Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incels

311 replies

Theninetieswerebetter · 26/02/2023 22:37

Is anyone watching ‘Untold’ on Channel 4?

I worry for my DD’s future

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 27/02/2023 04:35

Yup, I watched... horrific stuff.

It's all a self fulfilling prophecy I thought... they feel isolated, socially un-skilled, maybe they've had a bad experience (who hasn't), so they isolate themselves further, find a group online that makes them feel heard, welcomed, accepted... so they invest more time in that than real life, so real life by comparison becomes shittier and harder to navigate... round and round it goes.

I thought the UK lad 'D' really struggled once brought out into the real world, like he could hear how ridiculous and nonsensical some of the things he was saying really were, and the belief started to crumble.

I don't think there is one cause, you could lay the blame at the existence of the internet, after all without it it would not be possible to isolate oneself to the degree some people do. It would not be possible to cram together a bunch of people with such a toxic ideology and keep perpetuating it, without chat rooms and forums and social media.

I do think most people struggle, once out of education, to make new friends. If you don't leave the town you grew up in, but everyone else does; if you don't work and so don't meet anyone; you don't go out and 'do' something you're interested in, then you won't meet other people with similar interests... then it becomes harder and harder to engage with real life and meet new people.

I really doubt the 'lack of male role model' argument - the number of people who grow up without that must be huge, the number of people who do have a male role model but it isn't a dominant masculine alpha male type must also be huge. They're not all incels, no where near.

I wish I knew what the answer was... I have no clue. I see anti-incel stuff on SM, but I see it because it's what I want to see. If I were an incel, I wouldn't want to see it so I would not see it. SM is an echo chamber, you'll only see what you want.

greenspaces4peace · 27/02/2023 04:00

@echt lanegoodwin.com/how-to-be-more-masculine/
although more narrative than fact and data based. It discusses the view.
I’ve not found more scholarly articles but I gather this is what a good male role model provides.

CheekyHobson · 27/02/2023 03:15

You tend to see a lot those in their 20s who couldn’t be arsed suddenly panic when they hit their 30s and they realise they want children.

LOL, well now that you've made an extremely vague and unsupported but ominous statement, I'm convinced.

echt · 27/02/2023 03:05

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 00:16

The incel movement is what happens when a generation of young men are told to act in a less masculine way, only to find out that society finds feminine men off-putting.

At they save time they find that their peers who didn’t let themselves be brow beaten into ignoring their programming do better in every metric.

Got any data on that?

QueenCamilla · 27/02/2023 03:00

greenspaces4peace · 27/02/2023 02:46

@QueenCamilla the link to the cambridge article discusses the body dysmorphia and mental health issues. i was surprised to read they seem to suggest a link with adhd and autism.

Oh, I'll have a read - I like the science of body&mind and the "Clinical Intervention" part makes it sound particularly valuable. I do get tired of social sciences bulldozing their way all over the place these days.

QueenCamilla · 27/02/2023 02:53

I had a classmate. A bullied boy with Asperger's. I danced with him at school dances to help him feel better about those events and I remember other girls helping him out in some awkward social situations.
We stayed friends into young adulthood. He made a lot of money in programming, was the first to marry and have kids.
He was too nice and reliable a guy to be left bitter, angry and alone.

greenspaces4peace · 27/02/2023 02:46

@QueenCamilla the link to the cambridge article discusses the body dysmorphia and mental health issues. i was surprised to read they seem to suggest a link with adhd and autism.

QueenCamilla · 27/02/2023 02:39

I've never seen/heard an incel and have been left wondering as to why he's single.

There's often learning difficulties/ Mental illness present with badly channeled aggression. Monkey with a grenade type.
Same men nearly always lack in friendships too. We humans sense the "bad eggs".

It's actually quite bewildering listening to incels blame the unrealistic women, their own jaw size or lack of riches, when they always sound like horrible, spiteful, angry morons.

EllieM27 · 27/02/2023 02:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, this is largely true. I’ve done some research on these groups with colleagues. The majority of self-identified incels readily admit to not having a father in their lives. There is a lot of messaging that often happens with single mothers and their sons that can contribute. Some of it is overt, with them making negative statements about men due to their own bad experiences and to perceiving their sons as boys instead of future men. Or repeatedly telling them things like “you must be x kind of man, not y” without explanation or nuance. But much of it is also subconscious and harder to potentially address, such as the cases of single mothers with single sons and no partners, which often leads to enmeshment and codependency between mother and son.

It is also untrue that all/most incels are white. Incels come in every race, and often they’ll split into groups based on race/ethnicity so that they can address the issues that they perceive as being unique to their group. For example, “blackcels” or “Asiancels.” There are actually significant incel groups of Asian and Indian men that specifically want to date white women and, viewing skin colour and height as two major issues for them, discuss skin-bleaching and even limb-lengthening amongst themselves. It’s all quite fascinating and extremely sad.

greenspaces4peace · 27/02/2023 02:30

www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bjpsych-advances/article/incels-violence-and-mental-disorder-a-narrative-review-with-recommendations-for-best-practice-in-risk-assessment-and-clinical-intervention/6A934637D21AEE4C1D90FAF5FB63D769
a good fairly recent article.
@GothicViolence google seems to suggest it's not limited to mostly white but that could be bias in reporting.
i do agree that other cultures might have more family involvement so uncles and neighbors to help young men navigate the changing times (jobs expectations etc.)

Fixyourself · 27/02/2023 02:27

The movement is huge and has been very underreported. A lot of recent murders can be put down to incels. Not all men are incels but all incels are men.

I have girls and I am very worried for their future.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 02:17

Going back to the point incels mostly being white, why do you think that is? Truly? What is the difference between the Islamic treatment of masculinity and the secular western approach?

MrsClatterbuck · 27/02/2023 02:09

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 00:49

All fair enough questions.

Millennials and Gen Z

Its been a political push from the elites to subdue the west, they did this by me forcing the politics of the HR department onto wider society.

It depends on the household but the indoctrination starts at home, absentee fathers are a huge problem, it takes men to raise men.

The introduction of seed oils and soy into the modern diet has also caused testosterone levels to plummet.

The programming that meant men in the Stone Age could hunt the mammoth.

Any metric you can think of; career, interpersonal relationships, health, wealth..

Is that you Lori Alexander The Transformed Wife probably not but it's the kind of bull shit she spouts

ConfusedNT · 27/02/2023 02:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's mostly white men who are incels, not those from minority communities

It makes sense, a generation or two ago the white man was king. Now they have to contend with a greater equality which feels like somethings been taken away from them

They are still being socialised by society to assume that they are owed success because they are white and male, and when success doesn't come easily they haven't been taught to cope with that like women and POC are.

Put that alongside women who don't need them to the same extent and you get mediocre white men thinking everyone else had taken their birthright from them.

Now when you add in that men from single parent households are more likely to have witnessed domestic violence and abuse, if more incels do come from single parent households then it makes sense they would move towards toxic mysoginistic viewpoints.

But given children from lesbian (and gay) households tends to achieve the same outcomes as children from two parent households I'm not sure the fact that single parent households tend to be mums is the issue otherwise you would get the same issues with children raised by lesbian couples.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 02:01

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/02/2023 01:53

I'm not feeding the troll.

I will say that younger women appear to be choosing either women, or no one, to have a relationship with now more and more. As a lovely young man I know said, "well you can't really blame them, most teenage boys are horrible".

Men need to step their game up. Women now work, bring up children, run homes and do all the blue jobs. If men can't d blue or pink jobs, why do we need them? TBF DH's theory is I need him to find things or he'd be single.

A lot of women want kids though. You tend to see a lot those in their 20s who couldn’t be arsed suddenly panic when they hit their 30s and they realise they want children.

Just an observation from a “troll” mind.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/02/2023 01:59

"I'm not an X but..."

Yup.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/02/2023 01:53

I'm not feeding the troll.

I will say that younger women appear to be choosing either women, or no one, to have a relationship with now more and more. As a lovely young man I know said, "well you can't really blame them, most teenage boys are horrible".

Men need to step their game up. Women now work, bring up children, run homes and do all the blue jobs. If men can't d blue or pink jobs, why do we need them? TBF DH's theory is I need him to find things or he'd be single.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 01:53

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 27/02/2023 01:47

YANBU I do fear for a whole generation of boys and girls.

Incels are becoming so pervasive on social media that teachers and parents are referring their kids to the prevent programme which is usually for extremist religious ideologies. I ended up on an incel forum, and they were talking about the murder of a 19 year old girl and the things they were writing I wish I hadn't read and I'm not easily shaken.

Boys and young men are being told by people like Tatertot and in incel forums that women gaining rights, speaking up about and against sexism and misogyny is taking rights away from men. I'm seeing a creeping rhetoric that when women speak out against certain things like sexist jokes and about things like feminism, they get accused of being abusive and misandric and of "toxic femininity"

Boys and young men are being told on social media that girls are only good as holes to fuck and basically doing everything a man tells them to do without complaint.

Girls are being told that if they complain about anything then they're misandrists, abusers and displaying toxic femininity.

It's really fucked up, incels are only the tip of the iceberg. It's the Andrew Tates of the world who are shaping how young men view women that I worry about more, because he does it in an accessible, salesman type way. And boys are listening to him.

I don't think I've lived in a time where overt misogyny was so accepted and seemingly defended, it's insidious.

To be fair, as someone else pointed out, incels tend to be white. They’re an easy touch to refer to Prevent because there won’t be a backlash from the Guardian/opportunistic human rights lawyers.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 01:50

I’m not an incel but I said that absentee fathers are a huge problem earlier.

Idkrealorfake · 27/02/2023 01:49

So it's really men's fault for abandoning their children.

Weird I've never once heard an incel say that. You should let them know the true cause, and they can stop abusing women who want nothing to do with them and get therapy instead.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 01:49

No, I think the attitudes and politics of the HR department has permeated to wider society to everyone’s detriment.

As for the lads with floppy hair and eye liner I always found that they had more license to behave badly than their more conventional looking brethren.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/02/2023 01:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Men being uninvolved with child rearing is an issue. Maybe they should be more caring and sharing.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 27/02/2023 01:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So how do you square that with the majority of incels being European and white?

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 27/02/2023 01:47

YANBU I do fear for a whole generation of boys and girls.

Incels are becoming so pervasive on social media that teachers and parents are referring their kids to the prevent programme which is usually for extremist religious ideologies. I ended up on an incel forum, and they were talking about the murder of a 19 year old girl and the things they were writing I wish I hadn't read and I'm not easily shaken.

Boys and young men are being told by people like Tatertot and in incel forums that women gaining rights, speaking up about and against sexism and misogyny is taking rights away from men. I'm seeing a creeping rhetoric that when women speak out against certain things like sexist jokes and about things like feminism, they get accused of being abusive and misandric and of "toxic femininity"

Boys and young men are being told on social media that girls are only good as holes to fuck and basically doing everything a man tells them to do without complaint.

Girls are being told that if they complain about anything then they're misandrists, abusers and displaying toxic femininity.

It's really fucked up, incels are only the tip of the iceberg. It's the Andrew Tates of the world who are shaping how young men view women that I worry about more, because he does it in an accessible, salesman type way. And boys are listening to him.

I don't think I've lived in a time where overt misogyny was so accepted and seemingly defended, it's insidious.

Idkrealorfake · 27/02/2023 01:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Um what are you reading and which podcasts are you listening to?

Are we back to the 80s blaming single mothers for everything adult men do?