Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many women don’t want their ex involved?

217 replies

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 12:03

My ex doesn’t see our children because he doesn’t want to be involved. No real reason he just doesn’t want to be around. When I mention this to people they will usually fall over themselves to tell me how lucky I am that my ex doesn’t bother, and how they wish theirs wouldn’t bother. I’m not talking about cases of abuse that would be understandable (my ex however was not abusive to our kids) but they always go on to say that they hate “sharing” their kids with their ex and that I’m lucky I don’t have to and get to parent my own way. It’s always about how they feel and never any acknowledgment over how their kids would feel if their father didn’t want to see them.

Yet at the same time dead beat dads who don’t see or bother with their kids are rightly slated but it seems many women prefer the dead beat dad! So is it any wonder many men don’t bother when women make it clear they would prefer it if they weren’t around? 50/50 is apparently bad for children and they feel like they don’t belong anywhere but EOW is then considered not good enough and an uninvolved ex who only wants to do the fun parts of parenting but none of the hard work, so basically a Disney dad. What is the ideal contact set up or would most women just prefer if if their ex disappeared?

(Just to clarify again as I know people will comment on abuse but that’s not what I’m talking about, I’m not mentioning to people that my ex was abusive and now doesn’t see our kids and they are telling me I’m lucky, I’m simply saying he doesn’t see them and get met with “you’re lucky he doesn’t bother with them, I wish my ex didn’t bother!”)

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 15:49

Without fail when I post on these groups about DCs father not being around I get told I should be thankful he’s not, whilst I’m not suggesting it happens all the time I do believe a lot of women don’t want their exes around for selfish reasons.

I can, off the top of my head, think of 4 women I know fairly well who probably wish their exes would just disappear because it would genuinely be easier for their children who, instead, spend their lives being disappointed in their useless fathers.

But I stand by the earlier point - forums are like real life groups. You have to find one that works for you and perhaps the ones you're on aren't that helpful. MN's lone parents pages would probably be a much better and more supportive place.

SpinningFloppa · 27/02/2023 15:47

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 14:41

I think lots of people on this thread have acknowledged that it does happen occasionally. It's the suggestion by OP and others that it's often or all the time that people have had an issue with because that just does not seem to reflect the real life most people experience.

The odd woman who purposefully tries to keep children away from their father - sure, probably happens.

The bulk of women making a huge effort to facilitate contact between their DC and their exes - what we all see in real life.

I didn’t say it happens all the time I said it happens more than people believe, even if they don’t physically stop contact, they are resentful that their ex is around and wish they wouldn’t bother. Without fail when I post on these groups about DCs father not being around I get told I should be thankful he’s not, whilst I’m not suggesting it happens all the time I do believe a lot of women don’t want their exes around for selfish reasons.

OP posts:
MsMarch · 27/02/2023 15:45

Yes the mothers were happy to 'facilitate' contact but their starting position was never 50/50 and and the default assumption was 'a child's place is with the mother' (I have actually heard this phrase uttered on more then a few occasions). The men concerned were engaged fathers prior to separation and wanted to remain so, they sought accommodation in the neighbourhood so they could do school runs, all the extra curricular activities and generally 'be there'.

I don't buy the "child's place is with a mother" point and as someone whose DH was a SAHD and is still the primary childcare person, I think it's bollocks. Having said that, I do think in most relationships the women does tend to take on a lot more (even in mine - DH might spend more hours physically looking after the DC, but I still do a much higher proportion of the thinking, organising, planning, facilitating) so I understand why this is instinctive.

I've also met a couple of men in this situation who, down the line, have admitted that actually, 50/50 was much harder than they expected. To give them their due, the two men who have said this to me have both said they genuinely believed they were doing 50/50 so didn't understand their ex's initial reluctance until suddenly they had to make sure school uniforms were clean and school lunches were sorted etc. Chatting to a dad at one of DS' activities recently and I got the distinct impression that he was seriously pissed off becuase he had the DC during the holiday and therefore had to sort out their holiday club. But... he did it. So I'll take that as a win for 50/50 care!

DanseAvecLesLoup · 27/02/2023 15:24

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 14:41

I think lots of people on this thread have acknowledged that it does happen occasionally. It's the suggestion by OP and others that it's often or all the time that people have had an issue with because that just does not seem to reflect the real life most people experience.

The odd woman who purposefully tries to keep children away from their father - sure, probably happens.

The bulk of women making a huge effort to facilitate contact between their DC and their exes - what we all see in real life.

I appreciate this is anecdotal, I am in my late 40s and sadly a lot of the couples whose weddings I attending in my 20s are now seperated. The 'exDHs' concerned to the best of my knowledge were not abusive, had addiction issues, were cheating or were otherwise 'bad' people. The relationships failed and both parties divorced. Yes the mothers were happy to 'facilitate' contact but their starting position was never 50/50 and and the default assumption was 'a child's place is with the mother' (I have actually heard this phrase uttered on more then a few occasions). The men concerned were engaged fathers prior to separation and wanted to remain so, they sought accommodation in the neighbourhood so they could do school runs, all the extra curricular activities and generally 'be there'. I was surprised how these mums honestly thought they were initially being reasonable by proposing ('letting' or 'allowing') otherwise good loving fathers very limited contact each week and then getting the hump when this was rejected. Thankfully they were not involved in lengthy custody battles as common sense eventually prevailed (i.e. 50/50 shared custody).

Coyoacan · 27/02/2023 14:48

taxpayer1

Poor MRA, just because you are a bad father and man, does not mean that we think all or even the majority of men are like you.

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 14:41

FloydPepper · 27/02/2023 14:37

I think there’s truth in this, especially on a site like where the DNA/culture of the site is very much supportive of women. That can sometimes lead to thinking they can do no wrong.

I think lots of people on this thread have acknowledged that it does happen occasionally. It's the suggestion by OP and others that it's often or all the time that people have had an issue with because that just does not seem to reflect the real life most people experience.

The odd woman who purposefully tries to keep children away from their father - sure, probably happens.

The bulk of women making a huge effort to facilitate contact between their DC and their exes - what we all see in real life.

Mamamia32 · 27/02/2023 14:38

I'm not claiming to know anything about statistics. In my experience, nephew was used as a pawn by his mother and brother went to court, not because he was dragged there, quite the opposite. I also know of other children with rubbish dads and brilliant mothers. The OP's original post just clearly touched a nerve.

FloydPepper · 27/02/2023 14:37

Mamamia32 · 27/02/2023 12:55

I think a lot of women just don't want to believe that women keep children from thier fathers without good reason but they do. Not in every situation obviously but it happens.

I think there’s truth in this, especially on a site like where the DNA/culture of the site is very much supportive of women. That can sometimes lead to thinking they can do no wrong.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 14:25

Come on finger wagger, explain your point and show me how it's done according to your Google rules

FlippyFloppyShoe · 27/02/2023 14:24

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:02

I congratulate you. That should be the attitude. Of course, it is easier for you to remove the father as you don't have to discuss the religion, the school, the health, etc. But it is not good for your children.

Actually the reason I don't want him around is coz he adds nothing positive to my life except cash, he has had little interest in anything actually important for the children since they were born like school, homework, after-school clubs, friendships, healthy eating, emotional care, ie putting them first...he is considering things slightly more now he knows that they now see how little he does/did, but he will never change the fact that they are not his top priority and they see this and I have to deal with the ups and downs of that...plus all the workload of actually raising them, but he will play a blinder I'm sure, do sweet FA for most of their lives then put a couple of years effort towards the end of childhood so that they 'forget' how Disney like he was for the majority and people will heap praise on what an involved dad he is...and I will get told how lucky the children are that they have a good dad 🙄😡

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:21

9 Ways to Construct a Compelling Argument
Keep it simple. ...
Be fair on your opponent. ...
Avoid other common fallacies. ...
Make your assumptions clear. ...
Rest your argument on solid foundations. ...
Use evidence your readers will believe. ...
Avoid platitudes and generalisations, and be specific. ...
Understand the opposing point of view.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:20

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 14:12

@taxpayer1 - nice try but that's amateur grade effort. Is it your stance that one exceptional case makes a rule?

I assume so. But your point is not on point. If I say the vast majority child contact cases are resolved amicably, doesn't that mean your link falls into a category which is s minority?

Maybe you'd like to actually make an argument?

You don't have an argument as it is not based on anything.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 14:12

@taxpayer1 - nice try but that's amateur grade effort. Is it your stance that one exceptional case makes a rule?

I assume so. But your point is not on point. If I say the vast majority child contact cases are resolved amicably, doesn't that mean your link falls into a category which is s minority?

Maybe you'd like to actually make an argument?

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:08

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 14:05

@taxpayer1 - you are finger wagging and not thinking. If I say most people manage their arrangements fine, then that tells you that there is not a big issue with most splits except the emotional fall out. But cases in court will have other factors, because otherwise what happens is that these cases are resolved pretty fast since there is no real evidence of abuse or safeguarding risk.

This is about children, not the hurt feelings of parents. Those parents need to get over themselves like the vast majority do. Very few people like going to court. It is a real last resort. When people do go, it is always because no other way is available.

Like this you mean:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-humber-63349195

Mamma2bee · 27/02/2023 14:08

I've found this with my DP's ex. He's trying everything to see them more (no abuse in their relationship just one that didn't work out and he met me after that) but she's intent on keeping him away from the kids and since finding out we are expecting a baby (6 months in and exceptionally excited) she has been worse, cutting down the hours, erecting every barrier possible. I hate it as I love them so much and it's breaking my DP's heart, as well as the children's. 100% understand what you mean - she's like trying to phase him out which is preferable for her because then she doesn't have to deal with him moving on (out of sight out of mind kind of thing) and also then is playing the martyr 'he walked out on his kids etc' when in reality he's doing his utmost to see them more. It breaks my heart like because he's genuinely a really good dad and he's actually got physically sick all this.

Maybe this isn't other peoples' experience but it's definitely mine and DP's. I think there are some deadbeat dads but there are also some really really selfish mothers too in my experience.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 14:05

@taxpayer1 - you are finger wagging and not thinking. If I say most people manage their arrangements fine, then that tells you that there is not a big issue with most splits except the emotional fall out. But cases in court will have other factors, because otherwise what happens is that these cases are resolved pretty fast since there is no real evidence of abuse or safeguarding risk.

This is about children, not the hurt feelings of parents. Those parents need to get over themselves like the vast majority do. Very few people like going to court. It is a real last resort. When people do go, it is always because no other way is available.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:04

BiasedBinding · 27/02/2023 14:01

Yep, this kind of toys-out-of-the-pram thing shows that (1) you aren’t in good faith and (2) you can’t handle the fact that you can’t convince anyone

I am not trying to convince anyone. It is impossible to convince anyone that doesn't base their opinion on facts. I am just trying to relay my experience that supports the OP's experience.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:02

FlippyFloppyShoe · 27/02/2023 13:58

I would prefer it, coz ex is a dick and my life would be easier, but I can also appreciate my DC wouldn't prefer it and it is beneficial for them...but it isn't for me...the two things are entirely separate.

I congratulate you. That should be the attitude. Of course, it is easier for you to remove the father as you don't have to discuss the religion, the school, the health, etc. But it is not good for your children.

BiasedBinding · 27/02/2023 14:01

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:45

I apologise. I am convinced. There are no bad, vindictive mothers. I read it here. Also, I read here that 99.99999 percent of men are bad You are right. All men should be kept away from their children.

Yep, this kind of toys-out-of-the-pram thing shows that (1) you aren’t in good faith and (2) you can’t handle the fact that you can’t convince anyone

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 14:00

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 13:46

Hey taxpayer, you can check out the Ministry of Justice for the stats.

It is a minority of cases that go to court. Of those cases, there are disclosed factors to be considered by judges. That's the law as it applies. While not perfect, it means that we can see most cases which are going to court have such issues but these number of cases are tiny compared to the reasonable arrangements most parents make between each other,

So most splits are handled fine, but those minority of cases in court have to have some third party involvement for good reason. This is not new either. Most people can sort out their child arrangements without going to court and do.

How can you say "most splits are handled fine" without any knowledge? You don't know. I don't know either. You are just guessing and that is the problem. I was just trying to support the OP relating my experience but I didn't say most men are victims because I think I read it on Facebook. Or all men are good because my neighbor is good, etc. Believe what you want but at some point, it will affect you too. Even if you are a woman, your son (if you have one) will be affected in the future.

FlippyFloppyShoe · 27/02/2023 13:58

I would prefer it, coz ex is a dick and my life would be easier, but I can also appreciate my DC wouldn't prefer it and it is beneficial for them...but it isn't for me...the two things are entirely separate.

MsMarch · 27/02/2023 13:54

here are some statistics about court cases to number of family ratios

As stated by @LexMitior most situations are handled by families privately.

Triffid1 · 27/02/2023 13:49

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:45

I apologise. I am convinced. There are no bad, vindictive mothers. I read it here. Also, I read here that 99.99999 percent of men are bad You are right. All men should be kept away from their children.

Ooh, the over exaggerated sarcastic push back claiming things that NO ONE has said on this thread... it does (sadly) sometimes work in real life as the women it's used on feel the need to defend themselves. But it's not going to work here where we're all perfectly calm and know exactly what has and has not been said.

LexMitior · 27/02/2023 13:46

Hey taxpayer, you can check out the Ministry of Justice for the stats.

It is a minority of cases that go to court. Of those cases, there are disclosed factors to be considered by judges. That's the law as it applies. While not perfect, it means that we can see most cases which are going to court have such issues but these number of cases are tiny compared to the reasonable arrangements most parents make between each other,

So most splits are handled fine, but those minority of cases in court have to have some third party involvement for good reason. This is not new either. Most people can sort out their child arrangements without going to court and do.

taxpayer1 · 27/02/2023 13:45

I apologise. I am convinced. There are no bad, vindictive mothers. I read it here. Also, I read here that 99.99999 percent of men are bad You are right. All men should be kept away from their children.