Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate people not quite mentioning my weight loss?

129 replies

ShrinkingIngrate · 28/02/2023 00:16

I've lost a fuckload of weight and people are starting to mention it.

But they're always so coy about it.

"You're looking WELL!"

No one ever says it directly, the wimps.

Why is it impoltire to say it those words?

Tbfh, I don't think I'm dealing with it very well, I'd just rather no one said anything but I'm a crochety menopausal misanthrope I think I'd rather be in solitude with my celery and Bovril.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Wanderingowl · 28/02/2023 09:30

Look right, it's fatphobic to lose weight. It's fatphobic to compliment people on their weightloss. And it's fatphobic to have noticed that someone is overweight and it definitely is to think that losing it should be complimented. At least that's what some very vocal online people say about it. It's made mentioning weightloss more of a minefield than it should be.

When I lost weight and people commented on that, yes the obvious implication is that I was fat before. And guess what? I was. And I wasn't happy about it, which is why I went to the effort of losing the weight. Something was negative in my life, it was very hard to change but it mattered enough to me that I did. Of course I'd like to be complimented on that. Just like I'd like to be complimented on work success, having a baby, getting a divorce (😆), etc. So congratulations on doing the work and losing the weight. I bet you look great.

The one piece of advice I'll offer though, is that you mention celery and Bovril. So if you are really heavily restricting yourself, it's a good idea to think about how you want to continue once you are at your goal weight. The first time I lost weight, I put it all back on and then some, within a few years. The second time, I changed my whole lifestyle and became really sporty and athletic, which makes maintaining healthy weight much easier.

StuckInTheUpsideDown · 28/02/2023 09:26

I’ve lost a noticeable amount of weight. A few people have directly commented, meaning it as a compliment. I HATE it for a variety of reasons.

I really don’t think people who aren’t doctors should comment to others on their weight loss unless they are very close AND that person has been confiding in you about their desire to lose weight and how they are doing it.

RitaBea · 28/02/2023 09:21

It’s actually a fear of people commenting that stops me from dieting and losing weight even though I need and want to.

HarlanPepper · 28/02/2023 09:20

People really can't win, can they.

ibunofit · 28/02/2023 09:19

If you have been talking to people about how you want to lose weight and what you have been doing to achieve this etc, they feel able to comment positively.

If you haven’t they don’t, for all the reasons given here.

Stompythedinosaur · 28/02/2023 09:15

I would never, ever comment on another person's weight.

QuietlyConfident · 28/02/2023 09:14

JarByTheDoor · 28/02/2023 04:14

I believe it means "I have noticed that you've lost a lot of weight. I don't know whether you'll be upset by me directly noticing and commenting on this, or upset by me apparently not noticing and commenting, so I'm saying something which allows you to determine which way this conversation goes, so that if necessary we can both pretend that I didn't notice or comment on your weight."

Bingo.
It gives scope for you to say "thanks, I've taken up a new diet and exercise regime and lost 2 stone, it was hell but I'm proud of myself"
Or "actually I've had dysentery"
Or nothing and move on.

Sugargliderwombat · 28/02/2023 09:10

They don't want you to feel shit If you put all the weight on again.

Because the weight loss might be because of something bad.

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 09:10

It’s so so simple - there’s no need for people to try to “win”. Don’t make comments on appearance unless invited.

Swiftswatch · 28/02/2023 09:08

People can’t win.

No doubt you wouldn’t want them mentioning your weight before.

Arrrrrrragghhh · 28/02/2023 09:07

Some people don’t look better for losing a lot of weight. I normally will mention how well someone’s doing if I know they are trying but one friend looked awful after losing weight. She was after compliments but all I could say was “yes I see” when she told me.
Also you look well is the usually a euphemism for you look fat but happy. Have you lost a noticeable amount?

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 09:05

CrotchetyQuaver · 28/02/2023 09:03

There's been a big change in this. I believe people are frightened to ask now in case the person is offended.

Good.

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 09:05

ILiveAt64ZooLane · 28/02/2023 09:00

I regularly say to friends and colleagues that they look nice today or compliment them if they’ve had their nails done or are wearing something nice. A woman I’d never met before from work said she liked the dress I was wearing and that it suited me, I just said thank you. What’s wrong with that?

Maybe some of them don’t like comments on their appearance, like me, and just tolerate it? You like it, doesn’t mean everyone does. I am very polite to people who make comments on my appearance, because I know they mean well, but it doesn’t make me feel good, it makes me feel irritated, and I am allowed to say that here.

CrotchetyQuaver · 28/02/2023 09:03

There's been a big change in this. I believe people are frightened to ask now in case the person is offended.

ILiveAt64ZooLane · 28/02/2023 09:00

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 08:45

I don’t even like people saying “you look well”! There’s no need to comment on my appearance at all. But this stuff is considered small talk between women so we often have to tolerate it from randomers

I regularly say to friends and colleagues that they look nice today or compliment them if they’ve had their nails done or are wearing something nice. A woman I’d never met before from work said she liked the dress I was wearing and that it suited me, I just said thank you. What’s wrong with that?

housemaus · 28/02/2023 09:00

MarshaMelrose · 28/02/2023 04:15

Clearly your friends are MNers where it's forbidden to mention weight in any context.

I always compliment people because it's hard losing weight and part of the reward and the encouragement is people noticing.

Congratulations on your weight loss.

Everyone mentioning how great my sister looked when she lost 3 stone was what pushed her further into an eating disorder that took her 5 years to recover from. Not everyone is losing weight healthily. Not everyone needs (or should have) the 'reward' of people noticing.

musingsinmidlife · 28/02/2023 08:58

Thin is not a life achievement for me. I get that for many being thin is good and fat is bad and so they want to congratulate me on moving towards what for them is an important goal in life but it isn't for me. Being healthy, strong, having endurance and being happy with my level of fitness are my goals related to my body size and weight - not a number on a scale. When people comment on my body or weight, I assume they have their own eating / body issues that they are projecting onto me.

housemaus · 28/02/2023 08:57

I wouldn't point out weight loss in a positive or negative light for loads of reasons. Mainly because the size of your body is morally neutral and there's no congratulations or commiserations needed either way, but also because I've no idea how someone feels about the weight loss, whether it's as a result of illness, whether it's because of an ED that I might inadvertently feed/trigger by mentioning (esp with dramatic weight loss).

But I might point out if someone looks good or happy in themselves. So I might say you're looking well, meaning you look happy/glowy/generally good?

KimberleyClark · 28/02/2023 08:55

lljkk · 28/02/2023 08:34

I'd like to comment but honestly I reckon you'll gain it all back. Do you want me to comment when you gain it back, too? I don't want to have a relationship with your weight. You're just my friend-colleague-family, regardless of body size. Do you want me to imply that you looked bad before? You have a relationship with your weight, it's not for me to get involved.

I feel exactly the same about haircuts, btw. Any compliment about my hair now suggests that my hair looked bad before. I don't need to hear that opinion.

If you’ve radically restyled or coloured your hair it can make you feel like you’ve made a terrible mistake if people don’t say anything. Same with glasses, I remember when I changed my metal framed glasses for a much more “statement” tortoiseshell pair and nobody said anything I wondered if they looked awful on me.

Mellymoon · 28/02/2023 08:52

People are realising it’s not appropriate to comment on others weight or push their weight bias/predjudices on.

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 08:48

TinyCactusInAPot · 28/02/2023 08:26

Well done in losing the weight

next step: lose the anger when people are say something nice to you

commenting on someone’s weight these days is often construed as “fat shaming” so people don’t anymore

Not necessarily fat shaming. Might just be unnecessarily personal. Why do you think it’s ok to make unwelcome personal remarks? Weren’t you brought up knowing many people find it rude?

BiasedBinding · 28/02/2023 08:45

I don’t even like people saying “you look well”! There’s no need to comment on my appearance at all. But this stuff is considered small talk between women so we often have to tolerate it from randomers

MikeLitoriss · 28/02/2023 08:36

I lost 13 stone during COVID lockdown. I had one person directly comment on my weight saying oh my gosh you've lost so much weight you look incredible
Many others said your looking so good etc but not mentioning weight directly - I think it's more polite personally (although don't mind either!) As we both know they're referencing my weight primarily since I've lost a huge amount but people don't want to comment on people's bodies- it's so personal!

lljkk · 28/02/2023 08:34

I'd like to comment but honestly I reckon you'll gain it all back. Do you want me to comment when you gain it back, too? I don't want to have a relationship with your weight. You're just my friend-colleague-family, regardless of body size. Do you want me to imply that you looked bad before? You have a relationship with your weight, it's not for me to get involved.

I feel exactly the same about haircuts, btw. Any compliment about my hair now suggests that my hair looked bad before. I don't need to hear that opinion.

BeetleyCarapace · 28/02/2023 08:34

AmandaClare · 28/02/2023 07:23

I’m of an age where a possible answer to “you’ve lost weight!” Is “yes, I have cancer”. So I tend not to assume automatically that all weight loss is deliberate.

“You look well” seems quite a good alternative and let’s you then mention the weight loss yourself if you want to, or just say thanks if you don’t. So yabu.

My mother did this to a woman she (distantly) knew. She put her foot in it, was utterly ashamed of herself and still gets horrified about it 20 years later.

(The woman recovered from her cancer, in case anyone was wondering.)