Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many women don’t want their ex involved?

217 replies

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 12:03

My ex doesn’t see our children because he doesn’t want to be involved. No real reason he just doesn’t want to be around. When I mention this to people they will usually fall over themselves to tell me how lucky I am that my ex doesn’t bother, and how they wish theirs wouldn’t bother. I’m not talking about cases of abuse that would be understandable (my ex however was not abusive to our kids) but they always go on to say that they hate “sharing” their kids with their ex and that I’m lucky I don’t have to and get to parent my own way. It’s always about how they feel and never any acknowledgment over how their kids would feel if their father didn’t want to see them.

Yet at the same time dead beat dads who don’t see or bother with their kids are rightly slated but it seems many women prefer the dead beat dad! So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around? 50/50 is apparently bad for children and they feel like they don’t belong anywhere but EOW is then considered not good enough and an uninvolved ex who only wants to do the fun parts of parenting but none of the hard work, so basically a Disney dad. What is the ideal contact set up or would most women just prefer if if their ex disappeared?

(Just to clarify again as I know people will comment on abuse but that’s not what I’m talking about, I’m not mentioning to people that my ex was abusive and now doesn’t see our kids and they are telling me I’m lucky, I’m simply saying he doesn’t see them and get met with “you’re lucky he doesn’t bother with them, I wish my ex didn’t bother!”)

OP posts:
chezpopbang · 27/02/2023 13:41

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 12:51

Also it's frowned upon to tell a woman that she's lucky if her ex pays decent maintenance and is a caring involved parent because "it's not lucky it should be considered the norm" yet it's ok to tell women they are lucky their ex doesn't bother?

No it's not ok that someone said you were lucky. You should have said back. Well I don't feel very lucky and this isn't what I signed up for. Like others have said people say you are lucky until it happens to them. I'm sure it's not meant in a malicious way but people often say things to be clever or funny but don't really think about the weight behind their words.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:36

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 13:29

I think if you looked at the statistics the vast majority of people, something like 90 percent make arrangements without court.

For those minority of cases that do go, citing domestic violence or other serious safeguarding factors should not be s surprise. You are talking about extreme cases where there has been a risk disclosed and the court needs to rule.

What statistics? Please share.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:35

Coyoacan · 27/02/2023 13:26

Bad maths from a MRA Guess what, a lot of women will claim domestic violence to avoid paying the fee. 50% of child maintenance cases are opened by women that claim domestic violence. Do you really believe that 50% of men are domestic abusers?

I' don't believe it is that easy to get the authorities to believe there was dv, but leaving that aside.

A lot of men stay with their family. Of the ones who do separate, some make a private arrangement about payments and some receive payments from the mother. So, 50% of men being sued for cm is actually a small minority of men, not 50% of men.

It is not sued by CMS. Its parents that use the CMS to arrange payments either by Direct Payments or Collect and Pay.

BubziOwl · 27/02/2023 13:34

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 13:29

I think if you looked at the statistics the vast majority of people, something like 90 percent make arrangements without court.

For those minority of cases that do go, citing domestic violence or other serious safeguarding factors should not be s surprise. You are talking about extreme cases where there has been a risk disclosed and the court needs to rule.

Yes exactly, it really isn't surprising that the men who get have to get dragged to court to get child maintenance out of them are also more likely to be abusive.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:33

AmandaJonah · 27/02/2023 12:57

Nobody is saying it never happens. But it does not happen as often as is claimed.

Who claims? How do you know?

Brewskipa · 27/02/2023 13:31

I can see your point OP but I’m firmly in the camp that my DS does not need his deadbeat “dad” who decided a year ago he didn’t want contact with DS anymore. He was age 5 at the time. He caused massive conflict and significant instability for my child, who already had an attachment disorder (we adopted him when he was 1, separated when he was 3). His choice to walk away has enabled conversations with my son about how some people make bad choices, about how he did not deserve the way his “dad” treated him. An ongoing relationship between them would have made it much harder for my DS to understand that his dad was a piece of crap and he would have learnt that the behaviour (which bordered on physically abusive and had police and social services involved because of his heavy handedness with DS) was not acceptable. I don’t doubt it had caused significant damage to my DS but it is the lesser of two evils because we are working through it with significant early therapeutic input.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 13:29

I think if you looked at the statistics the vast majority of people, something like 90 percent make arrangements without court.

For those minority of cases that do go, citing domestic violence or other serious safeguarding factors should not be s surprise. You are talking about extreme cases where there has been a risk disclosed and the court needs to rule.

Coyoacan · 27/02/2023 13:26

Bad maths from a MRA Guess what, a lot of women will claim domestic violence to avoid paying the fee. 50% of child maintenance cases are opened by women that claim domestic violence. Do you really believe that 50% of men are domestic abusers?

I' don't believe it is that easy to get the authorities to believe there was dv, but leaving that aside.

A lot of men stay with their family. Of the ones who do separate, some make a private arrangement about payments and some receive payments from the mother. So, 50% of men being sued for cm is actually a small minority of men, not 50% of men.

SavBlancTonight · 27/02/2023 13:22

Personally, I'm always amazed at how often women are twisting themselves into pretzels to facilitate contact with useless men. I can't help thinking that in most cases, the children would be better off with zero access rather than what they get. But I appreciate that the children desperately want a father in their lives!

As I watched BIL come into SIL's house the other day, have an argument and storm out again all without so much as acknowledging their DC's existence (and obviously, not mine either - less of an issue though), I did find myself thinking, "when he finally gets bored and stops coming around, maybe that will be better for these little boys".

AmandaJonah · 27/02/2023 13:16

Most mothers want what is best for their children. So if their dad is decent and the children are therefore happy when they see their dad, then they want their children to spend time with their dad.
The issues arise when the dad is not a good add and the children do not want to see him.

MsMarch · 27/02/2023 13:11

I get that MN is not necessarily a true reflection of real life, but I see thread after thread on here from women desperate for their exes to turn up, take the children, be reliable etc. I see threads from women trying to work out how to handle an ex who disappeared for 2 years and has now reappeared and they want to facilitate contact but they're terrified of what that will mean for their children. I see threads from women tearing their hair out because their ex is a disney dad who takes the kids to mcdonald's every weekend, makes them sleep in inappropriate places, doesn't have a clean living environment etc.

And when there is the odd woman who is clearly just bitter, she gets lambasted and told the children need to be able to have a relationship with the father.

I also love the threads from dads on here. So often, they come on with the sob story about their ex but then it all starts coming out - they chose to move after the divorce and now live in another county, they do want to see their DC but can only do every Saturday and Sunday and can't understand why the ex might not want her children to be gone every weekend seeing as she "gets" them Mon-Fri. I especially love the ones who complain about having to pay CMS.

So yes, there must be the type of women who are vindictive - I absolutely believe that - but they certainly don't seem to be a dime a dozen.

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 13:04

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 12:21

Could you support your assertion with statistics, not with generations based on your limited experience? Have you been to family court? Have you waited months and months between hearings? Have you talked to fathers that want access to their children but are blocked by their exes? Your staunch defense of all women without any hard-based facts may come to haunt you one day if you have a son.

Can you produce statistics on how often women are irrational and just do whatever they can to get their children away from their ex for no good reason? No, I thought not. We don't have statistics either way.

But I do know that in real life, I haven't met a single man who has had to go through this becuase of a genuinely crazy and mean ex.

I have met a couple of women who are so angry about their break ups etc that they have started out being a little irrational and inflexible regarding contact etc. (and I did acknowledge this in my post and no, it's not okay) but in most cases, I've seen that calm down as things calm down.

What I HAVE experience is the examples above. The men who make these claims but don't seem to understand that actually, parenting involves a whole LOT of compromise. I'm the main breadwinner and in a happy relationship with a man who does his share but you know what? If I want to spend time with my children, facilitate their social/academic/sporting lives etc I have to compromise. In relationships, women tend to the the ones who do this (leave work early, arrange flexitime, go part time - obviously, not in all cases but in MORE cases) but when the relationships break down I see all these single dads who still seem to think they don't have to do any of this compromising and can still just see their children when it's convenient to them. That's not how it works and expecting an ex to continue to do all the compromising is magical thinking of the highest order.

The very occasional woman who does find a way to restrict access to her children for spite should absolutely be vilified. It's just not that common from what I can see. In stead, most single mothers are on their knees begging their exes to take the DC a bit more.

BubziOwl · 27/02/2023 13:02

My mum has said lots of things like this over the years post-divorce, because my dad constantly let us down and also financially cost us all a great deal. I love him, but he is a terrible father.

However, the reality is that, beneath the flippant comment, her real feeling was that she felt responsible for picking such a dud father for us, and she would have desperately preferred a co-parent who was more of a positive impact in our lives.

Lots of people make comments that they don't necessarily truly mean.

BiasedBinding · 27/02/2023 13:02

Yeah I can well believe more than 50% of men for whom women have taken out CMS claims have committed DV. Probably more.

SpinningFloppa · 27/02/2023 13:00

I actually think it happens far more than people realise

OP posts:
AmandaJonah · 27/02/2023 12:57

Nobody is saying it never happens. But it does not happen as often as is claimed.

Mamamia32 · 27/02/2023 12:55

I think a lot of women just don't want to believe that women keep children from thier fathers without good reason but they do. Not in every situation obviously but it happens.

ArtG · 27/02/2023 12:38

If kids grow up never seeing a parent then there is a danger that they will mythologise them. By this I mean that, the parent being a blank canvas so to speak, the child might ascribe qualities to them (usually diametrically opposite the qualities of the present parent) that they find sympathetic. If the absent parent is a jerk then this is likely to cause some heartbreak sooner or later.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 12:36

The older I get, the more I consider that a substantial number of fathers resent their own children, and that this makes their own relationships fall apart. I don't just mean being lazy, I mean they in essence regard them as competition. Someone, somewhere, raises men like these.

This kind of guy is real poison to a happy child because he has not had the kindness and love himself to give it to others.

Yousee · 27/02/2023 12:29

Arthurflecksfacepaint · 27/02/2023 08:45

I often thought I wanted my ex husband out of it altogether.

But only because he played such stupid games. He had to do the opposite of everything just to play some silly game with me, even when it was detrimental to ds.

He’s still at it now ds is a young adult. For example, we both always said we would hate ds to ride a motorcycle. Ex h uncle had a motorcycle accident which left him in a vegetive state for 20 years until he died. My grandfather lost his leg in a motorcycle accident.

So what did ex do? Encouraged ds to not learn to drive a car, but to ride a bike instead. Really pushed him into it. Said he would pay for a bike. So ds did.

And on the day he passed the test, ex sent me a message saying “when he ends up a vegetable with you wiping his arse for the rest of his life, it will serve you right. Ultimate revenge to see you suffer and have you worry that he will die everyday he’s on that bike.”

(Serve me right for leaving him 15 bloody years ago).

You can imagine all the other examples over the years from that one.

When ds was little and was with him, he would text me to say he’d lost him in shops or in theme parks. Just to make me panic. Then he would say I was unstable for worrying. I soon got wise to it.

He’s fucked up ds in so many ways and honestly, I think it would have been better if he’d had nothing to do with him.

This is genuinely one of the saddest things I've ever read on this site. It brought tears to my eyes thinking how you must have felt reading that text about your precious child. I'm so sorry 💐

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 12:21

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 11:55

O course there are women who have weird or unacceptable reasons for not wanting the dads involved, but I don't believe that is the norm. In almost every instance I've seen, the woman DOES want the dad involved, but his willingness varies from "over my dead body" to "if and when I feel like it."

And it's not just the ones who are obviously deadbeats. You can spot them a mile away. Apparently nice, normal, helpful, loving dads but who come out with any number of comments said in an on-so-reasonable tone. Things like,
"well, I'd like to see the DC more but I work really long hours and they live far away."
or
"It makes me so sad but my ex would rather the DC do their activities on the weekend than see me so it's impossible for me to see them as much as I'd like."
or
"I can't have the DC on Wednesdays becuase I have football"

And on the surface, fine, except that 9/10 the woman who DOES have the children isn't going to football, hasn't moved 200 miles away, is leaving work early and is facilitating these activities and social events.... but god forbid the man should do any of this.

Could you support your assertion with statistics, not with generations based on your limited experience? Have you been to family court? Have you waited months and months between hearings? Have you talked to fathers that want access to their children but are blocked by their exes? Your staunch defense of all women without any hard-based facts may come to haunt you one day if you have a son.

icanneverthinkofnc · 27/02/2023 12:14

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 11:49

@Qwertyyui It is so wrong that women can say if you want to contact or more contact take me to court. Of course, you can take her to court but it takes years and thousands of pounds. The family court system is a mess and not fit for purpose. You have to wait months between hearings, a barrister costs between 3k and 5k per day, solicitors 250 per hour, you take to take days off work, etc. Of course, you can represent yourself but you are at a disadvantage due to the emotions involved. Who gave women the power to force you to go to court to access your own child? As I said before if they have a son they will find out in the future that he cannot access his child for months or years and they won't be able to access their grandchildren either. Only then they will recognize the problem.

This...and if they are a dad on nmw/low income he won't get help for accommodation either, it's shared house until he is 35. So, nowhere to take kids, let alone have them stay.
Add in parental alienation, and mothers can ignore court orders too.
I keep seeing that the system is set up for men, but it's not if they are at the bottom of the pile.

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 11:55

O course there are women who have weird or unacceptable reasons for not wanting the dads involved, but I don't believe that is the norm. In almost every instance I've seen, the woman DOES want the dad involved, but his willingness varies from "over my dead body" to "if and when I feel like it."

And it's not just the ones who are obviously deadbeats. You can spot them a mile away. Apparently nice, normal, helpful, loving dads but who come out with any number of comments said in an on-so-reasonable tone. Things like,
"well, I'd like to see the DC more but I work really long hours and they live far away."
or
"It makes me so sad but my ex would rather the DC do their activities on the weekend than see me so it's impossible for me to see them as much as I'd like."
or
"I can't have the DC on Wednesdays becuase I have football"

And on the surface, fine, except that 9/10 the woman who DOES have the children isn't going to football, hasn't moved 200 miles away, is leaving work early and is facilitating these activities and social events.... but god forbid the man should do any of this.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 11:49

@Qwertyyui It is so wrong that women can say if you want to contact or more contact take me to court. Of course, you can take her to court but it takes years and thousands of pounds. The family court system is a mess and not fit for purpose. You have to wait months between hearings, a barrister costs between 3k and 5k per day, solicitors 250 per hour, you take to take days off work, etc. Of course, you can represent yourself but you are at a disadvantage due to the emotions involved. Who gave women the power to force you to go to court to access your own child? As I said before if they have a son they will find out in the future that he cannot access his child for months or years and they won't be able to access their grandchildren either. Only then they will recognize the problem.

SpinningFloppa · 27/02/2023 11:46

Qwertyyui · 27/02/2023 11:37

There are mothers who do not want to share. I have dated single fathers and been in situations where the men have wanted more contact and been told no and have had to go to court. Sometimes the women are using the kids as weapons and sometimes they use the kids as company as they do not like to be alone. My DD sees her dad most days. We share Xmas day at mine and birthdays. My current DH gets on well with my EDH and we work together as a family to raise DD. This apparently is rare. My mum used us as weapons I struggled never having a dad I don't want the same for my DD. I always advise the dads to keep records of conversations and issues and court papers to show the adult DC the fact they tried when they are older. There are dead beat dads out there (and mums) but the fact women can dictate when kids see their dads without courts getting involved is detrimental to the kids. I think the default should be 50/50 unless there is abuse. If the NRP doesn't want that then they pay maintenance. If the RP refuses to allow access they do not get maintenance as they shouldn't financially benefit when the refusal has no substance. Probably an unpopular opinion though!

Yep seen it with my own eyes yet people refuse to accept it happens. Women that don't like their exes being involved because in their words they don't want to be apart from their kids. They are lonely without them. Yes the father has contact but they view it as them letting their ex see the children. I've seen posts where a woman has met a new partner so they want their ex out of the picture so they can play happy families with the new partner. I think this is more common than people care to admit.

OP posts: