Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to homeschool for a year just for a new house

187 replies

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 11:56

We’ve fallen for a new build which ticks almost all our boxes, and will be ready to move into this summer. We’d look to live here for at least the next 15 years.

The house is close to the office for both DH and I (we alternate wfh days) and also to DD1’s school.

However… DD2 will be starting Y6 in September and it wouldn’t be feasible for us to drive from the new house to her current school (total 2 hours driving back and forth each day).

As long as her 11+ results are as predicted, DD2 should be going to the same secondary school as DD1.

I don’t want her to start a new school in Y6 so I’m considering pulling her out of school altogether and homeschooling for the final year. Realistically this would mean Oak Academy for the 3 days I’m working, then I have 2 days off where we could do more “fun” and interactive learning.

She herself has said she wouldn’t mind missing out on her residential, final year performance and prom… but will she regret this? WWYD?

OP posts:
thymee · 28/02/2023 15:16

You should either move her to a new school, or find a way to fit in the travel to keep her at her current school, or not move at all.

Don't do the home schooling thing, that sounds rubbish for her.

RachelSq · 28/02/2023 14:59

Why would you do this for a year?!?

Get her enrolled in the local school, a year is a very, very long time.

Kennykenkencat · 28/02/2023 14:56

We had a terrible time trying to find a school for Ds for year 6.

Lots of schools saying they would take him if forced to but…..

I do agree with going into a new school for year 6 as it will give her a chance to make friends and have a network when going into year 7

Stompythedinosaur · 28/02/2023 14:44

For a school half an hour away, I'd try to got her there if I could. That's closer than my closest school! Arranging some local childcare might help if it is the timings of the pick ups that is making it difficult.

If it really absolutely isn't possible, then I'd try a local school.

While I have no problem with homeschooling when this is an active choice, I wouldn't homeschool a dc who is used to school and getting on well there for a single year.

I mean, if you have the time to home educate, surely you have the time to take her to her current school?

SenoritaFajita · 28/02/2023 14:43

Thanks to the many responses I've had I'm now absolutely sure I won't be homeschooling DD2, but for the purpose of tying up loose ends...

DD2 and I had done a rough calculation of the hours of learning she does at school - minus lunch/playtime/assemblies etc. she has approx. 3.5 hours of lessons a day, so I was initially thinking of using a mixture of Oak Academy (plus any other Home Ed resources?) from 9:00 until 12:30, my work is flexible so I would’ve been able to give her some time during my working day (similar to during lockdown) and catch up on my work in the evenings - although I hadn't really thought about it in that much detail. We would not leave DD2 on her own at home, ever.

The drive back and forth from the "new house" to the current primary school would be 30 minutes each way, totally 2 hours of driving each way - as many of you have pointed out, this isn't a lot at all, I think we've just been too spoilt as at the moment we only live a 2 minute walk away - so shamefully I baulked at the idea of driving 2 hours a day. I've told myself to suck it up!

To those that have mentioned that I shouldn't let my experience of Y6 put me off changing primary schools for DD2 now - I think it's also because there are currently a few really mean girls in her class and I don't want her to meet new mean girls (better the devil you know I suppose) But looking at it from a different angle, perhaps she might meet some really nice new friends in a new school.

OP posts:
Brokendaughter · 28/02/2023 14:42

I am very pro home education in the right circumstances, have one adult child who was home ed & one teen who is now home ed.

Oak Academy by itself is NOT going to be enough, so where is the majority of this education going to come from?
At that age, a child will need a lot of hands on time from an adult, so are you going to be doing that?

You cannot expect a child that age to buckle down & study in isolation for a year during the day while you get on with your work.

It doesn't seem like this is actually about the best interests of your child & their education.

Your child seems to be thriving in a school environment & has expressed no desire to be home ed.
To base this decision on your desire not to do a long drive seems all about you.

If you can't find the time to get your child to school, how are you going to get the time to educate them?

Who is going to educate them on the days you are at work?

Pipsquiggle · 28/02/2023 14:35

Curtainsorblinds · 28/02/2023 14:31

Move house and just drive her the 30 mins each way!

Yes - this!

Get her in breakfast clubs and afterschool clubs. Or move her to a local school

I didn't realise it's only 30 minutes away - it's only for a year and you'll be in your dream house.

The pandemic taught me that I could never home school

Fcuk38 · 28/02/2023 14:32

You can’t leave her in front of a screen for 3 days whilst you work that’s not home schooling. Just send her to school. Why don’t you want her to go. Does she want to go to the new school for year 6? She’s not going to get any friends to go up to the school with if she’s kept at home.

Curtainsorblinds · 28/02/2023 14:31

Move house and just drive her the 30 mins each way!

Grimbelina · 28/02/2023 14:31

If it really is the perfect house, why not buy it and rent it out for a year and rent near your daughter's school while she finishes year 6... or if you can afford it your DN and DD1 stay in the new house and you rent with DD2 Mon to Thurs during term time?

Magnoliasunrise · 28/02/2023 14:30

Aphrathestorm · 28/02/2023 13:46

Half an hour there half an hour back is nothing!

I thought you meant it took 2 hours to get there!

That's a normal drive to a hill ime.

This is one of the most bonkers ideas I've ever heard on mn.

Totally this - I regularly had an hours round trip school run in the morning when my kids were at different schools, it is nothing. They used to practise spelling and singing in the car etc.
Really mean to pull her out of last year at primary whatever she says.
Your new house will probably be delayed and then it wont even be a year more like 6 months?
Then everyone is a winner.

ShakinSteven · 28/02/2023 14:27

Have you decided against this move then?

I would not keep a child out of school because I was worried they weren't going to make friends. They're definitely not going to make friends at the kitchen table. And that generation have had more than enough social isolation.

GloomyDarkness · 28/02/2023 14:27

think what people are also missing is that year 6 is really tedious

Possibly another reason DD1 did well with move as we moved to wales away from all the SATs preparation in Y6.

YukoandHiro · 28/02/2023 14:27

How would personally feel if she doesn't do well at the end of the year/in the 11+? Would you blame yourself?
I moved primary schools twice and it did really disrupt me and my education so I do understand you not wanting to start her somewhere else just for one year.
When you say it's an hour's drive, is it half an hour there, half an hour back? If so could you afford you pay a cab for her half the week and share the other picks and drops with Dh?

redskydelight · 28/02/2023 14:25

crazycrofter · 28/02/2023 13:40

@SenoritaFajita bear in mind that people on mumsnet are generally very conservative and like to do things 'the right way'. There's a lot of scepticism about home ed and people do think you can only really learn in a school. It's not true! You'd be amazed at how much time is wasted in school (and this is something my ds still moans about in year 12!). There are also loads of great resources, you don't need to use Oak Academy. Mystery Science was great - lots of really interesting videos and experiments to try. Conquer Maths was also very good and clear and we also used Khan Academy for Maths, as it's free. The home ed days at our local science museum (Think Tank in Birmingham) were brilliant and the Shakespeare Centre in Stratford also did some interesting days, like a hands on archaelogy day.

I don't think that's strictly true (there are an awful lot of people on MN who home ed themselves, for example).

I think most people realise that home educating can work very well. But equally that expecting your 10 year old child to self learn for 3 days a week on their own, is not an example of it working well.

SalmonSandwiches · 28/02/2023 14:24

I think my main concern would be that you can't be bothered to drive her half an hour each way, that isn't very far.
I'm not sure that is the best reason to home educate.

YouOKHun · 28/02/2023 14:21

DD2 is currently one of the top if not the top student in her year group which is why she "should" pass the 11+, although I understand that there can never be any guarantees

I know quite a few people who have been disappointed when their academically very able child struggles on the day due to some variable or other. I’m sure other more knowledgable posters can correct me if I’m wrong but isn’t the pass mark for 11+ and a place at grammar school based upon how the whole cohort in a given year does, rather than being top of a particular class? You are not competing against the child sitting next to you but against (among others) the tutored and the prep schooled AND tutored? That’s how tricky it is in Kent where I am. A year out from classroom teaching and the social side at that age would be pretty catastrophic I’d have thought? Better to be in a new school than at home. I think you’ve decided against it in a later post which is probably wise!

SalmonSandwiches · 28/02/2023 14:21

Hmm...
I have conflicting thoughts. Home education can be amazing, some Home Ed provisions aren't fit for purpose. There would definitely be worse provisions than this. I feel this is sort of somewhere in the 'ok'/somewhere between the 2. And at this point, children who have been Home educated from the start or at least a few years would be moving into more independent learning / given assignments. And you are there the other 2 days. I think it depends on the child ad to how this would work, and I suppose it is only a year.
I'm not familiar with Oak Academy, so no idea how good the resources are. Probably best combine it with some CGP books for good measure?
Could you afford an online school? I feel like this would be best with the circumstances. Does she attend any clubs? Could you take her to a home ed meet once a week?

Hankunamatata · 28/02/2023 14:20

I'd move primary schools. If it doesn't work out you could then home school

Lcb123 · 28/02/2023 14:10

I changed schools in year 6. If it helps I have excellent grades, a first class BA and a masters. didn’t go to grammar school. I think staying in a school is better than home schooling when you haven’t done that before

Pipsquiggle · 28/02/2023 14:10

There are 3 DC that have joined my DS's Y6 class this year - all seem to be doing great.

Have you actually gone to see the local primary schools near your dream house and spoken to the head teachers?

I would have thought it would be good to meet other local DC.

I understand that you had a shit time when you moved in Y6 but that doesn't mean that your DD will

bellswithwhistles · 28/02/2023 14:09

Awful idea.

Move your daughter to a different school to finish Year 6 if you can't be arsed travelling - but given you WFH at times, I'd say you're being incredibly mean to your daughter. I would let her stay at her existing school.

I drive 2 hrs a day doing the school run. So what. It's not for ever and the kids need it.

ittakes2 · 28/02/2023 14:01

I am very confused - is your DD1 not at this school at the moment? Are you driving her 2hrs there every day?

Bluevelvetsofa · 28/02/2023 13:56

Put her in school for Year 6. If she doesn’t get the grade needed for 11+, you’ll need to look at local secondary schools. It’s great that she’s very able, but she’s pretty much going to be home learning on her own, whilst you work, so won’t have professional input. Unless you’re going to have her tutored as well.

Your experience probably won’t be her experience and she’ll make friends, some of whom will go to the same secondary.

Christmascracker0 · 28/02/2023 13:52

Surely it would be better for her to go to a local primary for the rest of the year? That way she will have some friends going into secondary school.

Also if both DDs start a new primary school together they will at least have each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread