Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a place can cause depression?

233 replies

Kittycattenklump · 26/02/2023 23:38

I am wondering whether I might need a change of scene.

Appreciate that I am ‘lucky’ to live in a lovely place, I live and work in Windermere, Lake District, and have done for the past 6 years. I am 2 yrs single and happy with that, have some nice friends and am happily self employed, but recently I am coming to feel that the place itself makes me feel this weird depression, like a hopelessness, that I don’t feel when I visit other places or stay with my longer distance friends.

I left for a year during the pandemic, and it doesn’t feel the same since coming back. Even the people coming here seem different somehow. But I can’t explain. There was previously a kind of nature lover/alternative vibe which is now missing.
I rent and the prices seem to have flown up in the past year -although that’s an issue everywhere, there’s a sadness to it here as what’s left of the market is dated or drab for a very high price. Local friends are depressed with the housing situation as many are sold off to airB&B.

I am comfortable financially but the manic switch of quiet grey gloom then heavy tourism has begun to put me on edge, something hard to explain.
Perhaps the balance has shifted and it’s no longer the right place for me, no matter the grandeur of the landscape. It feels like a giant commodity, bland and soulless recently.

other areas of my life are great, so i do suspect I might be up for a move. Would you consider it? Would you live here? Would love some thoughts on this as I haven’t discussed it with anyone yet.

OP posts:
Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 10:53

Blackbirdbaby · 27/02/2023 10:51

Somewhere near the sea that isn’t completely dependent on tourism, has a year round ‘buzziness’ with good shops and transport links. And dog friendly 😊 🐕

This sounds like Exeter to me 😊

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 27/02/2023 10:52

beastlyslumber · 27/02/2023 10:32

Where's a happy place to live?

I've only ever lived on the "edges" of England, so can't say about anywhere central, but I have always been happier on the east side rather than the west - quite possibly because the west gets more rain, so is naturally greyer and damper.

Blackbirdbaby · 27/02/2023 10:51

beastlyslumber · 27/02/2023 10:32

Where's a happy place to live?

Somewhere near the sea that isn’t completely dependent on tourism, has a year round ‘buzziness’ with good shops and transport links. And dog friendly 😊 🐕

whereeverilaymycat · 27/02/2023 10:45

This is really interesting and I do think some people are more sensitive to their surroundings than others.

My child switched from one school to another. The walk to the first school I really enjoyed. Lovely roads to get there, not too busy etc. the walk to the new school I loathe and I've struggled to work out why. The schools are probably only a mile apart if that, but it feels so different and I've started driving some of the time as I find it hard to shake off the gloom. We may move and I'm working out the walk to school from each house I look at. Which seems bonkers, but it really does bother me.

I echo everyone that has said about how run down everywhere is feeling. My local high street has always been what you'd call functional, but now it's half empty it feels like it's lost something important. I really don't like going in unless I have to. I normally go to the next town over. I fantasise about moving there when the kids are older and we can downsize (it's much nicer so thus much more expensive)

OP it sounds like you're really in tune with your feelings and if you can make a change then go for it. If you can afford it, maybe see about talking to a therapist or coach that can help you unpick everything in a non biased way? Before you take a big leap it's worth seeing if smaller adjustments can give you the lift you need.

Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 10:41

@crackofdoom I think I know where you mean!! They'll look awful in a few years!

The passivhaus at Swanpool on the corner. Just looks so lovely there. 😊

MarshaBradyo · 27/02/2023 10:38

beastlyslumber · 27/02/2023 10:32

Where's a happy place to live?

I reckon it depends on the person and preference

I had a brief period of looking just outside London and the places were pretty big etc but I just felt depressed at the thought

Others would far prefer it, which I get but not for
me

crackofdoom · 27/02/2023 10:35

Cornishsocks
Totally agree, I can't work out who it is who's had an aesthetics bypass- the developers of these incongruously shiny, overly massive "family" homes, or the buyers. There's a row I can literally see from my window that are all 4- 5 bedrooms, huge footprints, grey cladding...and they're all occupied by older couples who have planted griselina or laurel in the Cornish hedges 🙄

Do you mean the passivhaus development at Jubilee Wharf? I used to have a studio there! (preens).

Blackbirdbaby · 27/02/2023 10:35

It’s strange when your experience of a place is so at odds with the expectation. I’ve only visited the Lake District a couple of times and it felt very unreal and a bit disturbing to me. Beautiful but not real.
Other places that make me feel out of sorts and can’t really explain why, are Bath, Nottingham, Bournemouth & Brighton. Actually I know about Brighton - I received some horrible news when I was visiting.

beastlyslumber · 27/02/2023 10:32

Where's a happy place to live?

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 27/02/2023 10:23

Oh it absolutely can. I got unbelievably depressed when I lived in Plymouth - I was fine almost as soon as I left.

FrostyFifi · 27/02/2023 10:06

It's interesting that a couple of people have mentioned the Yorkshire Dales as being a positive or happy feeling, I get the same, they can feel like a bit of fresh air after the Lakes.

Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 10:06

Definitely agree @crackofdoom

Even some of the "grand designs" here are so so ugly. I saw one yesterday near Truro and it was so out of place.

Towering above neighbouring properties (I'm surprised they even got planning!) - huge windows. Windows everywhere. Far more than required. No driveway as they built on it. And no garden as they built on it. Odd blue coloured cladding. The "landscaping" is just bog standard concrete. A huge family home with no room for the children to play!

In 10 years time it'll have faded cladding, rusty window frames, seagull shit layering the velux windows. Next door is a Georgian townhouse that still looks beautiful in 2023.

I love some of our more neutral grand designs. - like the passivhaus in Falmouth. It's beautiful and suits the area. It'll age well too.

crackofdoom · 27/02/2023 09:58

I think a lot of posters on here are sensitive to the horrible, horrible mess the British have made of their towns. Ugly new build housing, combined with a lack of aesthetic sense in the people who buy them. Neglected town centres, clogged with traffic and boarded up shops etc. I put this down to a lack of civic pride, driven by individualism. "I'm OK, with my shiny car and my expensive interior decor, who cares about the world outside my home/car?" You see an awful lot of that kind of thinking on here.

Contrast with France, where even the smallest, most insignificant town seems like a gem. Historical architecture cherished, and new builds sensitive and aesthetically pleasing. Town centres looked after, with evidence of a lot of local council input. It stems from more of an emphasis on the collective and communal I think.

I live in Cornwall, but I'm lucky in that it isn't a tourist village. Many of the incomers here work at the nearby University, which makes our little community really vibrant and active.

In the absence of any care or funding from above, it really is down to the community.

KimberleyClark · 27/02/2023 09:42

Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 09:29

Yes. Places in Cornwall make me feel sick / nauseous with depression. Its quite common especially with those who lived here in the 80s and 90s.

The deprivation is horrendous, hopeless grey skies, poor quality housing and many many families who are so poor that they've never been to the beach 2.5 miles away.

I wasn’t very keen on Tintagel when I went there. Found it depressing for some reason I can’t explain.

Siameasy · 27/02/2023 09:42

I’m really affected by my physical environment - certain urban environments* in particular really do provoke a deep feeling of unease - and I’m sure Windermere was mentioned on the Glastonbury threads.

*I really dislike both the railway stations in Catford, for instance.

PaulaTrilloe · 27/02/2023 09:39

Stayed in the Lakes earlier this month for a long weekend. Stayed in New Dungeon Ghyll which despite its gloomy name was not too crowded. The tall rocky pikes were dramatic but I could imagine being oppressive in poor weather. Drove through Ambleside and Windermere which were absolutely heaving with tourists. Spent a night in Morecombe bay which had great views but the town itself was very shabby. Then spent a day and a night in Lancaster which was more upbeat and energetic. Visited the castle and Prison (location of Pendle witch trials which had a heavy atmosphere). Stayed overnight just outside the city at a canal side mill off the River Lune with wide open spaces lots of birdlife and this seemed the lightest aspect of our stay.

I moved to Nottingham 20 years ago and love it. Whereas my friend moved here from Belfast and hates it (just here for work). They leave at any opportunity to go to Wales, Ireland or Scotland to experience wildness, big skies, mountains and the sea and probably for a top up of the Gaelic/ Celtic craic!

Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 09:38

There was a local group discussing the links between low mood and high radon in Cornwall.

Is there high radon in the Lakes too?

When I read it I dismissed it as nonsense but maybe they have a point.

mrsh1807 · 27/02/2023 09:35

Where are you? I’m in Sussex but hate the town I’m in 😩 want to live elsewhere.

Cornishsocks · 27/02/2023 09:29

Yes. Places in Cornwall make me feel sick / nauseous with depression. Its quite common especially with those who lived here in the 80s and 90s.

The deprivation is horrendous, hopeless grey skies, poor quality housing and many many families who are so poor that they've never been to the beach 2.5 miles away.

MarshaBradyo · 27/02/2023 09:29

Yes probably as beautiful as open spaces are I need the energy and feel of a big city more. London fits what I need

beastlyslumber · 27/02/2023 09:26

I feel this way about Edinburgh. A shadow of gloom and hopelessness falls over me as soon as I step off the train.

Words · 27/02/2023 09:24

I once read somewhere- on here probably- that there was some evidence to suggest that the geology can affect mood.

I feel the same about the Lake District. Whilst objectively beautiful, it seems to trigger a feeling of doom and foreboding. Parts of Wales have the same effect. Whereas the Yorkshire Dales, the North Pennines and Northumberland make my heart sing.

LakieLady · 27/02/2023 09:14

Merlott · 27/02/2023 08:03

Such an interesting thread. I grew up in the Lakes and it felt exactly like this. Heavy, brooding, eerie. For a few weeks holiday it could be magical but not a place to live. I'm in a Midlands town now which is not exactly a dream location but it is functional and feels more "alive".

Interesting to read about the pp who moved to "dream" location and regretted it. I fantasise about living on the South coast but I suspect it's actually a holiday I want! 😅

I live in Sussex, approx 5 miles from the south coast, as the crow flies. I moved here 31 years ago and I still really like it.

I'm in a small town, and I think the smaller towns are possibly friendlier than the big coastal towns. And there's lovely countryside, you're never far from the Downs, the Ashdown Forest, the huge expanse of Romney Marsh and of course, the sea.

Sadly, most of the bigger coastal towns are getting very run down and shabby, and have significant drug/alcohol problems and homelessness.

salutsandy · 27/02/2023 09:13

I felt like this in Liverpool and I really can't explain it - just a sense of heaviness and gloom the whole time I was there. You've got nothing to lose by moving OP, I would do it.

JoonT · 27/02/2023 09:05

Yes, I’m sure it can lead to full-blown depression. I live in an Essex town, which is one of the fastest growing in the U.K. Developers have thrown up ghastly new build estates on every piece of scrap land they can find, some of them so vast they are like new cities. I live on the edge of the town, and hate the place so much I will drive miles out of my way to avoid going through it. When I do, I can literally feel my mood dropping. It’s a physical sensation. And it’s much worse if there’s bad traffic (which there usually is - the town is virtually gridlocked) and rain. I also found the town hellish during the heatwave.

I’m hyper-sensitive to my surroundings. I suspect people prone to depression often are. I had a friend who rented a grotty house in a horrible part of the town. It always seemed dark in there. God, in the end I avoided seeing her because I couldn’t bear the low mood it triggered. It would take me all day to recover. If I had to go and live on a big estate, with noisy neighbours and awful traffic all around me, it would be a death sentence. I’d need Prozac to endure it.