Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Company wants me to pay back holiday days.

562 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 09:55

I started in a job in November 2022. We have an online annual leave system .
At the start of January 2023, 21 days on our online system became available to me for me to take.

I asked my manager could I take two weeks off at the start of the year. I took the last week of January and the first week of February off. This was approved by my manager. I took them. I was then moved to a new manager. Which was the way the company worked. New starters were with one manager. After two months you were changed to another manager

The company was pretty abusive and at the end of February I decided to leave.

I left. I then got an email from my second manager saying I had taken more annual leave days in the time I worked there, then I had accrued. And that I have to pay this annual leave money back. It is 550 euro. I'm in Ireland. This is a lot of money to me as i am now in between jobs.

Can they do this. My first manager who approved the annual leave days, never told me that I did not have enough annual leave days to take. She approved them. She never told me at any stage that if I left the company that I would have to pay these annual leave days back. If I had known that I wouldn't have taken them .

Can they do this to me now?

OP posts:
mushroom3 · 28/02/2023 15:03

Were you member of a union? If so I would contact them about the work conditions and that you had to leave due to these.

YellowDaffodillie · 28/02/2023 15:01

I would speak to an employment specialist before agreeing to any repayment plan.

If you’ve worked extra hours unpaid that effectively takes you below minimum wage, then you have a valid counter claim and should argue that the company owes you money.

In the meantime, report them to the Revenue for the outstanding tax that they haven’t paid from all the hours owed to you.

ErinAoife · 28/02/2023 15:01

21 days available were for the full year. If you left the company and took more annual leave you need to repay the company that is pretty standard.

Wheresthebeach · 28/02/2023 14:45

At the very least get them to agree to a payment plan rather than agreeing to pay in one hit.

momtoboys · 28/02/2023 14:40

We have something similar happening in my office but the person is still employed here. Individuals need to take accountability of knowing what benefits are allotted to them (especially in the beginning of a new job) and not just depend on a piece of paper.

Isthatyourname · 28/02/2023 14:39

Oh this thread is chaos !

I feel for you OP as that is a horrible situation. I’d ask for a copy of my contract just to confirm it is in there but like everyone has said it probably is.

I would suggest asking them if you can pay back in instalments as you can’t pay them what you don’t have. Ideally it would have been better to not leave without notice either as they could deduct that too, but we live and learn. Good luck for job hunting.

redastherose · 28/02/2023 14:37

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:26

Yes I agree it's not great to quit with no notice. I wouldn't have quit if I hadn't been broken down. But I wish now I'd thought about it a lot more before I'd do done it. I've never quit any other job. Ive def learned not to quit on a bad day again. As it will only hurt me more in the end

@Coffeellama if your system is really as you have described and the workload that ridiculous then the best thing you could do is contact the Employment Service and raise a complaint and claim constructive dismissal due to excessive working conditions. This may force the company to re-think trying to recoup the annual leave monies from you. In any event I would also email your manager and the managers manager and say that you are going to do this as it may also prompt them to allow you to leave without any repercussions.

JoeMaplin · 28/02/2023 14:37

Ah the rest of the posts have now appeared on my phone, before it was only showing the first few pages - I can see you are now aware of this. It definitely sounds like you are better off out of there, what a horrible place!

Unfortunately we live and learn by our mistakes. I do hope you find somewhere that appreciates you soon.

DancyNancy · 28/02/2023 14:36

Sounds like a stressful company. I can almost guess which one!

Annual leave is based on time worked as you know. Some companies do allow you to take more than currently worked up, usually done in good faith. Usually if someone hands in their notice , they will work a notice period. The holidays overpaid would be deducted off the final payslip. That's probably why you don't hear too many people owing physical money back.

It sounds like you quit outright and gave no notice? Unfortunately because that was also on pay day that left you in a negative balance.

Could you just work out the hours that you owe back? They are obviously desperate for staff so might accept that offer.
Horrible I know but if you haven't got a new job yet at least it would mean you are not paying out money from savings.

Google "Citizens Information" online and they have all the information about employment rights and entitlement. It's a good idea so you can manage these situations in future. It also holds information about breaks etc.

Employers must abide by the laws but it's not their responsibility to educate employees on it, so it's best to inform yourself and be prepared.

Best of luck I hope you find a way to work it out and be done with it. And I hope you find a nicer environment in the next job!

JoeMaplin · 28/02/2023 14:33

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 10:02

Yes but they never informed me about any of this at any stage.

I was a bit naive as I had been off work for a while. So when I saw I had 21 days available to take, I just thought I could take them at any stage of the year.

I asked my manager could I take the annual leave at that stage. Surely she should have said : you only have so much annual leave built up, so you can only take 2 days?

Why let me take two weeks?
And why not inform me at any stage that If I left the company I would have to repay these hours.

Surely it is their responsibility to tell me that if I leave the company I will have to repay these hours.

If I had known that, I wouldn't have taken the annual leave.

They didn't inform me of that.

It will be on your contract. They don’t need to tell you things which are in your contract or employee handbook as by signing the contract, you have agreed to everything.

notapizzaeater · 28/02/2023 14:29

If you was doing the unpaid overtime did it take you below minimum wage ?

Wheresthebeach · 28/02/2023 14:28

Op- Seriously if you can't take breaks then you should be looking into constructive dismissal.

AncoraAmarena · 28/02/2023 14:27

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 13:51

I didn't think working in a customer service job would mean taking back to back calls. As I know other people who do customer service jobs from home and they don't take back to back calls.

I have one friend who works in a customer service job from home. In his job, he takes calls for two hours in the morning, he then is taken off calls. He then answers emails for two hours. In the afternoon he take calls for two hours. He answers emails for one hour. He has administration time for one hour.

My other friend who does a customer service job from home. She answers calls for most of the day. She gets five minutes time between each call to do system work. She also gets half an hour for admin time in the morning and half an hour for admin time in the evening.

I get 20 seconds between calls, and no administration time at all.

You said I though the best place to keep my work contract was on my work computer. Not true. They have it set up , so it is only possible to keep my work contract on the work computer. They didn't send my work contract to my work email. It is on a system that you have to log in to. It is not possible to copy the work contract and it is not possible to email it to my own personal email address. When I tried to before it said that I don't have administration rights.

Ok OP

  1. request a copy of your contract of employment from your employer
  2. also request a copy of the holiday policy, and/or the employee handbook
  3. report them to the relevant authority for a breach in the Working Time Directive i.e. not allowing you to take breaks during your working hours. In the UK this would be the HSE.

Can you try to get a job where your friends work, rather than go back?

Oh and let your employer chase you for the money, they sound like they have treated you appallingly.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:26

Coffeellama · 28/02/2023 14:24

I doubt it, you quit with no notice and they’ve asked for what they are owed, their payroll haven’t done anything wrong and you’ve potentially caused damage by not showing up to shifts. Neither you or the employer have performed well in this situation.

Yes I agree it's not great to quit with no notice. I wouldn't have quit if I hadn't been broken down. But I wish now I'd thought about it a lot more before I'd do done it. I've never quit any other job. Ive def learned not to quit on a bad day again. As it will only hurt me more in the end

OP posts:
friendlycat · 28/02/2023 14:25

You really need to see the written company policy on all of this. You mention that you have a friend still working there. Can you ask them to send you over a copy of the company policy if they have this on their system?

Then at least you would have this to look at.

Then you need to make contact with the company and sort this out. Citizens Advice can also help you with this.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:24

It looks like I owe them for four days work in Feb and hol pay.
At the minimum it looks like I owe them at least a thousand euro. But they might say I owe more for the February days as February only has 28 days

OP posts:
Coffeellama · 28/02/2023 14:24

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:22

Knowing them , they'll prob over calculate what I owe aswell just to be extra nasty. And add on some kind of fine too.

I doubt it, you quit with no notice and they’ve asked for what they are owed, their payroll haven’t done anything wrong and you’ve potentially caused damage by not showing up to shifts. Neither you or the employer have performed well in this situation.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 28/02/2023 14:22

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:22

Knowing them , they'll prob over calculate what I owe aswell just to be extra nasty. And add on some kind of fine too.

😂

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:22

Knowing them , they'll prob over calculate what I owe aswell just to be extra nasty. And add on some kind of fine too.

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 14:20

I'm just trying to work out exactly what I owe them other than the hol oay. They paid me for month of Feb. I quit on 24th Feb and I was meant to work 25th 26th 27th and 28th Feb. But then someone on here said that pay is averaged over 31 days and as Feb has 28 I would owe more for those four days than if I quit any other month. So it's hard to know as its February pay

OP posts:
IconicKitty · 28/02/2023 14:16

I worked with someone who handed in his notice in April. He was told he would be paid for any holiday he hasn't taken. He gleefully told me he would get paid for 25 days holiday (our full entitlement) as he hadn't taken any holiday this year.

I tried to explain to him that I don't think it works like that, but he didn't understand.

So I don't think OP's thinking is unusual, some people see it as a perk and don't realise or understand it's accrued.

I worked at a supermarket and left on 26th March (our holiday was April - March). They took 0.5 days pay back from me as I had taken my full entitlement for the year.

WisherWood · 28/02/2023 14:15

They didn't send my work contract to my work email. It is on a system that you have to log in to. It is not possible to copy the work contract and it is not possible to email it to my own personal email address. When I tried to before it said that I don't have administration rights

That's really, really dubious behaviour on their part. You should be able to have your own copy of your contract. I've worked for some shysters in my time but never anybody who's done that. It does very strongly suggest that there is stuff in there that they don't want seen by unions or employment specialists. I would at least contact them and say that you would like a copy of your contract, with the relevant clauses regarding annual leave highlighted for you. You may find that if you start to play hardball a bit, they back off.

Lcb123 · 28/02/2023 14:13

Yes of course that’s normal. They wouldn’t think to tell you as prob assumed you wouldn’t leave so fast.

MrsPinkCock · 28/02/2023 14:13

OP, have you checked your contract?

They are only legally permitted to require you to repay holiday pay if there’s a written clause in the contract allowing them to do so.

It could be in the holiday section or it could be combined with a generic clause permitting the employer to make general deductions from pay for monies owed (which also has the effect of you owing them money if there isn’t enough in the final pay run to deduct).

If you don’t have a contract or they haven’t included a written clause then they can’t recover it from you.

Trialnerror · 28/02/2023 14:12

I agree you owe the money back to your employer in addition to the working days from 25th to the 28th of Feb if you were paid up to month end .

however please stop stressing about this . They will most likely accept it in instalments . But also if everything you say happened is correct I would be claiming for the unpaid overtime and breaks you did not get to take . Working in private industry is difficult and hard to take breaks at time.

I would contact NERA for advice too and even let your ex employer know you will be contacting them re your breaks and unpaid overtime .

you could also use this opportunity to meet with management and see if you could get things improved and go back ?

but please stop stressing . I don’t think they will show up demanding payment in full . Try work out a plan of action for yourself .