Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with being uncomfortable having a tracker on my car

211 replies

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 17:08

My DP recently bought and put a new stereo in my car. It's very fancy, you can operate it by app, does loads of stuff, I don't understand half of it, just enough to be able to do the basics I need. I did need a new stereo.

Driving my DS to school this morning, I took a different route so I could run an errand on the way. A message came in on the phone from my DP, and my DS read it to me. He asked what I was doing down X road, rather than my usual route. When I stopped at school, I talked to DP briefly by message, discovered that the stereo contains a tracker. DP claims he didn't know this. I said I had never agreed to be tracked, so he said he would turn off that function on the app on his phone. But he said it would be really useful if it was ever stolen, or I lost the car in a car park.

In the afternoon school run, I got a message from DP asking if I had the engine running, as apparently it also records engine temperature.

I feel uncomfortable. I'm not sure if I should be or not. I'm not doing anything I shouldn't be, in my life. DP says he will leave the tracker function turned off on his phone. Even so. AIBU?

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/02/2023 21:06

Controlling? I don't think so. I am a SAHM, so he earns the money, pays the bills, most things are in his name. We don't share banks. I have CB as 'my' spending money, and he puts some extra in my bank once a month, and extra if I ask. A friend of mine has said she thinks things should be in joint names, but because I don't earn, that's not always been possible, some companies won't accept me

Let me guess - he told you this? You don't have to be earning to be on a mortgage, or any other type of financial account. You are being played.

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 21:00

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 20:27

We’ve got a lot of these kinds of IoT
devices - I can turn the bedroom fan on and off, change the warmth and brightness of the lightbulbs…heck, I can even remotely lock the catflap.

All of these things come with notifications (my catflap app meows to tell me which one if my cats has entered or exited…or even just peeked through the flap!).

I bet, when he installed it, he accepted the pop up that said ‘allow this app to send you notifications’ and then when you went out, it popped up to say the stereo was moving (useful feature, if the associated phone isn’t in the same location, as it might indicate that some ne’er-do-well has snuck off with the stereo or the car).

I would be hard-pressed not to have a look, in curiosity. And then query why DP is wandering down a weird route (in a ‘is there roadworks or an accident…I wonder what changed up the routine?’ way). And then play around with all of the functions and go ‘how cool, did you know you could check the engine temp?!’.

I don’t see anything wrong with this. Sounds like you have a healthy relationship. Sounds like there’s trust and respect between you. Sounds like you married a geek (woop!).

I can appreciate that you might feel uncomfortable with him knowing where you are (can’t relate, we have Find My for each other’s phones and it’s super useful, as in ‘oh, I see you’re just passing Tesco, can you pop in and grab a metric fuckton of chocolate for me as it’s that time of month thx bye!’). But I’d just ask him to switch off notifications while you’re driving the car. That way you’re protected and he’s not getting distracted by the shiny new app notifications.

Simples.

I can’t believe you have taken this from the OP’s posts. Have you read the follow ups to the original??? 🤯
‘I would be hard-pressed not to have a look, in curiosity. And then query why DP is wandering down a weird route (in a ‘is there roadworks or an accident…I wonder what changed up the routine?’ way). And then play around with all of the functions and go’ - I mean you do you but most people absolutely wouldn’t do this.

Snugglemonkey · 27/02/2023 20:59

This is freaky as fuck. I would demand the spyware is removed.

FictionalCharacter · 27/02/2023 20:48

@LaughingCat Simples if you trust each other, but OP’s partner lied to her, he said he didn’t know there was a tracker despite having the app on his phone.

@Justmeandthedog1 I agree, I would never allow a child to control anything to do with a car, including the stereo. If he was sitting in the back turning it up full and switching stations every 10 seconds you wouldn’t be able to stop him.

Justmeandthedog1 · 27/02/2023 20:40

The app has also been put on my DS phone, so he can play with the stereo too.

I’m a bit of a safety nerd so is your ds ( don’t know his age) having control of your stereo really a good idea? I’m thinking child thinks it’s funny to switch it off then on again at full volume might just cause an accident. Playing with it switching stations, music, volume and driver can’t control it sounds very distracting.

poppylock · 27/02/2023 20:37

The CB are your NI contributions as long as it's paid direct to you?

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 20:27

We’ve got a lot of these kinds of IoT
devices - I can turn the bedroom fan on and off, change the warmth and brightness of the lightbulbs…heck, I can even remotely lock the catflap.

All of these things come with notifications (my catflap app meows to tell me which one if my cats has entered or exited…or even just peeked through the flap!).

I bet, when he installed it, he accepted the pop up that said ‘allow this app to send you notifications’ and then when you went out, it popped up to say the stereo was moving (useful feature, if the associated phone isn’t in the same location, as it might indicate that some ne’er-do-well has snuck off with the stereo or the car).

I would be hard-pressed not to have a look, in curiosity. And then query why DP is wandering down a weird route (in a ‘is there roadworks or an accident…I wonder what changed up the routine?’ way). And then play around with all of the functions and go ‘how cool, did you know you could check the engine temp?!’.

I don’t see anything wrong with this. Sounds like you have a healthy relationship. Sounds like there’s trust and respect between you. Sounds like you married a geek (woop!).

I can appreciate that you might feel uncomfortable with him knowing where you are (can’t relate, we have Find My for each other’s phones and it’s super useful, as in ‘oh, I see you’re just passing Tesco, can you pop in and grab a metric fuckton of chocolate for me as it’s that time of month thx bye!’). But I’d just ask him to switch off notifications while you’re driving the car. That way you’re protected and he’s not getting distracted by the shiny new app notifications.

Simples.

Greenfairydust · 27/02/2023 20:18

Having a tracker on the car makes sense from a safety point of view should it get stolen.

But that does not mean that it should be used as a tool for your partner to keep tabs on you.

I find it very worrying that:

  • he lied about not knowing that the tracker was there. That's nonsensical since he was actively tracking you without your knowledge so of course he knew about the tracker
  • he immediately messaged you to demand to known why you were taking a different route

Frankly I would really concerned that this is the start of an active attempt to control you.

Very likely that he got the stereo on purpose to install a tracking device and he is trying to gaslight you into thinking his behaviour is acceptable.

This would all be a massive red flag to me and I would be concerned that his behaviour is only going to escalate. This is not normal or acceptable.

BertHandsome · 27/02/2023 20:10

DP says he wasn't aware of the feature when he bought it, and I believe that. He's quite a techy sort
He’s a techy sort, he absolutely would have known about it. And IF he didn’t, big if! he wouldn’t have turned it on if he respected you. Come on OP, you’re being incredibly naïve here, alongside the financial abuse…, scary.

cassiatwenty · 27/02/2023 19:59

All right.

It doesn't have to be all or nothing. As in, this thread has been a little intense but you are doing what you can, when you can.

It might be beneficial to touch base with someone (new) face to face IRL. Even if things were swell, it's still important that you are connected to different people who make you feel safe.

It's good that you keep at it. Sometimes it's hard to leave the house, some days are more productive. So sometimes it might feel like one step forward, two steps back. That's okay.

As you struggle with MH, it might help to find someone positive and gentle to talk to on a regular basis. Perhaps your GP can be of help.

Clymene · 27/02/2023 19:58

You're in an abusive relationship, of course you have poor mental health.

How long have you been together? How many children? Do you know anything about your finances - hoe much he earns, how much your mortgage is, anything?

ArcticSkewer · 27/02/2023 19:46

Why aren't you married? His decision?

It's quite possible that you are depressed because of your relationship rather than in spite of it.

You own nothing, have no assets in your name, no job, get pocket money (I actually give my children the same amount per week spending money!), and now he tracks you and wants to know why you drive down a slightly different route

Things are not looking good

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 19:46

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 19:43

I am financially vulnerable, I know this. And it kind of happened like the boiling frog - a little at a time. And some while I was really struggling with my MH.

I have no property of my own, and have made no NI contributions since I gave up work to have first DS. I can't afford to make contributions, and we previously couldn't afford it as a family.

My friend has been pushing me to make some changes, but I do struggle - MH again. Equally it would be hard to get work, as some days I am ok, other days I can barely leave the house. I force myself for the DS only. Other than them, I have very little life. Distant family, and a couple of friends I see just occasionally when I am well enough.

Don’t despair. I think CB is relevant to contributions for NI if you don’t work, is that not correct? Someone better informed will fill you in. There is nothing to stop your partner adding you to the deeds of the property. The simplest solution is of course to get married. Is there any reason why you haven’t/won’t? Are you having help with your health? That’s vital for you.

