Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incels

311 replies

Theninetieswerebetter · 26/02/2023 22:37

Is anyone watching ‘Untold’ on Channel 4?

I worry for my DD’s future

OP posts:
dayslikethese1 · 28/02/2023 10:38

Who knew that masculinity has been brought down by chihuahuas? 😂😂

Allergictoironing · 28/02/2023 10:22

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:32

Allergictoironing balanced post, and I agree with most of it. But we can still be aware of all that and adapt without the need to completely emasculate men or 'defeminise' women.

Again, depends on your definition of "Emasculate" and "Defeminise".

I am definitely female, and though fat and comparatively plain looking I like to wear pretty dresses on the right occasions and try to look good wearing things that flatter me. Though never been (or wanted to be) a mother I am very nurturing e.g. siblings, nephews, pets, workmates, friends etc. The fact that I was a "tomboy" when I was growing up, have always liked sports, and wear trousers & flats most of the time (due to disability & practicality) doesn't make me masculine.

One of my best friends is very definitely male. He's a confident self assured man who used to play lots of sport in his younger years and currently does sport diving. He has "presence" and could never be considered emasculated in any way. Yet he is a father who still cares for his grown up offspring, has cats he adores and is very gentle with, used to have a very small dog he also adored, is empathetic and kind. He defers to me on subjects I know more about & vice versa.

I could be considered as de-feminised due to my clothing, the fact I have no dependency on anyone else, work for a living, love many traditionally male sports. He could be considered emasculated by some definitions because he is kind, loving, gentle, doesn't care that his dog was a tiny lap type dog & doesn't care too much about traditionally masculine trappings like what car he drives (practical rather than the sporty one he would have for pleasure), bragging about how tough he is, or throw his weight about.

knittingaddict · 28/02/2023 10:12

Modern warfare rarely needs massive muscles and the ability to club or punch an opponent into submission, or the levels of face to face aggression it once needed. Brains, co-ordination and the ability to use modern weaponry are much more important these days. As long as physical strength isn't in the equation women can do everything men can. There are women soldiers, sailors, fighter pilots, "on the ground" not in back offices.

Allergictoironing great post.

My less than macho husband would probably be great at modern warfare. He's intelligent, a problem solver and good with anything mechanical and building things. Not so great at wielding a broadsword, but less call for that these days.

Some of the posts on here are clearly written by out of date dinosaurs.

ConfusedNT · 28/02/2023 10:08

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:32

Allergictoironing balanced post, and I agree with most of it. But we can still be aware of all that and adapt without the need to completely emasculate men or 'defeminise' women.

To be honest I'm confused as to why women even seem to be responsive for the emasculation or otherwise of men anyway

We are talking about incels and how dangerous and destructive their views are, to women in particular and somehow we are back to blaming women

So once again male anger, male aggression and male violence are women's fault.

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 10:05

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:57

A positive male will walk gently, aware that everything is connected, nurture everything and live in balance

No eating then

That would be a bit silly.

That's why you nurture, have a positive influence so you can take what you need without destroying the balance.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:57

A positive male will walk gently, aware that everything is connected, nurture everything and live in balance

No eating then

Surplus2requirements · 28/02/2023 09:54

For me as a some time survival instructor and bushcraft nut I tend to think of toxic vs positive masculinity in terms of how we relate to the natural environment.

A toxic male will crash into wilderness, unaware and uncaring of what he destroys fully equipped to kill the biggest thing he can and feast. He has to move on and repeat.

A positive male will walk gently, aware that everything is connected, nurture everything and live in balance.

But then I have a beard and a silly little fluffy dog

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:32

Allergictoironing balanced post, and I agree with most of it. But we can still be aware of all that and adapt without the need to completely emasculate men or 'defeminise' women.

Allergictoironing · 28/02/2023 09:32

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:25

This is interesting. Ars**oles come in all shapes and sizes. Being non-manly doesn't make a man a nice person. He could have a completely off-putting personality and undesirable traits while being unmanly. I know quite a few men like this. We have come so far in our desire for emasculation that we equate manliness with evil and vice versa

Depends on your definition of "manliness" really. Being gentle when that's called for, not too concerned about having a macho image, not being into sport etc doesn't make someone "unmanly" in my eyes. Then again, being a violent ill tempered twat who hits people, throws their weight around and gets drunk after watching a football match isn't showing their "manliness" in any way IMO.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 28/02/2023 09:25

ItWillWash · 28/02/2023 03:31

But I struggle to see how women can be attracted to some of the stereotypes that are often seen as theoretical role models for young men today (e.g. vegan, walking chihuahuas, being scared of their own shadow, etc)

I am deliberately single. I'm not physically attracted to women, unfortunately, and men, are by and large, arseholes, imo but if I met a bearded, specialty coffee-drinking, vegan man walking a chihuahua I would be interested. I love coffee and chihuahuas and I'm always trying to eat better. Plus, he's vegan and has a Chi therefore the chances of him being an arsehole are significantly reduced.

This is interesting. Ars**oles come in all shapes and sizes. Being non-manly doesn't make a man a nice person. He could have a completely off-putting personality and undesirable traits while being unmanly. I know quite a few men like this. We have come so far in our desire for emasculation that we equate manliness with evil and vice versa

PortiasBiscuit · 28/02/2023 09:22

DH is a gentle man, loves cats, best of fathers, good to his parents and my Mum, office job.
Would I trust him to fight and die for me and the children if we were attacked, absolutely, and I would do the same for him.
The trick is knowing when your ploughshares need to become swords and acting appropriately.

ConfusedNT · 28/02/2023 09:16

Men are killing 2 women a week through domestic violence etc yet somehow the ones we need to fear, because of what they might do to society, are the ones with gentle hands....🙄

Allergictoironing · 28/02/2023 09:09

But the current drive from society to try to emasculate men at all cost is indeed worrying.

I think you're using the term "emasculate" in a very emotive way, and citing what you view as extremes of "emasculated" behaviours.

Firstly your stereotype "soy drinking, beardy, chihuahua walking" etc. In modern society there's no need for a large, aggressive guard dog, dogs are pets pure and simple and I really can't see why a smaller dog should be seen as weakening a man, these animals are fearsome ratters by nature and when brought up e.g. in a farm setting. The only reason in modern society for a pet dog owned by a man to always be big & macho is to make a statement by association with the animal - and a man who is confident in himself doesn't need that kind of symbolism. Sort of like the old "big car = big penis" thinking.

Regarding soy/non-cow milk, humans were lactose intolerant until very recently in evolutionary terms and cows milk still isn't very good for the majority of people. More and more people are realising that consuming something that isn't really that good for you isn't a terribly good idea, so are going lactose free whether that be soy, almond, oat, goat or any other lactose low/free variety.

Beard wearing is a ridiculous indicator of someone being emasculated. Fashions change, and many times in the past beards were an indicator of masculinity and clean shaven was seen as effeminate.

I can completely understand the desire in men to be protective of women. Women are physically weaker, have times when they are pregnant and less able to defend themselves, and due to these have historically been the ones to raise children.

They are also in many ways less "disposable" than men. If the men go out to hunt & only half come back, the remaining ones can still father the same number of children. Whereas if half the women die, you can only produce half the number of children.

BUT - the world has changed an awful lot since the caveman days or even medieval days.

Modern warfare rarely needs massive muscles and the ability to club or punch an opponent into submission, or the levels of face to face aggression it once needed. Brains, co-ordination and the ability to use modern weaponry are much more important these days. As long as physical strength isn't in the equation women can do everything men can. There are women soldiers, sailors, fighter pilots, "on the ground" not in back offices.

With changes in modern society bearing and raising children is no longer a dangerous potentially fatal task and can be much less time consuming e.g. modern medicines, schools, formal child care arrangements, modern technology. This frees up women to work, despite them often being expected to still pick up all the home tasks like cooking, cleaning, childcare & admin.

So women have in general adapted to how the world is now, at least in First World countries. They can fulfill just about any role without feeling de-feminised or masculine. Many men have adapted in the same way, sharing tasks and no longer dividing things into "men's work" and "women's work", as there's no need for that any more.

Unfortunately many men have failed to evolve. They don't seem to realise that being able to fight and/or oppress anyone weaker than them (in their eyes) is no longer an important trait for survival. This can frustrate them and they react in the only way they understand, by getting more violent & aggressive, often against the very people they should be protecting.

TL:DR
It's a very sad state of affairs when the whole historic reason for men needing to fight & be aggressive is turned against the very people those traits evolved to protect, rather than being able to adapt to the modern world.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 28/02/2023 08:59

'Gotta love that “bearded” in there as an example of an emasculated man.'

That's weird, must of the bearded men I know are big rugby playing blokey blokes. Did I miss a memo??

MeganTheeScallion · 28/02/2023 08:53

@TeaStory posted too soon!!

Ahem.

No no no, you misunderstand, silly female. Facial hair is a sign he's turning into a chihuahua.

MeganTheeScallion · 28/02/2023 08:52

@Over40Overdating YES!

@TeaStory no no

TeaStory · 28/02/2023 08:47

Gotta love that “bearded” in there as an example of an emasculated man. Because of course there’s nothing less manly than… checks notes… having thick facial hair.

Over40Overdating · 28/02/2023 08:21

I would not give a womanizer or bully the time of day. But why are we teaching young men that it's acceptable to be scared of other men? Can you imagine if the West was to be attacked and we had to rely on chihuahua owners, bearded speciality coffee drinkers, 'gentle hands' advocates for our protection?

Men are scared of other men because they are fucking dangerous. The overwhelming majority of violent crime - towards men, women and children - is committed BY MEN.

Chi owning, speciality coffee drinking, gentle hands men are showing common sense and awareness to fear the violent ones.
If more men were gentle hands, we wouldn’t have to worry about being attacked because the urge to murder, destroy and evade wouldn’t be there.

And in my very long experience, the only men ‘afraid’ to speak their minds are the ones who hold racist, misogynistic, problematic views to begin with. What they fear is rightful consequences for the actions - because newsflash, free speech is not the same of freedom of consequences for hate speech.
Angry man logic 101 - if I’m not free to spout hate and shite, I’m being oppressed, wah wah wah.
Nothing more unattractive than a grown man having a temper tantrum.

CheekyHobson · 28/02/2023 05:03

ImustLearn2Cook · 28/02/2023 04:05

I’m scared of chihuahuas, I would think he’s pretty brave to own one. 😉

Yeah, they can be really bitey little fuckers.

A vegan with a well-behaved chihuahua sounds to me like someone who has either strong morals or an iron will, and a sensible/fearless approach to dog-training to boot.

ImustLearn2Cook · 28/02/2023 04:05

I’m scared of chihuahuas, I would think he’s pretty brave to own one. 😉

ItWillWash · 28/02/2023 03:31

But I struggle to see how women can be attracted to some of the stereotypes that are often seen as theoretical role models for young men today (e.g. vegan, walking chihuahuas, being scared of their own shadow, etc)

I am deliberately single. I'm not physically attracted to women, unfortunately, and men, are by and large, arseholes, imo but if I met a bearded, specialty coffee-drinking, vegan man walking a chihuahua I would be interested. I love coffee and chihuahuas and I'm always trying to eat better. Plus, he's vegan and has a Chi therefore the chances of him being an arsehole are significantly reduced.

NoMoreDrech · 28/02/2023 02:36

ConfusedNT · 28/02/2023 01:09

If incels were the answer to a society where men apparently can no longer defend us (newsflash, they have been letti g women in the military for some time now) they would all be in the military.

And if I had to look to someone for protection, a bearded speciality coffee shop owner sounds like a better choice than a man who hides in his bedroom moaning on websites that he can't get laid

This!

As seen on this show, incels are normally inadequates, a significant proportion have learning difficulties and all are socially isolated and odd. They are not ‘macho men’ being oppressed by nice, bearded coffee drinking chihuahua walking vegans.

ConfusedNT · 28/02/2023 02:14

When I was volunteering for a kids thing one of the kids dad's would walk the daily chihuahua to come and pick up the kids. Lovely man, two children, steady job, nice wife. Never struck me as emasculated but there you go learn something new every day

I also know a man who part owns a speciality coffee company. Lovely man, four kids, 2 grandkids and a beautiful wife. Very successful in business, good at making and keeping strong friendships. Also has a small dog now I think about it. And is a public speaker so 'speaks his own mind', sometimes he even speaks about his fears and he's mesmerising. About as far as emasculated as I can think of.

Funny thing is they are the happily married ones, with some amount of an active sex life given they've had kids, and they seem really happy and content.

But sure these are the ones damaging society, not the ones who encourage each other to kill people because they aren't getting sex with beautiful women.

MeganTheeScallion · 28/02/2023 02:14

Imagine if you were a regular vegan bloke, working in HR and had a chihuahua, just going about your day, drinking your soy latte, totally unaware that you're responsible for the downfall of western manhood.

ConfusedNT · 28/02/2023 02:07

MeganTheeScallion · 28/02/2023 01:46

"Walking chihuahuas" as an insult is just chef's kiss level weird, well done! Excited to update my lists of Unhinged Internet Claims, cheers.

Will nobody think of the poor chihuahuas 😂