Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for double embryo transfer?

157 replies

Dexy007 · 26/02/2023 07:53

I'll try to give all the relevant information upfront:

in my mid-30s, my husband and I didn't feel ready to be parents but were conscious of our ages so we paid privately for two rounds of IVF (it's not that expensive in the country we live in - not Europe) and over those two cycles we ended up with 10 x 5 day blastocysts. I was 36 (exactly) and 36 and two months when we did these cycles.

Although no known fertility issues (we had never tried to get pregnant) clinic said my husband had lazy sperm so they did ICSI + IVF. I mention this because there is a slightly heightened risk of multiple births with ICSI, and to explain why we aren't tempted to try to get pregnant naturally (it seems likely it won't happen for us with my husband's sperm, and my frozen embryos are 2.5 years younger than I am now...)

I'm now 38. Do I go for double embryo transfer or single? What would you do if you were me? If I am lucky and the transfer(s) work I would be 39 when I give birth. My clinic has of course explained the success rates to me and I know the odds are stacked against us.

I hate the idea of pregnancy and birth (it is a factor in why we just didn't feel able to follow the usual 'get engaged get married get pregnant' pathway). The idea of completing our family with a twin pregnancy is so tempting. We would be getting a FT nanny because we have no family support (live overseas) and because we both work full time and have hectic jobs/schedules so I think we could manage 3 years of chaos and sleepless nights with twins as well as we could manage a newborn and a toddler. Maybe I'm naive.

But of course the pregnancy would be riskier and twins face so many more issues.

Argh I don't know what to do. AIBU to ask for two embryos to be transferred? My clinic doesn't have any rules about it as such, they have just said it depends on lots of factors.

OP posts:
MuggedByTheSleepThief · 26/02/2023 09:39

Hi OP,
I think you have asked fair questions and given the surrounding facts as clearly as you can which seems to have resulted in uninvited and imho unfair comments about your motivation. You are obviously a common sense analytical person trying to make a massive decision. Well done you for considering all the factors you outline including you career. I remember approaching motherhood decisions at times in the same way - it’s fucking ludicrous if you think about it - signing up for an utterly life changing irreversible move with no direct knowledge of the experience, so you end up mustering as many tangibles as you can to work through it. I utterly adore my kids , zero regrets but had no real understanding of this when planning. You sound wonderful, thoughtful and intelligent - great material for a mother! I’m afraid I don’t know anything about ivf but the criticism you were receiving is unfair bollocks so just wanted to say good luck. For what it’s worth I would approach the specific question of what to implant based on your medical professional’s opinion - ie pin them down re stats on relative success rates of 1 vs 2 as advice upthread from more knowledgeable posters suggests. News to me for example that 2 may decrease vs give you double the chance of success. Good luck - kids would be lucky to have you as a mum.

Babyenroute · 26/02/2023 09:37

I understand why you are choosing to use your embryos from two years ago rather than try naturally OP. I would say one embryo, as someone who would have quite wanted two in the past to get the family starting out of the way, before pregnancy and having the baby. Twins would be a whole new level of stress medically and I think the risk of complications would be double that of two separate singleton pregnancies, especially with a high stress demanding job (you don't want 9 months of worry).

ItchyBillco · 26/02/2023 09:35

At 6 or 9 months I wouldn't have a child in childcare Monday to Friday 8.30 to 5.30. That's just cruel.

You think it’s cruel to have 6-9 month old baby with a 1:1 nanny, 8:30-5:30, at home, where the OP works anyway?

Come off it.

I had a nanny for similar hours from when my baby was three months. She is a loving woman, we consider her part of our family, my son adores her and she is still with us nearly three years on. What’s cruel about that?

And as @countrypunk said, the OP’s reasons for wanting a family are brilliant. She doesn’t want a baby to play with, she wants someone to grow with and show the world to, someone to treasure and share things with.

Some of the sanctimonious know-it-all mother types on here saying she doesn’t really want or deserve a baby are really tedious.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 26/02/2023 09:35

We also had 10+ embryos to start with, 2 rounds of failed IVF with just then, we decided to try with two, and of course I got pregnant with twins!
Scary at first actually a blessing.

Pregnancy was fine, twins are high risk so you have more scans which is nice. You also can have an elective C section without having to insist.
And talking childcare, a nanny is not much more than two places at nursery!

Dexy007 · 26/02/2023 09:34

00100001 · 26/02/2023 09:26

The context given was "We would be getting a FT nanny because we have no family support (live overseas) and because we both work full time and have hectic jobs/schedules"

Implication: they work very long and odd hours, perhaps not knowing what time they'll be home or if they will get called away and that a FT nanny would be raising the kids on the most part, perhaps living in.

But OP changed her tone to say "mon-fri 9-5" type of normal working hours for most people. Which isn't the same as hectic jobs and schedules.

Neither of us have 9-5 jobs but I’m not aware you can get a nanny that works more than a 40 hour week!

i think we will have to make do and help each other out. You know - I have an emergency board meeting and he’ll have to move some deadlines and let some people down. And sometimes he will have a crisis and I’ll have to man the fort at home. Like I imagine most parents do….. share the load and juggle it as best they can.

bit odd that the idea of two parents with high pressure jobs is so radical tbh.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 26/02/2023 09:32

MrsMTJ · 26/02/2023 09:17

Hi OP, you seem to be getting some more measured responses now (instead of the earlier ones wanting to nitpick how you'd written your post rather than answer the question!).

We had lots of IVF to have our children and I read lots of literature too - the most recent studies are tending towards saying that a double transfer can lessen the chances of any implantation at all. However, it sounds like you have high quality embryos and so your chances of success are probably high enough that you could have twins.

I completely understand the urge to only go through everything once but still have two children - I felt like that too at first. My firstborn was very early though and we spent time in hospital. The number of twins in SCBU with us was eye opening and when we found out we were successfully pregnant with our second, I was terrified it could be twins.

It is your decision to make, of course, but knowing what I now do, I'm really grateful that we had two singletons. Pregnancy is tough but wasn't awful for me and I love that we had a chance to enjoy two baby stages separately. I know you've said you're more interested in the child your baby would become but I thought that too and actually they gain their personalities so early! Watching my older child become a sibling has been really joyful too.

Good luck with whatever you decide x

This is interesting information and I would explore it. I had 2 transferred each time due to my age. Dd was the result of a 3rd try.

You need to make your decision based on aiming for one healthy child, not 2. Ivf is already a riskier pregnancy. Getting one embryo to stick is the most important thing to overcome.

gamerchick · 26/02/2023 09:32

So maybe just one.

gamerchick · 26/02/2023 09:31

I'd say one just going on your posts. You can't rigidly plan for a baby to slot neatly into your life. It's lik a bomb going off, you have no idea how pregnancy will be for you, you could sail through it, but equally could be in and out of hospital. Everyone expects a child without disabilities but don't always get them.

Good luck OP. Hope it's everything you expect.

countrypunk · 26/02/2023 09:28

@Dexy007 I didn't have my embryos tested. Not much point with two. Also I've read conflicting accounts - apparently abnormal embryos can self correct after transfer. It's a very difficult decision. Not sure what I'll do on my next round.

Best of luck to you 🙂

Xol · 26/02/2023 09:28

Go for single transfers, much better chance of success.

Pardon45 · 26/02/2023 09:28

I had several double embro transfers. I got pregnant on two occasions. On both occasions I lost one twin at 7ish weeks and the next at 11ish weeks. The miscarriage of one triggered the loss of the other. Obviously, you can't say for sure if either would have survived as a single pregnancy. I personally would transfer one.

00100001 · 26/02/2023 09:26

Kranke · 26/02/2023 09:23

What? Every parent I know works. I don’t know any stay at home mums or dads, working is perfectly normal and essential in some cases.

The context given was "We would be getting a FT nanny because we have no family support (live overseas) and because we both work full time and have hectic jobs/schedules"

Implication: they work very long and odd hours, perhaps not knowing what time they'll be home or if they will get called away and that a FT nanny would be raising the kids on the most part, perhaps living in.

But OP changed her tone to say "mon-fri 9-5" type of normal working hours for most people. Which isn't the same as hectic jobs and schedules.

Kranke · 26/02/2023 09:23

00100001 · 26/02/2023 08:06

I find it odd that you're planning already to not be around for first 3 years of their lives, the most crucial part of their development.and have a Nanny raise them full time. Confused

that aside, twins are a high risk pregnancy for all involved.

What? Every parent I know works. I don’t know any stay at home mums or dads, working is perfectly normal and essential in some cases.

Eixample · 26/02/2023 09:21

The lower quality embryo reduces the implantation chances of the higher quality one, so for that reason I wouldn’t.
I have known five people pregnant with twins. Two of them had twins who died when they were still in the hospital, one pair have cerebral palsy from the delivery and two pairs are fine (although one pair was in the NICU for months). People underestimate how risky a twin pregnancy is

Newmumatlast · 26/02/2023 09:21

Skinnermarink · 26/02/2023 08:01

Something about the way you’ve described all this makes me uncomfortable.

Same to be honest. And I had IVF.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 26/02/2023 09:19

Dexy007 · 26/02/2023 08:37

Can i be honest with you Binfluencer? I don't WANT a baby, i want a family. I want little people to love and take on holiday and show the world. I want to be 65 and have my son/daughter bring their beau round for tea on a Sunday. I have no relationship with my one sibling and I've made my peace with that but DH and I are nice people (i think!) and i think we would do a good job of being parents.

And what happens if you end up with a child with disabilities then? Its not always that simple.

Dexy007 · 26/02/2023 09:19

countrypunk · 26/02/2023 08:52

Can i be honest with you Binfluencer? I don't WANT a baby, i want a family. I want little people to love and take on holiday and show the world. I want to be 65 and have my son/daughter bring their beau round for tea on a Sunday. I have no relationship with my one sibling and I've made my peace with that but DH and I are nice people (i think!) and i think we would do a good job of being parents.

These are MUCH better reasons for having children than the standard 'I want a baby'.

Ten embryos is a great number OP. I've had IVF and got 2 embryos from one round, so there was never much question for me - one transferred each time. I think if I were in your exact shoes I would have PGT-A done on the embryos, then one transferred and see what happens. There are so many risks with twin pregnancies - for you and the babies. It's easy to romanticise having twins but I have friends with them and it's really, really hard.

yes testing is a very good idea….but my clinic doesn’t offer testing. So they’d need to be transferred, thawed by new clinic, a little cell nicked from each, refrozen….I gather it’s a bit dangerous for the embryos.

if I did it again I’d have used a clinic that can do testing and then my understanding is that they can pinch a cell or two from the blast before freezing it and then test the cells they pinched. You live and learn!

OP posts:
MrsMTJ · 26/02/2023 09:17

Hi OP, you seem to be getting some more measured responses now (instead of the earlier ones wanting to nitpick how you'd written your post rather than answer the question!).

We had lots of IVF to have our children and I read lots of literature too - the most recent studies are tending towards saying that a double transfer can lessen the chances of any implantation at all. However, it sounds like you have high quality embryos and so your chances of success are probably high enough that you could have twins.

I completely understand the urge to only go through everything once but still have two children - I felt like that too at first. My firstborn was very early though and we spent time in hospital. The number of twins in SCBU with us was eye opening and when we found out we were successfully pregnant with our second, I was terrified it could be twins.

It is your decision to make, of course, but knowing what I now do, I'm really grateful that we had two singletons. Pregnancy is tough but wasn't awful for me and I love that we had a chance to enjoy two baby stages separately. I know you've said you're more interested in the child your baby would become but I thought that too and actually they gain their personalities so early! Watching my older child become a sibling has been really joyful too.

Good luck with whatever you decide x

EmilyGilmoresSass · 26/02/2023 09:17

Dexy007 · 26/02/2023 08:15

I do plan to take mat leave! Sorry I guess I should have said that, I assumed it was kind of a given. I get 6 months full pay and then DH would probably do 3 months (he is self employed so no paternity leave).

I am not sure what you guys have in mind but when i say FT nanny i'm talking like 8.30 - 5.30pm Monday to Friday....you know, like childcare! Lots of parents have to put their young children in full time childcare of some sort. I don't think it should be controversial in this day and age.

At 6 or 9 months I wouldn't have a child in childcare Monday to Friday 8.30 to 5.30. That's just cruel.

Binfluencer · 26/02/2023 09:07

@Dexy007

That makes sense! I didn't really want a baby or toddler either! The chaos, the lack of sleep, the bloody crafts.

But they are late primary/secondary now and much more rewarding.

EthicalNonMahogany · 26/02/2023 09:06

two cycles with single transfer is as likely to produce success as one with two. Stats are hard to read but broadly get you to that.

If it's male factor I'd just go for it now with one transfer.

IWillBeWaxingAnOwl · 26/02/2023 09:03

You will get good advice on the infertility boards here, although I'd recommend being transparent and thoughtful that your situation isn't exactly infertility.

I would recommend a singleton

secular39 · 26/02/2023 08:55

Twins are more riskier in my opinion and appear to have more risks of having disabilities compared to singleton born children.

Ifitistobesaid · 26/02/2023 08:55

I wouldn’t do it, especially as your embryos are likely to be good quality. I’ve been in the infertility world a long time and have seen some very tragic stories with twin pregnancies.

Heyjoewhatsup · 26/02/2023 08:53

You need to be very aware of the possibility of birth defects / complications and how you would manage that. You need to be open

The risks when me and my friends had babies in later 30s are 1 in 27 chance. BUT it turned out me and every single one of my mum friends had birth defects which has a huge impact on you. We were unlucky but it’s not that uncommon.

For me, my DC was in a medical devise full time for months, we had weekly hospital visits for months, surgery. They have to wear a medical device for a good few years and we have regular hospital appointments until adulthood. Friends are in similar boat with different conditions (eye, heart, feet … all birth defects).

Then there are special needs and neurodiversity - half the families I know have 1 child with additional needs or mental health problems. They are really common now.

You cannot outsource these responsibilities to a nanny. One or both of you need flexibility to deal with these responsibilities and your child has to come before your career. I say this as a career woman.

If you want twins go for it, but you need to be ready and willing to be flexible and adapt. You cannot predict and control what going to happen unlike your career.