Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have attempted to toilet train without DP’s ‘permission”

164 replies

lwatts32 · 27/02/2023 18:39

DP has a 12 (nearly 13) year old son, he's had full custody of him since he was about a year old and I've been in his life since he was 5 and he calls me mum etc. He has ASD and is very delayed. He's still in pull ups, he refuses pads etc and will only wear dry nights which are expensive. I'm also 24 weeks pregnant and I've just got our youngest out of nappies and me and DP were talking about trying again with SS.

We last tried when he was 8 and it didn't go well, we made the mistake of taking them away and putting him in underwear which made him very distressed so we gave up after about 2 days and haven't tried again since.

SS seemed interested when DS was getting praised for using the toilet so after school on Friday (DP was away with work) I asked him if he wanted to do the same, he said yes but I was unsure as he usually says yes as an answer to most questions. However, on Saturday he went on the toilet a few times, he did have a few accidents but then yesterday he was dry all day.

DP is now home and I've told him and he isn't happy that I've done this without his ‘permission’ as all decisions about SS should be up to him, reminded me about last time - although I've not mentioned wearing underwear to SS or taken his pull ups away, accused me of pushing SS into this etc.

Just to add, DP does seem to ‘baby’ SS, I don't mean that in a horrible way as I know he does struggle, but for example when DP is away SS usually will change himself, he will ask me but I encourage him to try to himself first and he knows I'm around if he needs help, however DP agrees and doesn't encourage him to try himself first as he says it's easier if he just does it.

Was I BU?

OP posts:
sashh · 28/02/2023 04:56

Your SS made his own choice.

Jesus Christ! Twelve, almost thirteen years old and still in nappies?!?!?!?! That's neglect. Bloody hell

Did you miss the buit where he is very delayed?

SchoolTripDrama · 28/02/2023 04:13

Btw, yes I am aware there is ASD but as a parent to a child with ASD, I still stand by my last post.

SchoolTripDrama · 28/02/2023 04:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/02/2023 03:20

You seem to be under reacting to this reaction imo. It’s great your dss wants to try to toilet train. This is a strange reaction.

I know it’s off topic but I’m wondering if you’re putting yourself financially and your dss and your relationship in a precarious position. Just you’re his mum in every sense of the word but by the sound of it not legally. You’re not married either. Your dp just told you what he really thinks about your role.

StarsSand · 28/02/2023 02:37

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/02/2023 20:23

all decisions about SS should be up to him

Then all care should be up to him.

Yes this.

Your DH should be beyond appreciative of you. Many people wouldn't have taken on what you have. Your SS is lucky to have you.

Good luck with the TT.

Ladyofthesea · 28/02/2023 02:14

I find it very concerning that he hasn't tried to toilet train his child for so many years. Tbh if I would know him in real life I would be concerned enough to call social services to have him checked for neglect. In what other areas is he neglecting his son? Thank god the boy has you.

saraclara · 27/02/2023 23:06

x2boys · 27/02/2023 21:19

If he's severely disabled it's not neglect at all my son has severe autism and learning disabilities he's nearly 13 he's toilet trained now but he was 10 when we got him out of nappies ,half his special school are still in nappies some will never train in guessing you don't have a disabled child?🙄

That poster pointed out that the father hasn't tried though. I taught children like your son, and we would talk to the parents every year about attempting training where it's possible. If it doesn't work, then were give it a break again. But there's no way we wouldn't work with the parents towards it.

Clearly OP's SS is showing the potential to be dry and clean.

Plainascanbe123 · 27/02/2023 23:00

*reminding

Plainascanbe123 · 27/02/2023 22:59

I don't understand your DP's reaction. Surely he should be pleased...

He's basically saying it's okay for you to act as SP for all this time, but the moment you do something good without him you are overstepping your boundaries and you should have sought his approval first ...

And he's deminding you that he's happy for you to care for your SS all day and every day, but you still don't have 'authority' to make decisions on SS welfare. Why is he in a relationship with you then and allowing you to help raise his child?

Sounds like he's immature and wants everything his own way.. he also doesn't seem to want to see his child make progress.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2023 21:51

Sharpbridge · 27/02/2023 21:39

Your DP isn’t parenting well I’m afraid, and is being very rude about you trying to help this shit situation. He should be thanking you. I guess he’s embarrassed that you’ve reminded him ofnhis laziness on this issue.

SS will NEVER learn toilet independence unless someone takes the time to work through weeks and weeks of encouraging him, enabling him, and crucially refusing to do it all for him. Of course it is easier to just do it for him.

That's it.

It is neglectful even if a child with disabilities if the child is expressing a wish to try and toilet train and it's 'too difficult' for the adult because there was distress four years ago.

Four years is a long time.

The point here is the kid is showing signs of wanting to and making a positive expression. That's for ALL the adults who care for him to respond to accordingly. Not go around seeking approval to appease other adults egos.

Sharpbridge · 27/02/2023 21:39

Your DP isn’t parenting well I’m afraid, and is being very rude about you trying to help this shit situation. He should be thanking you. I guess he’s embarrassed that you’ve reminded him ofnhis laziness on this issue.

SS will NEVER learn toilet independence unless someone takes the time to work through weeks and weeks of encouraging him, enabling him, and crucially refusing to do it all for him. Of course it is easier to just do it for him.

x2boys · 27/02/2023 21:19

GoodChat · 27/02/2023 18:44

He hasn't tried to toilet train his child for five years because last time he got upset. That's borderline neglect.

If he's severely disabled it's not neglect at all my son has severe autism and learning disabilities he's nearly 13 he's toilet trained now but he was 10 when we got him out of nappies ,half his special school are still in nappies some will never train in guessing you don't have a disabled child?🙄

ForestofD · 27/02/2023 21:15

100% correct. As soon as he was interested was a perfect time to start-that's half the battle. I taught my youngest loads of things by modelling that behaviour with her older sister. Well done you for seeing and acting on it- that's good teaching.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2023 21:01

SS seemed interested when DS was getting praised for using the toilet so after school on Friday (DP was away with work) I asked him if he wanted to do the same, he said yes but I was unsure as he usually says yes as an answer to most questions. However, on Saturday he went on the toilet a few times, he did have a few accidents but then yesterday he was dry all day.

DP is now home and I've told him and he isn't happy that I've done this without his ‘permission’ as all decisions about SS should be up to him, reminded me about last time - although I've not mentioned wearing underwear to SS or taken his pull ups away, accused me of pushing SS into this etc.

Let me get this straight. Your DP hasn't wanted to toilet train his son since he was eight. He's now 12. Thats four years ago.

You ask your SS if he wants to do something and he says yes. He's twelve and looking to further his own development.

But your partner has a shit fit at you 'authorising' it.

It's not even about your role in this. It's about your SS not being allowed to develop. When asked if he wants to go to the toilet himself - something about his basic dignity which he should have agency over - even as a child with learning difficulties (keeping in mind that we allow two and three year olds the chance to express whether they want to toilet train).

It's controlling and abusive for your partner to be having a shit fit at you over it.

It's even more so when you consider the dynamic with his son. Who hasn't been encouraged to toilet train for four years.

I am curious as to who cleans up the accidents too. I suspect it's you a lot of the time and your step son clearly trusts you. If he is trusting you and saying yes he wants to toilet train to you, then it's about your step son expressing himself. That's got fuck all to do with your partner in terms of making a decision. It's your step son making a decision which he is clearly capable of even with learning difficulties.

And actually that's the angle that needs shoving down your partners throat. Never mind the utter contempt he has for you.

Your step son is being deprived of any independence / dignity he can manage because it is inconvenient / difficult / doesn't suit your partner.

That's abusive. Pure and simple.

Rosebel · 27/02/2023 20:58

In your OP you said you and DP were talking about trying to toilet train your DSS so surely it was agreed that you were going to toilet train him.
Even if I've read that wrong your DP is still a massive prick. I'd just refuse to do anything and tell DP everything is on him now, especially finding childcare for his son at the weekend.
I think if you do this he'll realise he's being a twat but if he doesn't apologise and mean it then just continue to make him do everything. Or leave him as clearly he doesn't respect you.

EyesOnThePies · 27/02/2023 20:56

YANBU.

Your Dsd showed an interest and a willingness, and you responded by taking the opportunity…. While his father was away having left you in loco parentis.

Landndialamrhf · 27/02/2023 20:40

So DSS was interested in using the toilet and you let him and DH is mad?
if DSs is hungry must you call DH and ask permission to feed him?
what if DSS wants to change his clothes? Or go outside? All decisions must go through him right?

absolutely ridiculous.
if you’d taken his pull ups away and started full training maybe I’d see the point, but encouraging him to use the toilet when he wants to is not a problem
if DH thinks you’re unable to make reasonable decisions in place of him, when he’s not around, he needs to ensure he is the one caring for DSS 24/7 or that he finds someone who will do it to his standards.
also, not even attempting to potty train his son for five years, because it got a bit hard last time isn’t acceptable. He is doing DSS a disservice.

boboshmobo · 27/02/2023 20:39

Does he get money for ss , that would be my immediate thoughts to why he doesn't want him toilet trained

I have a son who has sn and it took me years of training to get him clean and dry but I wanted it so much I wasn't giving up .. we cracked it about age 6/7 .. he would still be in nappies now if I hadn't for sure !

Well done 👍

TomatoSandwiches · 27/02/2023 20:39
  • he should be grateful, sorry.
TomatoSandwiches · 27/02/2023 20:38

You have done such an amazing job of picking up the signs your SS was ready to try toileting again it breaks my heart a bit for your husband to have this reaction towards you tbh.

I have a child with ASD, still in pull ups and it sounds like your husband has fallen into the trap of thinking that it's easier overall if he just carries on doing what he is used to now instead of trying to encourage progress with his son.
It is a fallacy and he so grateful should be so grateful he has a supportive wife to help.
To not carry on with what you and SS have already achieved will negatively affect his son in the future, his stance is damaging, he needs to be made to understand this.

That boy is as much yours as his now, thank you for doing such a lovely job with him op.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 27/02/2023 20:37

I've got a severely autistic and learning disabled son and consistency is the key.if he's made progress in two days he's doing well so get your other half on board.
Its obviously going to cause a bit of distress as your changing the way he's toileted for all his life but it needs to be done so your other half needs to keep doing it too.

GabriellaMontez · 27/02/2023 20:37

LaFemmeDamnee · 27/02/2023 18:45

So you're good enough to act as a mother, and tend to all his personal care needs. But not allowed to make a decision. Fuck that.

This.

Littlefaeries · 27/02/2023 20:36

From now on ring your dp every time you have to do something for ss.
He wants a cheese sandwich, that OK?
Can ss wear his new trainers to the park?
Is ss allowed to go on his game?
Will you be free to take ss swimming/doctors/etc?

Give it a week.

aSofaNearYou · 27/02/2023 20:36

Actual issue with DSS aside, YANBU - your DP has an absolute cheek talking of "permission" when he's away with work and you've been looking after his child for him (and a child with complex needs at that). He should be eternally grateful to you, and ashamed of himself for saying that.

TheToyStoreAlienMum · 27/02/2023 20:35

YANBU

My DC has some LDs and took ages to potty train. For awhile while they were in preschool room of Nursery they'd just let DC sit on the toilet when their friends went, whether DC did anything or not they'd get a sticker and then that progressed to only getting the sticker if they did something etc.

It took 4 years in total to get them out of nappies fully including night time, and a lot of hardwork, but it was so worth it.

Well done you for being such a good mum to your DSS!