Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eldest Child and In-Law Wedding

333 replies

StarbucksSally · 26/02/2023 13:31

Brother-in-law split up with a long-term Partner at the beginning of the pandemic because of his unwillingness to get married. I think he was shocked that she left.

He is now marrying someone else. She seems a lovely woman; but consensus is he is marrying her as he doesn’t want to lose her.

DH is best man but children were not invited. MiL went batshit and I was upset. I think DH had his ego bruised that the kids weren’t invited. I said nothing and while I was upset thought it was their wedding.

They had a site that they signed up to and the bios of the wedding party were on and lo and behold there were a flower girl and ring bearer.

DH and MiL spoke to BiL and he seemed scared to rock the boat but on Friday invitations arrived for our youngest children that I share with DH. My eldest who is 12 is not included. MiL is not willing to intervene and DH spoke with BiL who absolutely won’t as bride.

DH has asked me to ask their dad to have her.

I am going to decline wedding. DH refuses point blank to let me decline for all the children. He wants his children there and thinks we will look stupid anyway if we now decline their invitations after all the fuss.

OP posts:
rowanoak · 27/02/2023 05:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

rowanoak · 27/02/2023 05:30

I feel so bad for your poor daughter! Your husband is not treating her the same as your other children and you aren't standing up for her or protecting her from this favoritism that is really damaging. You are setting her up for a lifetime of psychological damage and you are proudly stating that you're choosing your awful husband over her. Excuse me while I go vomit at you putting a man before your own child and then go cry for her because you don't care enough about her to show her that you wouldn't put up with ANYONE, not even your own husband, treating her so poorly.

user1492757084 · 27/02/2023 05:12

New idea! All get dressed up and all attend wedding. Let your older daughter attend the reception in your place while you have a migraine..
Your children will be happy and you can easily enjoy a night off. Don't tell her about being excluded from the invitations

user1492757084 · 27/02/2023 04:38

It is not fair to expect the 12 year old to carry a grudge against a family that she sees as hers. Most people love her.

Complaining about the exclusion of children was not right.
Then only two small kids got an invite.
So a small problem then a bigger problem.
If I were you I'd still have accepted the invitations and prepared very happily. I'd have taken all three of your children to the wedding but carefully had another event for all your children to attend during the reception. All the same.
The bride and groom possibly would understand and there would be no cost to them for extra catering.

CallItLoneliness · 27/02/2023 04:19

I've been the eldest child. You can delude yourself it is all fine, but you are setting her up for a life where she feels less-than. If you're ok with that, crack on, but don't act hurt when as an adult she withdraws from you.

falsepromises · 27/02/2023 02:27

I would spend the day with your daughter shopping or at the cinema, whatever she likes to do. Enjoy the time with her. However in future I would make it clear they were not her family. If she has an event they aren't invited. Her wedding - not invited. They are not her family. I don't see the issue with this if its how they want it. As long as its clear to her she wont get hurt.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 27/02/2023 01:05

yanbu to be miffed but ultimately it's their wedding and if they don't want any particular individual there it's fine for them to to invite that person but that's then a very clear statement about how much relationship they want with that person. so, fine, your eldest is firmly rejected. tells you what you need to know for any future contact. I agree with pp take your eldest out for a fab cinema and pizza day, just the two of you having some great 1:1 time, and let the others go to the wedding.

MIL and DH will obviously have to tag-team childcare of the younger kids between them, according to which of them have official wedding party duties at any given time. With any luck they will both regret their attitude by the time it's all over.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/02/2023 00:42

And sorry @Crazycrazylady, the first half of my post was directed at you but the second half wasn't... you've already acknowledged that you think it was mean to exclude one dc, regardless of how you might feel towards kids who aren't related to you. .

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 27/02/2023 00:39

Crazycrazylady · 26/02/2023 22:18

I think they're incredibly mean to exclude one child but having said that I don't always agree with the premise that's here on mumsnet that step nephews and nieces and step grandkids should be treated the exact same way as biological kids.by extended family. If my sibling remarried in the morning to someone with a child, I of course would be kind and nice to an innocent child but I would not feel the same way about them as my own biological nieces/nephews. They would ultimately be the child of my siblings partner. Things like a grandmother wanting a photo with her actual grandchildren would not bother me and I would not expect a step gran child to be automatically included. I think it's better to be honest with child about this than the slightly unrealistic expectation that her steps aunts uncles grandparents feel the exact same way about her as their siblings. I'd focus on her relationships with her own biological grandparents etc as they are far more likely to be real and lasting than 'forced' ones.

Out of interest, would you feel the same about adopted nieces, nephews or grandchildren? Ie, if the child isn't biologically related, you're not really interested?

Personally, I find that hard to understand, but then, maybe the blood relation thing just doesn't matter as much to me. I am as fond of my DH's nephews and nieces as I am off my sister's dc. They are all part of my family and I don't really distinguish between them.

Of course, you can't tell people what to feel, so if they aren't interested in step children who aren't directly related to them, then fair enough. They feel whatever they feel, and that's fine. However, regardless of what they might feel privately, I think it's unforgivable to openly exclude a child because you don't care about them as much. Wouldn't any halfway decent person just try their best to be kind, inclusive and fair to all of the children in their extended family? These are children who have no say in the composition of their families or who their parents decide to shack up with. Feel what you feel, by all means, but that doesn't mean that you have to make your feelings so obvious. What real harm would it do to include an extra child in a family photo? To add one child to the invitation list?

I would never make my child live in a blended family if there was even a hint of this kind of attitude. She deserves better.

journeyofinsanity · 26/02/2023 23:05

Equal

journeyofinsanity · 26/02/2023 23:05

OP I realise you are all trying your best but look at it this way. If your DH really thought of your dd as equal he would kick up a stink. Imagine if all 3 were his bio children and one was excluded. How would he react. He is not reacting the way he would if one of his bio dc was excluded so he isn't treating her as ewy

ImAvingOops · 26/02/2023 23:03

And actually yes, pp is right - you have colluded in this too and have exposed your child to a family life where she is lesser

ImAvingOops · 26/02/2023 23:01

You have a husband who will put the wishes of his mum/brother above the wishes she's of his wife. You don't want any of your kids to attend but your husband has basically said fuck you, he's doing it regardless of how you feel. And he's okay with throwing your daughter under the bus if necessary.

He can't force his family to love her, but he should love her enough to not see her excluded and treated differently.

I don't think I could (or want to) forgive this. Bil is a twat but your husband is worse for allowing it.

Puppers · 26/02/2023 22:25

Your poor, poor daughter. Your comments have been heartbreaking to read. You are lying to yourself when you say you wouldn't put a man before her. That's exactly what you are doing. It's all very well pointing the finger at your husband's family and criticising your husband (who absolutely doesn't treat your daughter the same as his biological children and happily props up his family's mistreatment of her) but at this point you are colluding in the way she is treated. You allow it. You are failing to protect her from it.

I don't know how any parent could describe their marriage as “happy” when it facilitates this kind of treatment of their own child. Appalling.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 26/02/2023 22:24

SaySomethingMan · 26/02/2023 19:01

calm, sensible post

Absolutely agree. None of this would have come to the fore if no-one had meddled in pushing for child invites. All the drama has only served to highlight the difference for everyone involved.

Sometimes it’s better to let sleeping dogs lie, especially in blended situations.

Crazycrazylady · 26/02/2023 22:18

I think they're incredibly mean to exclude one child but having said that I don't always agree with the premise that's here on mumsnet that step nephews and nieces and step grandkids should be treated the exact same way as biological kids.by extended family. If my sibling remarried in the morning to someone with a child, I of course would be kind and nice to an innocent child but I would not feel the same way about them as my own biological nieces/nephews. They would ultimately be the child of my siblings partner. Things like a grandmother wanting a photo with her actual grandchildren would not bother me and I would not expect a step gran child to be automatically included. I think it's better to be honest with child about this than the slightly unrealistic expectation that her steps aunts uncles grandparents feel the exact same way about her as their siblings. I'd focus on her relationships with her own biological grandparents etc as they are far more likely to be real and lasting than 'forced' ones.

lunar1 · 26/02/2023 22:15

Your poor daughter, what an awful childhood you've created. No matter what gloss you put on it, you have made her a second class citizen in her own family.

I will never understand how a parent can put their wants above their children's needs.

billy1966 · 26/02/2023 22:04

Unfortunately OP, you chose a man over your first daughter.

And not a good one either.

It was made very clear by his family where they stood, and yet you went ahead and married him.

Having more children with him changed nothing for his family.

I feel desperately sorry for your daughter and children like her.....second class within the family.

You are where you are and I can't imagine it is marriage ending for you.

But you chose poorly by choosing a man with a family like that, who were clear where they stood from the beginning.

I cannot imagine what it must do to a child's self esteem to be treated like that.

Your BIL is awful, really awful to single out a child like that.

Poor little mite.

She is living with your choices.

I think you know this and that is why it upsets you.

You gambled that they would change their view of her, but ugly people that would hurt a child like that rarely change.

How you expect her to grow up with a strong sense of herself within such a set up is hard to understand.

Lulu2171 · 26/02/2023 21:55

ItsShiela · 26/02/2023 17:12

Also as their mother you must put your foot down and tell your husband while you are having your make-or-break marriage discussion, that you will not give permission for the 7 and 5 year old to go. And they are not going. And it's as simple as that. In fact, contact BIL yourself to decline their invites.

He doesn't need OP's permission to take them somewhere. He's an equal parent.

Yousee · 26/02/2023 21:51

Sorry, that was too @SeulementUneFois

Yousee · 26/02/2023 21:49

Yes. Hardly taking the moral high ground about treating equally, taking your 12 year old to Disney and leaving your 5 and 7 year olds to go to a boring wedding that they aren't even wanted at! Crackers suggestion.
For further info: see numerous threads by SMs being slated for wanting to take all of their own biological children to Disney but not wanting to pay for their step children too.

PeraltasWife · 26/02/2023 21:42

I feel so deeply sorry for your eldest. I have been that eldest and even though my mum would say "it doesn't matter" "we can do something just us" it still stung everytime something like this happened and I was reminded that I wasn't "as good" as my siblings. Even little things where they were treated better and I was treated not as well hurt like hell as it just reinforced I didn't fit. They're the family of four and your the awkward 5th wheel that is made to feel like it would be easier for everyone else if you didn't exist. It damaged my relationship with my step dad, and with my mother and strained my sibling relationships into adulthood. Its hard to shake that feeling of being rejected by your own family when it's been ingrained in you from a child, that no one will stand up for you and ultimately they just want you to accept it and not make a fuss as its easier on the adults.

It's a horrible situation re the wedding invite which obviously is not OPs fault but as that child all those years ago its the child I feel truly sorry for.

Lulu2171 · 26/02/2023 21:35

It's not just up to you whether your younger two go. They are DH's children and this is his family. I'd say that gives him ultimate decision making responsibility. You're not the boss.

I can see that you'd want to support your eldest. So, out of a truly rubbish situation, I guess for the best DH and younger two go; you and eldest don't.

Floralnomad · 26/02/2023 21:11

2chocolateoranges · 26/02/2023 20:14

I feel so sorry for your eldest! Her stepfather is a weak man not willing to stand up for ALL the children in his family.

this is just setting a precedent for the future parties and invites.

do you want your child treated differently to her siblings and to be an outsider in what’s supposed to be her family.

in our family it’s all or nothing.

This exactly . Stop saying how wonderful your husband is and treats your daughter the same as the others because this proves he does not . You cannot just blame this mess on the BIL .

CuteCillian · 26/02/2023 21:02

Is there any chance your eldest will be invited to ex-H family weddings in Ireland? I think being positive about her bio-Dads family will help her to feel less excluded from step-dads extended family. As PP say, DD will probably have more fun on a day out with you, than her siblings do at the wedding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread