Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a wage/income that would shock people?

796 replies

Newmumatlast · 27/02/2023 20:40

Inspired by the tipping hairdresser thread, and a post on there about people having no idea what some people earn with an anecdote about a London cabbie earning twice what his nurse wife did.

I just wondered if anyone does a job where people would actually be shocked to know their true earnings based on stereotype- either way. For example cleaner earning loads or lawyer earning very little.

OP posts:
Swansridinghorses · 01/03/2023 09:02

Vet and about 38k which isn’t a bad salary but my student loan is bigger than when it started and people seem to think I earn a fortune. Hate the whole “you’re only in it for the money” because I definitely could’ve been earning far more doing something else

PearCrumbleCustard · 01/03/2023 08:59

@DoodleDoo37 I want your job! Please tell us your industry… feel a very late change of career through job envy going on…

hoorayhooray · 01/03/2023 08:56

Also where is the tipping hairdressers thread please??

AfterGlow87 · 01/03/2023 08:21

Im a staff midwife working as a sonographer on just under 50k (euro), that includes a 2k location allowance. I’m in Ireland and qualified 10 years. It’s a nice (busy!) job and I work 8-4, Monday-Friday so can’t complain really

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 08:05

The tories have done a right number on the population is people think £21k is a decent salary for skilled and responsible work. Why are people's expectations so low?

At the bottom, people tell themselves that they're doing OK because they're not starving, while the wealth of the elite goes up at astronomical rates.

(I don't work for the NHS, and was never a band 2 btw, so this isn't on my own behalf)

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 08:02

That isn't a decent salary, no! It may not require a nurse qualification, but it's skilled and responsible work.

And whether it's a decent salary or not is not what's being debated. It's whether working a few extra weekends and nights will cause a band 2 to out-earn someone on £40k. And I can't see how that will be possible unless the £40k person is including deductions for optional salary sacrifice arrangements.

midnightOK · 01/03/2023 07:47

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 07:25

For those unfamiliar with NHS pay bands, the top end of a band 2 is paid at £21,318 pa. Their gross pay before tax/NI/pension (assuming no additional hours/bank etc.) will only be £1,777 per month.

That's a decent salary in my opinion. Band 2 is not a proper nurse position, it doesn't require nurse qualifications, does it?

ibunofit · 01/03/2023 07:44

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 07:25

For those unfamiliar with NHS pay bands, the top end of a band 2 is paid at £21,318 pa. Their gross pay before tax/NI/pension (assuming no additional hours/bank etc.) will only be £1,777 per month.

But the renumeration is not just about immediate pay, is it? NHS staff have absolutely excellent pensions ( which would cost an absolute fortune to achieve for those on private pension, good contract conditions and other perks, working for a large employer which offers advancement and career progression, as well as being completely proofed against forced redundancy and extremely hard to sack.

The pressures in the job seem to be from understaffing and I know that stress is tough. But the contractual terms and conditions are really good, even compared to many other public sector employers.

wellstopdoingitthen · 01/03/2023 07:42

@Kaiserchief
Where did I say I was outraged?

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 07:25

For those unfamiliar with NHS pay bands, the top end of a band 2 is paid at £21,318 pa. Their gross pay before tax/NI/pension (assuming no additional hours/bank etc.) will only be £1,777 per month.

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 07:16

The NHS Pension contribution rate for someone on £40k is 9.8%, so how on earth are you taking home just under £1,800?

Even with student loan deductions, your take home pay would be at least £2.2k per mth, so I'm assuming you must have significant additional salary sacrifice deductions?

If your take home is low because you choose to enter salary sacrifice arrangements, it is disingenuous to point at a band 2 and claim they are earning as much or more than you.

Kaiserchief · 01/03/2023 07:01

wellstopdoingitthen · 01/03/2023 00:18

I remember working as a teaching assistant & being completely demoralised when my mum told me how much she paid her cleaner- more than twice my hourly pay. Her cleaner didn't get hit and spat at either!

No need to be outraged at the lowly cleaner daring to earn so much - quit being a TA and start cleaning!

ladymaiasura · 01/03/2023 07:00

1000N · 01/03/2023 06:51

I never said it was easy. I never sugested that a band 2 takes home 40k a year. I said - at the END OF THE MONTH take home i am taking home less than my friends who are band2 at top of their band and they have a lot less responsibility. Again, believe me or not🤷‍♀️ last month my Take home after tax was just shy of £1800 whilst i know of band 2 ( at top of band) who at the end of month took home just above that so the point stands. The reactions to the post were making me feel attacked and i do not need that in my life so yes i asked to be removed, do you hvae negative views about that too? 🤷‍♀️

I wasn’t trying to attack you. I just think it’s important that posts around nursing salaries have some context given the current political situation. I’m sorry if I have upset you.

saffy2 · 01/03/2023 06:53

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 28/02/2023 10:57

Well over your numbers then

I earnt £27k in one year working only 3 days a week as a childminder legitimately within my numbers. Do you even know what you’re talking about?! 😂
childminding can be very lucrative and I have always earned well while doing it. If you limit your outlay and work to capacity it’s easy to make good money. If I worked to full capacity 5 days a week, hired an assistant etc I could easily be over 50k in the year. I choose not to.
full time at full capacity for me 5 days a week would bring in £780 a week, with each child doing 40 hours a week. In reality they would actually do more. And that’s without any after school children. That would equal roughly 37k a year before expenses. Without any after school children and only working 8 hour days, so in reality I would earn much more if I went for full capacity 5 days a week and added in after school children too.
you don’t know what you’re talking about.

1000N · 01/03/2023 06:51

ladymaiasura · 01/03/2023 06:41

As I’m sure you are well aware, Nurses and support staff have been fighting for years to get recognition and fair pay for the work that we do. To suggest a band two can do a couple of night and weekend shifts and earn upwards of £40k is ridiculous and undermines all our efforts. Yes, a band 2/3 can earn that money but, as @poppettypop has shown, it takes a HUGE amount of work including overtime and anti social hours to do so. NHS staff deserve a fair wage no matter their band and they shouldn’t have to work themselves into the ground to get it. That’s why I object to your initial comment (that you have now withdrawn). Please don’t imply that it’s easy.

I never said it was easy. I never sugested that a band 2 takes home 40k a year. I said - at the END OF THE MONTH take home i am taking home less than my friends who are band2 at top of their band and they have a lot less responsibility. Again, believe me or not🤷‍♀️ last month my Take home after tax was just shy of £1800 whilst i know of band 2 ( at top of band) who at the end of month took home just above that so the point stands. The reactions to the post were making me feel attacked and i do not need that in my life so yes i asked to be removed, do you hvae negative views about that too? 🤷‍♀️

Notsoivorytower · 01/03/2023 06:45

I gave up a fantastic career to care for my eldest son who has complex needs and my DH took a step back from his £6-figure salary and job travelling away from home and halfway around the world on a regular basis to be there for us. (So much hospital time) I'm now on Carers allowance which is less than £70 a week and he's on less than half his previous salary supporting a family of 5. We cope but I'm glad that I was taught to be financially savvy!

ladymaiasura · 01/03/2023 06:41

1000N · 28/02/2023 21:07

The original Post asked for example of salaries that people do not believe in. I gave my example. Believe it or do not believe it, it does not change things 🤷‍♀️ no need to be offended or indirectly suggesting that I am lying. Again, it does not change things for me if strangers believe me or not.

As I’m sure you are well aware, Nurses and support staff have been fighting for years to get recognition and fair pay for the work that we do. To suggest a band two can do a couple of night and weekend shifts and earn upwards of £40k is ridiculous and undermines all our efforts. Yes, a band 2/3 can earn that money but, as @poppettypop has shown, it takes a HUGE amount of work including overtime and anti social hours to do so. NHS staff deserve a fair wage no matter their band and they shouldn’t have to work themselves into the ground to get it. That’s why I object to your initial comment (that you have now withdrawn). Please don’t imply that it’s easy.

LookingOldTheseDays · 01/03/2023 06:31

ladymaiasura · 01/03/2023 06:27

If you are band 8a then you are surely in senior management. So you are not doing the job people imagine when you say you are a nurse. Where I work, the band 8a above me manages a whole surgical department and has overall responsibility for nursing staff on several wards. When compared with other sectors and some of the salaries on this thread, I think £60k is a shockingly low wage for that level of responsibility.

With all that’s happening with strikes etc I don’t think it’s helpful to make comments like yours without some context. You must have worked your way up and should therefore be well aware of what your colleagues on lower bands are earning. Of course you earn more than colleagues in junior roles on lowers bands. This shouldn’t be a surprise to you!

I agree with this. An 8a won't do the kind of role most people would associate with the word 'nurse', and only a small minority of nursing roles would be a band 7 or above. You might be a nurse, but your actual job title is likely to be more informative about what you do.

Leftlegwest · 01/03/2023 06:30

Changedmymindtoday · 27/02/2023 22:00

I earn a very decent wage.
I have nice handbags that I use sometimes but tbh they are not a give away as people on not good salaries carry them too.

I get ignored notably at make up counters because I don’t look like someone that would spend money! Yes agree you Mac and Charlotte Tilbury you (not all but too many snobby) make up assistants. I take my buying sprees elsewhere.

Sometimes I travel for work and I dress so casual and wonder if the suit sat next to me has any idea that I likely earn way more!

it’s those that try to show the air of money that don’t have it.

My husband and I are like this. We aren't mega rich but we are comfortable and have a very healthy combined income. We had to buy multiple products in Apple before Christmas and were ignored for ages. We eventually weren't ignored and the person who served us made apparently her second highest sale since working there in three years and was delighted. Don't judge a book by its cover I guess. We aren't ever going to be showy people in what we wear. I have young children and am time poor so don't tend to get my hair and a nails done much either. All the presumed overt signs of wealth won't be there with us.

ladymaiasura · 01/03/2023 06:27

Wowzel · 28/02/2023 22:03

It's interesting watching the arguments about nurses salaries go on, as I earn more than that per year.

Last year I took home nearly 60k as a nurse. I think my friends and family would be surprised by that. My husband is.

(I'm an 8a and I do bank sometimes at the weekends)

If you are band 8a then you are surely in senior management. So you are not doing the job people imagine when you say you are a nurse. Where I work, the band 8a above me manages a whole surgical department and has overall responsibility for nursing staff on several wards. When compared with other sectors and some of the salaries on this thread, I think £60k is a shockingly low wage for that level of responsibility.

With all that’s happening with strikes etc I don’t think it’s helpful to make comments like yours without some context. You must have worked your way up and should therefore be well aware of what your colleagues on lower bands are earning. Of course you earn more than colleagues in junior roles on lowers bands. This shouldn’t be a surprise to you!

Orangetapemeasure · 01/03/2023 05:29

@hiyaqwerty and @Newmumatlast

yes, he has his own business and a lot of his custom is from high end restaurants. He also has a shop which is more of an experience than sawdust on the floor! The hours are brutal though -3am starts.

Drumrolls · 01/03/2023 04:26

@FlickWrk Yes it's one of the FAANGs. We're still waiting to hear who the layoffs will affect. Not too nervous as we're confident he has enough experience to be able to find work in one of the other companies, and we have enough investments to keep us afloat whatever happens.

We used to be pretty frugal before having the dc, so squirrelled away money into investments and put it into our main home, so our mortgage is very low (for a 4 bed London house). But we spend a lot on prep school fees and kids activities, though I feel like we spend a lot less generally than other parents/colleagues in similar roles (less glamorous holidays, and no car expenses living in Central London).

Eastmeetswest1 · 01/03/2023 04:00

Apologies for delay replying (had all children off yesterday). Youngest Children not in nursery as too expensive and re what I do - Basically administration I’m self employed which people don’t realise / I don’t publicise. But by working early morning (not often) and late into the evening once children in bed (Mostly), we avoid childcare. The work just Slowly increased over the last 10 years to what it is now.

The downside, I rarely get any downtime / never watch tv before 10 pm at night and yes it’s tiring but I am organised by normally making a ‘to do’ list every evening for the next day / writing ‘to do’ things as I go along at work if can’t get done immediately . But I am able to take the children to activities/ swimming lessons / clubs / school activities etc during the day and I keep reasoning with myself that the children will grow up in a flash and (surely) at some point I’ll be able to go to the cinema and not fall asleep! 🤣

MrsPetty · 01/03/2023 01:57

I’d love to actually know how much people ‘think’ I earn. I’m self employed and my office is a stones throw from my house so I often pop back for things or to appointments with DDs etc. I’m a Project Manager and returned to work a year ago having been a SAHM for eleven years. I think people would be quite surprised…

DoodleDoo37 · 01/03/2023 01:30

So I earn - salary plus bonus about 225k per year with pension contributions on top. I could earn more if I went for promotion but I can't be bothered. Household gross income is about 450k but that includes rental income from a property portfolio. I used to spend a lot on expensive clothes make up etc when I was younger - but now I'm happier getting a cheap designer bargain out of tk maxx. I tend to save as much as I can while still enjoying life the way I want to. Kids in private school so that takes a chunk and lots on extra curricular activities for them. House is nice but in no way pretentious could be a lot nicer - worth over 1mm and no mortgage. Property portfolio well thought out and worth millions (but with some mortgages). I don't buy into the whole expensive clothes, shoes and bags stuff anymore. I know I could buy them but I work too hard to pay their prices, instead I save so that as an earlier poster said you can get your freedom sooner and I prefer to spend my money on holidays and experiences and I want to retire early from work. Plus I wasn't born to rich parents, they had to watch money all their lives until retirement when I was working and helped them out, so I grew up not feeling rich but wanting to be and knowing the value of money (I feel guilty sometimes when I think of what my parents earned versus what I earn now) and even today I still don't feel rich, which may sound odd to some on here but honestly in some of the circles I mix in I'm not, I'm below average because they have had the advantage of inherited wealth, I've had to work for mine. I'm not sure what it will take for me to "feel" rich.
My boss doesn't know my wealth and neither do my colleagues as I don't talk about it and when they are boasting about their house price I just stay quiet and smile as I'm worth so much more. Plus the industry I work in is an incredibly jealous one and I wouldn't want people to treat me differently. You wouldn't look at me and assume my net worth for sure but I think showing off wealth in the times we live in now is inappropriate (just my opinion before I get flamed from those who feel they've earned it and want to splash out). I have all I want in life and way more than I need and I am very grateful for that.