Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Company wants me to pay back holiday days.

562 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 09:55

I started in a job in November 2022. We have an online annual leave system .
At the start of January 2023, 21 days on our online system became available to me for me to take.

I asked my manager could I take two weeks off at the start of the year. I took the last week of January and the first week of February off. This was approved by my manager. I took them. I was then moved to a new manager. Which was the way the company worked. New starters were with one manager. After two months you were changed to another manager

The company was pretty abusive and at the end of February I decided to leave.

I left. I then got an email from my second manager saying I had taken more annual leave days in the time I worked there, then I had accrued. And that I have to pay this annual leave money back. It is 550 euro. I'm in Ireland. This is a lot of money to me as i am now in between jobs.

Can they do this. My first manager who approved the annual leave days, never told me that I did not have enough annual leave days to take. She approved them. She never told me at any stage that if I left the company that I would have to pay these annual leave days back. If I had known that I wouldn't have taken them .

Can they do this to me now?

OP posts:
Jetstream · 28/02/2023 11:57

Did you not get a company policies and procedures handbook? You can check with you local citizen right bureau. www.citizensinformation.ie/en/employment/employment_rights_and_conditions/employment_rights_and_duties/employee_rights_and_entitlements.html#:~:text=You%20have%20the%20right%20to,in%20the%20workplace%20is%20unlawful.
The Workplace Relations Commission has published a Document to Employment, Labour and Equality Law (pdf) and a booklet on Employment Law Explained (pdf).

You can get more information on employment protection legislation from the Workplace Relations Commission’s Information and Customer Service.

Workplace Relations Commission - Conciliation and Mediation Services
Lansdowne House
Lansdowne Road
Dublin 4
D04 A3A8

Tel: (01) 613 6700
Locall: 0818 80 80 90
Fax: (01) 613 6701
Homepage: www.workplacerelations.ie/en/

PhillySub · 28/02/2023 11:56

Its noticeable from your posts that you don't want to take any responsibility for reading the company policy on annual leave, its all somebody else's fault.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:56

The only thing to do now is a payment plan or go back.

But I think the managers will make my life a living misery if I go back. I already work 9 hours without a break every day. If I go back they would probablt take me back, but i know the managers will abuse me badly for quitting .

I feel ill with stress

This job is going to psychologically break me

OP posts:
IkBenDeMol · 28/02/2023 11:54

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 28/02/2023 11:20

Hang on. If you are positive this is not in your contact, any other written agreement, or any document that states it forms part of your terms and conditions, they can't make you pay it back.

Employers are legally required to pay you for accrued holiday you haven't used. But it doesn't go the other way unless they have explicitly put this in writing in advance.

So if you are really sure they didn't, ignore them.

(HR person)

Yes but if OP is looking for a phrase such as "If you take all your holidays and leave we will take that from your last pay" that might not be in the contract. Someone else mentioned phrases like "statutory deductions" or there might be phrases about accrued leave or whatever. OP's contract may well be entirely legal but the salient point has been lost in legalese or the OP has assumed it doesn't say about paying back holiday as it's not spelled out in black and white in the way she was looking for it.

Agree best way forward is to agree a payment plan.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:54

Some people seem to think that:

I decided to take the annual leave and then quit.

But it wasn't like that.

I took the annual leave at the start of the year. Things got so bad a month later that I quit. When I quit I was just thinking of all the bad things I had gone through that week, I wasn't thinking about the annual leave I had taken, I forgot about it.

It was only after I quit and he told me about it that I remembered it. And I was like shit.

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:51

AllWorkYoPlait · 28/02/2023 11:48

It's quite usual to have your full annual leave entitlement available from January 1st.

Why would your employer pay you for more time than you're entitled to? If you hadn't taken leave and had given your notice, you probably would've received extra pay for your January leave entitlement, at whatever rate you accrue holiday.

Yeah I understand that. But I took annual leave at the start of the year.

Things got so bad a month later that I quit. When I quit I wasn't thinking about the annual leave that I took previously.

I was thinking how much suffering and in mental pain I was on the week that I quit. It's hard to remember everything when you are in a bad place and quitting.

It was only after i quit and the manager told me about the annual leave that I remembered it.

OP posts:
AllWorkYoPlait · 28/02/2023 11:48

It's quite usual to have your full annual leave entitlement available from January 1st.

Why would your employer pay you for more time than you're entitled to? If you hadn't taken leave and had given your notice, you probably would've received extra pay for your January leave entitlement, at whatever rate you accrue holiday.

FishandChipsarelife · 28/02/2023 11:48

@Mooshamoo The issue is now repaying the time you owe them. You will owe it regardless of whether your manager made you aware. I would contact them and advise that you arent able to pay it in one go and look to arrange some kind of payment arrangement with them. I did this with an employer when I had taken more leave than I should have for the point in the year when I left. I was head hunted for another job which I couldnt turn down, I hadnt been expecting to leave. I still needed to pay it back.

HurryShadow · 28/02/2023 11:48

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:43

That makes sense

But on the flip side, it means no-one can take a longer holiday or break at the beginning of the holiday year. For example, I took 3 weeks off in February once to go to New Zealand as it was the best time of year there. If my holiday year started in January I wouldn't have accrued enough time to go until October!

The system of using it and being aware of the potential to repay it is the much more logical way.

Definitely get a copy of your contract to see whether it was mentioned in there, and take advice from someone - is there the equivalent of ACAS in Ireland? If they didn't have it in their contract, or they're now trying to recoup it after you've already left, you may have some argument against it.

My first reply was before I'd read all your posts OP. For what it's worth, you've done the right thing in leaving. Working for the sake of building up accrued leave sounds like it would destroy you in other ways.

If you do need to repay it, tell them you can't afford it all in one go and they'll have to accept installments, perhaps starting when you find your next job.

gabsdot · 28/02/2023 11:48

I am in Ireland and I do the payroll and manage the holidays in my company.
This is totally standard. You'll probably find that it is written into the company's holiday policy.

We usually do not let new employees take more than 1 week more than they have accumulated so we probably wouldn't have let you take 2 weeks off a the start of the year due to you being a recent starter. However your company did allow you to take the holidays and you have been overpaid so they are within their rights to ask for the money back.

However If you have already left and have received your final pay it will be difficult for them to force you to repay the money.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:45

VWCVT6 · 28/02/2023 11:40

I've seen other posts by OP on another thread. She isn't young.

Yes I am in my late thirties. I don't know why some people assumed I was young. People can make mistakes at any age. I had been out of the work force for a couple of years.

OP posts:
Regularsizedrudy · 28/02/2023 11:45

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 28/02/2023 11:28

Everyone's just ignoring the actual HR person advice.

Yes, this is how it usually works. But they can't if it isn't in her contract/other documents.

I bet it is in the contract.

Also sounds like OP just walked out with no notice so her employers had no time to adjust her pay or inform her of this

Wheresthebeach · 28/02/2023 11:44

@Mooshamoo It does mean nobody is ever in your position, plus stops companies having to deduct holiday pay, or chase repayment. It is awful though if you start a job in January, and can't take any leave until the following January!

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:44

Overandunderit · 28/02/2023 11:42

You sound incredibly naive OP but which I think you've recognised. Even the comment about them locking you out of the system, of course they have. You quit - is that a shock?

You could probably agree with them to pay back a smaller amount each month rather than a one-off payment and then maybe wise up a bit?

No I'm not shocked that they locked me out of the system. I was expecting it. Someone just asked me did I reread my contract and I was pointing out that I can't get into the system to read the contract or hr files anymore as I am now locked out. So I can't read it again to see whats in it

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:43

Wheresthebeach · 28/02/2023 11:29

This is why in Canada you can only take the holiday you've earned...which means working a long time before being able to take a proper holiday. It sucks, but it does stop this sort of nonsense.

That makes sense

OP posts:
Overandunderit · 28/02/2023 11:42

You sound incredibly naive OP but which I think you've recognised. Even the comment about them locking you out of the system, of course they have. You quit - is that a shock?

You could probably agree with them to pay back a smaller amount each month rather than a one-off payment and then maybe wise up a bit?

Lastthingreally · 28/02/2023 11:41

You’ve made a mistake so look at the best way out of it. If you write them a strongly worded email detailing their illegal work practices and threatening to counter sue they might decide you’re too much bother to pursue. Why don’t you try the CAB for advice.

VWCVT6 · 28/02/2023 11:40

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 28/02/2023 11:38

Well I can now see why employers are keen to get older people back into the workforce. Are people really this daft?

I've seen other posts by OP on another thread. She isn't young.

Fiddledediddledeedee · 28/02/2023 11:40

Annual leave is based on you working for the year, and approved by your manager on that basis
You left before you did a year
If you get 21 days over 52 wks ( or 365 days ) then you get 0.4038 days per week holiday allowance.

So if you work out how many weeks you worked and multiply by 0.4038 that’s how many you are entitled to
In order to justify two weeks off ( assuming 5day wk so 10 days ) you would need to work 25 weeks.

HurryShadow · 28/02/2023 11:40

Totally normal, I agree. Our contracts state:

"in the event of termination of employment, holiday entitlement will be calculated as 1/12th of the annual entitlement for each completed month of service during that holiday year and any holidays accrued but not taken will be paid for. However, in the event of you having taken any holidays in the current holiday year, which have not been accrued pro-rata, then the appropriate payments will be deducted from your final pay"

Key points here would be:

  • whether payment is deducted from your final pay, or whether they're now coming back for it later, and whether that is allowed, if so; and
  • whether there are any equivalent rules about deductions not being able to take you beneath the minimum wage, as we have in the UK.

On the face of it though, it is, unfortunately, correct that they can do this.

It makes sense though that you accrue the holiday over the coming year, but you have to be able to use it in advance as otherwise everyone would have at least one day's holiday remaining to use in December every year.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:39

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 28/02/2023 11:38

Well I can now see why employers are keen to get older people back into the workforce. Are people really this daft?

Who said I'm young? Im not young

OP posts:
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 28/02/2023 11:38

Well I can now see why employers are keen to get older people back into the workforce. Are people really this daft?

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 28/02/2023 11:38

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:35

I didn't give them notice. I actually didn't mean to quit this early. I'm meant to give them a weeks notice. But what happened was it got to a stage where I felt I couldn't do it one more day and I just quit on pay day.

Now looking back, I think why didn't I think it through longer.

I'd had a really bad week last week. I was in tears with my manager. And the manager of the whole place rang me. He is over hundreds of people in Ireland. He rang me and asked me what was wrong. And I said you know, I'm never able to take a single break. I have to work through every break and I was crying.
And I was really suffering
And then come payday last friday I just decided to quit. Which was a stupid financial decision from all angles. I should have sat down and thought about what would happen to me logistically and long term.

Not just quit in an emotional moment because I couldn't cope that week

Have they said anything about the consequences of not working your notice period, or only the annual leave re-payment? Is the amount they've requested you pay both annual leave and a 'fine' for not working your notice, or just the a annual leave? Did they give a breakdown with the amount in the letter?

VWCVT6 · 28/02/2023 11:38

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 28/02/2023 11:28

Everyone's just ignoring the actual HR person advice.

Yes, this is how it usually works. But they can't if it isn't in her contract/other documents.

I just put that it is in my contract so I would have to pay it back.

@Mooshamoo Have you definitely signed a contract and have you found the bit that says you have to pay it back?

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 11:38

WFHbore2023 · 28/02/2023 11:36

You've been asked a few times and not answered - did you read your contract?

Yes. I did when I started. I can't log in to read it today as they have locked me out of the system. I work remotely. I quit two days ago, they've locked me out of everything already

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread