Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eldest Child and In-Law Wedding

333 replies

StarbucksSally · 26/02/2023 13:31

Brother-in-law split up with a long-term Partner at the beginning of the pandemic because of his unwillingness to get married. I think he was shocked that she left.

He is now marrying someone else. She seems a lovely woman; but consensus is he is marrying her as he doesn’t want to lose her.

DH is best man but children were not invited. MiL went batshit and I was upset. I think DH had his ego bruised that the kids weren’t invited. I said nothing and while I was upset thought it was their wedding.

They had a site that they signed up to and the bios of the wedding party were on and lo and behold there were a flower girl and ring bearer.

DH and MiL spoke to BiL and he seemed scared to rock the boat but on Friday invitations arrived for our youngest children that I share with DH. My eldest who is 12 is not included. MiL is not willing to intervene and DH spoke with BiL who absolutely won’t as bride.

DH has asked me to ask their dad to have her.

I am going to decline wedding. DH refuses point blank to let me decline for all the children. He wants his children there and thinks we will look stupid anyway if we now decline their invitations after all the fuss.

OP posts:
DiddlySquat52 · 07/03/2023 19:54

I think that you're doing the right thing by not going. If my daughter isn't family then I would take that as being I wasn't either so wouldn't want to go on that basis. Their wedding, their choice but I'd be entitled to make my own choices too. You've made the right call.

I don't think that I'd be able to get over something like this and so I would never see the BIL/SIL as my family. I would be leaving it up to DH to sort out all hosting, birthday, Xmas pressies, visits going forward. I'd be polite to them as DH's family but I would not be going out of my way to specifically do anything for them.

They've made it clear that your child isn't part of the inner circle so I would also be taking myself out of it too. Their children would mean nothing to me in the same way that yours means nothing to them.

MavisMcMinty · 07/03/2023 19:44

I hope to goodness everyone on this thread, including @StarbucksSally and her family, take it seriously next time you’re invited to a child-free wedding. Either book a babysitter or regretfully decline the invite. What a bloody palaver.

ItsShiela · 07/03/2023 19:37

Up until this wedding eldest has always been included in DH’s family stuff.

That is absolutely the complete opposite of what you said earlier....

ItsShiela · 07/03/2023 19:36

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 15:47

I am staying with my eldest child do she can’t hold anything against me if she arrives at the conclusion that her siblings’ uncle’s wedding is important.

The strong relationship between my children is important to me but I think keeping the younger two away from their family because eldest isn’t treated the same would actually damage their relationship. They know that they are technically half but we don’t mention it.
Up until this wedding eldest has always been included in DH’s family stuff.

I am staying with my eldest child do she can’t hold anything against me if she arrives at the conclusion that her siblings’ uncle’s wedding is important.

You don't get it. She WILL hold it against you that you allowed this to happen and didn't stop the younger two going. Your eldest will resent you, and will resent your siblings. Everything you can do wrong, you are choosing to do wrong. You are making the active decision that your eldest will hate her siblings and possibly hurt them, because of your actions. Your actions, will make your eldest hate and resent you, and hate and resent her younger siblings. You are actively choosing to destroy your relationship with your eldest, and you are actively choosing to ensure your eldest's relationship with her half-siblings is irrevocably broken.

ItsShiela · 07/03/2023 19:32

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 14:45

I think he does see why it’s upsetting.

If he truly saw why it's upsetting, he wouldn't be taking 2 babies that are far too young to understand, and couldn't give a stuff about going. You have some prize of a man there (not).

ItsShiela · 07/03/2023 19:30

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 14:38

i can’t deprive my younger children of their family.

Keeping 2 young kids away from a wedding that they neither know about even exists, or understand, is not "depriving them of their family". Not attending some wedding they neither know about nor understand nor give a stuff about is not depriving them. What you're saying makes absolutely no sense whatsoever, it's like you're flailing about and saying anything that comes into your head, to justify your inaction and your allowing your eldest to be excluded. That you are this desperate to throw your eldest under the bus and not stand up to your husband is heartbreaking and sad.

billy1966 · 07/03/2023 19:27

Hayliebells · 07/03/2023 19:19

I would honestly just reply saying you're not going because DD hasn't been invited. Tell them it's not about childcare, because you haven't even attempted to organise childcare. Then ignore the fall out. Let DH deal with everything to do with his family in the future. They're a bunch of arseholes.

I agree with this.

What a shower.

That poor child surrounded by people like this.

ItsShiela · 07/03/2023 19:25

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 13:50

Yesterday the bride texted me. She had been speaking to our mutual MiL. She said that she was sorry that their wedding was causing us a logistical nightmare… her words!
She was sorry that I wasn’t able to get childcare for the weekend and therefore couldn’t come.
She said BiL was very upset that I couldn’t join the rest of the family.
She talked about how happy she was that she was marrying someone with a close extended family but because of how close they were to cousins etc the inclusion of my eldest (she didn’t use her name) would mean they would have to invite 8 other children who were related. This has been explained apparently to both my husband and MiL.

I have no intention of replying. I was stunned.

They have invited the cousin’s son to be an usher as he is a Godchild. The Godchild’s 7 year old sister is staying home with her dad who isn’t related.

My husband does not treat my daughter differently when under our roof but can’t see how he can make his family treat her like a grandchild or niece.

I can’t stop him from taking my younger two to their family’s wedding. I have to balance the potential harm to my eldest and the potential bitterness of my other two if I stopped them going. I don’t think that would engender good relationships with their older sister.

I am going out for the day with her and I am insisting that they stay with MiL so we don’t see them getting dressed. Ah well!

the potential bitterness of my other two if I stopped them going. I don’t think that would engender good relationships with their older sister.

You're not making any sense, and you are making excuses. Your other two are so young they have NO CONCEPT of a wedding, and won't know they didn't go or be even aware of it. Yet if the younger two go and your eldest doesn't, your eldest is the only one out of the three who will know, will care, and who WILL be bitter at your youngest two.

Your arguments are completely back to front and make absolutely no sense whatsoever as the two young kids are too young to even know or care. ONLY your oldest is old enough to know and to care. Your excuses make absolutely zero sense whatsoever.

Hayliebells · 07/03/2023 19:19

I would honestly just reply saying you're not going because DD hasn't been invited. Tell them it's not about childcare, because you haven't even attempted to organise childcare. Then ignore the fall out. Let DH deal with everything to do with his family in the future. They're a bunch of arseholes.

sandyhappypeople · 07/03/2023 17:22

I think you’re doing the only thing that’s reasonable which is to stay with your eldest.

for all those saying she should keep the youngest two back.. it’s not her sole decision, she is married, and it’s not her place to decide that alone, if her husband disagrees she doesn’t automatically overrule him, in the same way that the husband can’t make his family see their eldest any differently, you’ve just got to accept what you can’t change, that’s not to say you can’t make your feelings clear on the matter, it’s a horrible situation all round, but you can’t control other people.

FWIW, from what you’ve said, I don’t think your husband DOES see your daughter the same as the other two otherwise he’d agree that it’s everyone or no-one, he wouldn’t even need to think about it, he obviously cared enough about it in the first place to stick his nose in and get his own children to be invited!! And now they are he seems happy with the arrangement?! I think him and the MIL knew exactly what they were doing when they interfered about the children, same way MIL kept your daughter out of the photo, I’d have no respect for anyone who punishes or condones punishing children in this way, it’s disgusting.

let this be a lesson for anyone attempting to interfere in other people’s weddings and decisions! If a couple don’t want lots of children at their wedding, no one has the right to feel any particular way about that, you’re free to not go! It’s THEIR wedding ffs! I understand their initial position especially as they don’t have children of their own, and I wouldn’t have changed my mind in the first place, if anything she seems too accommodating to me, what a shit start to married life for them!! No wonder the first one pissed off while she could.. sounds like she dodged a bullet!

ImAvingOops · 07/03/2023 17:12

You can't do anything about your bil not viewing your dd as family but you don't have to indulge it and you can make sure your younger children don't grow up thinking their sister is 'less' of a sibling. You are setting your family up for a fall.

Your younger kids won't resent not going to this wedding if you teach them that it isn't right to exclude one sibling. You and your dh are prioritising a man who doesn't even really want his own niece and nephew there anyway and letting your dd absorb the idea that when push come to shove, her step dad doesn't really see her as his child or worth upsetting the apple cart over. This will bite you in the arse eventually. Batshit crazy!

HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 07/03/2023 16:48

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 07/03/2023 16:21

X post.

So it seems that I'm right. He is their uncle and not hers, which is why you think it is OK for her to be excluded. Let's hope that she sees it in the same way.

I don't think that's what OP's saying at all. She's boycotting the wedding in solidarity with her daughter , she's not prepared to attend something her daughter isn't welcomed to.

With a blended family, it does get complicated. The unrelated-by-blood partner's extended family won't always see those children as "family" and there's nothing anyone can do to force it. It can get very painful.

Partyandbullshit · 07/03/2023 16:47

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:18

But it’s their uncle not hers. My son particularly would see it logically.

I am not the one saying that he would have to invite 8 other children but they are.

She is their sister! They have the same mother! It's on YOU to teach your son that this isn't about logic. It's about his sister.

One day you'll be dead and gone. Who will your DD have, then? Sounds like her siblings are being raised to prioritize their uncle over their sister, and it sounds like, if your DH survives you, he'd be cool with that. Bluntly, you're approving of the fact that everyone except you and your DD are in the same family, and all she has is you.

It's absolutely not my intention to lay into you, it's very difficult to convey tone on a screen. If you yourself are ok with making this blood-family distinction, then fine. Maybe her biological father is enough of a dad for you (and his siblings seem decent enough to a child they rarely see, including her half-siblings, (unlike your BIL, but hey)). But if you were comfortable with this you wouldn't be feeling this dilemma. It clearly does bother you. And this is why: there's a terrible truth underlying all this, which your DD is bearing the brunt of. She's not as much of a family member to your DH and her half-siblings, as his brother/their uncle is. I just couldn't imagine being made to feel that way, at an age where you're still entitled to feel that the world revolves around you and your siblings (to a large extent). She's being made to learn and feel just how cold it is out there, without her mum to back her up.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 07/03/2023 16:21

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:18

But it’s their uncle not hers. My son particularly would see it logically.

I am not the one saying that he would have to invite 8 other children but they are.

X post.

So it seems that I'm right. He is their uncle and not hers, which is why you think it is OK for her to be excluded. Let's hope that she sees it in the same way.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 07/03/2023 16:20

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:02

I think it’s Not that they’re more of a family with an uncle but the uncle sees them as more of a family.
Both MiL particularly and DH had told BiL the reasons I am not going, I don’t know if SiL knows but he says if eldest goes 8 cousins will have to go ages 14 to 3.

You seem to have a bit of a blind spot here, OP.

You keep saying that it isn't how your DH sees it, but it's how his brother sees it. However, if your DH really did see your dd as being as much a part of his family as his other children, then he wouldn't just shrug it off and say that his brother doesn't see it that way. Clearly, at some level, he feels that his brother has a valid point.

And who knows, maybe you do too? You seem quite willing to accept that your dd will be rejected by your in-laws and to buy into their logic that it's OK to exclude her. And you're putting your younger dc's relationship with their uncle as a higher priority than your dd's sense of belonging in her family, so perhaps while you would like her to be fully included, on one level, you too have bought into the idea that she isn't a blood relation so it doesn't really count?

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:18

But it’s their uncle not hers. My son particularly would see it logically.

I am not the one saying that he would have to invite 8 other children but they are.

OP posts:
Partyandbullshit · 07/03/2023 16:11

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:02

I think it’s Not that they’re more of a family with an uncle but the uncle sees them as more of a family.
Both MiL particularly and DH had told BiL the reasons I am not going, I don’t know if SiL knows but he says if eldest goes 8 cousins will have to go ages 14 to 3.

Adults may see the difference, but you as the parent and step-parent are sanctioning this distinction the BIL is making. She's old enough at 12yo to understand all this, but that's a bitter lesson to learn at that age. That these people she sees around Christmas etc don't see her as "family". The poor girl.

You're also copping out a bit, because you keep mentioning the resentment your youngest two would feel if they were kept away from the wedding because of their half-sister. Half-sister fgs! She's being treated like a leper and, I don't want to dig into you, but you're sort of letting it happen to her. You should be having a word with your youngest 2, telling them they've no right to get upset if their sister is being treated in this way, that they need to think about it from her perspective. It's one uncle, one wedding - it's basically a party and family celebration. Is their sibling relationship worth less than that?

If I were your DD I'm not sure I could see beyond my own hurt to understand and accept the logistical problems the bridge and groom are facing. I think that's too much to ask.

I do see that you're stuck in the middle here, especially as you yourself didn't say anything about children being invited, that it was your MIL and DH who asked. But you're not blood family to BIL either, and you need to stand back from this whole situation and see what matters to you. Your children first and equally, your husband second, your MIL third, your BIL last. I think you've lost sight of that a bit, personally.

Pylor · 07/03/2023 16:10

It now sounds like you are stuck in their reasoning- no of course they wouldn't have to invite 8 other children.
They are differentiating between the children in your family based on blood.
Your poor DD.

Please make it clear it is not about childcare and it is about solidarity with your daughter.
Quite honestly though I agree that I'd be saying none of the children go-that was after all what they wanted in the first place!

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 16:02

I think it’s Not that they’re more of a family with an uncle but the uncle sees them as more of a family.
Both MiL particularly and DH had told BiL the reasons I am not going, I don’t know if SiL knows but he says if eldest goes 8 cousins will have to go ages 14 to 3.

OP posts:
tensmum1964 · 07/03/2023 16:00

Although I don't agree personally with your partner taking the younger ones I think not responding to her email is a good idea. Sometimes saying nothing, speaks volumes.

Partyandbullshit · 07/03/2023 15:56

Wait a minute - has someone told your BIL and future SIL that the reason YOU are not going to the wedding is because you have no childcare for your DD12? So, your BIL and future SIL don't know that you're staying away because of the hurt they're causing to your DD, and that you need to be with her? And your DH hasn't corrected this?

This whole situation is so dysfunctional.

I also think there's something amiss with your reasoning: you too seem to think that it's fine to preserve the brother-brother bond, and the uncle-nephew/niece bond at the expense of your eldest DD. By DH and your joint DC going to the wedding, the message you're sending your DD is that your DH is more of a family with his brother than he is with her, and that her half siblings are more of a family with their uncle than they are with her. Frankly, that's SHOCKING.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 07/03/2023 15:53

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 15:47

I am staying with my eldest child do she can’t hold anything against me if she arrives at the conclusion that her siblings’ uncle’s wedding is important.

The strong relationship between my children is important to me but I think keeping the younger two away from their family because eldest isn’t treated the same would actually damage their relationship. They know that they are technically half but we don’t mention it.
Up until this wedding eldest has always been included in DH’s family stuff.

Well, you don't need to mention that they're only half siblings because it's right there staring them in the face.

For your sake and for your dd's sake, I hope that she won't hold anything against you in the future, but I think you're kidding yourself if you believe that staying with her on the day is enough to protect against that. This is about so much more than the wedding itself and what you do on that one day. It is about your dd's place in the family and her sense of belonging. Hopefully she won't be damaged by it, but you can't possibly know that right now. She may not remember it at all, or she may remember that you rolled over and did nothing when the rest of the family treated her like an outsider. Only time will tell, I suppose.

StarbucksSally · 07/03/2023 15:47

I am staying with my eldest child do she can’t hold anything against me if she arrives at the conclusion that her siblings’ uncle’s wedding is important.

The strong relationship between my children is important to me but I think keeping the younger two away from their family because eldest isn’t treated the same would actually damage their relationship. They know that they are technically half but we don’t mention it.
Up until this wedding eldest has always been included in DH’s family stuff.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 07/03/2023 15:43

I'd go away for a nice weekend with your eldest.

WillowKnicks · 07/03/2023 15:41

*Your children's relationships as siblings is far far more important than attending an uncles wedding (an uncle who didn't want any of them there in the first place).
You aren't denying your youngest children access to their family by deciding none will attend - you would be making the wider point to in-laws, your husband and your children, that you are a family and that your children should be treated equally, as the siblings that they are.

I can't believe you don't see this tbh, and still think it's somehow okay for your dh to take the youngest two and sanction the exclusion of dd.*

This