Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to homeschool for a year just for a new house

187 replies

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 11:56

We’ve fallen for a new build which ticks almost all our boxes, and will be ready to move into this summer. We’d look to live here for at least the next 15 years.

The house is close to the office for both DH and I (we alternate wfh days) and also to DD1’s school.

However… DD2 will be starting Y6 in September and it wouldn’t be feasible for us to drive from the new house to her current school (total 2 hours driving back and forth each day).

As long as her 11+ results are as predicted, DD2 should be going to the same secondary school as DD1.

I don’t want her to start a new school in Y6 so I’m considering pulling her out of school altogether and homeschooling for the final year. Realistically this would mean Oak Academy for the 3 days I’m working, then I have 2 days off where we could do more “fun” and interactive learning.

She herself has said she wouldn’t mind missing out on her residential, final year performance and prom… but will she regret this? WWYD?

OP posts:
CatSpeakForDummies · 28/02/2023 12:32

Sorry, cross posted. Good luck with what you decide.

CatSpeakForDummies · 28/02/2023 12:31

She would have a lot less of a culture shock starting a new primary in Yr6 than being in a weird on-line bubble for a year and starting a new high school. She would get things like the show and residential- I can't understand your logic at all. She'll also make local friends, there's no downside if staying in current school isn't an option.

Florin · 28/02/2023 12:31

30 mins each way is totally doable for a year, I would leave her where she is and suck up the commute for the three terms it’s 195 days of commuting either that or move them for a year, my dh did that when he was a child and he didn’t find it a problem and it was nice getting to know some local kids before a few of them went to secondary school together in year 7.

Dodgeitornot · 28/02/2023 12:31

Also, saying they don't mind missing it and actually missing out are two different things. She has no idea what she's missing out on and you've really put her in a difficult position. She's 11, not an idiot. She'll know that her wanting to stay in her current school will mean no new house.
You need to put a brave face on and become excited at the prospect of a new school. I joined a school in y6 and it was the best thing my mum could've done. I made a few friends that went to my secondary and it made a huge difference.

Cheeping · 28/02/2023 12:30

We’ve fallen for a new build which ticks almost all our boxes, and will be ready to move into this summer.

No it won’t. Those dates are completely fantasy. They tell you a date to get you to exchange and then string you along for months and months and months knowing you can’t walk away. If they’re saying in February that it’ll be ready this summer then it probably won’t be ready until summer 2024 anyway.

But, yes, massively BU to jeopardise your DD’s education like this. How would you feel if you tanked her 11+ results by withdrawing her from education? What if she didn’t get into the good school as a result? Have you considered the knock-on impact of that for her future/education/degree/career/jealousy of her sister/resentment of you?

TheChosenTwo · 28/02/2023 12:30

Sorry but this sounds like a terrible idea. Home schooling definitely has its place but this is not it. You’d be doing this because you don’t want to drive her to school.
Oak Academy is okay here and there but I wouldn’t want to rely on that and that alone. 3 days a week of it being your primary ‘book learning’ isn’t much fun and lacks diversity. If you’re working who is going to debate things with her? Conversations are crucial to embedding learning.
I just think the whole plan is not beneficial for her overall.

mast0650 · 28/02/2023 12:29

I wouldn't do that. It doesn't sound as if you have thought about home schooling before and both want to do it for positive reasons. You are doing it for convenience and that seems wrong. You want to largely remove her from her school friends for a year without the opportunity to make new ones. Three days of online learning largely by herself. I really don't understand why you wouldn't just put her into the new school where she would presumably get to know some of the pupils she would start secondary school with and some children who live locally to the new house. What is the problem with this? Why do you see homeschooling as less disruptive?

Also, I'm not totally clear what "2 hours driving back and to each day" means. Do you mean the driving time for you is two hours (so only a 30 min journey) or do you mean the driving time for her is two hours (so a one hour journey). If it is the former I would keep her at the old school. You would be giving up just as much of your spare time on the home schooling. If it is the latter I would probably move her.

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 12:29

My parents moved me to a different school in Y6 and it didn’t go well at all – everyone had already formed very strong friendship groups by then and by the time I’d made some friends it was time to all split up and go to different secondary schools. I think my negative experience has made me not want her to go through the same thing.

In the current Y7 cohort of the grammar school we’d like DD1 to attend, the maximum number of students from the same primary school is 6; DD1 only had one other student from her year get in. So it’s unlikely DD2 would make friends with anyone in a new primary school who’d end up going to the same secondary school, unless she didn’t pass the 11+.

DD2 is currently one of the top if not the top student in her year group which is why she "should" pass the 11+, although I understand that there can never be any guarantees. She has a couple of friends but I wouldn’t say they’re best friends. Perhaps because she’s quite serious and studious; she can be a bit of a marmite child. And my taking her out of school for a year would make things even worse.

@sirzy and others you are absolutely right – this is a stupid thought just to do with convenience which is why deep down I know what we should do – thank you all so much for your feedback. It’s really widened my much too narrow perspective and shaken me out of this dilemma. The right house will come along when it's the right time, which most certainly isn't now.

OP posts:
Dodgeitornot · 28/02/2023 12:28

Oh I'd 100% send her to school. She'll make tons of friends and if not, than pull out and home ed for the remainder. It'll be quite lonely for her otherwise.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 28/02/2023 12:28

I absolutely would not do this. Far better to either move her so she can make friends and settle in with a new peer group and learning environment, or to maintain her in the old school however you can. If it's really only half an hour away then surely there are some transport options even if one option is paying for a taxi? I think on balance it would be better for her to move and start making new friends, because chances are that some of those kids will go to secondary school with her.

Also, I have a DD that age. No way would she sit quietly doing Oak Academy 3 days a week for a whole year. I'd spend my whole working day taking her off YouTube/fighting about bits of work she was supposed to be doing.

KarmaStar · 28/02/2023 12:27

Terrible idea,she would be suffering educationally and socially because it's more convenient to you.
Move her to a local school so she has friends already when starting high school and there will be induction days the primary school will arrange.
hope your love your new home!😀

neverbeenskiing · 28/02/2023 12:26

Completely missed the bit about 3 days of Oak Academy! OP, expecting a Year 6 child to teach themselves the majority of the curriculum with only some online resources, no direct teaching or adult support, not to mention a complete lack of social interaction 3 days a week, is unfair and unrealistic. Either find a school for her closer to the new house or put off the house move altogether and prioritise your child's education..there will be other new builds.

Briallen · 28/02/2023 12:25

No I wouldn’t do this. Is it 30 min to get current school so there and back twice a day is 2 hours? If so I would either drive her to school or if really not doable, start local new primary so she can make friends in the area. Asking a 10-11 to basically teach themselves for 3 days a week isn’t ideal

GPFavo · 28/02/2023 12:24

YABU.

You’re not even suggesting home schooling, you’re suggesting that you pull her out of school and put her in front of a screen playing shitty videos in a new location with no friends, social life or experiences. That’s not what home schooling is.

I’m also a tad confused how you’ve decided this is a calculated risk for a new build. They’re almost all identical, are struggling to sell and by the time one is sold five more have popped up. Just buy one that’s exactly the same on the development a mile down the road in a years time, surely? Is it even finished yet? My friends bought a new build and didn’t move in until over a year later than the original date given.

cryinginhmart · 28/02/2023 12:23

So you’ll leave her to do oak academy alone for 3 days and then do “fun stuff” with her in the hopes of getting her to maintain a standard to pass the 11+?

I’m going to be honest I think this is really shitty.

Dishwashersaurous · 28/02/2023 12:22

And a million times easier to start at a primary school where you know no one, compared to starting at a secondary where you know no one

PuttingDownRoots · 28/02/2023 12:22

DD did 4 terms in a primary school, then moved up lnowing lots of people. She had a lot of fun that year.

Do you mean the old school is only 30mins drive away? Lots of people do that sort of distance in rural areas.

PeekAtYou · 28/02/2023 12:21

You should check that any schools you would put on your application form don't have a feeder primary.

My ds started a new school in y6 and made friends who ended up going to the same secondary. He was not the only new student either.

Dishwashersaurous · 28/02/2023 12:21

Just put her in a new school for a year. She will then know people to start secondary with.
Year 6 is really important for the transition to secondary school

BitOutOfPractice · 28/02/2023 12:21

Why don't you want her to start a new school?

Crikeyalmighty · 28/02/2023 12:20

I would move her school . At that stage I think it will actually be less harmful than a year of home schooling

Littleflowerseverywhere · 28/02/2023 12:17

That doesn’t sound like home schooling to me. It looks like leaving her alone to get on with it, and spending the two days you are there doing fun stuff.

so it would be a no from me. Because that’s not home schooling/

lieselotte · 28/02/2023 12:17

We moved house in my final year of primary school and I changed schools for the last term and a half. I can't see the problem with changing for the whole year at all.

BishyBarnyBee · 28/02/2023 12:17

This would be really sad and lonely for your child. 3 days a week of Oak Academy while you work is no substitute for the experience of being in school with friends and having proper teaching.

It's not unusual for a child to start in Year 6, and while not ideal for her, much better than the home schooling proposal.

But I couldn't imagine wanting a house so much it would be more important to me than my child's wellbeing.

neverbeenskiing · 28/02/2023 12:15

I think you are underestimating the importance of a 'transition year' in terms of readiness for secondary. Most primary schools now do a huge amount of work preparing kids for how difficult secondary will be, they do this because so many kids (sometimes those who have been absolutely fine throughout primary) find it hard to adjust. Being out of school for a whole year and then suddenly going into a secondary environment where you don't know anyone is a very big thing. At least moving schools for Y6, while certainly daunting, would give your child the opportunity to make some local peer connections and better prepare them for secondary.