesn’t mean kid leather gloves and shot at dawn for a creased cover but purposeful denigration is another matter. That a lunch time detention would solve. If a Muslim pupil was caught burning bibles that student should be disciplined also. It’s no one’s personal belief system that books should be destroyed.

Mynewname2023 · 28/02/2023 14:32

What madness!! If it was any other religion whose book got slightly damaged at a school, nobody would care. Why must we all tolerate this insanity 🙄

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 14:32

I wish we could edit!!

The three students involved were suspended - there was religion involved.
I meant "The three students involved were suspended - there was NOT religion involved."

DerangedViper · 28/02/2023 14:31

The BBC article doesn't mention anyone with autism. And does say that four pupils have been suspended (not one). Also that the Quran was not treated with the respect.

This is a diverse school, and according to the article, the school is working with the suspended pupils t ensure they understand why their actions are unacceptable.

Because in a diverse society, it is wrong to act in the way they did. You don't have to share a faith to realise how utterly wrongheaded it is to act provocatively with something you know the others around you hold dear.

Chickenly · 28/02/2023 14:31

When I was a teacher, students bought a cake from the local shop and brought into school. They ended up throwing it in a corridor and making a mess, damaging some A Level artwork that was on display. The three students involved were suspended - there was religion involved.

In this situation, students brought something into school, fucked around with it and damaged it. Even if you exclude the fact they were behaving like little shits (no one dares someone else to bring in a Qaran unless they're being a little shit) and ignore any religious factor, the punishment isn't unreasonable. No child innocently dares someone else to bring a religious text into school. When I was in Y9, a guy in Y11 brought in a bible and made a video of him eating it.

I've also received death threats - multiple times. In fact, I received them from parents whilst working as a teacher so the holier than thou on this site need not look too far for the kinds of people who make death threats. I've received them a lot as a lawyer. They almost never have any valid threat behind them. To compare what Salman Rushdie went through (and is still going through) with a simple death threat (whilst both are scary) is ridiculous. It's comparing a broken nail to a broken leg.

Everanewbie · 28/02/2023 14:30

UdoU · 28/02/2023 14:22

That article is so biased. So four white boys brought the Quran as a dare into a West Yorkshire school that has Muslim kids and the Humanist is expecting us to believe they treated it respectfully?

What a load of crap. It's obvious they brought it in to kick around in front of Muslim kids to upset them. Whatever your views on religion, this was a shitty thing to do. If the Muslim kids had done this to the Bible there would have been cries of terrorism.

It was stupid, I'm not trying to pretend that the boys were sensible, but they are kids, children, immature by definition. Its a bollocking from the teacher and maybe a school assembly, even. But police? Engaging local faith groups? Death threats? Its ridiculous.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread