Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell off DS for wanting me

63 replies

ToddlerAdvice · 26/02/2023 21:47

Posting in AIBU to try and get a range of responses.

DS is 2.5, and has an incredibly strong preference for me. I think this is partly innate, partly my parenting style, but mostly because my H is not around very much.

We're trying to get DS to accept my husband more, and while he's happy to play with him, he won't accept comfort or care from him if I'm in the house (or sometimes even when I'm not in the house).

Tonight out of the blue, DH came up to bathtime with us and started trying to get DS to undress independently. I supported DH, and then after a while of it not working, I said "let daddy help you get undressed while I fill up your water bottle", to give DH a bit of an opportunity to get involved. DS protested lots, but after reassurance I went downstairs to sort water, and then obviously stayed down to give them some time. I could hear they were getting nowhere, and DS just kept crying and saying he was waiting for me to come back. Next thing I know, DS has opened the stair gate and come downstairs to get me (didn't even know he could open it...). I just said "you didn't want daddy to help you?", he shook his head and I took him back upstairs.

DH's reaction was that I should have told DS off for coming downstairs to get me and not doing as he was told. He then proceeded to tell me it's my fault he and DS have no bond as I breastfed til 21 months and refused to do sleep training. My view is that DH doesn't spend enough time with DS (max 1 hour a day weekdays, maybe 2-3 hours on weekend days), and that's why they don't have a strong bond.

Should I have told DS off? I think it's not a disciplinary issue, but an emotional comfort one, but maybe that's just my approach all over and I'm too soft...

Getting my hard hat on, do your worst vipers.

OP posts:
ToddlerAdvice · 27/02/2023 00:15

The weekend time - I'd say 2-3hrs is an average of what I'd call "proper time" where he's actively engaging with DS and not either asleep or doing his own thing - sometimes it is more, but he's never up before 12 and usually not til later, so I've often gone out with DS, we're not back til later afternoon, before you know it it's dinner and into bedtime

OP posts:
Stopthebusplease · 27/02/2023 00:13

OP can I ask please, does your DH do anything on a regular basis with your DS? If not, then could you perhaps suggest that in order to help build a bond between them, that he takes him to the park on a REGULAR basis. It doesn't have to be at the same time of day each time, but he must take him for example EVERY weekend, and not just cancel because he doesn't feel like it. If the weather is too bad, then he needs to come up with an alternative that they can do together, maybe get on the floor and play something that your DS particularly enjoys, or perhaps take him somewhere like a pet shop where he can look at the fish, rabbits or whatever, but he needs to make it fun, and something that just the two of them do, so that your LO gets used to going places with just Daddy, and they can build from there. Your DH needs to find some fun little things that only he does with your DS, for example, when my child was tiny, my DH started pretending that her teddies talked to her, so he might stand behind the door, and just put teddy round the door, waggling him around, and then saying fun things in a funny voice, LO loved it, and it, and it became one of 'their' things, because Mummy couldn't do it as good as Daddy did. Obviously we don't know if your DH has ever had any experience of playing with young children, but if not, and it doesn't come naturally to him, you might be able to help him by suggesting ideas that he can try. I know that as a young mum I wasn't very good at 'playing' with my LO as I had never had any experience of young children, other than having been one, so felt a bit silly, maybe this is how your DH is? Just a few thoughts which I hope might help.

ToddlerAdvice · 27/02/2023 00:10

I think @Pinkypurplecloud you're on to the balance that we need to strike.

I'd much rather make a plan and stick to it, but he's terrible with making plans. I try to accommodate DH when he feels like / feels brave enough to get involved (he really struggles with the rejection). This is just confusing for DS though and I never know whether I'm best getting back involved or staying out of it.

Equally there are times when we've said DH will do something and then something with work will come up, or he "doesn't feel like doing it tonight" and I haven't held him to it because part of me just thinks "well fuck you, you're losing out". But this has then obviously contributed to the situation we're in now, and probably some subconscious attitude towards DH.

DS goes to nursery 4 days a week and is happy there, so he is looked after by others. We don't have family nearby though, so it's either nursery or us, but being predictable and consistent has got to be the key. At the moment I'm the constant and DH's involvement is a bit random, which is hard on all of us really.

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 27/02/2023 00:09

Have now read your reply
’D’H can’t be arsed to build the bond. To
put the work in. And then blames you.
he could wake up once in a while of a weekend that he would be able to spend more than 2-3h with his son.

he’s a manchild.

and you’re taking control because it’s what’s best for your son?
you have a ‘D’H problem and you’re enabling him by not giving him a kick up the arse. Easier said than done (and done again and again, I know)

Orangepolentacake · 27/02/2023 00:05

Why is he only spending 2-3 hours with your son even on weekends?

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 23:59

FictionalCharacter · 26/02/2023 23:52

In his shoes would you not have made more of an effort than being with your son just 1 hour per weekday and 2-3 hours on weekend days? That’s not parenting.

I take it during the week the husband is at work which is why he only sees the child for an hour. What the reasoning is for 2-3 hours a day at the weekend I don’t know.

MoreSleepPleasee · 26/02/2023 23:57

Yanbu. Your DH hasn't put the work in to form a bond with his child, what does he expect. Your have a husband problem not a child problem. Fuming for you that he dared blame you for him not having a bond with his own child that he lives with though.

ToddlerAdvice · 26/02/2023 23:56

Hit post too soon... going to have a re-read of replies though and come back more

OP posts:
ToddlerAdvice · 26/02/2023 23:54

Thanks all, this is really helpful - I'm glad I've had a mix of supportive and critical comments, as I genuinely do want to see what I could do differently.

Loads of replies, but first things that occur to me -

I didn't even consider the language I used - I was trying to reflect back what DS was feeling, but of course it's just perpetuating something negative. I'll really look at what I'm saying and the lead I'm taking / DS is therefore following.

We've tried before to get DH involved in bedtimes - around 7-8 months ago we were alternating and it was going ok. I can't remember why it stopped, probably a bout of illness, and then DH never picked it up again even though I suggested it.

Similarly have tried me going out on a weekend morning. Issue; DH has insomnia so struggles to sleep / get up in the morning. I do think he could do more to help himself here and/or suck it up, but I found it such a ballache to get him to wake up that I stopped making the effort after a few weeks. I guess I could try again but with afternoons, just... ugh, I do always feel it's me having to make the accommodations. Probably best for DS that I do though.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 26/02/2023 23:52

Singularity82 · 26/02/2023 23:47

@FictionalCharacter i totally disagree. I would have felt undermined in his shoes.

In his shoes would you not have made more of an effort than being with your son just 1 hour per weekday and 2-3 hours on weekend days? That’s not parenting.

Singularity82 · 26/02/2023 23:47

@FictionalCharacter i totally disagree. I would have felt undermined in his shoes.

FictionalCharacter · 26/02/2023 23:45

UsingChangeofName · 26/02/2023 23:23

Yes I found your language very odd. I would have reiterated that daddy is helping him and to go back upstairs, I’d be there shortly. I can see why your partner wouldn’t be happy if you told him that and I’m sure you wouldn’t like to hear it if the shoe were on the other foot

This.
I know it won't go down well on MN, but obviously your breastfeeding so long has meant that he feels he hasn't been given the opportunity to be as close to his ds as he might otherwise. Not clear from your OP with your comment about not being prepared to do sleep training, has meant about his ability to be involved in bed time routine either.
You should acknowledge that is how your dh feels, even if you don't agree with the possibility. You have to accept that this is where you are now - whether you disagree about how you got here, and, if you actually want your dh to be involved then you have to help facilitate that and not put the words into his mouth about "not wanting Daddy". I mean, why on earth would you do that ?

The fact you are putting that about yourself into a post when you are trying to make your dh seem bad then also makes me wonder how much of the same is going on sub consciously all the time.

Firstly Daddy wasn’t helping him. Secondly, the father only sees his child for an hour each weekday and 2-3 hours at weekends. How is his failure to be there almost all the time the fault of the mother breastfeeding? He spends no more time with his child than some visitors would!

FictionalCharacter · 26/02/2023 23:42

Singularity82 · 26/02/2023 23:01

Agree with this. Poor choice of language and I can see why your husband felt undermined and pushed aside by you.
his blaming you breastfeeding is silly though. And I wouldnt tell your son off at this age but I would be supporting and promoting a stronger relationship with dad.

She did not say this, she said “You don’t want Daddy to help you?” Which is completely different.
And Daddy wasn’t helping him. He was trying to get his 2.5 year old son, whom be barely sees and never baths, to get undressed independently. Very odd thing to do and suggests that the father has no idea of his son’s stage of development and what he is or isn’t capable of.
She didn’t undermine her husband at all, let alone push him aside. She left the father to it and he messed up. He let the toddler walk away from him, open the stair gate and go to her, then blamed her!

Pinkypurplecloud · 26/02/2023 23:26

It’s normal for a toddler to prefer one parent, but unless a child was really sick or something then mine were not allowed to chose or have favourites (we have certain things they do with a particular parent that’s their “thing”, but not ordinary day to day care). If DH and I agreed DH was doing bath time then that was that. If Mummy was doing bedtime that night then no amount of carrying on led to Daddy taking over. Our children have two competent parents, they don’t usually get to pick which one does what. And sometimes they don’t get either of us, they get Grandma or Aunty or a babysitter and I expect them to deal with that too!

Yes, your DH needs to spend time with his child, but it’s a vicious circle because of course he doesn’t know your son so well or how to do bath time, but he’s not going to learn if you let your toddler dictate things and he never gets that time. I wouldn’t have told your son off, but I would have told him that Daddy was helping him and returned him to Daddy. An hour and day and more on weekends is hardly so little time your son doesn’t know your DH and being helped to have a bath is hardly an emotional thing like eg which parent takes him to hospital.

UsingChangeofName · 26/02/2023 23:23

Yes I found your language very odd. I would have reiterated that daddy is helping him and to go back upstairs, I’d be there shortly. I can see why your partner wouldn’t be happy if you told him that and I’m sure you wouldn’t like to hear it if the shoe were on the other foot

This.
I know it won't go down well on MN, but obviously your breastfeeding so long has meant that he feels he hasn't been given the opportunity to be as close to his ds as he might otherwise. Not clear from your OP with your comment about not being prepared to do sleep training, has meant about his ability to be involved in bed time routine either.
You should acknowledge that is how your dh feels, even if you don't agree with the possibility. You have to accept that this is where you are now - whether you disagree about how you got here, and, if you actually want your dh to be involved then you have to help facilitate that and not put the words into his mouth about "not wanting Daddy". I mean, why on earth would you do that ?

The fact you are putting that about yourself into a post when you are trying to make your dh seem bad then also makes me wonder how much of the same is going on sub consciously all the time.

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 23:08

Singularity82 · 26/02/2023 23:01

Agree with this. Poor choice of language and I can see why your husband felt undermined and pushed aside by you.
his blaming you breastfeeding is silly though. And I wouldnt tell your son off at this age but I would be supporting and promoting a stronger relationship with dad.

Yes I found your language very odd. I would have reiterated that daddy is helping him and to go back upstairs, I’d be there shortly. I can see why your partner wouldn’t be happy if you told him that and I’m sure you wouldn’t like to hear it if the shoe were on the other foot. However he needs to be doing more with the child in any event. It’s normal for a toddler to favour one parent over the other, who knows OP he could favour your husband in a few months time.

Singularity82 · 26/02/2023 23:01

Onesipmore · 26/02/2023 22:23

Why would you say, you don't want Daddy?

Agree with this. Poor choice of language and I can see why your husband felt undermined and pushed aside by you.
his blaming you breastfeeding is silly though. And I wouldnt tell your son off at this age but I would be supporting and promoting a stronger relationship with dad.

UWhatNow · 26/02/2023 22:57

Merryoldgoat · 26/02/2023 22:53

I think your DS is not doing anything wrong but you are not going to encourage a stronger bond unless you back off and leave dad completely to it - tantrums and all.

I completely disagree with this. You don’t encourage a bond with someone else by taking away the safety and warmth he’s used to.

Dad needs to actually build the relationship up independently and then the rest comes naturally.

Rubbish. If mum were suddenly not around (say a week in hospital or something) the son would miss his mum yes, but he’d automatically fall in with his dad. He’s not a stranger! He’s a parent and a familiar presence from birth.

Merryoldgoat · 26/02/2023 22:57

From our first night home when I was still attempting to bf DH would get up, change the baby and bring him to me for feeding and then wind him (I’d had a very complicated CS and was very weak).

Once we moved to formula it was always shared. He took 6 weeks off after the birth, he takes holiday to cover school holidays, stays home from work when they’re sick, all the stuff that builds those foundations.

Our boys would settle for either of us from the very start.

Housefullofcatsandkids · 26/02/2023 22:54

Given from what you've said he hardly sees him so I'm not surprised he doesn't have a strong bond. If this was the first time your husband had come up to help with bath time I'd have stayed in there for comfort and just have your husband play with him in the bath alongside you and build up that bond. Do note stuff together instead of him taking over. If every time your husband is trying to build a relationship, you leave them alone, your son will associate the two...spending time with daddy means mummy leaves the room. That will only make bonding harder.

Merryoldgoat · 26/02/2023 22:53

I think your DS is not doing anything wrong but you are not going to encourage a stronger bond unless you back off and leave dad completely to it - tantrums and all.

I completely disagree with this. You don’t encourage a bond with someone else by taking away the safety and warmth he’s used to.

Dad needs to actually build the relationship up independently and then the rest comes naturally.

Merryoldgoat · 26/02/2023 22:50

You reap what you sow.

He hasn’t put in the work and now he’s seeing the result.

You don’t tell him off for seeking the only attachment he has. Your husband needs to build a bond with him.

Crunchingleaf · 26/02/2023 22:46

YANBU its normal for a toddler to prefer mom. It generally changes once they get bigger, but care tasks a very important in forming the attachment to the parent aka the caregiver.
Our toddler is a daddy’s boy especially since we brought the newborn home, but in this house daddy does things like bedtime, bath times, gets up with him at weekends, comforts him when he is sick. Apart from breastfeeding DH has been a very equal parent to DS. When I went to hospital to have our 4 week old the toddler wasn’t put out by not having me around as he was used to daddy looking after him.
Be prepared to be blamed for lack of bond between the two of them as there is always posters that will blame the woman when the man can’t step up and do what needs to be done.

feelinglikeanewparent · 26/02/2023 22:45

It's your fault your DH and DS have no bond 😂

Your DH needs to grow up and start being a parent. His way of doing things doesn't work for your DS and so he needs to adapt and stop looking for other places to lay the blame.

Failing that I'd be telling him to fuck off.

UWhatNow · 26/02/2023 22:27

I think your DS is not doing anything wrong but you are not going to encourage a stronger bond unless you back off and leave dad completely to it - tantrums and all. So whilst I wouldn’t have told him off, I would have (in a sing songy lovely voice) taken him back up to his dad and said ‘no Billy… daddy is getting you ready for bathtime.’
And left them to it

You can’t let a 2.5 year old’s emotions dictate your parenting choices. The sooner and clearer he is told in uncertain terms it’s daddy or nothing he’ll stop fussing.