Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do you not get offended by school cliques?

329 replies

Purpleicing · 27/02/2023 06:20

Could do with some advice to stop my confidence being more battered

4 years into school - son now year 3 - a once friendly group of mums in the class has developed into "the trendy confident ones" and "the rest of us"

The trendy ones not only invite each others children to the parties (at the exclusion of the children of the poor, the fat, the old, or the anxious), but have spend weekends on a 3 day partying spree - this weekend a bottomless brunch at a restaurant, one house party, and one day out at theme park with kids, all over social media

This in itself is just normal life I know, but what has riled me is that it doesn't stop them using the less trendy ones who don't get invited to play.

Specifically, we have a park holiday home which I have let a few people use for nothing or v little in past when everyone was more friendly across the whole class (think £20 for a long weekend) . Whole set of them asking to use it this summer already.

Other mums outside the clique I know do their fair share of help with after school pick ups and childcare

I'm also in an "approved profession" job and three times this week people have asked me for either legal advice or can you approve the passports (on my fifth lot of passport approval or 'can you sign my mortgage application' this month!)

My confidence is already battered, aibu to think jog on and find someone else to sign your bloody passports?

OP posts:
LexMitior · 28/02/2023 18:56

Oh fgs isn't this totally reasonable that you ask for holiday homes and passport signage etc without a little social grace in return? That's the exclusion bit that is a reasonable gripe I think. Breezily assuming that you get access to this stuff is socially deaf.

aSpanielintheworks · 28/02/2023 16:21

I had a close group of friends, we all met at baby group, toddler group and onwards. By the time the girls turned five we were firm friends, both at school and outside
We naturally gravitated to each other with a long shared history, although we never purposely excluded anyone and we chatted to many.

One of these friends had another friend who once told her she wouldn't talk to her in the yard as she was always with her 'clique' (us)

It really bothered me, I would never ever be purposely unfriendly or exclude anyone - none of the others would either.
I do think that if there has been enough of a friendship in the past for them to even know you have a caravan to let out, and they still feel comfortable enough to ask, then you may be being a little bit sensitive, and they may have no idea they are hurting you.

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/02/2023 16:13

@HelloOhHell

OP and anyone else that resonates with OP, your feelings are very very valid. Unfortunately lot of people are just exposing that they have zero empathy, but try to hide it under “the brutal nature of AIBU”

I think you’re missing the point here. Empathy is good. Absolutely everyone has experienced social isolation in some form at some stage of their lives. No one is exempt from that, however “confident” or “trendy” they are. There’s actually a lack of empathy and an arrogance in the attitude that only the introverts and anxious people can understand. A lot of superficially confident people have had to fight really hard for their confidence and are often masking themselves.

It’s not a question of empathy, it’s about identifying sinister motives in the behaviour of others because you see them behaving in certain ways in certain social situations. Assuming that there’s a “mean girls” script at work when two women have a conversation in a playground or arrange a drink outside school.

Trying to police the behaviour of other people in school related situations because you perceive them to be more confident than you is not fair. If you want to make more friends, take some ownership of your own lives. Deal with your demons and be aware that other people may be trying to hide theirs. You can’t expect to reduce everyone to bland, consensual “inclusive” behaviour because you are uncomfortable with their behaviour.

MargaretThursday · 28/02/2023 16:06

Dzogchen · 28/02/2023 09:41

I’m always open to new friendships with interesting people. I got on extremely well with a taxi driver on a long, traffic-delayed ride with my son last week. We turned out to have worked for the same newspaper decades ago, and he’s a writer and short filmmaker and active on the local poetry scene — we exchanged numbers and are going to meet at a poetry event in a couple of weeks.

You walk into a room and there's a group of people you know well, have done a lot together and you know you'll have a good chat and a laugh with them, also a few people who you haven't spoken much beyond a quick "hello" but don't really know them and another couple of people who've you'd talked to a few times but not really got a link.

Which group would you choose to go and talk to?

I suspect almost everyone would go to the group they know well.

It's a different matter when you are in a place with one other person and you chat to them or no one.

I seem to be the sort of person people chat to. I get told all sorts of things that are quite confidential. I'm happy to chat to someone I haven't met. I can find common ground with almost anyone. I don't care if you're in the "trendy" group or not.
But on entering a room I'd still make decisions as to who to go up to. And a good amount of that would be on those who I get on best with. Those I would regard as friends.

Treetopviews · 28/02/2023 15:56

HelloOhHell · 28/02/2023 14:10

The gaslighting about school mum cliques not being a thing is so weird to me. I clearly remember it as a child and I see it now as a mum. I don’t really care as it’s not something I usually need to navigate (mat leave so no need for breakfast/after school club right now so I see it, but still don’t care though). Your feelings are valid OP

i don’t think gaslighting means what you think it means.

Mirabai · 28/02/2023 15:53

HelloOhHell · 28/02/2023 15:11

Not sure who you think you’re talking to like that, but I used a term that can be used to describe friendships, intimate relationships, workplace relationships.

in short, i said what I said. Nice chat though.

OP and anyone else that resonates with OP, your feelings are very very valid. Unfortunately lot of people are just exposing that they have zero empathy, but try to hide it under “the brutal nature of AIBU”. 🙄

I can see from this why you’d find socialising hard.

HelloOhHell · 28/02/2023 15:11

Mirabai · 28/02/2023 14:51

Please don’t use gaslighting when you mean contradiction, it does abused women a disservice.

How did you distinguish groups of friends from cliques as a child?

Not sure who you think you’re talking to like that, but I used a term that can be used to describe friendships, intimate relationships, workplace relationships.

in short, i said what I said. Nice chat though.

OP and anyone else that resonates with OP, your feelings are very very valid. Unfortunately lot of people are just exposing that they have zero empathy, but try to hide it under “the brutal nature of AIBU”. 🙄

rookiemere · 28/02/2023 15:03

I have groups of Mum friends.

Hopefully it's ok as we're mostly a bit dowdy and our DCs are no longer pals. I'd prefer not to post on social media at all about our trips as we go away once a year, but one friend does post a few photos.
It's hard enough organising 5 of us never mind asking everyone.

Mirabai · 28/02/2023 14:51

HelloOhHell · 28/02/2023 14:10

The gaslighting about school mum cliques not being a thing is so weird to me. I clearly remember it as a child and I see it now as a mum. I don’t really care as it’s not something I usually need to navigate (mat leave so no need for breakfast/after school club right now so I see it, but still don’t care though). Your feelings are valid OP

Please don’t use gaslighting when you mean contradiction, it does abused women a disservice.

How did you distinguish groups of friends from cliques as a child?

FilthyforFirth · 28/02/2023 14:26

What is the difference between a clique and a genine friendship group? I am part of a group of mums at school, we go to a pub quiz once a week and are going up to London in a few weeks for a day out.

We did a whole class drink and off the back of that, I arranged further drinks with the mums I got on particularly well with. It is too umweildy to go out as 20+ mums en mass all the time.

What is to stop you arranging things with the mums you like? Does it have to be only with the cool trendy ones?!

Cam22 · 28/02/2023 14:18

Purpleicing · 27/02/2023 06:20

Could do with some advice to stop my confidence being more battered

4 years into school - son now year 3 - a once friendly group of mums in the class has developed into "the trendy confident ones" and "the rest of us"

The trendy ones not only invite each others children to the parties (at the exclusion of the children of the poor, the fat, the old, or the anxious), but have spend weekends on a 3 day partying spree - this weekend a bottomless brunch at a restaurant, one house party, and one day out at theme park with kids, all over social media

This in itself is just normal life I know, but what has riled me is that it doesn't stop them using the less trendy ones who don't get invited to play.

Specifically, we have a park holiday home which I have let a few people use for nothing or v little in past when everyone was more friendly across the whole class (think £20 for a long weekend) . Whole set of them asking to use it this summer already.

Other mums outside the clique I know do their fair share of help with after school pick ups and childcare

I'm also in an "approved profession" job and three times this week people have asked me for either legal advice or can you approve the passports (on my fifth lot of passport approval or 'can you sign my mortgage application' this month!)

My confidence is already battered, aibu to think jog on and find someone else to sign your bloody passports?

Oh no. They think they’re the Motherland lot. 🙄😆

theeldudebros · 28/02/2023 14:11

Oh dear OP I don't think this thread will have helped your confidence.

I think as social beings you will have people right across the "social spectrum" from extremely shy and/or anxious, through to confident and/or loud.

There isn't a "right" kind of personality to have - and don't beat yourself up for not being like someone else. You may find that you thrive socially in different situations, the school gates may just not be your place to do it - again nothing wrong with that!

A bit of a random question but how are your hormones/periods etc?

I'm more confident at certain times of the month, and basically a week before my period would feel anxious and less rational on all sorts of things.

I don't think people have been kind to you on this thread.

As social beings a fear of rejection is real, some people can cope with this better than others.

It may be worth examining if/why your self worth is tied up in school mums/this group of women. If so, I would take a moment to think or write down why this might be, and what you can do to improve your view on the situation and build your confidence.

Remember we are all different - and drawn to different people, some people can quickly strike up friendships, other people may take a bit longer etc. no one way is better than another.

Oh and mute them on social media. It is scientifically proven that social media affects mental health. You may find this is all you need to stop that negative voice in your head.

HelloOhHell · 28/02/2023 14:10

The gaslighting about school mum cliques not being a thing is so weird to me. I clearly remember it as a child and I see it now as a mum. I don’t really care as it’s not something I usually need to navigate (mat leave so no need for breakfast/after school club right now so I see it, but still don’t care though). Your feelings are valid OP

Randomizer · 28/02/2023 12:47

YABU to call other mums 'the fat, the anxious, the poor'. Get a hold of yourself for fuck's sake!

A 'clique' is a bitchy way of saying 'a group of friends'. People are allowed to form friendship groups and socialise with them, there's no obligation to be friends with all other 30 parents in a class just to avoid upsetting someone and triggering nasty facebook posts. If you get asked a favour and don't want to do it or reserve that sort of favour for actual friends simply say no, it's not difficult.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 28/02/2023 12:44

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/02/2023 09:14

@Dzogchen

I’m not usually one for the ‘only on Mn’ pov, but perhaps because it’s a big, anonymous women-dominated forum with frequent posts about loneliness, ‘cliques’, how to make friends as an adult, it’s a necessary outlet for many who don’t have many other forms of communication with others.

You're spot on with this. I saw a huge amount of this during the pandemic, masses of posts from people basically saying how relieved they were that lockdown gave them an excuse never to see anyone, ever. People offloading about how much they hated other people and never wanted to see anyone again outside "my little family" etc.

At one level its understandable that people who struggle with social events felt some relief at being able to step off the social treadmill for bit, but also profoundly worrying that so many people actively dislike having any contact at all with other human beings apart from the ones they are related to. It was often talked about on here as a good and liberating thing, but let's call a spade a spade: this is pathological. Never wanting to see or interact with other people is not a good thing.

I think this tendency to assume that all playground social activity is based on sinister cabals of "trendy" or "confident" women ganging up on those with anxiety comes from a similar place: it's the idea that other people are out to get you in some way and the less you and your children have to do with them, the better.

I think we have to ask ourselves a bigger question about why women in particular are suspicious of the idea of friendships outside the family and assume that other women who make friends are "bitches" or "cliques" or deliberately setting out to exclude their children. Is it connected with a historical impetus to shrink your social circle once you are married? Is it to do with the wider anxiety that capitalism brings people? I don't know.

I think a lot of women have been their own worst enemies in some ways because they are very quick to dump friends when they get married and have kids and shrink their own networks to revolve around their families, so the lose the "muscle" of making friends. Then one day they wake up and realise they are bored and isolated or that their husband doesn't treat them so well any more and have lost the knack of getting on with other women, just when they really need the support of other women. So when they see women at school making friends they are envious and attribute the worst motives to them.

I think its worrying and negative and we should call it out when we see it. This obsession with cliques is a really bad thing to pass on to your kids. If you find you are going down this mental rabbit hole a lot when you're at school you really need to check your own motives, think about why you are so suspicious of other people making friends and, if you need it, get help. But stop being unpleasant about other women making friends.

Excellent post!! You’ve honestly worded the situation perfectly.

I do feel for people who don’t enjoy cultivating friendships and resent those who do - what a miserable life.

Nooyoiknooyoik · 28/02/2023 11:52

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/02/2023 09:27

@lieselotte

This also works the other way, when you control your children's friendships to stop them mixing with the "wrong sort".

Of course. Social engineering by parents of their children's friendships is usually a bad idea.

But we're not talking about screening of child friendships, we're talking about situations where every social interaction between one parent and another parent on school premises is perceived as a "clique" or "bitchy" or an attempt to exclude another child.

A PP actually said parents should restrict themselves from having social interaction with other parents at school in order to avoid this. Its the idea that socialising by parents with other parents at school is inherently sinister or "sharp-elbowed" or exclusive.

Nah mate, I didn’t say anyone should restrict themselves and not talk to their friends. If that’s directed at me.

I said, and continue to maintain, that in a school setting, children’s friendships should be allowed to develop without the adults deciding that their child should only play with the children in their particular group, and that all other playdate invitations should be refused or ignored. Which absolutely does happen, and is almost certainly the cause of 99% of the angst about school mum “cliques”.

Stop making things up.

cont · 28/02/2023 11:40

@LolaSmiles you need to have more empathy.

Why might socialising be a chore? Fear of rejection, anxiety about your appearance, worried that nobody likes you. Feeling you don't fit in because of income, background etc.

Where might these feelings come from? Abusive parents or relationships. Being bullied at school. Physical differences, mental illness, all kinds of adverse experiences.

Why might someone feel bothered by other people? In op's case, because she has tried to socialise and feels like she's just being used when they want something. Maybe it is just 'insecurity and bitterness' but a bit of compassion wouldn't go amiss.

Have been on both sides. I've been on both sides and thought like this. Life has brought me down a peg or two.

Posts like this don't help anybody. You definitely wouldn't feel enthused to go and socialise after reading some of the posts on here. And none of them come from a good place.

LolaSmiles · 28/02/2023 11:31

Honestly, I think the idea that making friends is a horrifying chore or a political act of canny self-interest is one that is over-represented on Mn, which has a very high proportion of people who say they are socially anxious, regard social situations with fear and stress, don’t like answering their doors or doing the school run, regard friendships with a very jaundiced eye as unnecessary ‘drama’, and yet often say they’re lonely or friendless
Agree with this.
It doesn't seem surprising that people who view social interactions as a chore, won't answer the door, judge other people for forming friendships (whilst making no effort themselves) also the people who don't have friends, are lonely and complain that they haven't got a support network.

Some people are social butterflies and thrive on social events and relationships, others are friendly, get on with people and have a smaller circle of friends. Both these groups seem to have people who'd do them favours, and they'd also do favours.

There was a thread about support networks on here and a poster hit the nail on the head when they said that it takes time and effort to cultivate interpersonal relationships, so people shouldn't be surprised if they're all alone as their little family when they don't bother with other people.

RecommendedForYou · 28/02/2023 10:10

I have seen people say when their kids start school, ‘I drop and go, I am not here to make friends! I don’t need any friends from my kids’ school’ etc. I think it’s a defence due to a fear of not fitting in.

And there is also a weird sense of pride, especially since the pandemic to say, ‘I hate other people’ which always makes me
roll my eyes at the lack of awareness.

Of course bitchy and mean people exist. But most groups of women are not like this and it’s unfair to brand them as such, simply because they found each other in the playground.

I have always worked. But I was still friendly and smiled as I dropped and picked my kids. Made an effort at school events. Did play dates. My kids made friends and I became closer to those mums. Not because any of us was popular or ‘trendy’ or showing off. But because we had something in common via our kids and we found we quite liked each other. Our kids have all left home now and many of the school parents are now our friends for life.

Don’t turn your back on school parent relationships due to defensiveness or fear. It’s useful to get on with other parents. They can help in an emergency. My sahm friends helped me so much over the years. And I reciprocated when I could. I think relaxing some defences, being pleasant and polite could pay dividends. In any case, it’s a healthier mindset than being bitter and jealous.

Dzogchen · 28/02/2023 10:09

WandaWonder · 28/02/2023 09:44

Yes that is how we make new friends by talking to strangers but once friendships are established people tend to navigate towards

Yes there is lots of people out there who say 'well I always talk to strangers I deliberately look for them' or whatever but everyone I know usubut not always tends to have a pattern where they stick with people they know

To be honest, I think the attitude I find on Mn, that it’s the ‘trendy and confident’’s job to be permanently on the lookout for anyone alone in the playground, to approach them and determine whether they actually want to be left alone or are desperately hoping for an invitation or conversation etc etc is a bit mad, and takes the onus off the person themselves to make approaches or take action — especially if this is all happening at breakneck speed because of going to work.

I think my school friendship group is genuinely welcoming to newcomers (we’ve had a fair few Ukrainians joining the school lately), but after an initial coffee or chat, it does come down to whether or not I actually like you and want to see more of you. Of the last two new people who came for coffee, one is wonderful and now comes out for drinks sometimes when she’s not away for work, and the other (invited to an early dinner with our collective children during the Christmas holidays) turned out to be spectacularly dreadful in a number of ways, so I’ve turned down invitations to see more of her, and reverted to just saying hello.

Dzogchen · 28/02/2023 09:55

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/02/2023 09:37

@cont

I don't disagree that the OP owes no favours whatsoever to these women and I think she's well within her rights to say no.

I just really dislike the emotive, stereotyping language used: "trendy and confident" women who dare to be seen talking at the school gates and "fat and anxious" if they keep themselves to themselves. It's so reductive and insulting, to both groups.

In any other area of life this would rightly be called out as bigotry but because its the dog-whistle topic of "bitchy school mums" it brings a pile-on of people saying "ooh, yes, nasty bitches" and "block them, delete them". Based on nothing except one person's highly biased view. It's like a modern day witch hunt.

Agreed. It’s really reductive to both sets of people. Nothing the OP has said on this thread suggests any bad behaviour by the ‘trendy, confident’ women, other than them socialising with one another now, rather than the whole class, as they did when the children were newly at school. Someone asked for the use of her caravan, but she’s happily allowed them to use it at a subsidised rate before, so it’s hardly a particularly entitled request, and it’s one she’s obviously entitled to refuse now that her feelings about them have changed, ditto signing passports or professional advice.

I don’t use sm myself, but for those who do, it’s presumably hardly unusual to post about your social activities, without realising someone is noting your fellow-partiers and taking their lack of invitation as a personal slight?

It’s hardly a crime to move from whole class situations to developing closer friendships with some of the other parents, who are obviously up for a lot of weekend socialising, when other people don’t have the time or inclination?

RecommendedForYou · 28/02/2023 09:53

Secure confident person sees a group of friends. Insecure bitter person sees a clique.

This is mainly about you OP and your self-esteem I reckon, not them.

Though I hate doing passport applications and tend to try and get out of it.

WandaWonder · 28/02/2023 09:44

Dzogchen · 28/02/2023 09:41

I’m always open to new friendships with interesting people. I got on extremely well with a taxi driver on a long, traffic-delayed ride with my son last week. We turned out to have worked for the same newspaper decades ago, and he’s a writer and short filmmaker and active on the local poetry scene — we exchanged numbers and are going to meet at a poetry event in a couple of weeks.

Yes that is how we make new friends by talking to strangers but once friendships are established people tend to navigate towards

Yes there is lots of people out there who say 'well I always talk to strangers I deliberately look for them' or whatever but everyone I know usubut not always tends to have a pattern where they stick with people they know

Dzogchen · 28/02/2023 09:41

WandaWonder · 28/02/2023 09:35

Just some ramblings

When we are at school (or nursery) we first know no one, then we usually make friends and play then hang out with them mostly

We leave school start college/uni/work possibly make new fiends then hang out with them

We join evening, exercise, art classes etc. we make friends and usually stick with them

We go to events/parties again friends

How many times do we seek out strangers deliberately we tend to stick to people we know more closley

I’m always open to new friendships with interesting people. I got on extremely well with a taxi driver on a long, traffic-delayed ride with my son last week. We turned out to have worked for the same newspaper decades ago, and he’s a writer and short filmmaker and active on the local poetry scene — we exchanged numbers and are going to meet at a poetry event in a couple of weeks.

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/02/2023 09:37

@cont

I don't disagree that the OP owes no favours whatsoever to these women and I think she's well within her rights to say no.

I just really dislike the emotive, stereotyping language used: "trendy and confident" women who dare to be seen talking at the school gates and "fat and anxious" if they keep themselves to themselves. It's so reductive and insulting, to both groups.

In any other area of life this would rightly be called out as bigotry but because its the dog-whistle topic of "bitchy school mums" it brings a pile-on of people saying "ooh, yes, nasty bitches" and "block them, delete them". Based on nothing except one person's highly biased view. It's like a modern day witch hunt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread