Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister lies about how much help our parents give her

203 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 27/02/2023 11:03

It's not so much an AIBU as a WWYD in my position. Me and my sister are both single mums with two kids. She lives near my parents, I don't. I work full time, she's never held down a job for more than six weeks in her life. University educated, clever, attractive, personable - but there's always a reason why she quits the job and then has a few months off. Last time it was because her boss was a paedo (she didn't have any evidence for this, it was just a 'feeling'.) The upshot of this is that my parents give her a lot of money. They 'loaned' her a lot to buy her house (which they won't get back) and they have to pay her mortgage most months. They don't want to but my mum is a soft touch as far as she's concerned, in fact probably she's the reason why my sister is the way she is. They also do loads of her childcare. I live miles away and don't get any of the same treatment, but I'm not really bothered (that's why I live miles away) but what does bother me is that my sister tries to gaslight me about this. I struggle to speak to her on the phone as it always come back to how hard done by she is, and how terrible mum and dad are, and how they're rich and why don't they give her more money. I just found out yesterday that they bought her a new washing machine as hers packed up. My last conversation with my sister was a couple of days ago and that wasn't mentioned at all. She also says mum and dad don't help with her childcare, but every time I ring them, her kids are at their house. It's just a really weird dynamic. I think she's on the narcissism spectrum and she definitely does try and manipulate people - perhaps unintentionally - but just wondered if anyone could shed light on what is going on here, and what if anything, I should do? I've never said to her 'I know they help you loads, stop lying' because I know it would lead to WW3.

I also worry a lot what's going to happen when my parents die (as they're in their late 70s now) and she becomes my problem! When her kids leave home and she doesn't get those benefit any more, how is she going to finance herself?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tinker95 · 11/03/2023 04:24

I say shut her down and infront of your parents too because they need to see how she's walking all over them and they're enabling her. Call her out. If she still mad, that's her problem not your. You clearly have something to say to her. I think you should say it because you might regret it even more. And yes when your parents aren't around it is going to get worse because then she gonna try to leech off you when spends all your parents give her.

stevec711 · 11/03/2023 01:26

By the way, why would you "inherit the situation"? What happens if you don't help her?

stevec711 · 11/03/2023 01:23

It is obvious to me why she never holds a job; she doesn't have to. Your parents make sure she never goes without, no matter what. But rest assured, she is not your responsibility and never will be, unless you choose to let her take advantage of you. (Many times, I've noticed, people do this to "Keep the peace") It's time to make her sink or swim. And don't let her con you into supporting her for the sake of her children.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 01/03/2023 11:22

orchid220 · 01/03/2023 11:06

Just because someone is more prone to something it doesn't mean they have got it. 40 year olds are more likely to have osteoporosis than 20 year olds but you wouldn't assume a 40 year old has it. People with mental health conditions may be more likely to be mentally incapacitated then healthy people without mental health conditions but that doesn't mean everybody is.

And your point is ...?

Waiting until incapacity strikes (just in case it doesn't) before setting up a POA means that ... you can no longer set up a POA.

orchid220 · 01/03/2023 11:06

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 12:09

Oh don't be ridiculous.
That's like suggesting that it's ageist to say that older women are more prone to osteoporosis.

Just because someone is more prone to something it doesn't mean they have got it. 40 year olds are more likely to have osteoporosis than 20 year olds but you wouldn't assume a 40 year old has it. People with mental health conditions may be more likely to be mentally incapacitated then healthy people without mental health conditions but that doesn't mean everybody is.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 12:09

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:11

I'm not anti them. I think that they have a place. However, I think it's a bit ageist to suggest that anyone over 70 should have one put in place even if there are two fit and healthy people while probably not doing the same thing for themselves. If they are that essential then everyone should have one as anyone can become incapacitated. You say that you will set one up as soon as your children are adults but if it's important why aren't you finding someone e.g. another relative to be power of attorney is for you (should it be necessary) now?

Oh don't be ridiculous.
That's like suggesting that it's ageist to say that older women are more prone to osteoporosis.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/02/2023 12:07

HamBone · 27/02/2023 21:14

@orchid220 OK, if that’s the conclusion you want to draw from this thread.

The OP was asking for ideas on how to deal with the financial situation concerning her parents ( late 70’s) and her sister. Several people have suggested talking to them about making LPA’s. Perhaps it’s not the right solution but I don’t think it’s a bad suggestion.

Given that it could end up with Dsis getting the POA instead, it is. Nothing good will come of raising the issue and it could make things worse.

POA just isn't useful when it comes to protecting a person from someone they don't want to be protected from. It's not going to work here. OP has already confirmed that her mother wouldn't agree to it, which was bleeding obvious anyway. I don't understand why the attachment to the idea.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 12:01

Your sister will be entitled to a state pension, and possibly some additional benefits.

Only if she's registered her entitlement to have her NI payments waived as part of her child benefit. If she hasn't sorted that out, given that she's barely worked for decades, she won't be getting a state pension.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 11:57

The posters suggesting you get power of attorney are also being ridiculous. Why would they give you that if they are of sound mind?

Because it's too late to set up POA when of unsound mind - that would be illegal, @orchid220

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 11:53

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 16:11

I can see that it's annoying that they give her money and help with childcare and not you, but it's their money and their time and really nothing to do with you. I find your “concern” a bit fake as it's pretty obvious you are motivated by jealousy. She's obviously telling you one thing and they're telling you another but calling it “gaslighting” is a bit ridiculous.

The posters suggesting you get power of attorney are also being ridiculous. Why would they give you that if they are of sound mind?

Try reading OP's posts.
She's so clearly proud of her own financial independence & not leeching off her parents, it's hard to understand why you think she's motivated by jealousy.

And somebody who actively chose to move miles away in order to disengage from this situation is hardly expecting childcare.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 28/02/2023 11:48

C1N1C · 27/02/2023 15:40

Just tell your parents to make it clear to your sis that the ppt of money once they die is what she's using now. If there's 300k and she's used 80, she only has 20 left. That will shock her into doing something. She'll whine of course "the others don't need it, why do they get the same as me?", but that's because you've worked for it...

What makes you think that OP has A) any rights to command her parents like that & B) that they, especially her mother, would comply?

It's their money, & if they want to throw is all at their feckless child, that's exactly what they are going to do.

I think OP is right to have a chat with her dad, the more sensible of the pair, about protecting her mother from predation should the dad pre-decease her. But apart from that, she needs to live her own life, by refusing to allow her sister to become her personal leech when the parents become frail & eventually die.

Are you restoring your Himalaya-bound landrover yet OP? 😁
LIVE YOUR OWN LIFE don't you dare change your long term plans due to your sister's selfishness.

HamBone · 27/02/2023 21:14

@orchid220 OK, if that’s the conclusion you want to draw from this thread.

The OP was asking for ideas on how to deal with the financial situation concerning her parents ( late 70’s) and her sister. Several people have suggested talking to them about making LPA’s. Perhaps it’s not the right solution but I don’t think it’s a bad suggestion.

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 21:09

HamBone · 27/02/2023 20:35

@orchid220 Sadly her health problems are related to an eating disorder so being younger isn’t really relevant.

My personal opinion is that once a couple is in their 70’s, possibly 60’s, it’s a good idea to set up LPA’s with younger relatives. If I become incapacitated tomorrow, it’s likely that my DH could act for me for the foreseeable future. But if my FIL is incapacitated in a few years, it’s unlikely that my MIL would be able to act for him as her capacity is diminishing.

it’s not ageism, it’s a fact of life that certain health risks ,such as the likelihood of developing dementia, increase with age.

The reasons for her health issues are irrelevant. You may be more likely to have certain health issues the older you get but if you want to argue it is essential, then is essential for everybody because mental capacity can be lost at any age.

HamBone · 27/02/2023 20:35

@orchid220 Sadly her health problems are related to an eating disorder so being younger isn’t really relevant.

My personal opinion is that once a couple is in their 70’s, possibly 60’s, it’s a good idea to set up LPA’s with younger relatives. If I become incapacitated tomorrow, it’s likely that my DH could act for me for the foreseeable future. But if my FIL is incapacitated in a few years, it’s unlikely that my MIL would be able to act for him as her capacity is diminishing.

it’s not ageism, it’s a fact of life that certain health risks ,such as the likelihood of developing dementia, increase with age.

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 20:00

HamBone · 27/02/2023 19:42

You’ve got a good point, but as all my relatives are older than me, I’m assuming/hoping that I’ll remain healthier for longer! DH has one younger sibling, but she has health issues, unfortunately, so she’s not a good choice. Everyone else is older.

I’m hoping that as we’re under 50, it’s not a necessity yet. I’m sorry that you think it’s ageist to assume that LPA’s are a good idea for people in their 70’s - as I said earlier, I’m only recommending them on the basis of my own family’s experience.

Why assume that? As you say your DH his sister is younger and she is less healthy than you.

Daleksatemyshed · 27/02/2023 19:57

I'm not big on telling people to go to therapy but I'll make an exception for you @horseyhorsey17 because I think you could really benefit from it. All your life you've been put in the Big Sister/Part time Parent role and you're still carrying that with you and letting it spoil your life even though you've managed to break away a bit. Talking it all out could really help you find a different view on all this.

Your DS isn't your problem, your DPs have let her get away with murder and you don't have to clear up the mess they're making, their circus, their monkeys. On a practical note please remind your DPs that keep giving money to your Sister could impact their retirement, they can't afford to finance her for ever

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:57

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 27/02/2023 19:31

Nobody seems to have addressed the very real possibility that any LPA discussion/encouragement could lead to Dsis ending up with it, for DM at least. If she hasn't got it already.

