Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with being uncomfortable having a tracker on my car

211 replies

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 17:08

My DP recently bought and put a new stereo in my car. It's very fancy, you can operate it by app, does loads of stuff, I don't understand half of it, just enough to be able to do the basics I need. I did need a new stereo.

Driving my DS to school this morning, I took a different route so I could run an errand on the way. A message came in on the phone from my DP, and my DS read it to me. He asked what I was doing down X road, rather than my usual route. When I stopped at school, I talked to DP briefly by message, discovered that the stereo contains a tracker. DP claims he didn't know this. I said I had never agreed to be tracked, so he said he would turn off that function on the app on his phone. But he said it would be really useful if it was ever stolen, or I lost the car in a car park.

In the afternoon school run, I got a message from DP asking if I had the engine running, as apparently it also records engine temperature.

I feel uncomfortable. I'm not sure if I should be or not. I'm not doing anything I shouldn't be, in my life. DP says he will leave the tracker function turned off on his phone. Even so. AIBU?

OP posts:
Crumpleton · 27/02/2023 22:40

GrazingSheep · 27/02/2023 17:11

Replace the system.

And let your DP put this one in their car.

ConcordeOoter · 27/02/2023 22:40

There's a chance he is playing with the app that goes with the gadget and going through all the cool things it can do, and expected you to think it was cool, too, not having thought through how it came across.

If he is normally nice and you trust him, and the above sounds likely, definitely demand he promise to not track what you do.

If he isn't and you don't, I would get it removed or it would have an unfortunate malfunction.

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 22:38

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 22:27

Sorry! Mixed you up with someone else on here who did raise that point earlier - thought they’d come back on my response and I wondered why they thought I was ignoring most of their post!

Also, apologies. I saw red when you said the whole ‘you do you…but you’re weird’ comment - I shouldn’t have responded the way I did.

No worries at all!

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 22:27

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 22:08

I personally didn’t say anything about her partner lying to her about being on the mortgage or bills, though he likely is. My only point is that she has no security and her partner in addition to tracking her and controlling her access to money allows this position to continue despite their long relationship and her care for their children.

Sorry! Mixed you up with someone else on here who did raise that point earlier - thought they’d come back on my response and I wondered why they thought I was ignoring most of their post!

Also, apologies. I saw red when you said the whole ‘you do you…but you’re weird’ comment - I shouldn’t have responded the way I did.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 22:11

How do you like your new cage, and status as a hamster?

Seriously no good will come of this, and he sounds controlling. Give it a year and you will be a shell of yourself as he used the evidence he's gathered to tell you how shit you are and how your safety is vital.

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 22:08

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 22:05

Yes, exactly - that’s why I said I wasn’t disagreeing with you and that it’s a red flag that she’s not an equal partner in the finances. Totally agreeing with what you’re saying in every way. I was just querying what you said about him lying to her about not being allowed on the mortgage or certain bills, as my personal experience seems to suggest otherwise.

However, I made the point that my situation is totally different because my marriage-hating other half married me without a second thought as soon as he possibly could after the mortgage adviser gave us the news. Miles away from the OP’s experience.

So, definitely not disagreeing at all on the sentiment of your post, just that one minor point on the mortgage and bills.

I personally didn’t say anything about her partner lying to her about being on the mortgage or bills, though he likely is. My only point is that she has no security and her partner in addition to tracking her and controlling her access to money allows this position to continue despite their long relationship and her care for their children.

viques · 27/02/2023 22:07

He didn’t know there was a tracker? Hmmm.

Clymene · 27/02/2023 22:07

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 21:54

Laughingcat - I think the way you word it is largely how it likely happened. Totally in character.

And your experience with credit is right too - there are companies who will not let credit (whatever form it takes - mortgages, rental agreements, finance, etc) be in the name of someone with no income.

There have been some really kind comments on this thread, and definitely some food for thought for me, and there need to be some changes ahead. I have been too passive and allowed things to drift. But I do not recognise my kind and supportive DP in some of the posts.

Can I ask if any of your other friends and family have expressed concerns or is it just the one friend?

verdantverdure · 27/02/2023 22:06

If he didn't know it had a tracker how did he know you'd gone a different route @TrackMyCar?

And why did he ask you about it?

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 22:05

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 21:38

But you were on the deeds and you got married when you couldn’t be put on them. So nothing like the OP. The OP only has CB and what her partner deigns to give her. You sound like you have your own income.

Yes, exactly - that’s why I said I wasn’t disagreeing with you and that it’s a red flag that she’s not an equal partner in the finances. Totally agreeing with what you’re saying in every way. I was just querying what you said about him lying to her about not being allowed on the mortgage or certain bills, as my personal experience seems to suggest otherwise.

