Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many women don’t want their ex involved?

217 replies

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 12:03

My ex doesn’t see our children because he doesn’t want to be involved. No real reason he just doesn’t want to be around. When I mention this to people they will usually fall over themselves to tell me how lucky I am that my ex doesn’t bother, and how they wish theirs wouldn’t bother. I’m not talking about cases of abuse that would be understandable (my ex however was not abusive to our kids) but they always go on to say that they hate “sharing” their kids with their ex and that I’m lucky I don’t have to and get to parent my own way. It’s always about how they feel and never any acknowledgment over how their kids would feel if their father didn’t want to see them.

Yet at the same time dead beat dads who don’t see or bother with their kids are rightly slated but it seems many women prefer the dead beat dad! So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around? 50/50 is apparently bad for children and they feel like they don’t belong anywhere but EOW is then considered not good enough and an uninvolved ex who only wants to do the fun parts of parenting but none of the hard work, so basically a Disney dad. What is the ideal contact set up or would most women just prefer if if their ex disappeared?

(Just to clarify again as I know people will comment on abuse but that’s not what I’m talking about, I’m not mentioning to people that my ex was abusive and now doesn’t see our kids and they are telling me I’m lucky, I’m simply saying he doesn’t see them and get met with “you’re lucky he doesn’t bother with them, I wish my ex didn’t bother!”)

OP posts:
Aphrathestorm · 26/02/2023 13:28

I had a much better experience completely solo parenting than I've ever seen anyone coparenting with an ex.

I made my dc, I want what's best for them and dont want to have to negotiate that with someone else.

If I was a young woman of today I'd go/recommend the anon sperm donor route.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 26/02/2023 13:25

In my experience and that of plenty of other single mums I know, we did everything we could to maintain a good relationship between our DC and their father, even though it was difficult for us. We’d also really rather like some financial assistance with raising the DC they helped to create, and being a lone parent 100% of the time without a break is hard going, so you know, if the other parent looked after their DC from time to time that would also be nice.

SomePosters · 26/02/2023 13:25

I think there is something in it tbh

I was raised by a dedicated, loving single mum. No dad. Never met him. Never missed him. Never wondered what I did wrong to stop him bothering with me.

I have seen a lot of children, especially girls massively screwed up by t blaming themselves for their fathers inadequate efforts at parenting.

I suffered a lot less damage just knowing he was a bloke who ran from the idea of me rather than building a relationship that always makes me feel like I’m somehow not good enough for him to stick around for.

While I’ve seen a few coparentimg relationships that are healthy for the children often they are punted about and argued about like property.
I’ve certainly seen plenty of examples where I think the kids would have been better off with an absent father than strung along to win power over the mum or impress the string of new girlfriends.

BiasedBinding · 26/02/2023 13:24

Oh yeah, that huge money-making scheme CMS <eye roll>

again, it is far far more common for mothers to be struggling to get shitty fathers to pay even a small amount towards their children

men really don’t have to do much to be considered good fathers, but a good proportion seem to find it hard to even put that effort in

StepParent23 · 26/02/2023 13:17

TreadLight · 26/02/2023 12:52

Time and again I've seen mothers use the courts to try and stop the children from having a relationship with their father, and the fathers spending maybe amounts of money and emotional capital to maintain the relationship with their children.

So I agree with the OP, many mothers prefer to stop the children from having a relationship with their father.

Yup. I’ve seen both sides. Mothers trying to ban contact with caring dads who provide a good environment and care whilst with them and also Mothers who aren’t really all that interested in having the kids but keep hold of them as a means of extorting money from their ex.

Merryoldgoat · 26/02/2023 13:16

Viviennemary · 26/02/2023 13:11

I think the worst sort are the unreliable ones. Children looking forward to seeing their father then he either doesn't turn up or cancels at the last minute. And then the mother is left to deal with upset chikdren.

I know someone whose ex told their daughter he was taking her and a friend on holiday. Made all the arrangements with the friend and everything.

All waiting and packed and he didn’t turn up to go to the airport. No explanation. Nothing.

He was in and out of his kids’ lives until they said they wanted no contact. His behaviour has really screwed up their lives.

It would’ve been far better if he just fucked off for good.

MrsJackGrealish · 26/02/2023 13:16

There were times when I thought it'd be easier if my ex just fucked off for good.

That's only because he's such a half-arsed parent I often wondered why he bothered when it seemed like such a chore to him, despite the fact that he could have had time with DD at any time.

As a result, DD is 16 and she cant be arsed with him.

shieldmaiden7 · 26/02/2023 13:15

I would LOVE for my kids dad to be more involved. He used to be, had them multiple days a week and had a lovely relationship with them. He met someone new then couldn't be bothered. Saw them 12 hours last year, I've tried everything to make him make an effort but all I get in a return is nasty comments.

GiltEdges · 26/02/2023 13:14

Point is fathers are not valued. Well it doesn’t matter if they don’t bother, you’re lucky! No one would say that if it was a mother that had abandoned her kids.

But what other people say / what some mothers might think doesn't automatically correlate with men choosing to have a relationship with their own children or not. If they value the relationship they have with their DC in its own right, then they'll continue to pursue it irrespective of what anyone else thinks. If they don't, then they won't.

Hancocksmentalnft · 26/02/2023 13:14

@SpinningFloppa it’s an interesting point, in someways I think it goes against the grain for mothers to let children out of their sight for long periods of time. This is likely especially true when they are with someone who let you down and you subsequently can’t trust. I think this worry increases when there are new partners in the mix. lots of men are equally good or better parents than the mother of their children, these tend not to be the men who’s marriages that end in divorce though, mostly

LaughingCat · 26/02/2023 13:12

Seriously, this is what you hear?! I’m genuinely shocked as everyone I know would either give their back teeth for the dads to get more involved or are fully coparenting, discussing the kids and the progress pretty much equally and ensuring that the kids know that just because they aren’t together anymore, doesn’t mean they aren’t singing from the same hymn sheet. Most of those have the kids half each (so half the week each and every other weekend, and birthdays etc shared). They live close by and the kids consider both places ‘home’ and know they are always welcome in either.

Why on earth would you want your ex to do less unless he is either abusive or a super bad influence? (At which point, yah, rearview mirror mate).

Viviennemary · 26/02/2023 13:11

I think the worst sort are the unreliable ones. Children looking forward to seeing their father then he either doesn't turn up or cancels at the last minute. And then the mother is left to deal with upset chikdren.

Mamamia32 · 26/02/2023 13:11

My brother was also lucky that he could afford a solicitor. A lot of men can't.

BiasedBinding · 26/02/2023 13:11

it’s not fathers not being valued - it’s a greater proportion of fathers not understanding the value of the relationship themselves. Men gain status by being fathers purely by having a child, but minimal status is gained by them actually doing anything to raise their children. Fathers/men could solve this but choose not to, because it means more effort for them and they know mothers are picking up the pieces

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 13:09

Mamamia32 · 26/02/2023 13:07

I hate this attitude so much and agree with you OP. My nephew's mum would be over the moon if my brother didn't want to be involved and just paid her child support, completely selfish on her part. children benefit from having a good relationship with both parents.

Thank you someone that actually gets it but again people will insist there must be secret abuse and won’t acknowledge that some women actually just don’t want their ex around and want their kids to themselves.

OP posts:
SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 13:08

GiltEdges · 26/02/2023 13:04

So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around?

Well yes, actually, because then "bothering" or not should be nothing to do with whether the mother of their DC wants them around or not. It should be about their own desire to play an active part in their DC's lives.

Point is fathers are not valued. Well it doesn’t matter if they don’t bother, you’re lucky! No one would say that if it was a mother that had abandoned her kids.

OP posts:
Mamamia32 · 26/02/2023 13:07

I hate this attitude so much and agree with you OP. My nephew's mum would be over the moon if my brother didn't want to be involved and just paid her child support, completely selfish on her part. children benefit from having a good relationship with both parents.

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 13:07

BiasedBinding · 26/02/2023 13:01

Clearly people are being a bit insensitive OP, not to realise that the reason your children don’t see their father might not be a positive thing. But my general experience tells me that mothers are far more likely to be desperately trying to facilitate a relationship for their children with half-hearted fathers who keep letting them down, and if they wish they didn’t have to deal with that then who can blame them. They aren’t likely to actively stop them, but may wish they could put an end to the uphill struggle to get an uninterested man to put his children first

Thank you, that’s it I feel it’s very insensitive to say that to me. My children are struggling a lot with their father not bothering with them so I get sick of people telling me I’m lucky not realising the damage it can do to children. Even if someone’s ex is abusive that doesn’t mean MY kids are lucky.

OP posts:
maddening · 26/02/2023 13:05

DuplicateUserName · 26/02/2023 12:55

So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around?

Yes, it's very much a wonder - to me anyway.

Hell would freeze over before any decent father stopped seeing their own children just because their ex would rather they weren't around.

Stop making excuses for shit parents.

This is the statement that stuck out for me also - which women? Which men? Why are these men considered so weak minded that an opinion of some sort of group of apparent women means that they won't bother with their own children 🤔

GiltEdges · 26/02/2023 13:04

So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around?

Well yes, actually, because then "bothering" or not should be nothing to do with whether the mother of their DC wants them around or not. It should be about their own desire to play an active part in their DC's lives.

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 13:03

BungleandGeorge · 26/02/2023 13:00

What is your definition of abusive? There’s a lot of men around who behave really badly but don’t meet the extremes that would involve a criminal conviction. And unfortunately when dad gets a new family/ partner they often move on and the kids become a low priority. You can see why as loyalties lie with the current relationship but it leads to a lot of substandard parenting

I am not talking about abuse though see my above post it's women who don't like being separated from their children. Not all exes are abusive they tell me I'm lucky because I get to be with my kids "all the time."

OP posts:
BiasedBinding · 26/02/2023 13:01

Clearly people are being a bit insensitive OP, not to realise that the reason your children don’t see their father might not be a positive thing. But my general experience tells me that mothers are far more likely to be desperately trying to facilitate a relationship for their children with half-hearted fathers who keep letting them down, and if they wish they didn’t have to deal with that then who can blame them. They aren’t likely to actively stop them, but may wish they could put an end to the uphill struggle to get an uninterested man to put his children first

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 13:01

TreadLight · 26/02/2023 12:52

Time and again I've seen mothers use the courts to try and stop the children from having a relationship with their father, and the fathers spending maybe amounts of money and emotional capital to maintain the relationship with their children.

So I agree with the OP, many mothers prefer to stop the children from having a relationship with their father.

Yep but there must always be that the father was "abusive". Many times it's women just not wanting their ex around I've literally seen it with my own eyes on here women saying their ex is a good dad but they don't like "sharing " their child, they can't bare to be away from them, they stay in bed when their child is with the other parent because they can't face not being with them . Never mind the benefits to the child it's just about how they want to keep the child with them at all times.

OP posts:
JingsMahBucket · 26/02/2023 13:00

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 12:46

Even a unhelpful father would benefit a child more than an absent one though! It's not just about how the woman feels

This statement is oxymoronic.

BungleandGeorge · 26/02/2023 13:00

What is your definition of abusive? There’s a lot of men around who behave really badly but don’t meet the extremes that would involve a criminal conviction. And unfortunately when dad gets a new family/ partner they often move on and the kids become a low priority. You can see why as loyalties lie with the current relationship but it leads to a lot of substandard parenting