Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my brother didn’t deserve to die

161 replies

Azurehawker · 25/02/2023 22:10

My brother died of an accidental drug overdose last month, he was 41 years old. When he died the attitude of a lot of people seems to be that this is what is expected when someone has been a heroin user most of their life, and it was choices he made that lead to his death so there is no one to blame for this but him. I have to admit that to me this felt almost inevitable given how he lived his life and part of me is angry that he let this happen.

Although he was once popular and well liked by the time he died he had few real friends left, some having died already or not been able to stay in contact with him in case it jeopardised their own attempts at staying off heroin. Some people just didn’t want to be around him anymore, by the time he was in his late 30s my brother was a very obvious drug user. If you met him you would probably label him as a ‘junkie’ straight away.

However he had managed to hold down a job and work most of his life. Although people knew about his drug addiction, they also knew he was a hard worker and respected him for that. He had some minor convictions for drug related crime although he had never been to prison or been convicted of a violent crime.

He openly admitted he had mental health problems, and was severely depressed. We knew that he spent his adult life trying and failing to beat his drug addiction and we tried to support him as best we could while not actually enabling him to continue taking drugs.

We had what you might call a ‘difficult’ childhood and my brother became a troubled teen, he didn’t do well at school, he got into fights and was involved with gangs, took party drugs, shoplifted etc. He and his friends were targeted by much older members of a county lines gang who introduced them to heroin, they all became addicts although many of them eventually got clean and went on to live normal lives.

When people ask how he died I sometimes lie and tell them the cause of death is ‘unexplained’ because telling them he died of a heroin overdose instantly labels him as a ‘junkie’ and in most people’s eyes a waste of space, undeserving of sympathy and respect, a person who’s life was worth nothing compared to someone who has bravely fought and lost their life to cancer or another more socially acceptable illness.

AIBU to believe that the death of my funny, kind and caring brother was a tragedy, that he was a person who was deeply depressed and damaged by a traumatic childhood, from the moment he was introduced to heroin he never really had a hope of beating drug addiction, although he tried. And that he didn’t deserve to live his life like this or to die.

OP posts:
Namechange10101010 · 26/02/2023 00:35

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:59

Depending on the drug, and especially if introduced young, it very quickly rewires your brain.
OP’mentioned gangs, they’ll give you the worst ones to keep clients.
I disagree with your position about it being an illness, but respect it in the way you see it, but isn’t that also true for many illnesses (obesity etc) that have much less stigma ?

I guess I'm consistent as I would also class obesity as something strong enough in its own sense to describe the absolute struggle many people have with their weight. Sadly many obese people and substance misusers then develop related conditions / illness. Again respect those with differing opinions.

By rewiring of the brain are you talking about the illegal opiates binding to pain receptors causing dreadful withdrawals and constant chasing and failing to get the initial highs, then replacing it with the methadone that binds even more tightly causing more intense addiction and withdrawals or changes in brain plasticity?

The former I have previously done a little research on (and forgotten most), but believe happens very quickly and is the reason for addiction being so hard to beat, becoming more intense with the length of the addiction, but repairable over time. Not helped by the somewhat understandable reluctance of many medical professionals to adequately medicate pain with anything stronger than a paracetamol for genuine fear of overdose or further addiction, when research actually shows that due to the blocking of the pain receptors and high tolerance addicted individuals need higher levels of pain relief for the same results.

The latter I haven't researched in terms of addiction but have in terms of PD and CPTSD which is often a contributor to addiction and I'd guess substance misuse exacerbates and further distorts the brain enlarging the emotional and reducing the reasoning. For a long time it was believed that post brain maturity this was fixed, but modern research shows that the brain retains its plasticity (sp?) and can be rewritten through CBT, DBT etc. I'd hope this relatively new knowledge of brain plasticity would also be true of being able to undue changes due to opiate misuse.

Of course then you're back to the chicken and egg of needing to fix the underlying issues to give the best chance of recovery from addiction, but almost always being told this person has capacity and needs to stop taking drugs before we will assess and treat mental health.

Fully agree with gangs, very organised business. Don't forget the freebies through the door when people are clean or the intentionally giving unaffordable credit to tighten their grip.

I fucking hate drugs!

ArcaneWireless · 26/02/2023 00:32

@OllytheCollie

A beautiful end to a kind and thoughtful post.

ThreeLocusts · 26/02/2023 00:31

OP I'm sorry for your loss, sorry your brother had such a hard life and sorry that you still have to deal with the stigma of addiction.

It's good that you're here to remember him, the bad and the good. Take care

Requiem - tearful the day

Billslills · 26/02/2023 00:30

I am truly sorry for your loss. Your brother did not deserve the life he was dealt with. Addiction is a very real illness and no one deserves it. He is everything you've described him to be, kind, funny, loving hardworking. Sending lots of love your way.

OllytheCollie · 26/02/2023 00:26

I am sorry for your loss. I hope you are able to spend time focusing on the happy memories you must have of your kind funny brother.

I agree our society doesn't value the lives of people with addiction enough. We could do so much more to help people than we do currently. But lots of people who love people with addiction care very much, and so do many people who work with people with addiction. I am sure your brothers loss is being felt deeply by many around him. And maybe his kindness and some of the gifts he had to offer live on in you. He didn't deserve to die, but he did deserve your love and that's quite a big thing to have had.

Azurehawker · 26/02/2023 00:17

Thank you. It has honestly made me feel better to know that so many people are willing to offer sympathy for his death. I am always torn on how to handle it when people ask, we know from his history and the account of people who were with him that his death was caused by heroin, possibly mixed with other drugs. But the full toxicology results are not available yet so the working cause of death is ‘unexplained medical’ and that is what I tell people who ask. But the more time that goes by the more I want to tell people his story and what he went though in his life in the hope that they can understand that he was not a bad person.

I’m so sorry to everyone else who has posted on this thread that they know or have lost someone to drug addiction, it truly is awful to witness someone you love go though this 💐

OP posts:
shockthemonkey · 26/02/2023 00:13

I am so sorry for your pain, and for his.

Wider society as you call it should jolly well think “there but for the grace of god”. I think you might be surprised at the number of people whose close family have been touched by addiction. There is no place for judgement of any kind.

derbylass81 · 26/02/2023 00:08

So very sorry for the loss of your lovely brother. He was let down horribly but he is at peace now Flowers

PlanetLuna · 26/02/2023 00:05

@Azurehawker I’m sorry for the loss of your beloved brother. It’s a heartbreaking loss, no matter the cause, and you are not being unreasonable to feel the way you do.

Addiction is a serious illness, and your brother did not deserve to die. No one needs to feel ashamed for suffering from addiction or having a loved one who is/has suffered from it. ❤️

elenacampana · 26/02/2023 00:04

I have two uncles who passed in their early 50s, one was abused as a child, the other saw active service in Northern Ireland. One could never beat alcohol and the other didn’t really try. I wish they’d been able to come out of the other side of addiction and that my Nana hadn’t had to experience their losses within 8 months of each other or know, especially with the second one, that they had ‘done it to themselves’.

They died in 2005, we talk about them all the time and I know my Nana loves the bones of them, even though it’s been so long since she last saw them and the end of their lives brought her so much pain. I feel that somewhere out there, they are together, arguing about something… sober and finally content.

NomiMacaroni · 26/02/2023 00:03

What an excellent point.

dottycat123 · 26/02/2023 00:03

I have been a mental health nurse for over 30 years and have been involved with countless addicts who die prematurely. I have over the years formed a view on why so few people manage to beat the addiction and treatment offered fails so often. We know that most addicts have experienced trauma of some kind and need help with that but my view is that there is too great an expectation on addicts to make wise choices. I believe that if as a society we had legislation which allowed HCPs to have more power to enforce rehabilitation programs ( not just brief detox) which lasted 6-12 months there would be a greater long term success in people being able to stay off alcohol/ drugs. Addicts don't really fall under the powers of the MHA or MCA or if they do it is for a brief period. As soon as a person is deemed to have capacity they are free to make unwise decisions. I am aware that enforced treatment is abhorrent to the majority but the system in place now relies too much on addicts making sensible choices. In my role as a mental health liaison nurse we see addicts repeatedly in ED or on the general hospital wards withdrawing and know that many will be dead soon. There are people in their late teens/ early 20's who are known to services, have drug/ alcohol workers supporting them but still die and no one is surprised. There is no simple solution but current systems are not working and an alternative would require a complete change and have huge cost implications , making it very unlikely.

Sickofcoughing · 26/02/2023 00:00

I'm so sorry for your loss op and that your brother's life was so tough.

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:59

Namechange10101010 · 25/02/2023 23:55

Agree, I wish that laws could change, more could be done to stop imports of heroin and contraversially that addicts were classed as lacking capacity due to the strength of their addiction. I'm not in the camp that thinks it's an illness, addiction is a strong enough term for me and starts with a choice unlike illness - respect those who disagree.

Name changed as I'd never say this in real life but if the addict in my life died I would be devastated but also relieved and think finally he is at peace. He is also functioning most of the time - unable to work due to the damage done to his body, diagnosed with mental illness due to childhood trauma, decent periods of clean time then relapses, begs for rehab, but instead forced onto high doses of methadone. (family pay for rehab when we can which gives him his life back, unlike methadone which dulls)

My sympathies for your loss.

Depending on the drug, and especially if introduced young, it very quickly rewires your brain.
OP’mentioned gangs, they’ll give you the worst ones to keep clients.
I disagree with your position about it being an illness, but respect it in the way you see it, but isn’t that also true for many illnesses (obesity etc) that have much less stigma ?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/02/2023 23:59

I'm so sorry for your loss. Addiction is an illness. I'm so sorry that your brother wasn't able to get the better of that illness, but it wasn't his fault and of course he didn't deserve to die. His life was as valuable as anyone else's. I'm sorry that you've had to deal with some stupid, insensitive people who clearly don't understand what they're saying.

SnobblyBobbly · 25/02/2023 23:59

People always ask how someone died when they die young don’t they? I think their main motivation is to look for a reason why it can’t happen to them..

’Drug addict? Oh well then.’ (Won’t happen to me)
’Heart Attack? Didn’t her dad have heart problems?’ (Won’t happen to me)
’Cancer? Oh and her sister had it?’ (Won’t happen to me)

You’re absolutely right to love and protect your brother & his memory - ‘people’ generally haven’t got a clue and I’m really sorry things didn’t work out differently.

Tellmemore16 · 25/02/2023 23:58

3 children that should have said x

Tellmemore16 · 25/02/2023 23:57

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:50

Completely agree, it’s admirable he tried so hard.
I was taken into care at 10 because it became obvious my mother just wasn’t bothered (never ever accepted any suggestions of help).

I’m sorry to hear you had such a difficult time too, if I didn’t have such a solid dad I would have ended up in care too.

Now that I am a parent I can’t imagine not even at least trying for my son to get better, I suppose I will never understand how she felt as luckily I haven’t battled any addictions but from the outside she came accords as cold, uncaring and very indifferent that her 3 weren’t in her life.

I hope you have still managed to do ok in life despite your mums actions xx

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 25/02/2023 23:55

Yanbu I'm so sorry for your loss iv struggled with addiction and I know how judgemental people can be. Your brother deserved better 🥺

Namechange10101010 · 25/02/2023 23:55

Agree, I wish that laws could change, more could be done to stop imports of heroin and contraversially that addicts were classed as lacking capacity due to the strength of their addiction. I'm not in the camp that thinks it's an illness, addiction is a strong enough term for me and starts with a choice unlike illness - respect those who disagree.

Name changed as I'd never say this in real life but if the addict in my life died I would be devastated but also relieved and think finally he is at peace. He is also functioning most of the time - unable to work due to the damage done to his body, diagnosed with mental illness due to childhood trauma, decent periods of clean time then relapses, begs for rehab, but instead forced onto high doses of methadone. (family pay for rehab when we can which gives him his life back, unlike methadone which dulls)

My sympathies for your loss.

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:53

EnglishRain · 25/02/2023 23:45

I am so sorry to hear about your brother, OP. My brother died prematurely also (aged 31) and I can relate in terms of feeling protective about him and his cause of death.

I am probably quite naive when it comes to drugs. Despite that, I just think it's desperately sad for any life to be extinguished prematurely. In my mind drugs seem to be a coping mechanism in a lot of cases, and yes an unhealthy one, but a way out of sheer desperation to want to be able to cope and stick around longer. I have no doubt there would be a very strong relationship between mental health issues and drug use. And it feels like mental health support in this nation is so poor due to a lack of resource.

I'm rambling, what I really wanted to say was being so naive about drugs, I'm probably someone who could be perceived to be very judgemental. However, I just think it is so desperately sad and that your brother was let down in so many ways. The word 'junkie' doesn't even come to mind. I expect plenty of others would think as I do, and that it is just your closeness to the situation which makes you worry so much about what others think. But I really don't think that's as accurate as your brain might make you believe x

Love your post as you mention not knowing much.
I think a lot has been said already, so I won’t repeat, but the world needs more people like you

Forfrigz · 25/02/2023 23:53

His death is a tragedy no less than anyone else dying young from something horrible they couldn't overcome. Although there is stigma attached to drug overdose, many more people these days realise it's a disease just like any other mental illness (with very real physical elements). I'm so sorry for your loss.

DancyNancy · 25/02/2023 23:52

I'm really sorry for your loss OP. It sounds like your brother struggled with pain all through his life, a soul deep sadness. I'm not religious, but I hope his soul is at peace now.
It must be an enormously heavy grief for you. A family friend struggled with addiction and died accidentally in his 30s. I had little to no contact directly in adulthood, but I feel so filled with sadness when I think of him because I remember him as a very regular part of my childhood and I can't believe he's gone, that boy I knew. I can only imagine when it's your brother, the life connection there

It's a difficult grief as there's stigma and fear around the way he died.

Again, I'm so sorry for your loss and I can hear from your words that the sadness you are carrying is so heavy, so be kind to yourself and consider seeking support with others who have been there xx

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:50

Tellmemore16 · 25/02/2023 23:45

I’m so sorry for your loss, it is admiral that your brother fought so hard to try beat his addiction and also worked during this whilst living with a mental health condition. I hope he is at peace xx

my mum was a heroin addict and I had a pretty brutal childhood because of it however my experience is completely different from yours in that she didn’t want or try to get better and blamed everyone else, in the end she managed to come off the heroin but died a couple of years ago from an alcohol addiction. No one wants to be like that but I lost respect for her because she never even once tried to stop even after being offered the best rehab money could buy and the support of a very loving family. Addiction is so sad, no one wants to live like that and I salute anyone who tries to get better and crawl back from such a dark place

sending you my love and wishes

Completely agree, it’s admirable he tried so hard.
I was taken into care at 10 because it became obvious my mother just wasn’t bothered (never ever accepted any suggestions of help).

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 23:47

Blankscreen · 25/02/2023 23:40

Op I'm so sorry for you loss.

My bil died 4 years ago and was an alcoholic. I think one of the saddest things of the 'what did he expect' attitude is that it attempts to minimalist your grief almost brush it under the carpet. I think it's an excuse for some people when they don't know what to say.

First and foremost he was your brother that you loved. Hold onto that. He wasn't just an addict. X

I wouldn’t excuse it as don’t know what to say, either they offer condolences for his illness, or f*uck the hell off.

At least that’s what I always tried to teach my kids in care : it’s an illness, anyone who says otherwise isn’t worth your time (bit trickier with the teens, got a few punches from them to people who reacted like idiots, it was really hard to manage ; no serious injuries or convictions fortunately, but we did have to have really serious conversations with the older ones about criminal convictions for assault). It’s so hard