Shmithecat2 · 27/02/2023 19:45

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 19:43

I am financially vulnerable, I know this. And it kind of happened like the boiling frog - a little at a time. And some while I was really struggling with my MH.

I have no property of my own, and have made no NI contributions since I gave up work to have first DS. I can't afford to make contributions, and we previously couldn't afford it as a family.

My friend has been pushing me to make some changes, but I do struggle - MH again. Equally it would be hard to get work, as some days I am ok, other days I can barely leave the house. I force myself for the DS only. Other than them, I have very little life. Distant family, and a couple of friends I see just occasionally when I am well enough.

Claiming child benefit will give you NI credits so you don't need to worry about that too much but I'm guessing there's no private pension you pay into and that your name is not on the mortgage or deeds of the house (assuming its bought not rented)?

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 19:44

I do appreciate everyone's feedback and support, and will give it a lot of thought, and consider my next actions.

OP posts:
Hawkins000 · 27/02/2023 19:44

in terms of security i can understand your dp, perspective, as for the misuse of tracking and micro management , i can understand your perspectives op

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 19:43

I am financially vulnerable, I know this. And it kind of happened like the boiling frog - a little at a time. And some while I was really struggling with my MH.

I have no property of my own, and have made no NI contributions since I gave up work to have first DS. I can't afford to make contributions, and we previously couldn't afford it as a family.

My friend has been pushing me to make some changes, but I do struggle - MH again. Equally it would be hard to get work, as some days I am ok, other days I can barely leave the house. I force myself for the DS only. Other than them, I have very little life. Distant family, and a couple of friends I see just occasionally when I am well enough.

OP posts:
Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 27/02/2023 19:42

Sahm and I'm on everything. Mortgage, deeds, every utility bill. If memory serves I wasn't on the bins or possibly the Sky at one stage but that's so we could take advantage of new business customer rates instead of returning business.

On the flip side I do get CB paid into my account and topped up, but that's purely accounting and to save unnecessary transfers. I'm topped up so that our discretionary spends match and everything else is joint.

Shmithecat2 · 27/02/2023 19:40

GoodChat · 27/02/2023 19:00

A friend of mine has said she thinks things should be in joint names, but because I don't earn, that's not always been possible, some companies won't accept me.

Let me guess, he told you that?

Indeed. I'm a SAHM. My name is on everything I want it to be.

bigbluebus · 27/02/2023 19:40

Why is the App on his phone and not yours? If it's your stereo in your car then he shouldn't need the app.
The issue is not the feature of the stereo, the issue us your DP tracking you and questioning your movements.

Notsurewhattothinkaboutit · 27/02/2023 19:39

The sinister thing is how closely he is monitoring you and immediately questioning you. Fuck that. He knew exactly what he was doing.

IAmMeThisIsI · 27/02/2023 19:34

It depends. I bet you can probably set the car stereo so that it doesn't link to other devices or deactivate the location settings. Maybe it's just a feature of the stereo as it does sound modern etc. But you need to ask if YOU'RE comfortable with this.

Sharpbridge · 27/02/2023 19:32

I wouldn’t care about the tracker per se, but I would be LIVID to receive backseat driver type messages demanding that I explain why I was driving X route and whether or not the engine is on. That is extremely controlling. It doesn’t matter whether you think he is controlling, or if he has done it before. Sending you real time messages about your driving is controlling behaviour.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 27/02/2023 19:32

Controlling? I don't think so. I am a SAHM, so he earns the money, pays the bills, most things are in his name. We don't share banks. I have CB as 'my' spending money, and he puts some extra in my bank once a month, and extra if I ask

As a fellow sahm (mostly) also with mental health issues I'd find that controlling. I'm on the mortage, the deeds and everything else I need to be. No company has ever had an issue with that. Every penny my dh earns goes into a joint account as does his family money from a trust. Given that he trusts me to raise our children, he also trusts me to spend whatever I like on whatever I want.

CB is very little money in the scheme of things and having an "allowance" and/or asking for more doesn't sound like an equal relationship.

MadeofElephantStone · 27/02/2023 19:30

If you are a SAHM and not married, have you been topping up your national insurance in that time? Your position is hugely vulnerable, no income, no pension, no rights to the financial gains your partner has made at the expense of your earning potential. You really shouldn't have to ask for extra money like you are a child rather than an equal partner of 20 years. I think you know things aren't right and your friends are trying to warn you.