Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to homeschool for a year just for a new house

187 replies

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 11:56

We’ve fallen for a new build which ticks almost all our boxes, and will be ready to move into this summer. We’d look to live here for at least the next 15 years.

The house is close to the office for both DH and I (we alternate wfh days) and also to DD1’s school.

However… DD2 will be starting Y6 in September and it wouldn’t be feasible for us to drive from the new house to her current school (total 2 hours driving back and forth each day).

As long as her 11+ results are as predicted, DD2 should be going to the same secondary school as DD1.

I don’t want her to start a new school in Y6 so I’m considering pulling her out of school altogether and homeschooling for the final year. Realistically this would mean Oak Academy for the 3 days I’m working, then I have 2 days off where we could do more “fun” and interactive learning.

She herself has said she wouldn’t mind missing out on her residential, final year performance and prom… but will she regret this? WWYD?

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 28/02/2023 13:50

OP how much time have your spent watching Oak Academy lessons?

We tried in lockdown and both DCs lost interest very quickly indeed. to be fair SOME of the lessons were good but some were delivered in a monosyllabic tone and were the most mundane things I've ever had the misfortune to sit though. Even I lost the will to live on the subject of the Norman Conquest and my degree is in History. Also don't forget Oak Academy may deliver lessons but to the best of my knowledge offer no feed back on what work is done

A whole year with no local friends, no academic feedback, no group work,, not a lot of social interaction, a lot of rather boring screen time and a looming 11+ exam.. I'd see that as a recipe for a mental health breakdown.

Please either find her a school or look into what real home education consists of and do it properly

Aphrathestorm · 28/02/2023 13:46

Half an hour there half an hour back is nothing!

I thought you meant it took 2 hours to get there!

That's a normal drive to a hill ime.

This is one of the most bonkers ideas I've ever heard on mn.

QuimReaper · 28/02/2023 13:44

For different reasons, I did Y6 at a different primary than I'd been at for the rest of my school life. It had no real impact on who I hung out with at secondary school (as far as I recall), but I had a blast at the new school, and still value the friends and memories I made that year.

SimplySipping · 28/02/2023 13:44

Let her try the new school. You can always move to online school if it doesn't work out.

mindutopia · 28/02/2023 13:43

I would start her in the new school. We moved at the end of Y4 and my dd literally had like 5 new best friends after about a week. It was such a smooth transition and she was really happy in her new school. I would feel sad to think of her having missed out on those friendships and the fun she's had.

Daisies246 · 28/02/2023 13:40

As a result of a house move, my niece started a new school at the end of year 5 (a couple of weeks before the end of term) and was there for year 6. She was very happy there. No harm in starting a new school at that point.

crazycrofter · 28/02/2023 13:40

@SenoritaFajita bear in mind that people on mumsnet are generally very conservative and like to do things 'the right way'. There's a lot of scepticism about home ed and people do think you can only really learn in a school. It's not true! You'd be amazed at how much time is wasted in school (and this is something my ds still moans about in year 12!). There are also loads of great resources, you don't need to use Oak Academy. Mystery Science was great - lots of really interesting videos and experiments to try. Conquer Maths was also very good and clear and we also used Khan Academy for Maths, as it's free. The home ed days at our local science museum (Think Tank in Birmingham) were brilliant and the Shakespeare Centre in Stratford also did some interesting days, like a hands on archaelogy day.

Hayliebells · 28/02/2023 13:36

Why miss out on the house of your dreams, for the sake of a bit of extra driving? If you work from home, it's just like adding an hour's commute each way to your day, which is what many thousands of people routinely do. Presumably DD1 can get themself to school, being Secondary age, so you only need to drive DD2. I wouldn't homeschool for a year, no way, and I understand why you don't want to move schools. But I would definitely drive DD2 to their own school, once the move is finalised. And I my experience of new builds is anything to go by, it won't actually be completed on schedule, so you may well not need to do the drive for that long anyway.

user1471538283 · 28/02/2023 13:35

Y6 is the year that they all are getting ready for high school. Even with this support from the school, my DS struggled initially to adapt to high school because it is so different from primary. And it gave him chance to say goodbye properly to his friends (he was going to a different high school to most of them). I know it's a long old way but I would still take her.

crazycrofter · 28/02/2023 13:35

@SenoritaFajita I'm going to go against the grain here as we did something similar. We actually pulled ds out of school before we moved (June of year 4) because he was unhappy. We finally moved house in the November of his year 5 and I thought about moving him to a local school. But we knew he was going to try for grammar like his sister, and to be honest the local comps weren't great, so we probably wouldn't have sent him to one if he'd not got into the grammar. So there wasn't a massive benefit to him going to a local primary , as it was unlikely anyone else in his class, other than maybe 1 or 2, would be going on to one of the grammars, as they're superselective round here.

I think what people are also missing is that year 6 is really tedious (our daughter was never home schooled) - loads and loads of SATS practice and only a tiny bit of fun at the end of the year. We spent the end of year 5 prepping ds for his 11 plus, but other than that, he had a much more relaxed year 5 and 6 than he would have done at school, did lots of trips (with parents and with the home ed community - there's huge amounts of stuff organised round here) and probably spent half an hour to an hour on 'school work' each day. He coped with year 7 in grammar school fine. He didn't know anyone else going and he had a long journey on the bus, but he adapted easily. I think he was more confident socially than his peers who'd just been at primary, as he was used to meeting people.

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 28/02/2023 13:34

We moved half a term into year 6. The year 6 DC coped fine, and although it sounds like awful timing it was actually good. His new class knew each other well (too well), same as he was stuck in some slightly unhealthy friendships in his old school, so a bit of fresh blood from both perspectives was good. He then knew people going into year 7.

Regarding school work, it was so similar, as I think all schools do basically the same thing (even though on paper school 2 was better) that it didn’t impact him at all. Only thing was the DC did a couple of topics they’d already done (eg the solar system) and missed a couple out.

He said it took 2 weeks to settle into school after the long covid lockdown, but 2 days to settle into his new school.

I’d only ever home school if it was to the benefit of the child.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 28/02/2023 13:30

How can you work from home and homeschool at the same time? Sounds impossible and also pretty sure your employer wouldn't approve.

Suck up the drive (or could she get a bus?) and keep her at school for the year.

FeebasAquarium · 28/02/2023 13:29

We moved mid year 6 (March) and our twins started the new school as soon as they could, absolutely no regrets.

As it was a feeder school for the secondary we wanted the friends they made then they’re still friends with now (year 8), also due to covid restrictions being removed around the same time, they got a chance for the residential, year 6 play and ‘prom’.

It wasn’t without bumps initially but I’m really glad the had the chance to finish primary with friends. And day one of secondary school was a lot less daunting.

mondaytosunday · 28/02/2023 13:28

No way could l home school my kids as I don't have the patience or knowledge (I am educated through masters degree but they teach things differently and my focus is narrow). But I don't know what Oak Academy is - online? Would she be at home alone all day those days?

Newtoadhd · 28/02/2023 13:27

We did similar for a while so if it really is a dream house I'd see if I could make it work. Our move was for dh work but ds really wanted to finish his final year at his old school.

For the first term until the Christmas holidays ds and I stayed in our old area in an air bnb on weeknights. Drove down on a Monday morning, home on Friday afternoon. Our school finished St lunchtime on a Friday so back home nice and early.

After that we did a mix of driving with me hanging around working in libraries and cafes in the old area and the odd night in an air bnb. It was an hour each way so we left home at 7.30am and were back by 4.30ish. That was annoying for me, I've never drunk so much coffee. But the time in the car was quite nice.

The spring term actually passed quite quickly with bank holidays, a week of school camp, and just knowing it was nearly over. And the odd sick day (but don't tell anyone).

It wasn't massively fun, it cost a bit, but we managed and after that time we were all in the same place in our lovely house and we've never moved since.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 28/02/2023 13:26

Move her to another primary. We moved, admittedly in year 5 to avoid middle school. DD made lots of new friends and moved up to secondary with them. Had a fab year 6 with party, residential etc. I think DD will regret missing year 6.

JennyDarlingRIP · 28/02/2023 13:25

Can you have a frank conversation with the developer about time lines, explain that you're not in a rush and would prefer to know if there were going to be delays as that would actually be of benefit to you
These things rarely run to time.
If it is going to be ready this summer I would move her or suck up the commute for 9 months

GloomyDarkness · 28/02/2023 13:20

but definitely find out about the local home ed community. and ask there (lots of Facebook groups too).

This is probably worth looking at - I think there is a board on here as well.

However if you do home school I think it will need more of a plan than Oak Academy 3 days while you work - there are on-line schools you could check out and if she was signed up for local clubs to keep her social skills that could also work.

Catcharolo · 28/02/2023 13:19

No way. Put her in the school closest for a year. She’ll have a horribly lonely year at home. Y6 is a brill year! You get 11plus out the way by October and then it’s fun, friendships, sleepovers..it’s an important one, it marks the transition between being a proper primary aged child to becoming an more independent tween.

chopc · 28/02/2023 13:18

I would go for the new house and new school. If she doesn't get on , you can pull her out and homeschool

TenoringBehind · 28/02/2023 13:15

she will almost certainly be fine with a change of school.

even if you decide against that, surely 2 hours driving a day is going to be much easier for you than home schooling. Also factor in the impact of not socialising with other children.

Xmasbaby11 · 28/02/2023 13:14

There are some good reasons for homeschooling, but this isn't one. I think you'd both quickly regret it.

I can't see the problem in moving primaries in Y6 so I'd just do that. It'll make starting secondary easier too.

Bramshott · 28/02/2023 13:14

Honestly - lots of kids move schools during primary (many more than in the past), including at the start of and even during Year 6. Don't let your past bad experience influence what's right for your DD.

ManchesterGirl2 · 28/02/2023 13:12

mast0650 · 28/02/2023 12:29

I wouldn't do that. It doesn't sound as if you have thought about home schooling before and both want to do it for positive reasons. You are doing it for convenience and that seems wrong. You want to largely remove her from her school friends for a year without the opportunity to make new ones. Three days of online learning largely by herself. I really don't understand why you wouldn't just put her into the new school where she would presumably get to know some of the pupils she would start secondary school with and some children who live locally to the new house. What is the problem with this? Why do you see homeschooling as less disruptive?

Also, I'm not totally clear what "2 hours driving back and to each day" means. Do you mean the driving time for you is two hours (so only a 30 min journey) or do you mean the driving time for her is two hours (so a one hour journey). If it is the former I would keep her at the old school. You would be giving up just as much of your spare time on the home schooling. If it is the latter I would probably move her.

Agree that half an hour each way every day is doable, for a year. Get some good podcasts and audioboojs, or use the time to chat with her.

FlamingoQueen · 28/02/2023 13:12

There are always children that move schools in Y6. At least then she will be with her friends.

Swipe left for the next trending thread