Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this round of teacher strikes have barely been noticed?

233 replies

Crunchymunchies · 28/02/2023 13:02

I know it’s regional, but I can’t find a thread here, only a brief mention on the BBC and even the daily mail it is way down.

is this a bad or good sign?

OP posts:
Nellodee · 01/03/2023 11:45

That’s the narrative that’s being pushed isn’t it? Those naughty public sector workers, wanting to push up inflation! Look at it another way - why they hell should the government be allowed to use teachers and nurses living standards as a tool to manipulate inflation. “It’s fine that we screwed over the country’s finances. We won’t pull it back by windfall taxes on the rich, or by any kind of wealth redistribution. No, let’s pull it back by screwing over health and education a bit more.”

There’s a point at which conditions in a job become so bad that not enough people want to do them anymore for the amount of money they pay. We’re already long past that point with teachers, nurses, care assistants, probably a shed loads more professions too. At this point, making the job less worthwhile also actively makes the service those jobs provide lower quality. Not enough nurses = crap healthcare. Not enough teachers = crap education. It’s very obvious.

Funny that the people fucking over our education and health service don’t actually use them anyway, isn’t it?

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 11:31

@Nellodee Exactly! But it’s still the fault of the striking workers, according to some short sighted people, rather than the Government who are causing this shit show!

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 11:29

@noblegiraffe these people won’t comment on those threads - can’t be blaming the Government 🤣 It’s the greedy teachers that are causing starving vulnerable children. 👀

Nellodee · 01/03/2023 11:29

Why are we supposed to expect everything getting worse, year after year after year? I’m not just talking about teachers, I’m talking about all of us. We should not sit back and see our living standards eroded whilst companies hand out bumper rewards to shareholders. Why should we, the workers, suffer, when those at the top are getting richer and richer? The FTSE 100 companies didn’t suffer in 2022, but the people working for them in the ground floor did. The energy companies didn’t lose out in 2022, but we all did. Why did we have to pay through the nose so they could reap record profits? The fuel aid we all received - that was a loan, not a gift. And it didn’t really come to us, it went straight to the energy suppliers. How is that fair?

We’re not all in this together. We’re ruled by people with more money than we can even imagine. Ask yourself, why did some of these people want Brexit so much? It’s so clearly shit for us, but lots of Tory’s are still invested in it, even now. What’s in it for them? We’re run by people who make decisions that fuck over the country for their own gain.

What’s wrong with wanting a country that invests in the health and education of its people? Don’t be fooled that the money to have these things isn’t there. It’s there alright. Is just lining the pockets of the rich.

The world does not have to be this way. The way we change it, as workers, is with solidarity against those who would rather set us against each other than have us see them as the parasites they really are.

Yes, I’m angry. Our shelves are bare, people are dying queued outside hospitals, our kids have no Sen provision, no subject specialists, cover teachers half the time, stuck in bigger and bigger classes, with worse and worse behaviour in schools that are crumbling over our heads. Yes, it’s all lost in one big story that Britain is going to shit. Britain IS going to shit.

And whose fault is that?

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 11:26

@Springchicken75 My comment is hyperbole but you’ve just compared a 2 day strike to a lockdown? 😂

Of course problems exist in all walks of life, that’s why I commented that there are higher instances of these issues in poverty stricken families. Not no issues in middle/upper class families - a higher prevalence of problems where poverty is an issue.

And you haven’t answered the key question- why is wanting enough money to pay bills, feed yourself and your family and heat your home greedy? Everyone deserves that, every single person in this country, regardless of profession. Unfortunately some professions, like teachers, are having to strike to achieve it.

noblegiraffe · 01/03/2023 11:17

Here’s a thread about vulnerable children going hungry, springchicken that you don’t seem to have commented on.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/guest_posts/4743312-800000-children-in-poverty-are-being-denied-a-free-school-meal-the-government-must-fix-this-injustice-immediately

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 10:54

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 10:13

@Springchicken75

99% of the problems you have quoted are poverty related! Instances of substance abuse, poor mental health outcomes, young pregnancies, experience of care, all these things happen more in low income and deprived families! Can money obliterate these things? Of course not. But it can help!

As for wanting more money - do you want your children taught by people who can’t pay their bills? And are experiencing the accompanying stress? Do you want to be on a train driven by a driver in debt who is suicidal? Do you want to be treated in our NHS system by a nurse who hasn’t eaten for 48 hours and is experiencing the related brain fog? None of the striking professionals in the UK are doing it for a bloody holiday home! Everyone needs to be able to pay their bills.

As for working with inconvenience, schools are there to support the children you so vehemently champion, not to be a convenient source of free childcare for the parents. I was one of those vulnerable children: were you? If not, I’d not comment on a vulnerability that you haven’t experienced. It’s offensive.

What total hyperbole.

Clearly you are the kind of blinkered person who thinks that all wealthy middle class children have perfect lives and none are exposed to drug addictions, alcohol dependency, domestic violence. It’s exactly this kind of very limited thinking and mindset that allows presumptions and stereotypes to continue. There are issues in every area of society and not just those on benefits/in deep poverty that are very clearly struggling.

I was indeed an off the radar neglected child, and school offered the only source of calm stability. I feel so sorry for vulnerable children having endured the awful pandemic and lockdown only to find themselves now ‘locked down again’ by greedy teachers.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 10:13

@Springchicken75

99% of the problems you have quoted are poverty related! Instances of substance abuse, poor mental health outcomes, young pregnancies, experience of care, all these things happen more in low income and deprived families! Can money obliterate these things? Of course not. But it can help!

As for wanting more money - do you want your children taught by people who can’t pay their bills? And are experiencing the accompanying stress? Do you want to be on a train driven by a driver in debt who is suicidal? Do you want to be treated in our NHS system by a nurse who hasn’t eaten for 48 hours and is experiencing the related brain fog? None of the striking professionals in the UK are doing it for a bloody holiday home! Everyone needs to be able to pay their bills.

As for working with inconvenience, schools are there to support the children you so vehemently champion, not to be a convenient source of free childcare for the parents. I was one of those vulnerable children: were you? If not, I’d not comment on a vulnerability that you haven’t experienced. It’s offensive.

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 10:00

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 08:56

@Springchicken75 I think your comments need directed towards your Government, not teaching staff. I’m only 32 - when I was at primary do you know who’s job it was to feed/clothe/heat/get me to school/do homework/provide extra curricular activities? My parents. Not my school! My school was there to educate me. And I was living below the poverty line and would be ‘vulnerable’ by todays standards. The Government needs to pay EVERYONE (not just teachers) enough money to care for their children adequately. And parents need to do their job and not assume the school will do it for them.

Do you honestly think you can ‘buy’ better parenting?!
Children are vulnerable due to an array of issues that are not money related: alcohol and/or drug addiction, poor mental health, young unsupported pregnancies, too much time in the care system, abuse, domestic violence - I could go on.

Many of these children won’t be ‘registered’ anywhere. They will simply be struggling silently. Many working families depend on school for their children to eat, to be warm.

Not everything boils down and can be fixed by this limitless stream of money you assume exists purely for your benefit.

In your world clearly all you care about is a pay rise for yourself, but trust me your strikes are just damaging vulnerable children.

Well cared for children will continue to thrive.
Most parents are used to working with inconvenience and stopped caring long ago about moany teachers. Most people generally could not care any less.
So that leaves the voiceless children that are not on the ss radar that need school for protection, warmth, security and stability they are punished because you want more money. Well done you.

Crunchymunchies · 01/03/2023 09:33

I know, I do say above that some will have partial closures.

OP posts:
Forever42 · 01/03/2023 09:11

I did find a list somewhere yesterday of fully closed schools , and it was only a handful and I think only one secondary. I guess some will have had partial closures though.

DfE have encouraged schools to open for "vulnerable" pupils. Those schools won't be classified as closed. Eg, the school I teach in is open for children with EHCPs and those with social care involvement. That's about 10 children out of 200 to be supervised by the Headteacher and support staff. It is classified as open though. My DC's school is open to Year 11 and Year 13 to come in and study independently but not be taught. It will still be recorded as open.

noblegiraffe · 01/03/2023 09:07

That 3% recommendation is a normal government process separate to anything going on with the unions.

Crunchymunchies · 01/03/2023 09:06

OK - thanks!

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 01/03/2023 09:03

Crunchymunchies · 01/03/2023 07:54

Didn’t you say there was a 3% increased from September, or was that Scotland?

Sorry, getting confused!

That was their recommendation to the independent pay review body, who will consider the evidence and make their recommendation back to the government who don’t have to accept it. It’s all a long, drawn-out and fairly stupid process as the independent review body basically recommend what the government wants them to.

Velvian · 01/03/2023 08:59

East Anglia here and it's a strike day. DD's school on strike, DS's is not, he was not impressed.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 08:56

@Springchicken75 I think your comments need directed towards your Government, not teaching staff. I’m only 32 - when I was at primary do you know who’s job it was to feed/clothe/heat/get me to school/do homework/provide extra curricular activities? My parents. Not my school! My school was there to educate me. And I was living below the poverty line and would be ‘vulnerable’ by todays standards. The Government needs to pay EVERYONE (not just teachers) enough money to care for their children adequately. And parents need to do their job and not assume the school will do it for them.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 08:53

I think it depends where you are - I’m a teacher in Scotland and every school (bar nurseries) is closed. That’s a big impact.

noblegiraffe · 01/03/2023 08:51

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 08:03

The teachers strike is a damp squib because ultimately there are others in far, far more need, many of whom have children that need school to eat, to be warm for the day and to be safe.

It shocks me the disregard for vulnerable children to secure yet more pay rises for themselves. The lack of awareness of real suffering and teachers contributing substantially to that suffering with these pointless strikes is largely ignored by those motivated by politics and/or greed on here.

The unions have largely failed in their attempts to strong arm the country into unaffordable pay rises. They can’t afford to continue indefinitely and have lost public support.

Wheeling out vulnerable kids as a concern only ever seems to happen on a day schools might be closed and never in evenings, weekends or holidays. It’s a pretty disgusting tactic.

In any event, many schools are making special provision for vulnerable children.

If you care about vulnerable kids you should be horrified at the actions of the government who don’t care about them enough to fund support or food for them, not teachers who regularly go above and beyond to support them.

Rae36 · 01/03/2023 08:35

I've noticed.

3 kids off here in Scotland for 2 days, another 2 days scheduled in just a couple of weeks time.

2 kids in exam years. Its really tough.

HappyAsASandboy · 01/03/2023 08:09

I've noticed - one of my children's schools is closed but the others are not! There is a lot of sibling resentment here this morning!

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 08:03

The teachers strike is a damp squib because ultimately there are others in far, far more need, many of whom have children that need school to eat, to be warm for the day and to be safe.

It shocks me the disregard for vulnerable children to secure yet more pay rises for themselves. The lack of awareness of real suffering and teachers contributing substantially to that suffering with these pointless strikes is largely ignored by those motivated by politics and/or greed on here.

The unions have largely failed in their attempts to strong arm the country into unaffordable pay rises. They can’t afford to continue indefinitely and have lost public support.

Crunchymunchies · 01/03/2023 07:54

Didn’t you say there was a 3% increased from September, or was that Scotland?

Sorry, getting confused!

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 01/03/2023 07:40

Crunchymunchies · 01/03/2023 07:08

I think a lot aren’t striking. I did find a list somewhere yesterday of fully closed schools , and it was only a handful and I think only one secondary. I guess some will have had partial closures though.

If teachers don’t strike, can the government rescind the original offer?

There wasn't an offer in England, there was a pay award. It has applied (i.e. been teachers' pay) since last September. Schools who have given that pay rise to teachers have had to take the money from other parts of the school budget to do so because the government only announced at the very last minute what the pay rise would be and that there wouldn't be any money given to schools to pay for it. Schools had already had to set their budgets for September by then, so had to make cuts (or not give the pay rise).

CarrieSmisher · 01/03/2023 07:30

Not much being said here, I'm in Scotland. Parents are used to it, nobody at work has mentioned it. I noticed some pickets outside a Stirling secondary school but they were gone by five past nine when I returned. I suppose we're all used to teachers complaining. I'm waiting on my pay award this year. It won't be 5% , or any percentage, across the board.

Copasetic · 01/03/2023 07:14

It's certainly having no impact here. Son (year 7) has had one strike day so far where some lessons offered online but his weeks are pretty full on with training every night after school so was quite welcome. Again tomorrow he will have a day at home and it'll give him a chance to do any homework he hasn't yet done etc. I'm actually all for a 4 day week! I actually will be working but I bet he has a nice day. He is lucky though that he is in an early secondary school year where the impact won't be felt too much. My daughter at uni is very much less happy when her lecturers strike!

Swipe left for the next trending thread