Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stand up for DD?

33 replies

Itslookinggood · 26/02/2023 20:28

Just got off plane with DD (17). We were a bit late arriving, and large man opposite pushed into the aisle, put on backpack and pushed DD, who was standing, right back against her seat, backpack in her face.

I saw DD pinned to her seat and told her to ask the man to move. She wouldn't, so I tapped him on the arm, and politely pointed out what he was doing. He apologised and moved.

DD furious with me. I had overstepped, in her view. In mine, she was being a wet blanket & should have been more assertive.

So WIBU to step forward and intervene? Back story is that DD is a real people pleaser and I do find it frustrating.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UdoU · 27/02/2023 13:57

DiddyHeck · 26/02/2023 20:33

Quite clearly and obviously you weren't being unreasonable

But on the subject of 'wet blankets', why are you looking to strangers to reassure you that you did the right thing?

He didn't realise the backpack was bothering her, you politely told him it was, he politely moved.

Why are you even still thinking about this non event after it happened?

What is it with people constantly asking OP's why they are posting on MN?

Why are you even on this thread if you think she shouldn't be posting? Go find another thread.

ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 27/02/2023 13:35

Itslookinggood · 26/02/2023 21:11

I did not call her a wet blanket. I would never say that to her. But I did think it.

Oh she knows you think it, don’t you worry about that. Have a quiet (non judgmental) word with your DD about assertiveness at home by all means, but do not show her up in public, she will hate you for it.

BleepBipBoop · 27/02/2023 12:46

Sarahcoggles · 27/02/2023 00:18

Both my teens (17 and 13) beg me to never ever ever say anything in the face of unfair treatment. It drives me mad. But apparently it's really embarrassing.

Are you talking about the two posters who have discussed their own children? I haven’t seen anyone claim the “wet blanket” thing applies any more widely than that. But even if someone did we all know obviously that these are generalizations and don’t apply to every single person born in the same few decades. None of us has enough evidence to make objective statements about an entire generation of people but the human brain craves patterns and categories. People form their opinion based on their own limited experience and worldview, then it is amplified by social and mainstream media so it becomes “a thing” and other people are more likely to notice examples that confirm it. It’s silly enough when it’s widespread but you are trying to argue with what appears to be two individual strangers about something they didn’t even say.

BleepBipBoop · 27/02/2023 12:27

DiddyHeck · 26/02/2023 20:33

Quite clearly and obviously you weren't being unreasonable

But on the subject of 'wet blankets', why are you looking to strangers to reassure you that you did the right thing?

He didn't realise the backpack was bothering her, you politely told him it was, he politely moved.

Why are you even still thinking about this non event after it happened?

She’s thinking about it because her daughter is furious with her. Asking strangers for their opinions about interpersonal situations is literally the reason why AIBU exists.

AmandaClare · 27/02/2023 11:42

People with backpacks are almost always completely unaware of their impact on others. Don't think it's a M/F thing.

I think you did overstep. Your daughter is her own person and can choose for herself how to react to things like this. I also think it's very easy to forget how one was oneself at a particular age- you think that 17yo you would have reacted differently but you have no way of knowing this as you see your past self through the prism of your present self.

If you want your daughter to develop confidence, stop overriding her decisions.

Onnabugeisha · 27/02/2023 11:34

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 26/02/2023 23:35

The thing is , by overstepping and always telling/showing her that she is wrong /why she is wrong, you're not teaching her to stand up for herself and speak up. It's just extra (even if only implied) criticism and pressure to conform to someone else's rules/standards.

Exactly this OP and even though you aren’t calling her a wet blanket, push over, people please to her face, it’s most probably very evident that you hold this contempt for her decisions and why you bulldoze her & overrule her when she says no.

user1492757084 · 27/02/2023 03:41

Small first world issue. Man did not mean it. Daughter was not that impeeded so chose to put up with it for a few minutes. You tried to be helpful to DD, though you had asked and she had said - it's fine. You should have listened to DD. She is allowed to have her voice and to have it respected. Let her practise her power and speak for herself - she will not always assess things like you.
Shake hands and move on. DD reacted like I would have. I am not a pushover and I would have alerted man had I not been able to tolerate situation.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 02:06

Summerfun54321 · 27/02/2023 00:45

Your job as a parent isn't to save your child from embarrassment. It's to model behaviour you want to see. And if you want to see her sticking up for herself then keep doing what you are doing.

Do you ever see the endless threads on here by 50 something middle managers that are peeved their younger reports are sticking up for themselves lol

Sarahcoggles · 27/02/2023 00:45

@GothicViolence I can't speak for others, but my kids are of an age to talk about "Karens" (which I hate), and they think that any middle aged woman making a fuss is just embarrassing.

Summerfun54321 · 27/02/2023 00:45

Your job as a parent isn't to save your child from embarrassment. It's to model behaviour you want to see. And if you want to see her sticking up for herself then keep doing what you are doing.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 00:22

Sarahcoggles · 27/02/2023 00:18

Both my teens (17 and 13) beg me to never ever ever say anything in the face of unfair treatment. It drives me mad. But apparently it's really embarrassing.

It’s quite interesting that the common opinion on mumsnet is that millennials and gen Z are “snowflakes” “entitled” etc, but at the sametime are also “wet blankets” for not immediately getting aerated about the same trivia that their mothers do. Which one is it guys?

Sarahcoggles · 27/02/2023 00:18

Both my teens (17 and 13) beg me to never ever ever say anything in the face of unfair treatment. It drives me mad. But apparently it's really embarrassing.

UWhatNow · 27/02/2023 00:14

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 00:04

I wonder if your daughter is a “wet blanket” because she’s had a lifetime of dealing with situations caused by you being “assertive” over complete non-issues like the one in your OP

It wasn’t a non issue. Some thoughtless oaf was forcing the dd back uncomfortably into a seat with his big backpack.

I don’t think many older women would’ve passively stood by and let their dd endure that. Just because her dd is 17 and old enough to speak for herself, doesn’t mean she has the confidence and life experience to let blokes know they’re being inconsiderate.

There was a thread on MN just the other day about men expecting to take up the room on a pavement and expecting women to automatically make way. So many posters commented how oblivious they were to this male entitlement as young women but how infuriated they were with it once they were older and wiser…

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 00:04

I wonder if your daughter is a “wet blanket” because she’s had a lifetime of dealing with situations caused by you being “assertive” over complete non-issues like the one in your OP

Doormatnomore · 26/02/2023 23:47

I have no problem being assertive and neither does my dm BUT we have totally different ideas about when to use it. Anyone walks in front of her to get through a door is going to get a speech about her not being invisible, I don’t care as long as we’re moving. Someone is rude is going to get a “who do you think you’re talking to?” from me, which makes mum want to curl up and die. It’s all about perceptions, one persons assertive is another’s making a scene, at 17 unless something is actually dangerous I think she probably gets to decide for herself.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 26/02/2023 23:35

The thing is , by overstepping and always telling/showing her that she is wrong /why she is wrong, you're not teaching her to stand up for herself and speak up. It's just extra (even if only implied) criticism and pressure to conform to someone else's rules/standards.

Meloncholie · 26/02/2023 22:53

DiddyHeck · 26/02/2023 20:33

Quite clearly and obviously you weren't being unreasonable

But on the subject of 'wet blankets', why are you looking to strangers to reassure you that you did the right thing?

He didn't realise the backpack was bothering her, you politely told him it was, he politely moved.

Why are you even still thinking about this non event after it happened?

This

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 26/02/2023 22:48

My dd would act the same

It's a teen 17 to thing.

Weatherwax13 · 26/02/2023 22:32

I would've done same as you OP. Your DD has reacted to you out of that dreaded teenage embarrassment. She'd rather be squished than "cause a scene"
I think you were setting a good example . Someone invading her space is not something she needs to put up with and that using her voice is actually acceptable. Lack of confidence is such a curse for young women isn't it?

Itslookinggood · 26/02/2023 22:15

Hmm a real mix of views.

Thanks all. I will try to step back next time.

Tiger mother in me took over. But it's heartening to hear that some of you have experienced similar.

OP posts:
MomOfTwoGirls2 · 26/02/2023 21:53

My DDs are 2-3 years older. They get SO cross with me for ‘making a fuss’.

Yesterday we were at a museum and I didn’t notice exhortation price of a piece of lemon drizzle cake until I purchased it. I declared to DD2 that if it wasn’t a fresh slice I would be returning it.

The level of disgust DD2 has for that comment!!

Thankfully the cake was nice enough so I didn’t need to take further action.
I was thinking I was a wimp for buying it once presented with the bill and not telling them to put it back at that price. But I would have acted if it wasn’t good quality.

I am hoping they grow out of it by mid twenties..

lailamaria · 26/02/2023 21:19

all you did was make her feel embarrassed, it's not up to you to judge how she approaches conflict 'my generation fought very hard against sexism' you're hardly a suffragette every generation of women has fought against sexism, she's 17 i wouldn't want to engage in conflict with an adult man either, she could have ended up being sworn at or spit on, it doesn't matter if you were there or not, she didn't ask for your help she's 17 not 7

WandaWonder · 26/02/2023 21:15

It is up to her how it was handled, if she was a baby of course you should step in

JudgeRudy · 26/02/2023 21:13

Itslookinggood · 26/02/2023 20:28

Just got off plane with DD (17). We were a bit late arriving, and large man opposite pushed into the aisle, put on backpack and pushed DD, who was standing, right back against her seat, backpack in her face.

I saw DD pinned to her seat and told her to ask the man to move. She wouldn't, so I tapped him on the arm, and politely pointed out what he was doing. He apologised and moved.

DD furious with me. I had overstepped, in her view. In mine, she was being a wet blanket & should have been more assertive.

So WIBU to step forward and intervene? Back story is that DD is a real people pleaser and I do find it frustrating.

You were unreasonable to override your daughter's wishes. I'd be furious. She really didn't want to make a fuss. She definitely didn't want you acting on her behalf. She didn't need protecting or defending.
You've essentially told her her feelings are invalid. You've done much worse than Mr Careless

Itslookinggood · 26/02/2023 21:11

I did not call her a wet blanket. I would never say that to her. But I did think it.

OP posts: