Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incels

311 replies

Theninetieswerebetter · 26/02/2023 22:37

Is anyone watching ‘Untold’ on Channel 4?

I worry for my DD’s future

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 27/02/2023 09:34

Dippyeggz · 27/02/2023 09:11

Haven't RTFT but had anyone mentioned porn? Because porn plays a huge role in this, I suspect (as does Reddit)

I did Dippy

I think the easy availability of porn - particularly extreme porn - is hugely influential. And children seem to be accessing these sites at a very early and impressionable age, before they have had a chance to develop relationships and find out what true intimacy is.

I thought it very ironic that there was recent attempts to Bowdlerise Roald Dahl to "protect" child men from such words as "female", when those same children are just a click away from watching a girl being tortured and raped. Of course, there is another (AGP) agenda at play here, and it is linked to pornography

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/02/2023 09:34

TerrysGotPeeves · 27/02/2023 00:46

Wonderfully put. I fecking love this post, thank you @ConfusedNT .

Absolutely!

Incels are far from acting “in a feminine way” (whatever that means). They seem to be the most toxicly masculine ones out there!

Allergictoironing · 27/02/2023 09:33

Plenty of incels could easily find girlfriends, the issue is these women they could land don't meet the standard they feel they deserve.

This, very much so. It isn't that the fat, plain or socially awkward women have rejected them, it's only that the beautiful, slim & "model" type women who they want have gone for someone else.

Well guess what? Women who are considered "below average" according to modern standards of beauty, femininity or social skills tend to be rejected by "above average" men. Doesn't turn us all into man hating violent people blaming society for unrealistic stereotypes and murdering good looking successful men. We just pick ourselves up and look around for someone who appreciates us for who we are as a person rather than on societal stereotypes, but many men don't seem to apply the same logic. You don't see very rich, powerful or famously good looking men with short, fat, plain or sour tempered women on their arm, they get their "pick" of the sweet beautiful women. Works both ways - if a woman is desirable enough to have her pick of men she can go for the one who can provide best for her or is the most attractive to her.

I was never particularly attracted to uber masculine "alpha males", violence isn't a turn on for me nor is entitlement. Give me a man who has a brain & uses it, is kind and considerate, is comfortable in their own skin, and without a chip on their shoulder because they think someone else has an advantage over them, and things like looks and physique don't really matter to me. If I was in the market for a partner, I would be very happy to meet someone who may be not particularly attractive, doesn't earn a fortune, and prefers gaming or watching history documentaries rather than playing sport all weekend then going out getting pissed.

Yes I can see a beautiful male body on the TV and admire it, or think "wouldn't kick THAT out of bed on a cold night", but that's just like window shopping at a really expensive shop you can't afford. I don't think "not fair, I deserve someone who looks like that" and blame it on society that this gorgeous looking 20 something won't look twice at a middle ages, plain fat woman.

Opaljewel · 27/02/2023 09:31

Real men don't act or think like incels or damn andrew tate. Real men respect themselves and women at the same time. My man isn't a fighter or an alpha. He's amazing, kind, cooks and cleans. Is hot in bed and still likes sport etc. He likes animals and adores our cat. The difference is he treats me as a person and not an object. Incels need to realise if they get out of their self serving drivel, then maybe they might start to live a wonderful life. It starts from yourself and how you treat yourself and others. No one in this world is entitled to anything or anyone. Women are not your enemy.

highfidelity · 27/02/2023 09:29

@ConfusedNT has it absolutely spot-on.

Despite living in a patriarchal society, incels believe they oppressed by women. Never has there been an idea as ridiculous as it is offensive.

Apologies for a Daily Fail link, but this article clearly lays things out.

Brefugee · 27/02/2023 09:21

I think you also have to look at societal expectations. A man alone gaming in his room is seen as some sort of weirdo. He should be going to the gym, hanging out with other “lads”, dating etc etc. That’s how society thinks men should be living when single. But why is it an issue if someone just prefers to be gaming?

The absolute kicker here, of course, is that more and more women than ever are gamers but their experiences in online gaming are awful. What with all the messages, private and otherwise and so on. And some of the women are stunning looking too - you'd think that gamer-incels would try being nice to them. But no

As pp said, it isn't even that they want a relationship, they all want to have [insert current stunning woman in the public eye] as their girlfriend, who is the perfect woman (what is it, loves sex and turns in to a pizza at midnight?). And to get this stunner, they don't want to do anything at all.

As for the insults towards single mothers - if fucking bollocking "men" wouldn't abandon their families when they divorce, but do what a responsible father would do and keep up with their father-role, this wouldn't be an issue. Far far from being women's fault, it is absent-fathers' fault. Incels probably see these absent disengaged fathers, living their best lives (possibly fathering more children) as Role Model Alpha Types.

There are lots of people who diss social science, but IIRC one of the things it has taught us is that if people of a similar "attractiveness" (as in superficially allocated on a scale of 1 to 10) - say two 6s - they have far more chance of staying together than if one is spectacularly more good looking than the other (this is not the only criteria, but i was interested when I read it. I'm sure i didn't dream it up)

Moopsi · 27/02/2023 09:21

I definitely think porn plays a massive part in it too. Which is why I never understand how some women are OK with their husbands/boyfriends watching porn. Let alone all of the other moral issues, like sex trafficking, that come into it.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 27/02/2023 09:15

ConfusedNT · 27/02/2023 00:38

No the incel movement is what happens when some men realise that now that women don't have to rely on men for social and financial reasons, men actually have to be decent men to attract women, and instead of being decent they decided to bitch about how women should still be relying on them instead

Meanwhile men who are decent men are still getting women and that really pisses them off. Because that means that womens emancipation hasn't stopped women getting together with men, it's just stopped them getting together with/staying with the bad ones. And that means they would have to do something about their behaviour and that's hard. So it's easier to bitch about women instead.

Exactly this. So it isn't just women who need to be afraid of incels, it is also men with partners.

PortiasBiscuit · 27/02/2023 09:15

How the fuck do you get more female ancestors than male ancestors? Every baby comes from one male and one female, that’s how sex works.

Feefee00 · 27/02/2023 09:13

SamanthaCaine · 27/02/2023 09:08

Yes, sorry. I wasn't being intentionally disagreeable. I guess I just interpreted success as financial but it could be anything really, so you're quite right.

Yes, OH definitely has his head screwed on. He's special to me but ultimately not special (if that makes sense), which makes it quite sad that more people lack any security in themselves. It shouldn't be that difficult but it seems to elude so many people.

Society really needs to help these people, as distasteful as it may sound, as we all suffer otherwise.

I work with some people with mild Learning disabilities and Autism. We were doing relationship workshops the difference between the male expectations and females omg. The males were saying they wanted a normal girlfriend who looked like a model, the females just said they wanted a man to go for dinner with and have hug, spend time together. Ironically the man who had the most success wasn't very choosey the other men would rip the piss out of him but he was the one having sex and getting girlfriends . There's definitely an ingrained male entitlement view that they would rather stay lonely than have to lower themselves.

Dippyeggz · 27/02/2023 09:11

Haven't RTFT but had anyone mentioned porn? Because porn plays a huge role in this, I suspect (as does Reddit)

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 27/02/2023 09:11

Incels are claiming women all want ‘chads’ yet I am surrounded by women whose partners are Scott from IT, or Nick in marketing or Sam who works in the training dept or sales.
They all seem happy enough with nice,
ordinary looking men who have a ok paid job, go to home matches on a Saturday and take the kids swimming on a Sunday and do their share of house/ life/ kids stuff.

SamanthaCaine · 27/02/2023 09:08

SerafinasGoose · 27/02/2023 09:01

Agreed. I think that depends how you measure 'success'.

No one thinks on their deathbed that they wished they'd spent more time at work. And after your time has come, unless you're J K Rowling, Stephen Hawking, Anita Roddick or Steve Jobs, you largely won't be remembered for any of your professional accomplishments.

Your DH sounds as though he has his head screwed on.

Yes, sorry. I wasn't being intentionally disagreeable. I guess I just interpreted success as financial but it could be anything really, so you're quite right.

Yes, OH definitely has his head screwed on. He's special to me but ultimately not special (if that makes sense), which makes it quite sad that more people lack any security in themselves. It shouldn't be that difficult but it seems to elude so many people.

Society really needs to help these people, as distasteful as it may sound, as we all suffer otherwise.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 27/02/2023 09:07

@GothicViolence
’The guys that work in “the city” making a shit tonne of money, apart from being good at maths what traits do they have?’

connections mainly. And many of them are shit at maths by the way. It’s all bravado and algorithms. Also, you may not have heard this as I assume you don’t leave the house much, but lots of women work in finance now too.

Feefee00 · 27/02/2023 09:07

It's male entitlement really. Incels never say they want any woman. It's they want young beautiful virgin 4 foot 11 and 6 stone. There's many women out there who can't get a long term partner but don't resort to violence.
Elliot Rogers was not an ugly man but had an entitled vile personality.

SerafinasGoose · 27/02/2023 09:01

SamanthaCaine · 27/02/2023 08:55

This, although I'd say men that are secure and not necessarily successful are fearless.

My OH has done ok for himself. I asked him what it means to be a man and he said that he doesn't know and doesn't really care. Being a decent human being is all that really matters. Doing what's necessary to be a decent father/husband/colleague/citizen is what's important, not some idea of manliness.

I'd say the same for women. The sooner we can raise children that are secure in themselves, the better. And get rid of the idea that being a man or woman means anything.

Agreed. I think that depends how you measure 'success'.

No one thinks on their deathbed that they wished they'd spent more time at work. And after your time has come, unless you're J K Rowling, Stephen Hawking, Anita Roddick or Steve Jobs, you largely won't be remembered for any of your professional accomplishments.

Your DH sounds as though he has his head screwed on.

Soubriquet · 27/02/2023 09:00

I’m watching it now and yeah it’s disturbing.

Incels not only feel they are entitled to women for sex, they believe they are entitled to what they perceive as beautiful women for sex.

If they were that desperate for women, they would go for the so called femcels. Then both situations would be solved wouldn’t it

QueefQueen80s · 27/02/2023 08:59

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 01:34

I thought that was outlandish too, but it really is the best thing for a young man’s development

Ugh you are really grim. Toxic male traits are not attractive, they give us the ICK.

Surplus2requirements · 27/02/2023 08:59

Gothicarsewipe doesn't see himself as an incel, he sees himself as an alpha.

Both are inextricably linked and rooted in toxic entitlement.

Weak men that fear they will be overwhelmed by loss of privileged misogyny

SamanthaCaine · 27/02/2023 08:55

SerafinasGoose · 27/02/2023 08:36

It's fully internalized toxic masculinity to a fault.

I find it's a common misconception that this term means men - especially men with so-called 'masculine' traits, are toxic. The perpetuation of these narrow, reductive stereotypes and dismissal of all men who don't meet their machismo, alpha male standards are somehow lacking, is what toxic masculinity really is. The incel movement is no small perpetuator of this idiocy, and the one on this thread has swallowed it hook and bait.

Men who are secure and 'successful' don't fear not living up to these regressive stereotypes.

And it's all another very good example of why the manufactured social construct known as 'gender' is a bunch of BS.

This, although I'd say men that are secure and not necessarily successful are fearless.

My OH has done ok for himself. I asked him what it means to be a man and he said that he doesn't know and doesn't really care. Being a decent human being is all that really matters. Doing what's necessary to be a decent father/husband/colleague/citizen is what's important, not some idea of manliness.

I'd say the same for women. The sooner we can raise children that are secure in themselves, the better. And get rid of the idea that being a man or woman means anything.

takealettermsjones · 27/02/2023 08:53

sanabria · 27/02/2023 08:42

I think there is a biological aspect to all of this too...

Statistically we do have have more female ancestors than male. Good looking men have always fathered more children with more women, and many men will die without having fathered any children.

Also women's perspective of male attractiveness tends to be very skewed in that women tend to rate more men as "below average". And so the truly below average get rated very harshly.

So I think it's fair to say that incels have always existed. The only difference now is that rather than these men being invisible, they congregate online and create very angry and bitter communities which occasionally attracts media coverage.

I think saying that "all these men need to do is improve their personalities" is missing the bigger picture. We do tend to treat people differently based on how they look. Plenty of people report that they notice they are treated better when they are slimmer, fitter, or notice changes in how they are treated as they get older or if they have a physical or learning disabilities.

Likewise, not all of these young men have the ability to become highly successful or socially enigmatic in order to become more attractive. A couple of other posters have mentioned that a lot of these young men appear to have autism. Which, if true, will also weaken their ability to succeed socially or professionally.

So I can very much believe that these young men probably have been treated poorly and experienced rejection by their peers and romantic interests. This could be enormously damaging to their development especially if such treatment starts early in life.

I don't think we can do anything to change this reality either, as women aren't about to change their selection criteria and I don't think society is going to stop judging and treating people differently by appearances.

The incel communities are toxic and hateful and it is instinctive to hate them back. But I try to have a bit of empathy for them. They are clearly struggling and you have to wonder what their life experiences to this point have been like to make them this way.

Good grief not another one.

So I think it's fair to say that incels have always existed. The only difference now is that rather than these men being invisible, they congregate online and create very angry and bitter communities which occasionally attracts media coverage.

No, the difference is that now they're getting together to egg each other on to murder women and girls, and some of them are succeeding. Not sure why or how you're feeling so sorry for people who think murder, torture and rape is the answer to their problems, no matter how those problems were caused.

Funny how there's so much rhetoric about "women's selection processes" and "focus on looks/physique", as though women are never assessed harshly by men or valued by their looks alone.

ZuzuMyLittleGingersnap · 27/02/2023 08:52

@Emotionalsupportviper
c) Bullying men displaying "toxic masculinity" aren't "strong" men. They are men lacking emotional intelligence and maturity.

^^ This. A hundred times, this.

JanusTheFirst · 27/02/2023 08:51

Surely someone is taking the piss. No one can be that stupid, can they?

Naunet · 27/02/2023 08:50

AngelinaFibres · 27/02/2023 08:46

Did you watch the programme last night.
I cannot imagine you would have quite so much empathy for them if you had.The website where a woman was decapitated with a machete and another was suffocated in a plastic barrel was a particular low point.

Fucking hell. They’re a step away from the Taliban.

SchrodingersUnicorn · 27/02/2023 08:49

I really did wonder if Gothic was parodying for a while there...
This 'single mums produce incels' rhetoric. Are we sure it isn't because the dad in question is a complete arsehole (probably why they split up) and has access to the kids every weekend to fill the teenage boys' heads with this nonsense?

@Simonjt you got there before me replying to that one! I was going to ask Gothic if he thinks there are only two types of men: 'white' and 'Islamic' (and no overlap don't you know... 🙄)