Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you approach this situation? Re childcare

35 replies

majormumma · 26/02/2023 14:06

DH works full time, covers all bills, self employed in manual type job, very physically demanding - no wfh
I work PT, 23 hours, my pay covers childcare / bits for kids - wfh/ office split
this is not working.
DH believes that when DC are sick it is 100% my job to provide childcare, his argument… he can’t pay mortgage if he takes time off. I don’t feel I can argue with that despite me offering to make up difference.
My job is seen as extra income but not “necessary” as doesn’t pay for bills etc
Many arguments, much disagreement not really any further in this. I have no friends with kids, mum is no longer with us, my dad is in agreement with DH. I read multiple threads about this type of thing on MN but as everyone situation differs I wanted to talk to mums/ dads in similar position. How do you work it out?
we’ve spoken about me getting an evening job, I’m not willing to do this and my reasons are that I would be exhausted. DH wasn’t thrilled by this.
envious of all the women who’s husband is around in the week.
im not happy, countless conversations not moving forward. DC 5&2. To think this is enough to split? DH is helpful when home, present, does necessary jobs. Lacks initiative though. All mental load is on me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Needanewnamebeingwatched · 26/02/2023 16:33

Your married, I really don't understand this whole I pay for xy and z husband pays for j t and f

All the money should go in one pop, bills, food, kids needs including childcare come out of that and you each get an equal portion to spend.

I would go back to work full time and he can do 50/50 housework and mental load. Plus 50/50 children's needs.

Headabovetheparakeet · 26/02/2023 16:32

We base it on three things:

  1. Who has the most flexibility with work that day?
  2. Can we avoid losing a day's pay? (One if us is employed and one is SE)
  3. Has one of us already had to take a day recently?
cadburyegg · 26/02/2023 16:26

So as you work 23 hours a week - is that over 3 days? You can do something like this if child is off sick for a whole week.
Day 1 you're not working so you look after sick child.
Day 2 you're wfh so you look after sick child.
Day 3 you're in the office so your DH looks after sick child.
Day 4 you're back wfh so you look after sick child.
Day 5 you're not working so you look after sick child.

That's still only 1 day out of 5 that your DH has to take off

RegardingMary · 26/02/2023 16:24

We split it 50/50 here.

CatOnTheChair · 26/02/2023 16:10

Totally, completely and utterly unfair on your employer to shoulder 100% of sick leave.
Assuming your hours arent 5 days a week, your DHs employer already has it good as you only work PT. You need to split any sickness on your days evenly - and you cover 100% on days you are off.

The way your household works for money shouldn't affect how much childhood sickness your employer has to deal with.
I know this is idealistic when not working means no pay, but it is another reason young females are not prioritized at work - because they phone up for days off at minimal notice for ill kids.

budgiegirl · 26/02/2023 16:04

I agree with your husband......the one who pays the mortgage and bills works whilst the one who's job is flexible looks after I'll DC. Makes financial sense to do it that way! In my sil and bil case he looks after DC as sil is the higher earner...

You are falling in to the trap of assuming that the lower paid/part time job is more flexible. It may not be. In my first office job, the entry level/part time workers had set hours, but the higher paid, managerial jobs had much more flexible working hours. It would have been much easier for my boss to take time off to look after sick kids than it would have been for me.

Either way, it's only fair for each parent to pick up their share of childcare, or for the one with the more flexible job to do so, regardless of hours/pay. It's not fair of the DH to say that the OP should do it, just because he 'pays the mortgage'. They both contribute to the household income, so that's immaterial.

thaisweetchill · 26/02/2023 15:48

My situation is practically the same although we are 70/30 on bills.

My partner works self employed so if he doesn't work = doesn't get paid. If my DS is sick childcare will fall to me as really I can't expect him to take a day off unpaid when I can take a day off paid?

Not saying your unreasonable I understand your frustration as I do feel I am the 'default' parent from a practical view I am the person who has to take the hit.

Kickmeupthearse · 26/02/2023 15:40

Dont quit because if your DH is sick or injured - he won't be able to work and you'll have to go FT.

He's being an asshole. He'll be begging for you to work if he broke his leg!

Lolacat1234 · 26/02/2023 15:32

Usually I agree it should be a team work deal in situations like this, but he's self employed, you can take an emergency day if you're employed, I take it if he doesn't work for a day he doesn't get paid? It's shit but if that's the case I see his point. My OH used to be self employed and it always came down to me to pick up the slack with that sort of thing, now he's employed its probably more 70/30, still majority is me but he sometimes comes home early so I can cover some extra hours I've lost in the afternoon early evening.

aloris · 26/02/2023 15:21

I think what matters is the underlying approach to power and control and how you fare in that negotiation. In most employment situations, the worker taking unscheduled time off (to care for sick kids) will eventually cause problems, whether the worker is part-time or full-time. The employer of a part-time person presumably needs that person present during their scheduled hours, even if the total weekly hours are not full time. Just because your husband earns more money does not mean that you taking off unscheduled time for sick kids won't impact your employment.

So what he is really saying is that: it is acceptable if you lose your job because of taking so many sick days to look after the kids.

So is it? It may be acceptable to him, but is it acceptable to you?

It sounds like you are already in a situation where your time and effort are not valued because your on-the-books income is lower than his. Is your "in kind" contribution of childcare valued? Or is it just treated as "Oh well you're home you'd have to look after them anyway." Is the care of your children treated as a nice hobby that is just yours, rather than a moral obligation that is half the responsibility of each of you? The fact that your salary "pays for childcare" and "bits" suggests the former. Try thinking of it differently. How much would it cost to buy your services on the open market? The best comparator for your services isn't a babysitter or a childminder. It's a nanny. And actually a mum does more than a nanny because a nanny probably won't deep clean the toilet while also watching a child. Your work is valuable and would cost a lot to replace!

If you lose your job due to taking too many sick days, you will become completely financially dependent on him. How do you think that would go? Would he be respectful? Would the earned money be just as much yours as hiis? Remember, if you quit, it would be SPECIFICALLY because he wants to keep his earning power and does not want to compromise that for sick days. So even if you never earn another penny, it would be YOUR childcare that allows him to maintain and increase his earning power, and it would be HIS refusal to participate in his half of the childcare that prevented you earning your own income. Would he recognise that? Or would he just come to see you as a bon-bon-eating deadweight? Will he be willing to equally share any disposable income on your needs and wants as much as his own? Or will you be watching him go on nights out with his buddies while you can't afford to get a haircut or a new coat? Will he even recognise that you have needs? Or will he dismiss your claims that you need him to babysit so you can see a doctor as "Oh you're not that sick, you'll be fine."

Remember that this can change slowly over time. The man who initially seems to divide things fairly may come to see you as a deadweight when you are both older and he has increased his income to a high and stable level, whereas if you've been out of work for a decade and can only get a minimum wage job, he may think of you as only being "worth" minimum wage in the relationship. Even though that change in your earning potential was a direct result of, again, leaving the job market not out of laziness but because he wanted to grow HIS career and didn't care about yours.

Only you can make the best estimate as to the answers to those questions. But I think him wanting you to quit is not a good sign. Just my opinion.

budgiegirl · 26/02/2023 15:12

I think it's more who's employer and type of work is more flexible

This. What does it matter who pays what? Between you, you cover bills/mortgage/childcare. It's not just your responsibility to cover the childcare costs just because you're a woman/part time.

Looking after the kids when sick is a joint responsibility too. So you should take it in turns, or arrange this according to the parent who's job is most flexible. It shouldn't fall to you by default, just because you work less hours.

DH wants me to quit, I enjoy working

Don't quit to please him - by the sounds of it, he just wants you to quit to make his life easier.

kitsuneghost · 26/02/2023 15:04

What did you agree when you planned for kids? Did he say he would do 50:50 sick days? Has his job changed since then?

Bleese · 26/02/2023 15:03

I agree it's bit reasonable for your employer. I worked in retail and there were a lot of women who'd take loads of unpaid time off when their children were sick because their husbands had the big jobs. That wasn't really the retailers' problem though - it needed those workers in just as much as the husbands' employers needed them in.

RE the evening job, you'd be working 23 hours + presumably the rest of the 9-5 week doing childcare but have to work again in the evening? How is that fair?

monomatapea · 26/02/2023 15:03

I understand his point of view but no you shouldn't give up your job if you like it and no you shouldn't be the only one covering sickness. I am not surprised your employer is getting fed up. You already work less so the time you aren't working is spent looking after the children.

If anything I would argue he needs to be doing the same or more childcare than you when they are off sick. If I were your employer that is what I'd expect now I had let you know it was becoming interfering with your position.

NumberTheory · 26/02/2023 15:01

You do have to balance the books now. You talk about what your incomes pay for rather than how much they are. What percentage of the family pot do you bring in working 23 hours a week? And what percentage does DH bring in? (And how many hours a week is he working to do that?)

If he worked less so that you can work more, what would that really look like in terms of income? Could you make it up? Would you need to downgrade your lifestyle? Would that downgrade be temporary until your career took off more and/or the kids are back in school. And would you be okay with that, or do you really want the lifestyle DH’s company allows?

I think you need to be clear in your own mind what you’re really asking for from him and what you’re proposing to do. If he’s worked hard to develop a business that makes good money and you’ve been in minimum wage jobs without any plan for improving your prospects, but have enjoyed a better lifestyle because of his wage, I can see why jeopardizing that so you can go into work might seem unreasonable.

But if you’re earning lower than him because you’re just at the beginning of your career and he’s expecting you to jeopardize your earning potential so he can keep his earning potential, he’s being very unreasonable.

But you both need to sit down and talk about what sort of life you want, how to share the income generation and childcare fairly, with an eye on the future not just the now.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/02/2023 15:01

majormumma · 26/02/2023 14:56

Thanks all v helpful
agree that we should utilise joint account better, the way the money is split isn’t right.
My employer is losing patience with me, they are relatively flexible but the way my hours are means I can pick up hours in the evening from when kids are in bed 8-10 but as my role involves lots of collaboration it doesn’t always work. DH wants me to quit, I enjoy working.

Please don't quit if you don't want to, OP. It isn't your DH's decision.

I don't blame your employer for being annoyed either. I have been the employer in that situation and it's very frustrating to employ someone who has decided that their partner's job is more important than their own.

cadburyegg · 26/02/2023 15:00

If your employer is getting fed up then your dh definitely needs to step up. Your job matters too. Your dh wants you to quit because then he won't have to shoulder any responsibility for the children at all Hmm

DistantSkye · 26/02/2023 14:58

I think the problem goes deeper than childcare by the sounds of it - the idea that your 23 hours a week doesn't count seems really dismissive. Why doesn't it count? Is it super low paid? Because surely it's all household income so it counts just as much towards mortgage/bills as your husbands salary?
Also you taking on the mental load and being isolated. Does your husband make you feel valued/happy?

All that aside, what we do is the one with more flexibility takes the time off.
For instance my husband is the higher earner but can WFH where as I cant, as school staff. I am PT and do have a non teaching remit for some of my week so I can use those days/hours if the kids are sick, and on my teaching days DH takes annual leave or WFH. But the crucial difference is I don't bear the whole mental load and he doesn't think the kids are just my job. We're a team.

majormumma · 26/02/2023 14:56

Thanks all v helpful
agree that we should utilise joint account better, the way the money is split isn’t right.
My employer is losing patience with me, they are relatively flexible but the way my hours are means I can pick up hours in the evening from when kids are in bed 8-10 but as my role involves lots of collaboration it doesn’t always work. DH wants me to quit, I enjoy working.

OP posts:
cadburyegg · 26/02/2023 14:55

I agree that your setup is part of the problem - he pays for mortgage while you pay for kid related stuff.

A more reasonable split would look like -
When you're wfh then you look after sick kids.
When you're office based you take it in turns. So if you're in the office 2 days a week then you take one day each.
If you're ill or you have something important like an interview etc he needs to step up also.
In theory, then he would really only be needed on a few occasions.

DorotheaHomeAlone · 26/02/2023 14:54

I’m really surprised that capo many people agree that your DH has no responsibility to care for his own DC when they are sick. We’re not dissimilar to you in that i work pt and DH significantly outearns me. But we split any illness days when both of us are working 50:50.

I think the way that you’re presenting this might play into perceptions here and at home. Why does your wage cover childcare but his covers bills? Those are both big spends that you’re both responsible for. What if you covered bills and your contribution to childcare was your non work days? What if he covered childcare costs because he can’t look after them himself those days? Would that make your contribution to the family more obvious?

He is a parent. Childcare is not just your responsibility. He should be picking up his share of emergency cover when needed. It’s not fair to you or your employer that it all falls on you.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/02/2023 14:53

Whataretheodds · 26/02/2023 14:48

my pay covers childcare/ bits for the kids

This mindset is part of the problem. Why are you not both paying a share of childcare and bits for the kids.
Can you go FT?

Well, yes, I agree, but equally, why aren't they both paying a share of the bills?

londonrach · 26/02/2023 14:50

I agree with your husband......the one who pays the mortgage and bills works whilst the one who's job is flexible looks after I'll DC. Makes financial sense to do it that way! In my sil and bil case he looks after DC as sil is the higher earner...

Whataretheodds · 26/02/2023 14:48

my pay covers childcare/ bits for the kids

This mindset is part of the problem. Why are you not both paying a share of childcare and bits for the kids.
Can you go FT?

mybunniesandme · 26/02/2023 14:44

I agree with your husband

And to be honest when you say you'd be too tired to get an evening job don't you think He is exhausted working a full time manual job and also carrying the financial responsibility for the family?

Swipe left for the next trending thread