Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a place can cause depression?

233 replies

Kittycattenklump · 26/02/2023 23:38

I am wondering whether I might need a change of scene.

Appreciate that I am ‘lucky’ to live in a lovely place, I live and work in Windermere, Lake District, and have done for the past 6 years. I am 2 yrs single and happy with that, have some nice friends and am happily self employed, but recently I am coming to feel that the place itself makes me feel this weird depression, like a hopelessness, that I don’t feel when I visit other places or stay with my longer distance friends.

I left for a year during the pandemic, and it doesn’t feel the same since coming back. Even the people coming here seem different somehow. But I can’t explain. There was previously a kind of nature lover/alternative vibe which is now missing.
I rent and the prices seem to have flown up in the past year -although that’s an issue everywhere, there’s a sadness to it here as what’s left of the market is dated or drab for a very high price. Local friends are depressed with the housing situation as many are sold off to airB&B.

I am comfortable financially but the manic switch of quiet grey gloom then heavy tourism has begun to put me on edge, something hard to explain.
Perhaps the balance has shifted and it’s no longer the right place for me, no matter the grandeur of the landscape. It feels like a giant commodity, bland and soulless recently.

other areas of my life are great, so i do suspect I might be up for a move. Would you consider it? Would you live here? Would love some thoughts on this as I haven’t discussed it with anyone yet.

OP posts:
rglet · 28/02/2023 09:00

I am from a fairly flat part of the Uk. I've been to the Lake District, peaks, Wales, Edinburgh and always been able to appreciate the beauty of hills and valleys and the land in general.

I'd never ever want to live there however as I find that reduced amounts of sky above my head is oppressive and depressing - probably just what I'm used to but it feels real to me. If I had grown up somewhere like that, I'd probably find East Anglia hideously bleak but having grown up here, it's what I prefer.

Percypigmegapack · 28/02/2023 05:22

YANBU. We lived somewhere for years that I began to find really depressing (Glasgow) - I found it especially hard coming back to it after holidays. We moved away and the depression lifted, I love where we live now and am so much happier.

ElephantInTheBoxRoom · 28/02/2023 05:20

Mile End, Whitechapel and Stratford make me unbearably depressed. They have such a feeling of foreboding.

BasiliskStare · 28/02/2023 05:08

Oh and one more - & I am sorry for this - I know how so many people love it and it is full of culture and restaurants and lovely places - but if I never see Manchester again it will be too soon, (This for the avoidance of doubt is my particular fault - I know it is a fantastic place - but for some reason I don't like it and that reason is irrational - I know that - it's just a feeling. Quite happy to pasted for that one 😊 )

BasiliskStare · 28/02/2023 05:03

@Kittycattenklump - I do see your point - my parents have been going to the lakes for over 50 years . I love some of it - not others. It does not distress me ( as long as only quick visits ) - I live 300 miles away

My DH had family in Herne Bay - Kent - SE England. Oh, now they have passed away ( sadly ) I will never go there again - I find It eerie and creepy) Look nothing wrong & I thing Sandi Toksvig lives there but it gives me the shivers - can't explain why but it does ) That whole Herne bay , whitstable , Kent coast area with such flatness just - I don't know - I can't abide it - but so many people love it - I suppose each to their own . I am not a one for ley lines etc - I just found it a bit depressing and the flatness I found oppressive. That said , I had a lovely afternoon when FIL took me to Reculver where they did a test of the bouncing bomb. But was happy to leave.

I think it is funny how people like different things. I went to school on the coast & would never live there again. For others , it is what they want.

This is a really interesting thread - thanks all

SnoringPains · 28/02/2023 04:51

I get it totally. We left London is search of a rural idyll in Scotland, which we found and we hate. Me and DH are so miserable here, we’ve got a trip down south in a few weeks that we already feel sad about coming back from. We’re planning to move back to the city as soon as I can find a job and just the knowledge we’re planning to leave has made me feel so much happier!

ItsRainingCatsAndDogsAgain · 28/02/2023 04:23

RoseBucket · 27/02/2023 15:17

Happiest places apparently… you have to scroll down for the tip 20

www.which.co.uk/news/article/revealed-the-happiest-places-to-live-in-great-britain-in-2022-aRVdf3l80IOC

I'm very surprised to see St Ives at No 1. I've heard and read about a lot of unhappiness locally because of mass tourism and the huge number of second homes, holiday lets and Airbnbs.

lifekeepsgoing · 28/02/2023 04:19

Liverpool, the heaviness as you walk through the center with those tall buildings and wide roads and biting winds, lovely people but that city is so tough and I find Leeds is the same, maybe even worse.

mathanxiety · 28/02/2023 04:08

@Kittycattenklump

Would you consider Northern Ireland?

mathanxiety · 28/02/2023 04:07

@beastlyslumber

DD3 visited Edinburgh last summer and got so depressed she stayed in her hotel until it was time to go home. Her friends brought food back from the restaurants they ate in. When she got back to Dublin her mood immediately lifted.

Kittycattenklump · 28/02/2023 02:23

GreyIvy · 27/02/2023 17:29

@Kittycattenklump Kittycattenklump

If you're considering Shrewsbury, also might be worth having a look at bridgnorth . Shropshire imo is very underrated and down played, but there are some beautiful rural/semi rural areas which thankfull y have retained both their character and amenities, but importantly, are still affordable! Bewdley( I think technically may be Worcestershire) is also thriving market town, with pretty river running through it and arty independent shops alongside supermarkets etc. Depends how much you need to rely on public transport though, because neither of these places have a train station, although Kidderminster station is only couple miles from bewdley. Also, cleobury mortimer ( small rural town)/ Ludlow(large town with train station and easy links to wales, but you do get the tourist issue here) may fit the bill?

I agree about Shropshire.
Having lived in Ludlow, although briefly, I can honestly say that the tourist onslaught is nowhere near the level of the Lakes. It's almost a delight in comparison. There is an actual community and stuff going on that isn't dependent upon visitors.
I am definitely drawn to this area, perhaps the more northern end, will give it some thought.

OP posts:
GreyIvy · 27/02/2023 17:29

@Kittycattenklump Kittycattenklump

If you're considering Shrewsbury, also might be worth having a look at bridgnorth . Shropshire imo is very underrated and down played, but there are some beautiful rural/semi rural areas which thankfull y have retained both their character and amenities, but importantly, are still affordable! Bewdley( I think technically may be Worcestershire) is also thriving market town, with pretty river running through it and arty independent shops alongside supermarkets etc. Depends how much you need to rely on public transport though, because neither of these places have a train station, although Kidderminster station is only couple miles from bewdley. Also, cleobury mortimer ( small rural town)/ Ludlow(large town with train station and easy links to wales, but you do get the tourist issue here) may fit the bill?

Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:26

Gawd, please excuse iPad typos Blush

OP posts:
Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:26

Moveforward · 27/02/2023 16:21

Interesting you feel like you do. I'm.the same and live in a similar place.

We've lived here 30 years and our area was where families lived and the holiday homes were just down the road as you approach the sea. During COVID it seemed an idyllic place to be but then came the crazy house market and people being kicked out of rentals for holiday homes or for sale. We now have 5 out of 7 neighbours that are holiday homes. Additionally, the cost of living crisis has hit and local people are struggling, I'm.sure businesses must be too, and I wonder how good the summer will be given the oversupply of accommodation.

It also feels like a doom has blown in.

I've not been well - having lost my Mum quite suddenly last year- so a lot is put down to that, but reading this, I'm not so sure. I think there is a sort of PTSD created by the pandemic which I looming it's head.

I sorry to hear about your mum.
mine passed away a few years ago, too. I think fief opens you up emotionally and you become more sensitive to surroundings and people in your life. However, this sensitivity is likely truth, a clarity that grief can bring, which forces us to assess our lives.
I would say never make a big, immediate life decision after a loss (been there!), but don’t push those feelings away either. Keep an eye on how you feel and trust your judgement going forward.

OP posts:
Moveforward · 27/02/2023 16:21

Interesting you feel like you do. I'm.the same and live in a similar place.

We've lived here 30 years and our area was where families lived and the holiday homes were just down the road as you approach the sea. During COVID it seemed an idyllic place to be but then came the crazy house market and people being kicked out of rentals for holiday homes or for sale. We now have 5 out of 7 neighbours that are holiday homes. Additionally, the cost of living crisis has hit and local people are struggling, I'm.sure businesses must be too, and I wonder how good the summer will be given the oversupply of accommodation.

It also feels like a doom has blown in.

I've not been well - having lost my Mum quite suddenly last year- so a lot is put down to that, but reading this, I'm not so sure. I think there is a sort of PTSD created by the pandemic which I looming it's head.

Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:20

Newpeep · 27/02/2023 16:18

We've been renters twice and looked after the properties. Lots of renters do but unfortunately those where we live now do not.

A lot of family and friends rent and all look after the property and in some cases above and beyond when their landlord clearly doesn't. But at the moment, where we are it really is a big divide between owners and renters as to how they conduct themselves.

I know what you mean, and I can’t relate to renters who shit on their own money this way.

OP posts:
Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:18

Regarding Tintagel, like Grasmere it is likely a shell, a husk of what once was a fascinating or lovable place for many. An empty, hollow space with investment property and cosmopolitan eateries. Not quite the dream village people are seeking, but the marketing is stroooooong.

Most of these types of places are now hollowed out, a ghost of their former selves. Grasmere reminds me of an open air garden centre with a cafe, some raincoats and a London style hotel. Lovely scenery, but nothing of substance.

OP posts:
Newpeep · 27/02/2023 16:18

Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 15:30

And it is such a shame this opinion of rentals persists, because as a renter I am very mindful of my home and want it to be beautiful and cared for. Sadly we can’t choose structural or many other alterations in an effort to keep things nice - although I have been lucky to live in some fabulous, attractive houses in my time!
BTL don’t care much, they leave dated, ugly fixtures in the houses and the outside areas are bleak. Nothing a tenant can do here apart from choose with their pocket. Many cant, so the issues perpetuate.

Many homeowners and renters allow property to degrade, but of course there is more incentive to keep up if your home is your investment.

Yet for me, my rent is also my investment, it is my home, my work, my life, so I want it to be lovely. We don’t get all that much time here on earth!

we (the proverbial) really needn’t have such a low opinion of renting, it is great for many of us who don’t wish to stay fixed or on maintenance mode. All of our housing should have dignity and care. It’s depressing.

We've been renters twice and looked after the properties. Lots of renters do but unfortunately those where we live now do not.

A lot of family and friends rent and all look after the property and in some cases above and beyond when their landlord clearly doesn't. But at the moment, where we are it really is a big divide between owners and renters as to how they conduct themselves.

GreyIvy · 27/02/2023 16:13

@Kittycattenklump

Yes! That's it - sick building syndrome!

it is a cloying sensation , like being wrapped in a heavy embrace and it's squeezing the air out of you. Interesting that you've experienced something similar,I don't often talk about it because it's hard for most people to understand.

I've saged the place, including the oppressive cellar, but no change unfortunately.

Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:12

Ambleside is weird, lol. Nice people locally though.

OP posts:
Kittycattenklump · 27/02/2023 16:12

I will definitely give these comments a lot of thought, thank you.

For rents, it’s fascinating that in many run down areas the prices are similar to much nicer areas. Not sure if this applies to buying/selling though.
If you can be geographically mobile/fluid this is great but not so much if you are tied to schools, work, etc.

I am currently looking on rightmove at two houses - one in Wigan (Greater Manchester) and one in Shrewsbury (Shropshire). Same price but astonishingly different. The one in Wigan is in a known drug/crime infested street. The Shrewsbury house is beautiful and in a nice place, with a fairytale garden and gorgeous inside.

it’s a mess.

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 27/02/2023 16:05

KimberleyClark · 27/02/2023 09:42

I wasn’t very keen on Tintagel when I went there. Found it depressing for some reason I can’t explain.

Someone else mentioned feeling that Ambleside was like a film set. Tintagel feels the same way to me. It's such a pointless place . Crap for tourists and crap for locals

GloomyDarkness · 27/02/2023 16:00

Some places can be depressing and sometimes it clear now bit grotty or run down other times it's harder to pin point however sometimes it's the people you come into contact with being down - due to housing/work issues, cost of living and that brings you down.

If you've been away a bit could be fresh eyes or place moving on without you a bit.

If you can easily move I'd give it a try - we are on the welsh side of the border when we first moved here town center - money had been spent on center- and secondary were on the up and have since dropped a lot but we love the house and feel settled something we never did in previous location.

GriddleScone · 27/02/2023 15:58

The UK, along with many other countries, is a worrying place at the moment. This stress is not just affecting the behaviour and mood of individuals, but also their perception of their environment.

And while I do agree that places can make you depressed, I have also experienced the dark cloud following me to new locations.

On the other hand, a new place and a fresh start might lift your mood anyway.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 27/02/2023 15:55

I think places can be depressing for you because something in them doesn't chime with some part of you- your need for space, or a certain type of light, or the people around you and so on. Or they remind you of an unpleasant emotion, like an echo. I'm not convinced everyone in Bath or Brighton is depressed however.

The whole of the UK is looking ropey. There's another thread on this right now. Parks are untended, roads are unswept, leaves clogging up drains, pot holes everywhere, buildings not cleaned and then a pandemic in which people had to holiday in the Uk so clustered in the touristy areas whilst being quite traumatized. I don't think anywhere is feeling uplifting right now if you ask a lot of people.

So think carefully what you want to do next- what do you want out of a place and where might provide that. Moving is a great idea for a fresh start, if you can keep friends as well. But a lot of beautiful areas for tourists are all beset by the same problems of the local economy tanking except for tourists, Air B and B wrecking the local rental market and so on.

I love where I live. It's very touristy but I see that as a sign that it's lovely and people want to come here! In summer, I love it but live a very particular way, I stay home in the day, have picnics, the doors open, enjoy the sun and then go out in the late afternoon and early evening to the beach to get away from the crowds. Sunsets are lovely. I don't ever eat out on Sunday lunchtime in high season, I go for early brunch with a friend. I adapt around the tourists, I don't attempt to follow them round and then get frustrated they are there. There are also very specific things about this area which I prefer to other parts of the country I've lived in but that others may hate- it's super-green as it rains all the time. I like it but someone else might find the dampness annoying!

Perhaps do some visits/try some places out to see how they might feel,, but do take account of the fact that everyone seems quite down at present, more than usual, so there is a general gloom that probably isn't just about the area you live.

Swipe left for the next trending thread