Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How come some people ’get it all’, or nearly all, and some people really don’t get to have anything - other than a shit sandwich of a life?

208 replies

TabooOfNoSex · 27/02/2023 17:10

It is baffling to me.
It really is.

That someone can have (relatively) good health, mental healt, friends, at least ok parent(s),
bf/gf - MANY of them through out life - as in multiple people wanted to love them, kids (if they want them), pretty/handsome, be at least okey in school/ be pretty smart, money, people who want to spend time with them… etc.

I consider all of these things to be incredible privileges and yet so many people don’t even have to think about it.
Nevermind have multiple things on that list.

And then are people who got fuck all…

Now, please don’t hit me with the comparison is the thief of joy, this is not about that obviously.
And I know I get told IABU, just having a little sad vent now that I’m once again feeling nothing will ever work out for me.

But still!
Shouldn’t there be like a cosmic balance that everyone would at least get something?
Something to make this life worth living.

OP posts:
anythinginapinch · 27/02/2023 20:12

My belief is, everyone gets some shit in life's sarnie, each of us has a time of profound struggle and pain. For some it's early in life, for some the middle but, some of us haven't had it yet but it's a-coming.

I would say - and often do - that I'm one of the luckiest people you'll ever meet. But 10 years ago I was a total miserable angry mess. Even now my life is far far from perfect. But lucky omg yes.

I think some people are just, well, luckier. My dads a lucky person - runs for a train, just misses it, next train he meets someone whose in his line of work, turns out to be a great contact blah blah. Loses a fiver finds a fifty. But - he's blessed with self belief, great communication skills, a "friendly" face ... all of which he passed on to me, which makes the useful chap on the train start chatting, whereas if we had a less friendly face the connection wouldn't have been made.

It's fucking unfair. I count my many blessings and share what I have as best I can.

Swisspolkadot · 27/02/2023 20:06

@Willowtre1 I really loved your post. I keep rereading it x

OutsideLookingOut · 27/02/2023 20:04

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/02/2023 19:42

I could’ve written your post OP. I’m really sorry.

Honestly if there were a painless way to die tomorrow I’d absolutely take it. I’m not even 40 and I’ve just had a gutfull of it.

I’m so sorry, I could not read and just skip this though I have nothing to offer you. I can still hope things get better for you.

For some of these posts I just want to reply with “Oh please!” That is not to say that you can’t always change your path but we should recognise some people are thrown in pits they can’t ever escape even with all effort.

MrsBradyOIdLady · 27/02/2023 19:57

I have what looks like a pretty cushy life.

Grew up in a huge house with loads of siblings and a happy family. Did well in school, have an amazing job, lots of money, gorgeous house, amazing husband.

If people dug deeper, they’d know that there was serious money issues growing up so that my parents could keep that magnificent house that looked amazing from the outside but was crumbling inside; that all of my siblings grew up in an emotionally and occasionally physically abusive home that has had huge impacts on us as adults and really caused a lot of issues with our ability to form relationships; that I’ve struggled hugely with a health issue that has shaped my life massively and I’m fighting every day to keep working; and that my very lovely husband has severe mental health issues that have dictated pretty much every aspect of our lives for twenty years.

I’m a private person and don’t share those elements. I don’t like to burden people, or be seen as weak or not in control.

Do don’t be too judgmental, OP, everyone is carrying their own load.

KarmaStar · 27/02/2023 19:53

Everyone has their own life path.we are all here to evolve by learning.
Try not to look at others and see a perfect life,they won't be perfect 100% of the time.Accept the path you chose,yes,you chose,and practice when you can,mindful living.there is a reason why we go through hard times,for now we can't see it but,in time,it will make sense.🌈

gogohmm · 27/02/2023 19:49

It's partly down to your situation family wise but not entirely, some people make far better decisions and cease opportunities better eg both my ex h and I were not born into money but went through schools taking the opportunity to learn (sink comps, very few went to 6th form) then university. I took good financial decisions, no family help, he chose a good career. We went our separate ways but are living proof you can't blame your upbringing on your life chances

Maverickess · 27/02/2023 19:47

Livinghappy · 27/02/2023 17:39

@2bazookas Many people I know who "have it all" got there with the same effort as less fortunate people - they just had more luck or better genes from the outset.

We are not all created equally so effort for one person will not generate the same result as it does for another. One of my dc is incredibly bright, he does not have to work as hard as others, which gives him more time for hobbies, friendships etc.

Quite simply he is luckier than many. I try to make sure he knows that he has had a headstart in life, as I don't want him to look down on others, who might not achieve as much as he does.

This is how I see it and see examples of it around me too.

We're not all starting from the same place and all have different set backs at different times.

I am the eldest of 3, I have a different 'real' dad to them, they have the same dad, and he brought all 3 of us up, me from being 4, them from being born.
The middle sibling is by far the most successful, but, she's also not had to face some of the issues myself and the younger sibling have such as physical health issues (some because of lifestyle and some not) and mental health issues.

She's also the only one who was planned. That's not to say me and my youngest sibling weren't loved or looked after, but she was longed for and came along after years of trying and losses.

My own father was abusive and he put my mum through hell and was in and out of my life like a yo-yo and I genuinely think those early experiences changed the dynamic between me and my mum. From both perspectives.

My youngest sibling was the result of missed contraception (as parents attest) and came very soon after the middle one, and I think it was overwhelming for our parents having two very young children and a confused and mentally unwell teen all at the same time (not that I don't understand why!).

And I think those circumstances meant that although we all had the same physical parents for most of our lives, we had very different experiences and none of us started from the same place, and we have all had different set backs to contend with.
But the middle sibling has always been a little ahead and therefore has found the challenges easier to contend with, my youngest sibling and I had to work harder to just keep our heads above water, so any setback had a deeper effect than it would have done the middle one.

For example youngest and I are in 'unskilled' occupations, but have stuck with it through a lot and worked hard and managed to claw our way up a bit, and middle has an MA and professional job and out earned us on entry to the profession. We've all worked hard, but the outcomes have been very different.

I don't resent middle at all, I'm incredibly proud of the achievements, but it does get tiresome (not from them but it's a belief you see a fair amount of in society and definitely on here!) that middle has worked harder and made more sacrifices and that's why they're where they are and nothing to do with some of the advantages they had starting and along the way.

taxguru · 27/02/2023 19:42

@VanillaSox

People who look at the positives live longer and happier lives.

In general, yes, I think they tend to live longer and happier. Just look at some pop stars - I'm talking about the successful ones, that have that perfect mix of raw talent, hard work, luck, etc (not just the z list slebs famous from reality tv!). Some soar with the eagles and go from strength to strength, whatever shit life throws at them. Others seem to self destruct even though they aren't shat upon from above! Just why? Well the difference always seems to be positivity.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/02/2023 19:42

I could’ve written your post OP. I’m really sorry.

Honestly if there were a painless way to die tomorrow I’d absolutely take it. I’m not even 40 and I’ve just had a gutfull of it.

PinotPony · 27/02/2023 19:41

I agree with the comments that upbringing has a lot to do with it, not only whether you have a "good" start in life (as that invariably creates more opportunities) but how you are taught to view life and its challenges, how resilient you are to stresses.

I genuinely believe that a positive outlook makes a massive difference. All the people I know who seemingly have shit lives spend their time moaning about their shit lives, they do nothing to help themselves. It almost becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

DeadbeatYoda · 27/02/2023 19:32

There is no reason to expect life to be fundamentally fair, it's entirely random, a genetic / geographical lottery. It's the job of our society to try and iron things out a bit ( unless you are a Tory, that is).

VanillaSox · 27/02/2023 19:31

Ariela · 27/02/2023 18:38

A lot depends on how you look at life. I go round thinking positively, that's my natural default. So the car breaks down, never mind it's nice to walk. That type of thing.

This.
People who look at the positives live longer and happier lives.
Also what you see from the outside is not all it seems.
The woman who wanted my life a need and went all out to get it now see what it was really like.

OldSkoolLikeHappyShopper · 27/02/2023 19:31

I think it’s a matter of perspective.

I could describe my life as: single mother of 2 DC with additional needs who are incredibly challenging. Own chronic health problems (registered disabled). Head permanently fucked by an extremely abusive relationship which caused my physical health problems too. Not rich. No husband, never likely to have one, and have to do everything myself. Small circle of friends. Don’t really go out to social events at all.

OR I could describe it as: mum of 2 wonderful kids who despite their difficulties are pretty cool humans. Part time job which I love and is fulfilling, and pays enough money to live. The past hasn’t been great but makes me appreciate the now. Have a lovely bf who lives far away and I don’t get to see much, but I love dearly and enjoy the time we do get so much. Some close friends who completely love and accept me for who I am and vice versa.

Nevermind31 · 27/02/2023 19:26

upbringing has a lot to do with it. Better education means more knowledge, which can equip you to make better choices. Connections.
external circumstances are unfair. A terminal illness. A disabled child. Redundancy…
but someone who has a good support network and a believe that things will work out for them will have better resilience to deal with that too, and they will still cope better/ have more than someone who was already struggling/ has no support network

blubberball · 27/02/2023 19:23

The Frank Grimes/Homer Simpson episode is springing to mind reading this thread.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 27/02/2023 19:22

Livinghappy · 27/02/2023 18:43

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime, what do you helped you to meet a great DH ? Luck, secure attachment so you chose well or something else?

I know 2 sisters, both close in age, both married. Older sister married a man who has been highly sucessful (lucky as well as he benefitted from nepotism) consequently her life has been easier, not stress free or without some ups & downs but nothing too difficult. She has not had to work full time and has help in the home as well as paid childcare so able to cultivate hobbies & friendships.

The other sister's husband developed MS, so she became a carer and their standard of life dropped enormously as both unable to work full time. Husband died around the same time as their mum became ill. Same sister ends up caring for the mum so has never been able to fulfil her career. She hasn't had children either.

The difference in their lives is enormous and the root cause was the health & subsequent wealth of their husbands.

I met him in a pub and we liked each other so we started talking and that built into a relationship.

Continuing that relationship for 22 years has been work, it's not perfect, he isn't a perfect human being and neither am I.

We disagree about lots of things but we handle that by either

  • talking it through till we come to an agreement or compromise
  • talking it through until we realise we can't agree but we can respect/tolerate each others view point

We keep the humour, both sarcastic and dark humoured and neither of us take life too seriously.

We accept each others faults and play to our strengths. He has no career drive, is doing the same job for the same salary now as he was 10 years ago. I've quadrupled my salary in that time and pay the lions share of the household finances.

He's more emotionally intelligent, funny and artistic. He could play silly fun games with DD for hours and be enamoured by it while I'll be bored and just playing along 30 minutes in.

He was there for me when both parents died, I was there when his alcoholic dad died, we've supported each other through illnesses, job losses, infertility etc and enjoyed each others company through the good times.

You could say it's luck that we met in the pub that day, but everything that happened afterwards was decisions. The decision to stay together when things get hard, the decision to approach a situation calmly rather than to give into anger, or fear or upset and start a fight, the decision to overlook differences and try to find common ground, the decision to treat each other as equals and to share workload and responsibilities, the decision to have conversations about what's bothering us rather than bottle it up, to work together to find solutions, to call out when something is important to either of us and to agree on what is important to us collectively as a family.

QuieterMass · 27/02/2023 19:21

Polis · 27/02/2023 19:11

For to him who has will more be given; and from him who has not, even what he has will be taken away

It’s worth noting that that verse refers to insight into Jesus’s message, not material goods, talent, influence etc.

Ah, that makes sense. I thought it was a general rule! (Especially as it does seem to happen that way with material goods etc.)

hattie43 · 27/02/2023 19:18

Shit life - A lot of it is down to poor choices .
Good life - making the most of opportunities that come your way , positive outlook and grit to change your lot

Badbadbunny · 27/02/2023 19:18

An awful lot of it is absolutely random. Yes, childhood and education are key factors but even if you've had a brilliant childhood and excellent education, life still throws curveballs at you. Yes, a lot of it also depends on choices you make. But lots of healthy people suffer serious health conditions for no obvious reason, lots of people suffer marriage breakdowns through no fault of their own, lots of people lose their jobs or businesses through no fault or their own (look at the effects of Covid lockdowns on business failures!).

The best you can do is put yourself in the best possible position to weather life's storms. No guarantees of course, but with a good education you're more likely to have a good job/career, and more likely to have independent earnings/finances in case of relationship breakdowns. (People can also become financially successful after poor educations, but less likely). If you are careful with your diet, don't over-indulge with alcohol, don't take drugs, you're more likely to be able to get through a serious health condition (or live longer if it's something terminal). Avoid drugs and you're less likely to suffer from MH problems. Note I say "more" or "less" likely - there are no guarantees! It's all probability not certainty.

My OH has terminal cancer. It's one of those cancers that has no known causes - apparently just purely random, maybe some genetic tendency according to statistics but none of his relatives have suffered it. He's never smoked, never drank more than one or two drinks at social events, never taken drugs, done regular sport/exercise, healthy weight, etc, so his diagnosis knocked him for six as he really couldn't have done anything more to avoid it! The "good" thing, if there is such a thing, is that he is/was so healthy generally, that he's responded exceptionally well to the treatment and has already lived well beyond the "normal" life expectancy after diagnosis and still going strong, so his healthy living may well have helped him through treatment and extend his life - according to his oncologist, his treatment will continue for as long as it keeps the cancer cells from spreading and the healthier you are and the better "lifestyle" you have will increase the effectiveness of the chemo and reduce the impact of the side effects!

Willowtre1 · 27/02/2023 19:16

And also - acceptance that life is just intrinsically chaotic, no one is owed a balance of good times and bad. It really does help to overcome those gutting feelings of it's not fair erc

Willowtre1 · 27/02/2023 19:14

I think it is a combination of your start in life, your personality, your resilience, your wherewithal to seek help/problem solve, your propensity for mental health difficulties, an unfair social system (which dictates a lot of how things go for people), and on top of that sheer good luck or bad luck.
People with the better start are probably less likely to have some of the difficulties those with a bad start face, but personality, propensity for mental health problems and luck all get in the way and can either make things better, or de-rail life.
The only thing I can offer, having been through a very difficult period of my life, is that having clarity on your values and what you think is most important in life is vital to feeling content. In that mindset you can appreciate the smaller, simple things that make life enjoyable and stop striving for things that are not meaningful. The ability to get through hardship though is of course dependant on the factors above, not least financial stability - which doesn't buy happiness but removes a huge source of worry and allows you to seek support.
I'm sorry for everyone having a difficult time x

Sunset6 · 27/02/2023 19:13

Interesting thread. Every sympathy for those posting who have serious health issues, bereavements, bad things happen to them in childhood etc, which are totally out of your control. However with a lot of the things people are talking about (jobs, relationships, housing etc) there is normally a lot that most people can do to help themselves and you are better off taking ownership of your decisions rather than playing the victim and comparing yourself to others. Few people are totally unemployable, totally unable to get a partner, or have absolutely no choice over where they live - so if you are unhappy with your situation there’s normally something you can do to improve it.

Polis · 27/02/2023 19:11

For to him who has will more be given; and from him who has not, even what he has will be taken away

It’s worth noting that that verse refers to insight into Jesus’s message, not material goods, talent, influence etc.

Guis · 27/02/2023 19:10

Life isn't fair.
Who your family are. How bright you are. Your life experiences. Health.
It just isn't fair.
You can make the best of your situation. It might mean you have a health condition you can do nothing about but do the best you can regardless.
At some point realise that no matter any difficulties of the past you can decide how life goes forward for you now. And to find value in yourself and not rely on someone else to provide it for you.

March12th · 27/02/2023 19:00

This not thin ffs!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread