Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MIL is rubbish/favouritising

139 replies

Happygoclucky · 27/02/2023 10:16

Husband has a sister who has a son and daughter. We have 2 sons and a daughter. MIL frequently favours her daughters children and spends lots of time with them. My children often feel like an afterthought. Most recent issue was halfterm. My MIL does not work, she chose to spend 3 out of the 5 days in the week of halfterm with her daughter and daughters DC. She didn’t ask me to come along on their days out and didn’t call or text once to arrange something with my children. Previous halfterm I asked her to spend time with myself and my DC but she had plans. She also spent time with her daughter and daughters DC that week too.
When she is around my children (when we take them to visit their gran) she is great with them and seems to care about them. Other than that she doesn’t make any effort. It is the noticeable favouring of the other grandchildren that hurts my feelings. For example she recently took her other grandkids out to the cinema, when I made it clear that my sons would have enjoyed going to the cinema too she gave me £10 to take them to see a film. The point I was making was that I wanted her to spend time with them, it seems to go over her head though.
I don’t think that she is completely oblivious to the fact that she spends more time with sister in laws DC though because if I ask her what she’s been up to (when I know she’s been out with sis in law and children) she will change the subject and will miss out the parts where she’s taken the kids out.

we have butted heads over the years over similar issues and it always ends in tears, she doesn’t take criticism well and I’m afraid of the arguments if I do speak my mind.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1497787065 · 02/05/2023 05:56

My MIL always favoured my SILs children over mine. It will not change so I’m afraid it will be something you have to accept.

ColadhSamh · 28/02/2023 17:48

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/02/2023 02:22

How would the children notice? I never knew or thought about what my grandmother was doing when not with me.

Telling the kids they are getting short shrift is just pot-stirring.

What you experienced does not matter. @Happygoclucky has stated that her children have noticed more than once that their grandmother treats them differently when they are with their cousins. How many posts on here are there where posters ask for advice or are retelling their childhood where they are treated differently to other siblings, cousins etc, Of course children notice.

There is a lot of projection and excuses on here as to why their grandmother acts as she does. However that is not the OP's and her children's lived experience. Her children are starting to notice the difference and she must protect them. Otherwise they will be the next generation posting on here and elsewhere asking why their grandmother treated them so differently to her other grandchildren.

CrazyLadie · 28/02/2023 11:17

Happygoclucky · 27/02/2023 20:59

To answer a few questions:

I have always encouraged her to be around the children. I take them to her and always have done (she lives locally and drives) she drives to SIL to see her children or take them out.

Relationship with SIL is fine, we aren’t in each others pockets but we chat occasionally. No problems.

lots of comments about DIL’s who complain about their MIL being too involved. This has never been me, have always welcomed MIL involvement and have facilitated it. Since my DC were newborns. She was more keen to be involved than I do remember.

it’s not possible for DH to take children to see her everytime, again this detail is outing. It’s not child friendly for them to go.

yes we frequently invite MIL to do things with us and to see us, to visit. She does sometimes but seems put out and I guess it feels like there’s some water under the bridge and I’m not sure why. DH doesn’t understand it either and notices that sometimes she is off with him.

I think the biggest issue here is tension between myself and MIL. I get the feeling that since she went through the menopause she has struggled with her mental health and as a result has become distant. We are different people, I am very career focused and did a professional job when I worked, she always commented that she ‘never did anything with her life’ and has always seemed sad about that, I have always celebrated her talents- she is really crafty and makes wonderful things. I think perhaps she leans on her daughter for support and I completely understand this. It’s not the time she spends with her daughter that I resent. Just the disparity with DGC.

I have a great relationship with my own DM and speak regularly and she would love to spend more time with the children but her job just doesn’t allow for it, she works long hours and very rarely gets any time off. We are both sad that she doesn’t get to see the DGC as much as she would like.

I’m not expecting MIL to fill in the gaps just to make a little time for her other DGC, and make them feel special like she does the others.
she could do this however she chose to, I would be happy for DH to take them to see her (when timing allowed) and I have suggested this. Or happy for her to take my DC out if she wanted and of course she is welcome here, I am sure she knows this as I am always offering and I thank her lots when she does come to visit on the occasion.

anytime she does do anything for or with my DC’s I make sure they thank her and I always do too and how much we appreciate it.

lots of helpful responses, I appreciate everyone’s input!

I think you need to tell her what your kids have said tp you about noticing the difference and the itnis her choice but I'd she continues to test them differently yours will pull away eventually and stop caring

CrazyLadie · 28/02/2023 10:23

Happygoclucky · 27/02/2023 10:49

I think you are probably right.

My mom works full time and I think I sometimes feel a little sad that I can’t spend much time with her and the kids. So I guess I am probably a bit jealous that my sister in law gets to spend lots of time with her mom and the grandkids get to see their Nan a lot.

its not for the childcare either. More for the company. It’s lovely when someone comes out with myself and the children and gets to enjoy them having a nice day together.

How does your kids feel about it? Do they notice. My grandparents treated their grandkids different and it used to break my heart watching them drive right passed my house to go to a cousins house and not their daughters kids. Their oldest daughters kids got everything about 10 x as much even, at Xmas when we were all in the same house. It really hurt!!

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 09:13

I agree that there are many unhealthy family dynamics out there and mothers favouring their daughters over their sons is only one of them but acknowledging and normalising these dynamics isn't healthy. Both sexes need to grow up in loving families with parents who value their children regardless of their sex. It seems to me that a lot of posters on here are trying to normalise favouring daughters over sons.

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 28/02/2023 09:07

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 08:47

@MonkeyMindAllOverAround . You castigate the OP for not having 'the relationship you are supposed to have with your own mother'. Are there rules about such things? It is such a reactionary and old fashioned viewpoint. Are men not supposed to do equal parenting? Are sons not allowed an equal relationship with their own mothers. Because some old fashioned attitudes survive, does that make them right? Sons have long been favoured in some parts of the world to the huge detriment of daughters. Is that right because it is traditional?
The kind of viewpoint from some posters claiming that it is normal and right for a mother to favour her daughters is just as bad as the countries/ cultures where boys are favoured over girls resulting in a huge imbalance in the number of boys born compared to the number of girls. The kind of viewpoint peddled on MN about women naturally favouring daughters over sons is dangerous and unhealthy for both sexes.

I am not “castigating” her, so don’t project your issues and agenda on me. Most married women have been through similar, daughters tend to be closer to their mums than daughters in law are close to their mothers in law. Children tend to have more contact with relatives that are closer to their parents.

I am closer to my MIL than my mum, my sister is closer to my mum than to her MIL, it is no surprising to see my mother spending more time with my niece and therefore being closer to her, in the same way that my son is closer to my MIL just because we interact more regularly with her.

I think this very much comes also from the fact that, with time, MIL and I have became friends: we can talk hours over a coffee while the rest of the family is asleep or entertaining themselves in other things, and it is in these conversations that she has also get to know and understand her grandchild better through what we talk about. That has made them closer, and this is a situation that is replicated between my mum and my sister, and therefore my niece.

So the moral of this story is, you cannot get any person to be more interested in your kids by talking or demanding equal rights, what you need to do is become closer to them so that their relationship can develop, whether you are a mum or a dad. But, you also need to accept and move on if your interest is not reciprocated.

Conkersinautumn · 28/02/2023 09:07

I don't think this is 'normal' at all. Why is she spending such a massive amount of time with these children? Seems there is an issue somewhere. Golden child? Incapable child?

aSofaNearYou · 28/02/2023 09:00

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 07:41

If all these posters maintaining that it is normal to be closer to their mothers and to have their children favoured over children of brothers, you can see why some adult men turn their backs on caring for their parents in old age.
I do wonder if these parents cannot see how unhealthy it is for families favouring one sex over the other growing up. I know it was common when I was growing up for parents to physically chastise sons but they would never smack daughters. I so want to hope that boys and girls are loved and valued equally in families but it is clear from the overwhelming number of posts on here that a lot of female posters believe it is right and normal for a mother to favour daughters.

Don't worry, there are also a HUGE amount of mothers who don't expect their sons to lift a finger and treat them like the golden child, whilst expecting their daughters to be on hand to help them. There's a lot of evidence that people expect more of girls growing up than boys. The world isn't overwhelmingly full of mothers favouring their daughters.

And of all the mothers that are closer to their
adult daughter and her kids than their adult son and his, a great many are that way because the daughters put more active effort into spending time with her and mums in general are more active with their kids, meaning they'd need to go through their DIL to get close to their son's kids and feel like they are overstepping doing so.

There are many unhealthy dynamics out there. The one you're worried about is by no means the only or the dominant one.

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 08:47

@MonkeyMindAllOverAround . You castigate the OP for not having 'the relationship you are supposed to have with your own mother'. Are there rules about such things? It is such a reactionary and old fashioned viewpoint. Are men not supposed to do equal parenting? Are sons not allowed an equal relationship with their own mothers. Because some old fashioned attitudes survive, does that make them right? Sons have long been favoured in some parts of the world to the huge detriment of daughters. Is that right because it is traditional?
The kind of viewpoint from some posters claiming that it is normal and right for a mother to favour her daughters is just as bad as the countries/ cultures where boys are favoured over girls resulting in a huge imbalance in the number of boys born compared to the number of girls. The kind of viewpoint peddled on MN about women naturally favouring daughters over sons is dangerous and unhealthy for both sexes.

Fundays12 · 28/02/2023 08:03

Untitledsquatboulder · 28/02/2023 00:30

Mmm, that says more about you than perhaps you'd like other people to know.

Agree this says more about that poster. It's such a dated old fashioned attitude. My MIL is the same. She has barely any relationship with most of her son's kids except one.That's her choice as she has made it blatantly clear that her son's kids don't matter as much as her daughters. As a result DH and some of her grandkids are now making it blatantly clear she isn't important to them. No doubt she wonders why.

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 28/02/2023 07:51

You are expecting from your MIL the relationship you are supposed to have with your own mum. As equalitarian as we want to be, most times it doesn’t work like that.

No amount of talking is going to help, in fact it would make it worse. What you need to do is get along with your MIL so well, become a friend to her so she enjoys spending as much time with you as with her DD. The stronger the friendship you have with her, the more time she will have to get to know your children better and enjoy having more time with all of you.

Alternatively, you can foster such a relationship with your own mum so your children do not miss out.

follyfoot37 · 28/02/2023 07:47

Favouritising?

Lambchop1 · 28/02/2023 07:45

It’s normal for people to spend more time with their daughter than daughter in law. Don’t take it personally and maybe try to spend more time with your own family ?

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 07:41

If all these posters maintaining that it is normal to be closer to their mothers and to have their children favoured over children of brothers, you can see why some adult men turn their backs on caring for their parents in old age.
I do wonder if these parents cannot see how unhealthy it is for families favouring one sex over the other growing up. I know it was common when I was growing up for parents to physically chastise sons but they would never smack daughters. I so want to hope that boys and girls are loved and valued equally in families but it is clear from the overwhelming number of posts on here that a lot of female posters believe it is right and normal for a mother to favour daughters.

anexcellentwoman · 28/02/2023 07:33

Hi OP. You sound like a lovely DIL and a lovely Mum. I am so impressed at your effort to try and establish a good relationship between your children and their grandmother. This is such a sad state of affairs and is I think a cultural thing. It is not healthy or good for the nurturing of sons if a parent favours daughters over sons as they grow up. I think it is unfortunately very common. Lots and lots of women on MN do their best to justify being unkind to their in laws and keep them at arm's length. They are probably the same DILS who pile on here to complain about wills not being fair. Adult sisters may try to freeze out their brothers and try to stop them having a relationship with their mothers. It isn't healthy or right in my opinion. Women on here complain about men but lots want to deny them a relationship within their birth family. Undoubtedly lots of women on here favour their daughters over their sons and treat them badly compared to their daughters. Isn't their research that shows mothers in families where their are sons and daughters, hug their sons far less,
It is not right, not fair and clearly unhealthy in terms of nurturing sons.
I would hope that given the efforts MN posters go to ensure that men do their fair share of parenting, men will be allowed by their partners to maintain a relationship with their own family without being frozen out by their wives and her family.
In many countries sons are traditionally favoured over daughters. In many western countries daughters are now favoured over sons. Neither is right or good for nurturing secure and loved children.
There are so many posts on here that make for uncomfortable reading.

Mothership4two · 28/02/2023 02:34

It's something that is quite common but it's not really fair to the grandchildren. My MIL spends a lot more time with her daughter than with her sons and always has done. She made it very clear that regular childcare would not be an option before I had even had mine but looked after my SIL's two days a week. They rarely did the odd babysitting when DS were young but again the implication was for it not to become a regular event so we used sitters. They did used to moan about babysitting another GC because of his attitude (BIL's son) which seemed unfair as a) he was just a kid and b) was normally behaved with no issues as far as we were aware but this made me hyper aware of their attitude to our DS. SIL's now adult children are very much the golden ones but are close to them. Mine are closer to my DP despite them living hundreds of miles away from us (PIL live locally). It is something that I've accepted but has bothered DH but he doesn't look at the situation as clinically as I do and will make excuses for them. The only thing that I do find hurtful on behalf of DS is the "golden grandchildren" get a different class of presents ie more expensive than the others. THAT I find quite pathetic.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/02/2023 02:22

ColadhSamh · 27/02/2023 11:31

I cannot believe how many here find MIL behaviour acceptable. OP has said her children have noticed how they are being treated differently. This is not acceptable. I constantly read here how behaviour like this is very damaging to children and I agree.

You have to prioritise your children and put their welfare and wellbeing first. If that means staying away from her and keeping your children from her then so be it. She has made her choices clear. She knows what she is doing is wrong but does it anyway. Stop forcing the relationship, stay away with your children and do something they will enjoy without being made to feel second best.

How would the children notice? I never knew or thought about what my grandmother was doing when not with me.

Telling the kids they are getting short shrift is just pot-stirring.

jollyroll · 28/02/2023 01:58

Unpopular to say, but it's likely a dominance issue. Your MIL is her daughter's mother, easier for her to maintain the power dynamic from childhood.

You are a stranger, not her child. You might make yourself subservient to her in an effort to ingratiate yourself, but that absent, her ability to dominate you is greatly weakened.

This is natural. We are animals after all. We love a hierarchy. Some/a lot/most? people enjoy having some control over the settings they place themselves in. It's comfortable.

With her daughter, your MIL know where she stands and can exert some sway. With you, not so much.

The upshot of this, sadly, is that your kids miss out on the closeness with one grandmother. You can talk frankly with your MIL about this. You can make attempts to reconcile. If you try and she doesn't, unfortunately she's chosen to alienate her own grandkids. Nothing you can do about it.

Find other relatives, neighbors, or friends for the kids to spend time with and be close to. The kids'll be fine.

SleepingStandingUp · 28/02/2023 00:43

Happygoclucky · 27/02/2023 10:43

I have suggested this to my husband. He is very much of the attitude that she shouldn’t have any problem with seeing all of us together.

i think perhaps my MIL doesn’t have a great relationship with me and that’s why she keeps her distance but I honestly don’t know how I can change that. I am really polite to her and make a point of listening to her advice (parenting) and asking her opinion on
things to do with the kids (birthdays/school).

i make a note of things she likes to get for her birthdays and my husband spends lots of time with her.

so I don’t know how I can change things between the two of us.

I don’t think that should affect the children though. They love her and think a lot of her.

You've said DH spends lots of time with her, does he take the kids? Sounds like largely she's spending time with her daughter and the gc at the same time, whereas her son sees her alone whilst you mind the kids

Untitledsquatboulder · 28/02/2023 00:30

Toomuchtrouble4me · 27/02/2023 23:04

It’s normal. Is it because you think that your SiL is getting more free childcare than you?
because other than that I can’t see an issue, she prefers to be with her own daughter than you. Your daughters children are like your own, your sons children will always be another woman’s children, that’s just the way it is.

Mmm, that says more about you than perhaps you'd like other people to know.

Bizzybee900 · 28/02/2023 00:28

Maybe she doesn't feel as confident to spend time with your children? Becuase she doesn't know you & them as well as her own daughters children (who she has spent loads of time with already by the sound of it).
I personally feel much happier and relaxed taking my sisters daughters on a day out than my SIL daughters even though they are similar ages etc. It's just much easier to look after someone you know really well children as you know the right way to handle the children in any situation.

Siawouldwannabeya · 28/02/2023 00:17

Yes I’d get DH to say to her that DC miss her , also that time goes by so fast and they will be grown before she knows ! My Dc ‘s didn’t spend regular time with my parents but had a few lovely holidays, but zero time with my in-laws, I was always told that in-laws had done their bit with their other sons children and didn’t want to do it anymore !!

Badanxiety · 27/02/2023 23:37

I’ve had this with my own mother, always having my nephew and not my DS’s, but she’s always favoured my sister and we’ve fallen out so many times but she never seems to get it. We have fallen out completely now over other things but has only asked to see my DS’s twice since November and my nephew is constantly at her house. I’ve stopped hiding it from my oldest now so when she took my nephew on holiday he asked her why she wasn’t talking him! Maybe get your DC to ask her if they can visit on a particular day instead of you, might be harder to turn down the DC than you x

Toomuchtrouble4me · 27/02/2023 23:04

It’s normal. Is it because you think that your SiL is getting more free childcare than you?
because other than that I can’t see an issue, she prefers to be with her own daughter than you. Your daughters children are like your own, your sons children will always be another woman’s children, that’s just the way it is.

MirabelMadrigal · 27/02/2023 22:26

Hi OP, my MIL once said to me she will be a true grandma when her daughter has children and i wonder if this is what your MIL feels like aswell. Her daughter has been having difficulty TTC so MIL is all over my children. I see the love between them but I also wonder how much of it is real and what will happen to my children when her daughter has children