However, I made the point that my situation is totally different because my marriage-hating other half married me without a second thought as soon as he possibly could after the mortgage adviser gave us the news. Miles away from the OP’s experience.

So, definitely not disagreeing at all on the sentiment of your post, just that one minor point on the mortgage and bills.

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 22:00

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 21:54

Laughingcat - I think the way you word it is largely how it likely happened. Totally in character.

And your experience with credit is right too - there are companies who will not let credit (whatever form it takes - mortgages, rental agreements, finance, etc) be in the name of someone with no income.

There have been some really kind comments on this thread, and definitely some food for thought for me, and there need to be some changes ahead. I have been too passive and allowed things to drift. But I do not recognise my kind and supportive DP in some of the posts.

The big difference with the poster you mentioned is that her partner did have her on the deeds of the house. When for whatever reason that wasn’t possible, they got married. That’s a major, major difference in terms of how your partner treats you.

FictionalCharacter · 27/02/2023 22:00

StickofVeg · 27/02/2023 21:49

Both our cars have trackers and we can track them on our phone apps. Doesn't bother me at all. DP had never asked about any of my journeys and I rarely look at his - just if he's late and I check he hasn't come to harm

OK, but OP’s DP does look at hers, then messages her asking questions. So she’s not in the same situation as you.

Botw1 · 27/02/2023 21:57

@TrackMyCar

You haven't answered why he was asking why your route had changed

DancingDaughter50 · 27/02/2023 21:54

How well do you know him?

If my dh did this I would think it's a good idea but he's not weird or creepy etc and I don't care if he knows where i am.

I would love a proper sterio, mine is so old it has a tape player.

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 21:54

Laughingcat - I think the way you word it is largely how it likely happened. Totally in character.

And your experience with credit is right too - there are companies who will not let credit (whatever form it takes - mortgages, rental agreements, finance, etc) be in the name of someone with no income.

There have been some really kind comments on this thread, and definitely some food for thought for me, and there need to be some changes ahead. I have been too passive and allowed things to drift. But I do not recognise my kind and supportive DP in some of the posts.

OP posts:
StickofVeg · 27/02/2023 21:49

Both our cars have trackers and we can track them on our phone apps. Doesn't bother me at all. DP had never asked about any of my journeys and I rarely look at his - just if he's late and I check he hasn't come to harm

ZeilanBlueSky · 27/02/2023 21:48

MadeofElephantStone · 27/02/2023 18:01

This is a good point. I wouldn't like this at all and would hate to have to justify a perfectly reasonable activity of driving another route. Take the whole radio out of your car and be wary of any other tracking devices he may have on your phone/ tablet etc. Seriously creepy behaviour.

Yes, I'd be getting my other devices checked for tracking/logging/spyware apps.

Going straight to a stereo with tracking and other capabilities (the engine) is quite a leap.

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 21:38

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 21:32

I was on the call with the bank when we bought our new house last year - until then I’d been named on the deeds of the last house but not the mortgage (my credit rating at the time thanks to a stupid default would have given us a worse deal than his earnings alone). This time, found out banks just aren’t willing to do that anymore, told me to my face that there was no way I could be on the mortgage or the deeds. So I’m not. (My OH then married me on the next available date at our local registry office to ensure that I would still be entitled to my share of the property should he die/we split).

This is happening to a lot of friends if they don't earn, as well. Mortgages are getting tighter.

There’s lots of bills in either my or his name. Only a couple in both.

I agree though, total red flag that the OP isn’t more involved with the finances - that should be something both are across, aware of and involved with regardless of earning status - but sometimes a void of earning status, especially when it comes to credit agreements, has a huge impact on available deals and therefore it’s more financially savvy as a family unit to not be named on there.

So not disagreeing in any way, shape or form, but just saying that it’s not always the case that you are automatically entitled to be on the mortgage or some other bills.

But you were on the deeds and you got married when you couldn’t be put on them. So nothing like the OP. The OP only has CB and what her partner deigns to give her. You sound like you have your own income.

Clymene · 27/02/2023 21:38

@LaughingCat - lenders lend money to a person. They don't care who the property belongs to so that's bullshit. It's perfectly possible even if you have a terrible credit rating to be on the deeds.

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 21:32

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/02/2023 21:06

Controlling? I don't think so. I am a SAHM, so he earns the money, pays the bills, most things are in his name. We don't share banks. I have CB as 'my' spending money, and he puts some extra in my bank once a month, and extra if I ask. A friend of mine has said she thinks things should be in joint names, but because I don't earn, that's not always been possible, some companies won't accept me

Let me guess - he told you this? You don't have to be earning to be on a mortgage, or any other type of financial account. You are being played.

I was on the call with the bank when we bought our new house last year - until then I’d been named on the deeds of the last house but not the mortgage (my credit rating at the time thanks to a stupid default would have given us a worse deal than his earnings alone). This time, found out banks just aren’t willing to do that anymore, told me to my face that there was no way I could be on the mortgage or the deeds. So I’m not. (My OH then married me on the next available date at our local registry office to ensure that I would still be entitled to my share of the property should he die/we split).

This is happening to a lot of friends if they don't earn, as well. Mortgages are getting tighter.

There’s lots of bills in either my or his name. Only a couple in both.

I agree though, total red flag that the OP isn’t more involved with the finances - that should be something both are across, aware of and involved with regardless of earning status - but sometimes a void of earning status, especially when it comes to credit agreements, has a huge impact on available deals and therefore it’s more financially savvy as a family unit to not be named on there.

So not disagreeing in any way, shape or form, but just saying that it’s not always the case that you are automatically entitled to be on the mortgage or some other bills.

Emptycrackedcup · 27/02/2023 21:26

I wouldn't care, but the messages from DH would bother me. Why is he checking up on you?! YANBU

Eyerollcentral · 27/02/2023 21:23

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 21:18

@FictionalCharacter - just because you’ve got an app on your phone that allows you to change the stereo settings doesn’t mean you realise there’s a tracking function, until someone else gets in and drives away with it. Yeah, I absolutely can see some setting then pinging to say ‘Hey! Your stereo’s leaving town! Quick! See where it is!’.

@Eyerollcentral - good thing I’m not bothered about being just like everyone else, isn’t it, then? 😂 My other half would absolutely do the same as me…and then send me a running text commentary of all the things he could ‘see’ with it. Because…so…cool. So would most of my friends for that matter. But hey, you do you. Even if we’d think that was weird and boring. (Sorry, had enough of this patronising tone yet? Because it’s only fair you take what you dish out).

The not normal bit wasn’t the main aim of my post to you. The concern about the financial abuse of the OP, her mental health problems and societal isolation was. Didn’t you pick up on any of that?

Jobalons · 27/02/2023 21:19

Sounds more like he has installed an OBD device in the diagnostic port of your car not just radio. You mentioned engine temperature that is not coming from a radio but the diagnostic port in your car. It is usually under your dash by the steering wheel.

www.amazon.co.uk/AutoWiz-OBD-GPS-Tracker-subscription/dp/B018QFTCNG

LaughingCat · 27/02/2023 21:18

FictionalCharacter · 27/02/2023 20:48

@LaughingCat Simples if you trust each other, but OP’s partner lied to her, he said he didn’t know there was a tracker despite having the app on his phone.

@Justmeandthedog1 I agree, I would never allow a child to control anything to do with a car, including the stereo. If he was sitting in the back turning it up full and switching stations every 10 seconds you wouldn’t be able to stop him.

@FictionalCharacter - just because you’ve got an app on your phone that allows you to change the stereo settings doesn’t mean you realise there’s a tracking function, until someone else gets in and drives away with it. Yeah, I absolutely can see some setting then pinging to say ‘Hey! Your stereo’s leaving town! Quick! See where it is!’.

@Eyerollcentral - good thing I’m not bothered about being just like everyone else, isn’t it, then? 😂 My other half would absolutely do the same as me…and then send me a running text commentary of all the things he could ‘see’ with it. Because…so…cool. So would most of my friends for that matter. But hey, you do you. Even if we’d think that was weird and boring. (Sorry, had enough of this patronising tone yet? Because it’s only fair you take what you dish out).

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 27/02/2023 21:10

TrackMyCar · 27/02/2023 19:43

I am financially vulnerable, I know this. And it kind of happened like the boiling frog - a little at a time. And some while I was really struggling with my MH.

I have no property of my own, and have made no NI contributions since I gave up work to have first DS. I can't afford to make contributions, and we previously couldn't afford it as a family.

My friend has been pushing me to make some changes, but I do struggle - MH again. Equally it would be hard to get work, as some days I am ok, other days I can barely leave the house. I force myself for the DS only. Other than them, I have very little life. Distant family, and a couple of friends I see just occasionally when I am well enough.

LISTEN TO YOUR FRIEND! She has your best interests at heart. You’re a frog in water that’s getting hotter and you can’t even see it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread