Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Company wants me to pay back holiday days.

562 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 09:55

I started in a job in November 2022. We have an online annual leave system .
At the start of January 2023, 21 days on our online system became available to me for me to take.

I asked my manager could I take two weeks off at the start of the year. I took the last week of January and the first week of February off. This was approved by my manager. I took them. I was then moved to a new manager. Which was the way the company worked. New starters were with one manager. After two months you were changed to another manager

The company was pretty abusive and at the end of February I decided to leave.

I left. I then got an email from my second manager saying I had taken more annual leave days in the time I worked there, then I had accrued. And that I have to pay this annual leave money back. It is 550 euro. I'm in Ireland. This is a lot of money to me as i am now in between jobs.

Can they do this. My first manager who approved the annual leave days, never told me that I did not have enough annual leave days to take. She approved them. She never told me at any stage that if I left the company that I would have to pay these annual leave days back. If I had known that I wouldn't have taken them .

Can they do this to me now?

OP posts:
nc345678 · 28/02/2023 11:22

The best thing you can do in the circumstances is call HR of your previous employer and explain the situation. They will more than likely be able to enter into a payment arrangement with you to make affordable repayments. As long as you are engaging with them and taking steps to address it, it is unlikely they will take further action. The worst thing you can do here is bury your head in the sand. Hope you are ok.

Brefugee · 28/02/2023 11:22

i think you have several issues here.
(expecting the answer no) are you in a union? join one so you don't get shafted in your next job

Sorry, it all feels like complete shit but maybe you can go back (if they have a retention problem they might be ok about that) and work until you have "accrued" enough leave to quit again?

LaLaLouella · 28/02/2023 11:22

I think we can all stop explaining this to the Op and calling her stupid - she's got the message and she's very upset, so maybe don't make it worse for her?

@Mooshamoo I'm sorry you're going through this and it's causing you stress. I hope your mum has recovered from her illness. Please warn your colleague so that you can stop her making the same mistake you did. Have a long walk and then come back and make a plan - How you are going to get another job, pay your living costs and arrange a way to pay back the money you owe your old job.

And, well done for leaving a toxic work environment, I hope your next job is much better!

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:21

Aprilx · 28/02/2023 11:18

Oh drop the pretence it is really tedious. 🙄 Nobody is dumb enough to think they can use all of their “annual” leave when they have only worked there a couple of months.

I am that dumb. Because obviously i wouldn't have left if I had known!

What is the point in saying "no one can be that dumb".

When I've shown you that I am that dumb! Obviously I wouldn't have left a job and then have to pay them.back 700 euro, if I had known!.

Can we ascertain once and for all: yes I am that dumb. I really didn't know. I wouldn't have done this to myself if I had known that.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 28/02/2023 11:21

"If I had known that I wouldn't have taken them ." your comment sounds like you knew you were going to leave the company before you took the holiday? before you had a new manager you didn't like?

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 28/02/2023 11:20

Hang on. If you are positive this is not in your contact, any other written agreement, or any document that states it forms part of your terms and conditions, they can't make you pay it back.

Employers are legally required to pay you for accrued holiday you haven't used. But it doesn't go the other way unless they have explicitly put this in writing in advance.

So if you are really sure they didn't, ignore them.

(HR person)

Imisscoffee2021 · 28/02/2023 11:20

@Mooshamoo this is pretty much how every company works, as if they made you just take 2.5 days per month people wouldn't get to take any meaningful time off or go away for a week or more. They don't in good faith you're there for the year and if not you pay it back, it's how every company I've worked at has operated. Your manager wouldn't warn you as again they assume you're there all year or longer. It's not the answer you want but I hope they can give you a payment plan, I'd say all other places you work will have this policy too.

MyBloodyBrother · 28/02/2023 11:20

Anklespraying · 28/02/2023 11:07

It actually is expected to be explicit. Contracts should explain the holiday accrual rate. And they should say pay is subject to statutory deductions. These are all standard clauses.

Sorry, yes. I meant that it should be in the contract, of course, but I don’t think it’s the responsibility of HR/ her manager to then go through that contract to ensure that their new employee fully understands what each sentence of the contract means.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:19

I could possibly say I would go back to the job, and they might take me back. It would make financial sense for me at the moment.

I'm just worried that If I go back I will look really bad for quitting, and that the managers will make my life even more of a misery if I go back.

OP posts:
Charlize43 · 28/02/2023 11:18

Did you walk out without any notice period?

It seems really unprofessional that this wasn't all calculated and offset against your final settlement.

Aprilx · 28/02/2023 11:18

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:09

I genuinely didn't know. I had never heard of anyone leaving a job and having to pay annual leave back. I honestly didn't realise.
And now of course im thinking how did I not know that that system even existed.

I think I thought that annual leave would only be available to me to take , if I had built that annual leave up.

So when I logged in and saw I had 22 days to take. I somehow misunderstood that they were my days to take for this year, no matter what.

I don't know what to do for the best. Have to have a long walk and try to see the best way forward ,

Oh drop the pretence it is really tedious. 🙄 Nobody is dumb enough to think they can use all of their “annual” leave when they have only worked there a couple of months.

Brefugee · 28/02/2023 11:16

C'mon OP, "annual" leave has the clue in the title.

Mummyto2rugrats · 28/02/2023 11:15

Yes they can annual leave is accrued through the year majority of places show your full entitlement and you can use this but if you leave within the full year then what has been used and not accrued is required to be paid back
So for example if uk and entitled to 24days leave plus 8 bank holidays

The 24days is multiplied by the average hours that business works in a day so 40hr week 8hr per day meaning an entitlement of 192hr this is then divided by the the number of weeks in a year 52 giving you 3.6923 hours accrued per full working week completed
If you start 1st Jan and that is when leave is calculated from in the company some are different and go by your birthday month some by a random month (mine is october) but say it is 1st Jan this means between 1st Jan and 28tb Feb you have completed 8 and 2 days so you have 8 full weeks gaining you 29.5384 hrs plus 3days at 0.36923hr total rounded 29.91hr if 40hr week not even a full weeks holiday entitlement and you took 2 weeks so they are entitled to claim back on 40hr weeks 50.09hr holiday you took not entitled to

BananaCocktails · 28/02/2023 11:14

Yes they can -that holiday entitlement is given for the year , you didn’t work enough days to accrue the holiday

They should have taken it out of your wages to begin with rather than ask you to pay it back so that’s their fault

WaddleAway · 28/02/2023 11:14

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:09

I genuinely didn't know. I had never heard of anyone leaving a job and having to pay annual leave back. I honestly didn't realise.
And now of course im thinking how did I not know that that system even existed.

I think I thought that annual leave would only be available to me to take , if I had built that annual leave up.

So when I logged in and saw I had 22 days to take. I somehow misunderstood that they were my days to take for this year, no matter what.

I don't know what to do for the best. Have to have a long walk and try to see the best way forward ,

If you could only take what you had accrued, it would lead to everyone taking all of their leave in the second half of the year which would be extremely bad for resource management.

Snazzysausage · 28/02/2023 11:10

Well it's like everything, if you don't know, you don't know. I'm sure you feel crap about it.
I would perhaps ask the company to wait until you have another job,then offer to pay what you can afford each month.They can't get blood out of a stone. If they did go to small claims court and you'd taken responsibility and offered a payment plan, the court would take a dim view I think. Get in touch, take a bit of control over it and propose a plan.

HauntedPencil · 28/02/2023 11:10

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:09

I genuinely didn't know. I had never heard of anyone leaving a job and having to pay annual leave back. I honestly didn't realise.
And now of course im thinking how did I not know that that system even existed.

I think I thought that annual leave would only be available to me to take , if I had built that annual leave up.

So when I logged in and saw I had 22 days to take. I somehow misunderstood that they were my days to take for this year, no matter what.

I don't know what to do for the best. Have to have a long walk and try to see the best way forward ,

Contact them be honest say you can't pay all at once and see what they say I would. Better than ignoring it

EmilyGilmoresSass · 28/02/2023 11:10

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 10:02

Yes but they never informed me about any of this at any stage.

I was a bit naive as I had been off work for a while. So when I saw I had 21 days available to take, I just thought I could take them at any stage of the year.

I asked my manager could I take the annual leave at that stage. Surely she should have said : you only have so much annual leave built up, so you can only take 2 days?

Why let me take two weeks?
And why not inform me at any stage that If I left the company I would have to repay these hours.

Surely it is their responsibility to tell me that if I leave the company I will have to repay these hours.

If I had known that, I wouldn't have taken the annual leave.

They didn't inform me of that.

Where I am it's pretty standard practice you'd have to pay back any holidays you had overused in any job, so that's likely why they've not made a point of saying. Why would they say you'll have to pay them back if you leave unless you'd mentioned you were leaving 🤔

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:09

I genuinely didn't know. I had never heard of anyone leaving a job and having to pay annual leave back. I honestly didn't realise.
And now of course im thinking how did I not know that that system even existed.

I think I thought that annual leave would only be available to me to take , if I had built that annual leave up.

So when I logged in and saw I had 22 days to take. I somehow misunderstood that they were my days to take for this year, no matter what.

I don't know what to do for the best. Have to have a long walk and try to see the best way forward ,

OP posts:
Bronteheart · 28/02/2023 11:09

You must have accrued some leave between November to the end of February to off set the 10 days you took.

How many days pay do you owe them, can you withdraw your notice?

notamumyet2010 · 28/02/2023 11:08

I’m sorry you have got yourself so confused.
In fairness to you, if you have never been told something even if it is obvious to others I can kind of see where you have got mixed up.
For future reference-you earn AL, so think of it like for each month your there you earn 1.5 days for example. It is very common for people to have to pay it back if they leave mid year, and I guess even more so if you leave at the start of when your holiday year starts (not always the same as Jan-Dec, it may be March-April or even the month)
Have you considered working an extra 2 weeks of your notice? Assuming they are as short staffed as you say, they may well
jump at having you for an extra 2 weeks. I know it’s hard when you’re in a negative environment but once you know you’re going then it’s so much easier. I did 8 weeks notice last year in a truly toxic job but I just kept my head down and remembered I wasn’t going to be there much longer.

Therealjudgejudy · 28/02/2023 11:08

Yes you have to pay it back, that's just common sense.

The holiday is accrued throughout the year, but you need to work the year to earn it.

Best bet would be to contact HR and try to negotiate a payment plan.

Best of luck finding a new job. I know the hospitality sector in Ireland is crying out for workers right now so maybe try there.

Ceryneianhind · 28/02/2023 11:08

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 10:35

I do think that jobs should tell you how holiday entitlement works. They ar the very least should say "if you leave this job you will need to pay a/l back". I've looked through my contract and done see it anywhere.

I am on a WhatsApp group with colleagues . I can see one of the other girls on the group saying she is finding this job really hard and she can't do it a day longer as she feels faint, and wants to quit the job next month. She just wrote "I will have to remember to take all my annual leave before I go as I am owed those holiday days". She also doesn't understand and she is going to make the same mistake and the same thing is going to happen to her.

she will be 'owed' what she has earned

they will either pay it, or she can take in her notice period

with your scenario
I start a job in January, I take my 22 day (or however many) in Jan, then hand in my notice (a week) and basically get paid for 6 weeks and work 2?

see how that works? it doesnt does it

Anklespraying · 28/02/2023 11:07

MyBloodyBrother · 28/02/2023 11:04

I really don’t think it’s up to a company to explicitly explain to every employee standard employment law that fully functioning adults should be able to understand. It’s like trying to say the company was wrong for deducting tax and NI because you thought the pay stated on your contract would be the pay you take home. Of course you have to pay back holiday taken if you’ve taken more time off than you accrued. Otherwise anyone could walk into a job, take their 4 weeks annual leave, get paid and then hand in their notice.

It actually is expected to be explicit. Contracts should explain the holiday accrual rate. And they should say pay is subject to statutory deductions. These are all standard clauses.

ColdHandsHotHead · 28/02/2023 11:06

Just a suggestion, will they allow you to work, unpaid, for the days you owe them? Assuming you'll be between jobs?