Exactly. Why would they give OP the power of attorney rather than the sister. I'm not sure the fact that she wants to stop them doing what they currently do when of sound mind is going to sell it to them.

theoldhasgone · 27/02/2023 19:52

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 27/02/2023 19:31

Nobody seems to have addressed the very real possibility that any LPA discussion/encouragement could lead to Dsis ending up with it, for DM at least. If she hasn't got it already.

This is a good point. With all these discussions about wills or anything, there is the possibility that the parents will do what they think is best, even if that is giving everything to the sister. Only OP can guess what is likely to happen.

HamBone · 27/02/2023 19:42

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:11

I'm not anti them. I think that they have a place. However, I think it's a bit ageist to suggest that anyone over 70 should have one put in place even if there are two fit and healthy people while probably not doing the same thing for themselves. If they are that essential then everyone should have one as anyone can become incapacitated. You say that you will set one up as soon as your children are adults but if it's important why aren't you finding someone e.g. another relative to be power of attorney is for you (should it be necessary) now?

You’ve got a good point, but as all my relatives are older than me, I’m assuming/hoping that I’ll remain healthier for longer! DH has one younger sibling, but she has health issues, unfortunately, so she’s not a good choice. Everyone else is older.

I’m hoping that as we’re under 50, it’s not a necessity yet. I’m sorry that you think it’s ageist to assume that LPA’s are a good idea for people in their 70’s - as I said earlier, I’m only recommending them on the basis of my own family’s experience.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 27/02/2023 19:31

Nobody seems to have addressed the very real possibility that any LPA discussion/encouragement could lead to Dsis ending up with it, for DM at least. If she hasn't got it already.

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:31

theoldhasgone · 27/02/2023 19:24

Many people don't have wills, but being without one is a bad idea. Same with LPAs. For adults in general.

As soon as I really realised the implications of having or not having an LPA, and how easy it is to put one in place, I put one in place. Literally within weeks.

Sorry to sidetrack your thread OP.

True. but do those without wills tell other people to get them. I doubt it.

Bassetlover · 27/02/2023 19:27

Talk to your parents about Lasting Power of Attorney, just in case your sister tries to take control of their finances if they become unable to manage them.

theoldhasgone · 27/02/2023 19:24

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:11

I'm not anti them. I think that they have a place. However, I think it's a bit ageist to suggest that anyone over 70 should have one put in place even if there are two fit and healthy people while probably not doing the same thing for themselves. If they are that essential then everyone should have one as anyone can become incapacitated. You say that you will set one up as soon as your children are adults but if it's important why aren't you finding someone e.g. another relative to be power of attorney is for you (should it be necessary) now?

Many people don't have wills, but being without one is a bad idea. Same with LPAs. For adults in general.

As soon as I really realised the implications of having or not having an LPA, and how easy it is to put one in place, I put one in place. Literally within weeks.

Sorry to sidetrack your thread OP.

orchid220 · 27/02/2023 19:11

HamBone · 27/02/2023 17:31

@orchid220 Why are you anti-POA’s? Have you/someone you know had a bad experience with them?

I'm not anti them. I think that they have a place. However, I think it's a bit ageist to suggest that anyone over 70 should have one put in place even if there are two fit and healthy people while probably not doing the same thing for themselves. If they are that essential then everyone should have one as anyone can become incapacitated. You say that you will set one up as soon as your children are adults but if it's important why aren't you finding someone e.g. another relative to be power of attorney is for you (should it be necessary) now?

BensonStabler · 27/02/2023 19:00

I agree that your sister sounds like she’s a narcissistic personality, the things she says and does, the extremely selfish, everything is always me me me, manipulative, grabby, she’s the constant victim, gaslighting, lying, covering things out of shame that dents her ego, her generally being life sucking force who makes everyone around her miserable and she takes takes takes, and it always comes back around to her, wants everything handed to her without ever earning it, nor being grateful, nor having insight into her impact on others, her lack of empathy, and her never changing or growing out of things, you’re treading on eggshells because you know that even the smallest comments or perceived slights she blows up at. That in itself is a manipulative tactic so that people learn not do do that again to her.

You wondered why she thinks and acts certain ways, but all these things your sister says and does are very likely caused by the narcissism. There are more than one type, but they pretty much are all on the same script.

Please go online to youtube and search for Dr Ramani. She’s a professional psychiatrist and is a leading expert on this very personality type and dedicates a lot of her time to educating people on how to understand why they do what they do, and how to make things better for you to cope with, and what to do or not to do or say that would make things worse.

I can’t recommend her and her videos enough. They’re all fairly short 8-12 minutes long, clearly titled and it’s extremely eye opening, educational and life changing help for some people suffering with these people in their lives. Although we can’t change them, by education you learn the tools needed to keep your emotional suffering to a minimum, to keep you safe, and how best to engage with them. Just knowing WHY they do what they do can at least be validating, and there’s loads of support on the comments sections from others who have this type of person in their own lives too.

I am sorry you and your parents are going through this, and hope that there’s some useful information, and advice that will help ease the burden.