Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to homeschool for a year just for a new house

187 replies

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 11:56

We’ve fallen for a new build which ticks almost all our boxes, and will be ready to move into this summer. We’d look to live here for at least the next 15 years.

The house is close to the office for both DH and I (we alternate wfh days) and also to DD1’s school.

However… DD2 will be starting Y6 in September and it wouldn’t be feasible for us to drive from the new house to her current school (total 2 hours driving back and forth each day).

As long as her 11+ results are as predicted, DD2 should be going to the same secondary school as DD1.

I don’t want her to start a new school in Y6 so I’m considering pulling her out of school altogether and homeschooling for the final year. Realistically this would mean Oak Academy for the 3 days I’m working, then I have 2 days off where we could do more “fun” and interactive learning.

She herself has said she wouldn’t mind missing out on her residential, final year performance and prom… but will she regret this? WWYD?

OP posts:
AmandaJonah · 28/02/2023 13:11

Oak Academy is resources for teachers to plan lessons. So are you going to plan her lessons? Or do you just mean leaving her to muddle through by herself?

whattodo1975 · 28/02/2023 13:10

As child we moved houses when I was about to start year 6. My parents ferried me back and forth to the same primary for a year.

When I finished year 6 I went to the comp near to new house, and starting year 7 as a new kid with no primary school friends alongside me was tough, as every other child had at lease 15 or more other kids they already knew.

There was a great primary school 100 yards from our new house so no idea why they didn't move me, would definitely been the right call (although I would have protested at the time I imagine).

Also a year been shut in with just your parents for company cant do a child any favours.

redskydelight · 28/02/2023 13:09

You should home school because you see the benefits of homeschooling.

However it sounds like you actually just want to make things easier for yourself and will actually mostly leave DD to her own devices.

I'd personally leave her where she is and suck up the driving. Can you find a working space near her school so you don't have to drive back and forth?

BitOutOfPractice · 28/02/2023 13:09

@SenoritaFajita this is not how AIBU works! You’re not supposed to be DLL reasonable and take on board the advice 😆

do you know what word stuck out for me in your OP? Almost. The house ticks “almost all the boxes”. That doesn’t sound enough to me for you to turn everything upside down.

good luck with whatever you decide.

user1492757084 · 28/02/2023 13:09

Your child would miss out on social relationships and also physically with sport, apart from having an untrained teacher. Move to the new school.so she has a head start with friends and program for next year.

sonjadog · 28/02/2023 13:08

The obvious thing is for her to swap schools now. She is not you and your class you weren’t happy in in not her class. You are letting your own experience colour your decisions too much.

DreamBuilder · 28/02/2023 13:07

@SenoritaFajita currently have DS at grammar and he was home schooled pre starting school. For us it was absolutely feasible, with a huge home schooling community near us, we had zero concerns when it came to things like socialising etc.
I had my wobbles, wondering whether we were keeping up with standards in all areas. Well, I am truly shocked, DS is further ahead in all areas including humanities and sciences. It is doable, but of course it all depends on you, your family and community support.

Changing schools isn't always great, I changed schools in primary, fell like I was lost when it came to work and friends, hated school life in general after that.

Good luck with what you decide, but definitely find out about the local home ed community. and ask there (lots of Facebook groups too).

Relocatingrose · 28/02/2023 13:07

CatOnTheChair · 28/02/2023 12:11

DS1 started a new school in Y6.
It was fine, ad he went to secondary knowing at least a few people (we moved 3000 miles).
I wouldn't discount a new school for the last bit if primary.
What happens if she doesn't get the 11+ mark required?

Hats off to you! I'm too scared to move 300 miles up the road let alone 3000!

I used to be so brave and then I had DC and now I'm soft as shit. 😂

(Sorry for the derail!!)

IAgreeWithHim · 28/02/2023 13:03

Ostagazuzulum · 28/02/2023 12:01

If she goes to a local
primary school for year 6 then it might mean she has some local friends for summer hols and maybe know some people for when she starts secondary?

This makes sense to me.

FWIW though my DS1s school is 45 minutes (in light traffic) away and usually longer than that each way. He has additional needs which means he cannot go by bus.

We have managed to work it out for the past 5 years - it's a pain, but doable and he is only in Year 8 so we will be doing it until the end of his schooling. I take him in the morning and get home by 09.15 and then mostly wfh. DH picks him up in the evenings and then makes up the time if he needs. Granted we have (one) good employer but we are not the only parents doing that by any stretch. It might be possible to think of the logistics if you would only be doing tghat for one academic year?

very best of luck to you all.

BertieBotts · 28/02/2023 13:00

I moved schools in year 6 and it was fine - it's a good idea to contact the school in advance and find out if you need to sign her up for the residental while still in year 5, as it's a great bonding/independence experience.

SleepingStandingUp · 28/02/2023 12:56

So you don't work two days a week and then you and DH wfh across the week? I think you need to sort with work to keep taking her to her current school. It's 30 minutes each way.

Sharpbridge · 28/02/2023 12:55

Home schooling is NOT Oak Academy. Oak Academy is an online resource set up to help parents struggling through covid lockdowns. It cannot replace school, or good home ed (and, while impressive, much of Oak Academy was created in a huge rush, and isn’t great).

It is not possible to work and competently educate a yr 6 child unless you treat the 3 days you work as her weekend, hire an amazing nanny to keep her company and take her out and about for those 3 days, then you do full onhome education for the other 4 days ie you’ll be teaching her for the whole weekend, every weekend.

I’ve done home ed and it is much harder than you think, frankly after a couple of months ‘honeymoon period’ you get sick of the sight of each other. For a yr 6 child I would never recommend it unless there are serious problems ie SEN/bullying. A yr 6 child needs to be out and about away from her parents growing in independence and exploring the world, not stuck at home with mum.

When you say 2 hrs total a day do you mean school is only 30 min away, so 1 hr round trip in morning and same in afternoon? If so I know LOADS of parents who do that, and I also know several children who commute 50 min each way to school.

Best option is keep her where she is and commit to the long drive. If I have misunderstood you and it’s 2 hrs away (so 8 hrs driving per day) then you simply need to move her school for the final year.

Please don’t over-estimate yourself. You can’t teach yr 6 maths and science as well as a teacher, and sticking her in front if a computer for 3 days a week would do a huge amount of damage to her social development. You’d be setting yourself up for major social problems at secondary, particularly if she’s headed to a grammar school where she’ll need to be on the ball from day 1.

Firefly2023 · 28/02/2023 12:53

A few years ago it was very common for children to finish state juniors at 11 and take two years out before moving to the 13+ grammar here. Most of my DCs friends home schooled for those years. It avoided the children going to the local secondary (which didn't have a great reputation) or paying for private prep school. The time was used to intensively prepare for the 13+ exams to ensure success. Some also used it to travel and learn a foreign language. I know families that decamped to France for the intervening period and it worked well. If your DC is keen then I don't think she would be adversly impacted by it.

redspottedmug · 28/02/2023 12:52

Suck up the driving. We moved at the start of Year 13 for various reasons, and DC agreed providing they could stay at their current 6th form. It meant 9 months of DH and I doing work arounds to accommodate this.
In a nutshell, it wasn't their decision to move, there was no benefit to them and therefore as parents we had to make it as stress-free as possible for the DC.

Mariposista · 28/02/2023 12:46

OoooohMatron · 28/02/2023 12:15

This is probably one of the worst ideas I've ever heard. Either suck up the driving (2 hours is half an hour each way so nothing really), or move schools which is the most sensible option.

This

Littleflowerseverywhere · 28/02/2023 12:41

Just rent. But you really can’t take your kid out of school and leave her to teach herself whilst you do the fun stuff a couple of days a week. That’s terrible. And just as you didn’t have a good year six doesn’t mean she will. Goodness me.

Whiteroomjoy · 28/02/2023 12:40

restisall · 28/02/2023 12:00

How come you don’t want to put her in a new school for year 6? Moving away from her friends and not having the chance to meet new ones at school sounds quite isolating. Would she at least be in lots of clubs and things?

This. We moved our son in year 6. Not an issue

dont underestimate how important the social aspect of schooling is, especially after lock down. If she goes to a school local to where your dd1 school is then she’ll probably have got to know a few allies to go into secondary school with.

and you’ll also have reassurance if she doesn’t pass 11 plus then she
l also have already integrated with friendship groups to make that transation easier as well

dont isolate her at such a vulnerable age.

unless you have a teaching background or are passionate about the ethos of homeschooling and the sheer commitment it needs, don’t think it’ll be ok for you to stick her in front of some learning forum and do “interactive” stuff with her on your days off. You need to have a curriculum, lesson plans, aims, assessment, objectives…when are you going to do all this? You’re not doing this becuase you’re passionate about her education, but because of a house. Please don’t be so arrogant to think it’ll be ok you stepping in , in between work

DinnerThyme · 28/02/2023 12:39

I cannot express to you how quickly children lose the ability to do things that they do not practice. Even the summer holidays are a nightmare for teachers to get pupils back into routines, habits and basic classroom cognition.

If she spends months not using a pen, not practicing actually counting, not physically doing actual learning, she will not pass her 11+. The top of the class are not a year ahead of the bottom of the class. Furthermore, working all day is a skill and she will lose that skill. Asking someone to maintain a skill that they aren’t practising is really hard. Imagine playing an instrument and having it taken away for a year and then being expected to just start up again - you’re doing that with her ability to be at school all day. On top that, sitting in a chair all day will damage her posture, staring at a screen all day will harm her eye sight and cause headaches, wearing earphones all day will damage her ears…

Dishwashersaurous · 28/02/2023 12:39

And if she's not particularly happy at her current school then even more reasons to move.

Plus although she'll probably pass the 11 plus there are no guarantees. She could feel unwell on test day and not perform well etc

2bazookas · 28/02/2023 12:39

Unfortunately "home education" requires "home teaching", and teaching is a full time job all on its own ; the planning, the preparation, the face to face explanations, support, supervision, repetitions, follow up, asking and answering questions.

That's why teaching isn't a WFH job we can do in pyjamas while simultaneously conducting an international zoom meeting, banging dinner in the oven, playing with the cat and answering the doorbell.

Dishwashersaurous · 28/02/2023 12:37

Just because you had a horrible year 6 experience doesn't mean she will.

Take the dream house.

Move school.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 28/02/2023 12:37

I have friends who moved into a new build last year. It was about 8 months later than they originally thought it would be, and they sold their house and ended up in limbo. They had to move into a flat in the city - our little town hasn't got much in the way of short-term rents. They drove 40 mins in each direction twice a day for 8 months to take their kids to school, because they had to. It was hard and they were exhausted by the end of it. They were stuck because any other option would have meant moving the kids twice. I would actively avoid both homeschooling while trying to work yourself (are you mad? Have you forgotten lockdown?) and the drive if you can help it.

lunar1 · 28/02/2023 12:37

I would do the trip to her existing school for a year, otherwise it's a huge disruption to her just for convenience.

You never know how school is going to pan out, if something happens in the future meaning you don't have a choice to move her, you would regret this one.

I'd never move a happy, settled child unless there was absolutely no choice.

GloomyDarkness · 28/02/2023 12:37

I don’t want her to start a new school in Y6 so I’m considering pulling her out of school altogether and homeschooling for the final year.

DD1 was Y6 when we moved work and secondary related it worked really well for her got her (knowing people before secondary, small cohort fun teacher and got her away from some low level bullying) - it was a completely new area so no hope of traveling to old school. So it could work - otherwise I'd pass on the house or commute back for a year.

Home school can and does work I'm just not sure your plan for it is that great or well thought through especially if the 11+ is looming.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 28/02/2023 12:37

Have you researched a local home ed community? She'll need to meet up with people regularly. You can normally do better at home than at school, but you would need to be very committed.