Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this round of teacher strikes have barely been noticed?

233 replies

Crunchymunchies · 28/02/2023 13:02

I know it’s regional, but I can’t find a thread here, only a brief mention on the BBC and even the daily mail it is way down.

is this a bad or good sign?

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 01/03/2023 12:45

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:36

@FourTeaFallOut not every region has open schools, every school in my local authority is closed yesterday and today which is why we are picketing the gates. Maybe @MistressIggi is the same.

This is reasonable. I think we're schools are closed it makes sense to protest outside of the place of work.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:43

@Nellodee billionaire overloads has made this thread for me 😅

For the people championing these vulnerable children that they so want to help and believe we are ruining their lives by striking, teacher recruitment was down 27%, I believe, this year.

Post Grad only takes 9 months, the Teach First program through your local authority can have you earning a salary in less than six months. If we earn as much for doing as little as some of you think, we should be turning you away really.

Nellodee · 01/03/2023 12:43

Seriously, how naive do you have to be to think millionaire public school boys want the best for state education and is those pesky selfish teachers who are fucking the kids over?

FourTeaFallOut · 01/03/2023 12:42

Give over with your nice try gibe. When you said the purpose of the picket was to prevent staff from entering the building and then it was job done, it wasn't clear there were no children in the building.

KievsOutTheOven · 01/03/2023 12:42

Firstofmarch · 01/03/2023 12:10

I feel like I’m protesting against the whole fucking set up. We need to kick these bastards out of government.

But you aren't kicking the government. Do you think Rishi gives a shit if you turn up to work or not?

You're kicking the care workers, the checkout assistants at Tesco, the self employed, the factory workers and the nursery nurses, who won't get paid if they don't show up.

That is who you are delivering a swift kick too. And they will not lobby their MP and complain and say "give these poor teachers more money as their strike has disrupted my life." They will stand in discontent crowds at drop off and pick up, they will mutter on WhatsApp and Facebook, their sympathy is not with you.

The thing is, teachers are also parents, they also are impacted by the strikes - for example, my kids school strikes on different days than mine, except I am physically not able to take a day off to cover it as we don’t have “holidays” in the way that other employees do, and parental leave policy does not apply as it is a “planned” closure (ie we knew about it so it’s on us to work out childcare)

Teachers are also not paid when they are on strike, and teachers are financially struggling too. Hence why we are striking.

Teachers don’t want to be on strike, but their pay has been cut by 24% in the past 15 years. In the same time, the workload has grown exponentially, to the point that I’m working over double my contracted hours most weeks. Often this means that I’m earning less than national minimum wage for each hour I work.

And before someone says it. No, we don’t HAVE to do that. We could regurgitate five year old lessons and we could not differentiate work for the increasing number of children who need it. We could leave our classroom walls blank. We could not read up on strategies for managing various learning barriers we have in class. We could not try and make our lessons engaging in the hope that it minimises the constant stream of low-level behaviour. We could not try to minimise the wealth divide in our classroom by organising supported study.

However, the only people that would suffer would be the children. We are striking because what we are doing now is untenable, especially for what we are paid.

We completely accept that we are fairly well paid in comparison to others (in terms of salary) and most teachers support strikes in other sectors too. Yet the narrative is constantly “lazy teachers work 9-3 and get 11 billion weeks of holiday, what about the poor …”

We have the power to strike over our own pay and conditions; teachers getting fairly compensated for their work sets the precedent for others to get a wage rise too.

The argument that “paying teachers 10% will drive up inflation” is a red herring. Less than 1% of the population of Scotland is a teacher. There are around 54,000 FTE teachers.

Lets assume that all of them are at the top of the pay scale, and there are no promoted teachers which is absolutely not true, but probably works out to a similar wage bill. this means teachers in Scotland cost £2,268,000,000 PA in a wage bill. (That’s 2.2 billion) against a budget of 4.1 billion for education, and a total budget of 56.5 billion against approx 50 billion spending.

The 10% pay rise amounts to approx £226,800,000. Which is a lot of money on a personal level, but when speaking about a country as a whole, it’s not much.

Nellodee · 01/03/2023 12:41

As far as I understand it, the argument goes that it’s private sector pay rises that push up inflation, not public sector ones. Either way, there’sa lot of wiggle room between the current offer and an inflation busting one. It could be funded, and not out of school budgets as well.
But well done to the posts saying that it’s teachers screwing over mums at the school gate. Your billionaire overlords will appreciate your support.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:36

@FourTeaFallOut not every region has open schools, every school in my local authority is closed yesterday and today which is why we are picketing the gates. Maybe @MistressIggi is the same.

MistressIggi · 01/03/2023 12:36

FourTeaFallOut · 01/03/2023 12:29

I thought most teachers who are protesting are doing so away from the school gates? There haven't been any picket lines outside of school gates here. So once you have demonstrated your feelings to the teachers who are working in your school and the school kids, the vulnerable ones who are invited in and the ones studying for exams, are you just going home?

Nice try. I'm in Scotland and replying to a post about a picket line in Scotland. There are no children coming in the building.
Pickets are held outside your workplace (and members of the public will see them if it's a busy place) but they aren't the same as rallies.
As to what we do afterwards - well no one is paying me anything today so what I do is up to me.

Heytheredaisy · 01/03/2023 12:29

Yazo · 01/03/2023 12:18

@Firstofmarch I agree with you mostly. And what of the teaching assistants? They're never going to be on £40k and many of them are fully qualified teachers. Never hear anything about them in the strike and many of them treated really badly.

This must be a regional thing? As our TAs require very minimal qualifications. I was one until 2019 but upskilled and left for an office job.

My TA colleagues rarely had GCSE C or above in Maths and English.

But yes they do deserve a pay rise.

FourTeaFallOut · 01/03/2023 12:29

MistressIggi · 01/03/2023 12:23

Back from today's picket line. Loads of public support, from a whole mixture of ages/sexes. Negative comments only from two passers by, including one in a BMW who didn't look like he'd be too negatively affected by the strike to be honest.
A pp mentioned the picket line near her being gone by just after nine. The primary purpose of the picket line is to do with workers entering the school building. They will all have been due in before then, surely?

I thought most teachers who are protesting are doing so away from the school gates? There haven't been any picket lines outside of school gates here. So once you have demonstrated your feelings to the teachers who are working in your school and the school kids, the vulnerable ones who are invited in and the ones studying for exams, are you just going home?

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:27

@Firstofmarch Last month in Scotland we had massive public support on the picket lines. Lots of people insulting the Government and campaigning the right to strike for all workers My school had parents and kids on the picket with us bringing hot chocolate etc! Same yesterday. Don’t be fooled into thinking that no public support lies with striking teachers, that’s a media narrative that the Government wants everyone to believe so that we feel bad and get our arses back into our chronically underfunded classrooms.

MarshaBradyo · 01/03/2023 12:24

Firstofmarch · 01/03/2023 12:10

I feel like I’m protesting against the whole fucking set up. We need to kick these bastards out of government.

But you aren't kicking the government. Do you think Rishi gives a shit if you turn up to work or not?

You're kicking the care workers, the checkout assistants at Tesco, the self employed, the factory workers and the nursery nurses, who won't get paid if they don't show up.

That is who you are delivering a swift kick too. And they will not lobby their MP and complain and say "give these poor teachers more money as their strike has disrupted my life." They will stand in discontent crowds at drop off and pick up, they will mutter on WhatsApp and Facebook, their sympathy is not with you.

I’d say it goes for women in other sectors too going by comments

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:23

@Yazo In Scotland, the members of the union of the school support staff (including what you would call teaching assistants) voted to strike several months ago. It was called off at the eleventh hour and they settled. In my setting and many others, teaching staff (including myself) were refusing to cross the picket line of the support staff if the strike went ahead. At the cost of our own days wage. Because we want everyone to have a fair wage and support the right of any union member to strike for that increase.

This is so much bigger than teachers. Everyone needs to be able to pay bills, feed and heat themselves. Only by showing our Government that we won’t accept this shit show will anything change.

MistressIggi · 01/03/2023 12:23

Back from today's picket line. Loads of public support, from a whole mixture of ages/sexes. Negative comments only from two passers by, including one in a BMW who didn't look like he'd be too negatively affected by the strike to be honest.
A pp mentioned the picket line near her being gone by just after nine. The primary purpose of the picket line is to do with workers entering the school building. They will all have been due in before then, surely?

bnotts · 01/03/2023 12:22

Secondary closed here in the East Mids. Primary class was closed last time but not this time but may well be on the 15/16th

ilovesooty · 01/03/2023 12:21

@Springchicken75 if you cared about these children you'd care about any pay rise being unfunded.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 12:20

@Springchicken75 it depends where you are, my school is closed for two days. This time. How many more times we do this depends on the Government. But to be honest even if it’s two days a month for the next year it still doesn’t compare to a global lockdown during a pandemic that killed people and that comparison is potentially very hurtful towards people who lost COVID victims. Your words matter.

Yazo · 01/03/2023 12:18

@Firstofmarch I agree with you mostly. And what of the teaching assistants? They're never going to be on £40k and many of them are fully qualified teachers. Never hear anything about them in the strike and many of them treated really badly.

DustbinDimberflake · 01/03/2023 12:15

Plumbear2 · 28/02/2023 13:09

There was a very short announcement on local news. But it's the Northern half of the country, you can bet it will have alot more coverage when it's the southern half 🙄

I'm in Wiltshire. All three of my children's schools are closed, and the one I work at.

Yazo · 01/03/2023 12:15

Schools were closed for a how long during covid..if there's anything most people can do it's keep the kids occupied and/or wfh when schools are shut for the odd day. We already do it the other 14 weeks of the year they're not open...so the impact on the economy or working parents is not massively disruptive. The impact is mostly on the kids and teachers. So not sure how newsworthy it is, although I hope the teachers get what they need to do the job

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 12:14

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 01/03/2023 11:26

@Springchicken75 My comment is hyperbole but you’ve just compared a 2 day strike to a lockdown? 😂

Of course problems exist in all walks of life, that’s why I commented that there are higher instances of these issues in poverty stricken families. Not no issues in middle/upper class families - a higher prevalence of problems where poverty is an issue.

And you haven’t answered the key question- why is wanting enough money to pay bills, feed yourself and your family and heat your home greedy? Everyone deserves that, every single person in this country, regardless of profession. Unfortunately some professions, like teachers, are having to strike to achieve it.

So are you confirming the strikes will be just two days?

Springchicken75 · 01/03/2023 12:12

Nellodee · 01/03/2023 11:45

That’s the narrative that’s being pushed isn’t it? Those naughty public sector workers, wanting to push up inflation! Look at it another way - why they hell should the government be allowed to use teachers and nurses living standards as a tool to manipulate inflation. “It’s fine that we screwed over the country’s finances. We won’t pull it back by windfall taxes on the rich, or by any kind of wealth redistribution. No, let’s pull it back by screwing over health and education a bit more.”

There’s a point at which conditions in a job become so bad that not enough people want to do them anymore for the amount of money they pay. We’re already long past that point with teachers, nurses, care assistants, probably a shed loads more professions too. At this point, making the job less worthwhile also actively makes the service those jobs provide lower quality. Not enough nurses = crap healthcare. Not enough teachers = crap education. It’s very obvious.

Funny that the people fucking over our education and health service don’t actually use them anyway, isn’t it?

So are you are saying all of these pay rises won’t push up inflation for everyone else? 🤔

Firstofmarch · 01/03/2023 12:10

I feel like I’m protesting against the whole fucking set up. We need to kick these bastards out of government.

But you aren't kicking the government. Do you think Rishi gives a shit if you turn up to work or not?

You're kicking the care workers, the checkout assistants at Tesco, the self employed, the factory workers and the nursery nurses, who won't get paid if they don't show up.

That is who you are delivering a swift kick too. And they will not lobby their MP and complain and say "give these poor teachers more money as their strike has disrupted my life." They will stand in discontent crowds at drop off and pick up, they will mutter on WhatsApp and Facebook, their sympathy is not with you.

Heytheredaisy · 01/03/2023 12:01

Our schools aren't striking and didn't last time either. So very unnoticed here!

Nellodee · 01/03/2023 11:59

And whilst I’m ranting, there’s another thing people don’t seem to take on board. There’s a tipping point, a cascade effect. When you don’t have enough workers, and you end up with a department of 5 doing the work of a department of 10, it becomes like a last man standing competition. Who’s going to leave and work in the Arab Emirates next? Who’s going to quit their nursing job and work on the bank, or leave the profession forever? Who’s on long term sick now? And the people left paddle faster, work longer, get more and more stressed as despite all this, they are forced to do their job less and less thoroughly.

Until they just CAN’T anymore.

I’m under no illusion that this is only happening to teachers. Or nurses. Life is bloody hard right now for a whole legion of people.

We’re doing something, anything, because we’re protesting things being this shit. I’m on strike. I don’t feel like I’m striking just as a teacher, to be honest. I feel like I’m protesting against the whole fucking set up. We need to kick these bastards out of government. We’re need to remember what a fucking terrible job they’ve done and we need to keep them out of power for a generation (preferably forever).

They are never in power for our benefit. Only their own. The world has too many problems that need collaborative solutions that benefit everyone. We’re can’t afford, either in monetary or in absolute existential terms, to run the world for the benefit of a handful of billionaires.

Swipe left for the next trending thread