Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Company wants me to pay back holiday days.

562 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 09:55

I started in a job in November 2022. We have an online annual leave system .
At the start of January 2023, 21 days on our online system became available to me for me to take.

I asked my manager could I take two weeks off at the start of the year. I took the last week of January and the first week of February off. This was approved by my manager. I took them. I was then moved to a new manager. Which was the way the company worked. New starters were with one manager. After two months you were changed to another manager

The company was pretty abusive and at the end of February I decided to leave.

I left. I then got an email from my second manager saying I had taken more annual leave days in the time I worked there, then I had accrued. And that I have to pay this annual leave money back. It is 550 euro. I'm in Ireland. This is a lot of money to me as i am now in between jobs.

Can they do this. My first manager who approved the annual leave days, never told me that I did not have enough annual leave days to take. She approved them. She never told me at any stage that if I left the company that I would have to pay these annual leave days back. If I had known that I wouldn't have taken them .

Can they do this to me now?

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 12:33

Yoyooo · 28/02/2023 12:27

@Mooshamoo thanks for your reply, however I still can't see why you can't take a break? Just when you're finished with one case, change your status so you have no more calls coming in and let your team leader/manager know you are taking your break.

Do you have a schedule which tells you when your scheduled breaks are? Have you told a manager before that you haven't been able to take any breaks and you need one?

Its not possible. Once I receive a call, that call has to be logged and sent within a certain timeframe. We get back to back calls.

We have no admin time. There is no time to do what they want to us to do. The only possible way to do the tech work is to do it on my break.

If I don't get it down I will get into huge huge trouble for not doing it. As contractors won't have been sent out to the customers in time.

No one in my team is able to take a single break ever. We have all told the managers that we need administration time every day, that we need to be off calls for 15 minutes.. They won't give it to us.

OP posts:
bitingthedust · 28/02/2023 12:32

When you put in for annual leave did you ask the manager would you be covered if you left? A manager does not sign off leave having whipped out a calculator with all different scenarios of entitlement should you leave at various points.

Brefugee · 28/02/2023 12:32

There is so much technical work to do on systems , and we have no administration time (no time off calls) at all, that the only possible way to keep on top of the technical work is to do the work during your alloted break times. 15 mins break in morning, 30 mins lunch , 15 mins afternoon. There is no possible way to keep on top of the work other than work through your breaks.

you said that the press have got wind of this and this is why the big boss called you? Tell the people you are still in touch with to have their breaks. 2 x 15 minutes and 1 x 30 minutes. Because if they are planning on quitting anyway, they may as well be fired. Right? You all need to join a union

JOIN. A. UNION.

I can't stress that enough. Did i mention unions? Too late for this job, but not for the next.

People getting fired for taking their breaks? more than one of them? The papers will have a field day.

afinishedkiss · 28/02/2023 12:32

You know what OP, I was a bit abrupt with you earlier but my sister worked in one of those places like you were in. It completely depleted her, affected her mental health and her confidence until one day she just walked out with no other job to go to. Horrible place to work and they honestly don't let you get a breath between calls. They time you going to the toilet, it's disgraceful.

Contact them and tell them you are not working and that you have not got the means to pay them back in full at this time. Ask them if you can have a payment plan and then offer a small amount a week until such time as things change for you. Make a point of contacting them though and offering this and don't panic. If you don't have it to give they cannot take it but make the contact and get the ball rolling. It will be ok xx

Roselilly36 · 28/02/2023 12:31

Standard practice the holidays are accrued over the year, often employees chose to use them before they are accrued, this is fine but they will be deducted from your pay should you leave, also if you have earned holiday and have not taken them they will be paid in final salary.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 28/02/2023 12:31

It’s not illegal because they are not stopping you taking a break.

You are choosing not to have a break so you don’t get behind, but that is your choice.

Take your legal break entitlement and if you fall behind, so what? Perhaps then your company will see the workload is too large.

BlueLabel · 28/02/2023 12:30

I know Fiddledediddledeedee however many HR departments will allow an exceptional carry over where holidays could not be taken (for example because an employer is undergoing training). I any case since it seems unlikely OP can pay it back and chasing through courts would be more expensive than the actual holiday pay itself its possible they'll agree as the easiest and cost efficient option.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 12:29

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 28/02/2023 12:23

So you deliberately didn’t take breaks and are trying to blame them for it?

So nobody actually stopped you having a break at all?

How did I deliberately not take breaks, when there is no time to take breaks?

If the level of workload is so huge that their is no time to take breaks, that is their fault.

All of my team say the same thing that there is no possible time to take breaks.

I spoke to three different managers about this last week. That the workload is too huge for us to be able to take a break. That we need to have 15 minutes scheduled administration time. I told them about this.

None of my team are able to take breaks. The last three people in my team quit because of the same reason, because they couldn't take a single break. It's physically impossible to keep up that level of work without a break every day.

I don't think it is humanly possible to take 9 hours of back to back calls, and updating 4 tech systems at the same time without any breaks at all.

It's illegal and it's extremely detrimental to your health.

I see one of my colleagues on the WhatsApp chat today saying that she is going to quit because she couldn't take a single break all week , and she is really sick now because of it.

OP posts:
Yoyooo · 28/02/2023 12:28

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 28/02/2023 12:23

So you deliberately didn’t take breaks and are trying to blame them for it?

So nobody actually stopped you having a break at all?

This

Cosyblankets · 28/02/2023 12:28

How bad the job is regarding breaks etc is a totally different issue to you not understanding how the leave works. Other colleagues not being happy etc is not going to change anything

CraneBoysMysteries · 28/02/2023 12:28

OP as others have said, if you get paid on 24th and it's for the whole month, you may owe some salary back.

We get paid on 21st and its 3 weeks in arrears and 1 week in advance. So if I left on 21st and received a full months salary, I would owe back a week

Please keep this in mind

Yoyooo · 28/02/2023 12:27

@Mooshamoo thanks for your reply, however I still can't see why you can't take a break? Just when you're finished with one case, change your status so you have no more calls coming in and let your team leader/manager know you are taking your break.

Do you have a schedule which tells you when your scheduled breaks are? Have you told a manager before that you haven't been able to take any breaks and you need one?

FeinCuroxiVooz · 28/02/2023 12:26

You are being unreasonable to expect more paid time off than you earned, and it's ridiculous to think that they should have warned you about something so obvious, but it's perfectly reasonable to not pay it back all at once if you can't afford it. I don't know about Irish law but in the UK they aren't allowed to make a deduction from your final pay cheque without your agreement, and have a duty of care not to put you into financial hardship even when your service is terminating, so it would in the UK with these circumstances be possible to receive your final pay with no deduction for the holiday pay owed, and then to make an arrangement to pay them back at an affordable rate (e.g. £5 per month). You would have to speak to whatever the Irish equivalent of Citizens Advice is to find out if this would be reasonable under Irish legislation.

Fiddledediddledeedee · 28/02/2023 12:26

BlueLabel · 28/02/2023 12:22

Sorry OP, as others have said it's correct you'd owe them for the holiday time and this is in no way a failing on their end - its not normal to have to micromanage employees through holidays, and certainly not usual to remind employees of terms they have already signed. You need to hold yourself accountable.

That being said, if you started at the beginning of November it's possible you had 3 days of holidays from last year that you may not have taken if you didn't use any holiday time in the initial November/December period. I would contact them to ask if this can be taken off the balance if so and the rest deferred until you find work or made into a payment plan to give yourself some breathing space.

But lots of companies won’t allow people to carry holiday allowance over to the next year….it’ll be in the contract if that’s the case

Plus sounds like that OP might have been some sort of training period…again if there’s holiday allowance for that it’ll be in the contract
As OP didn’t get a contract till January I’m guessing that’s the case.

nizo1245 · 28/02/2023 12:25

Do you have an employment contract?
It will be explained there.

It's normal to have to pay back excess holiday you've taken though. Otherwise people could start a new job, take all their holidays and get paid for them, then leave.

Bearonthestair · 28/02/2023 12:24

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 12:21

My colleague just texted me on the WhatsApp chat that she wasn't able to take a break all day yesterday and she feels faint

If that's the dope that thinks she can have a free 4 weeks holidays with out accruing it give her a heads up.

Brefugee · 28/02/2023 12:24

No I'm not shocked that they locked me out of the system. I was expecting it. Someone just asked me did I reread my contract and I was pointing out that I can't get into the system to read the contract or hr files anymore as I am now locked out. So I can't read it again to see whats in it

ok look, this sounds so obvious but when you get your next job, get a print of your contract. I can't believe that people don't know this basic stuff. I'm in Germany so it maybe different, but when you sign a contract there are 2 paper copies, i sign both, employer signs both and i keep one. Make sure this happens when you sign your next contract.

The second thing is this: see if you can go back. Say you were feeling hugely overwhelmed, it's too much work for too little breaks (and I'm sure in Ireland that's not legal - in Germany you MUST have at least a 30 minute break after 6 hours of work and companies enforce this). Tell them that you have calmed down now, and that you were also under some outside stress in your private life that is now under control. Apologise if you must (but don't grovel)

And when you are back at work, try to take breaks. If you get pushback try to talk to HR or boss-of-boss and explain that their high turnover is due to the lack of breaks in part and if they solve that they'll bring down their recruitment costs.

Fiddledediddledeedee · 28/02/2023 12:23

The problem with holding off payment as a way of bartering with the company over grievances is that a court will always say….pay first argue later to get it back.

If they have a deadline for your payment you need to stick to it.
You can write and complain but be mindful of that deadline
If they start adding interest, management fees etc for non payment it will never end ( they should state this on their letter to you, or it may be in your contract which I appreciate you can’t view now )

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 28/02/2023 12:23

So you deliberately didn’t take breaks and are trying to blame them for it?

So nobody actually stopped you having a break at all?

BlueLabel · 28/02/2023 12:22

Sorry OP, as others have said it's correct you'd owe them for the holiday time and this is in no way a failing on their end - its not normal to have to micromanage employees through holidays, and certainly not usual to remind employees of terms they have already signed. You need to hold yourself accountable.

That being said, if you started at the beginning of November it's possible you had 3 days of holidays from last year that you may not have taken if you didn't use any holiday time in the initial November/December period. I would contact them to ask if this can be taken off the balance if so and the rest deferred until you find work or made into a payment plan to give yourself some breathing space.

Velvetween · 28/02/2023 12:22

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 10:02

Yes but they never informed me about any of this at any stage.

I was a bit naive as I had been off work for a while. So when I saw I had 21 days available to take, I just thought I could take them at any stage of the year.

I asked my manager could I take the annual leave at that stage. Surely she should have said : you only have so much annual leave built up, so you can only take 2 days?

Why let me take two weeks?
And why not inform me at any stage that If I left the company I would have to repay these hours.

Surely it is their responsibility to tell me that if I leave the company I will have to repay these hours.

If I had known that, I wouldn't have taken the annual leave.

They didn't inform me of that.

  1. Are you an adult?
  2. Did you have a contract?
  3. Did your employers have reasonable grounds to believe you would read and understand your contract yourself without them having to revisit and explain all the detail to you?

YOU didn’t inform YOURSELF. It wasn’t up to them. Harsh lesson learned, OP.

VWCVT6 · 28/02/2023 12:21

BritWifeInUSA · 28/02/2023 12:20

I wasn’t the only one. Or the nastiest. Not sure why you felt the need to single me out. Whatever makes you feel big, I guess.

Just because other people are being nasty doesn't mean you get to join in. Grow up, maybe.

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 12:21

My colleague just texted me on the WhatsApp chat that she wasn't able to take a break all day yesterday and she feels faint

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 28/02/2023 12:21

It's pretty obvious really,it's called annual leave for a reason.
Common sense would (should)tell you that was part of your year's holiday,why on earth would they give you two weeks leave after three months work?were you expecting more as well?no because you knew that was part of a year's entitlement.
Unfortunately you are going to have to pay it back.
If they were so abusive you had to leave can you look at that angle?because leaving without having another job is quite the move to make in this climate.
Hopefully they will allow a payment plan.good luck

Mooshamoo · 28/02/2023 12:21

Yoyooo · 28/02/2023 12:12

Regarding the breaks (and I work in a contact centre so I know how it works) what would happen if you took your break - which I assume was at a set time according to your schedule? Especially working from home where there isn't a physical presence of a manager, why did you not just take it? I get the workloads and targets and call queues meant you felt you couldn't, but you know you can just change your status and go on your break? What would happen if you asked about going on your break? And was your managers aware of you not taking any breaks?

I'm saying this as a manage a large team in very busy contact centre which constant queuing and I make sure my guys take their breaks, we worse closely with resource planning to ensure we have enough people on so people can have their break.

Hi thanks for asking. It is not possible to take breaks.

The customer service role that I was in was quite specific and had a lot of responsibility.

It is not like a customer service role where I answer questions about online shops for example.

In my role I received calls from the public and then I had to log the call in a specific time ,and I sent these call requests to engineers and contractors to go out and do work for customers all over ireland. I was connected to a lot of moving networks around Ireland. These call requests had to be sent by me to contractors in a very specific time.

When the customer called in , while I wsa son the call I had to update four different technical systems with the information, send the correct info to the contractors within a certain timeframe. We get 20 seconds between each call, calls are back to back all day. There are no time between calls .there is no scheduled administration time. I end up doing casework for the previous call on the next call

There is so much technical work to do on systems , and we have no administration time (no time off calls) at all, that the only possible way to keep on top of the technical work is to do the work during your alloted break times. 15 mins break in morning, 30 mins lunch , 15 mins afternoon. There is no possible way to keep on top of the work other than work through your breaks.

OP posts: