Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my brother didn’t deserve to die

161 replies

Azurehawker · 25/02/2023 22:10

My brother died of an accidental drug overdose last month, he was 41 years old. When he died the attitude of a lot of people seems to be that this is what is expected when someone has been a heroin user most of their life, and it was choices he made that lead to his death so there is no one to blame for this but him. I have to admit that to me this felt almost inevitable given how he lived his life and part of me is angry that he let this happen.

Although he was once popular and well liked by the time he died he had few real friends left, some having died already or not been able to stay in contact with him in case it jeopardised their own attempts at staying off heroin. Some people just didn’t want to be around him anymore, by the time he was in his late 30s my brother was a very obvious drug user. If you met him you would probably label him as a ‘junkie’ straight away.

However he had managed to hold down a job and work most of his life. Although people knew about his drug addiction, they also knew he was a hard worker and respected him for that. He had some minor convictions for drug related crime although he had never been to prison or been convicted of a violent crime.

He openly admitted he had mental health problems, and was severely depressed. We knew that he spent his adult life trying and failing to beat his drug addiction and we tried to support him as best we could while not actually enabling him to continue taking drugs.

We had what you might call a ‘difficult’ childhood and my brother became a troubled teen, he didn’t do well at school, he got into fights and was involved with gangs, took party drugs, shoplifted etc. He and his friends were targeted by much older members of a county lines gang who introduced them to heroin, they all became addicts although many of them eventually got clean and went on to live normal lives.

When people ask how he died I sometimes lie and tell them the cause of death is ‘unexplained’ because telling them he died of a heroin overdose instantly labels him as a ‘junkie’ and in most people’s eyes a waste of space, undeserving of sympathy and respect, a person who’s life was worth nothing compared to someone who has bravely fought and lost their life to cancer or another more socially acceptable illness.

AIBU to believe that the death of my funny, kind and caring brother was a tragedy, that he was a person who was deeply depressed and damaged by a traumatic childhood, from the moment he was introduced to heroin he never really had a hope of beating drug addiction, although he tried. And that he didn’t deserve to live his life like this or to die.

OP posts:
Boogismyname · 26/02/2023 20:30

You are definitely NOT being unreasonable.
How insensitive for people to suggest otherwise.
I'd be so upset if my brother died, and wouldn't think he deserved it no matter what the cause.

autumnboys · 26/02/2023 20:29

I’m so sorry about your brother, how painful for you. I can hear how sad you are. YANBU at all to be choosy about what you tell people.

missymousey · 26/02/2023 20:22

So glad to see that most on here are good hearted. If you want to tell us more about your brother and what he meant to you, we will listen.

Mimilamore · 26/02/2023 13:54

There is always a bigger picture.... you're brother mattered, I'm sorry x

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 26/02/2023 13:31

My Dsis died of aggressive cancer. Everyone has been sympathetic. My friends 's DBro and another friend's adult DS died of suicide and overdose. But the reality is whatever had caused Dsis and their DS and DBro to die , we each face the same loss, same devastation, and there is no difference to our grief. We each have regrets we couldn't stop it.

In some ways my two friends face a more complicated grieving process than I do/ did, precisely because they wish they had known earlier and could have prevented it. It makes for a head f-ck of angst and even more frantic wishing to go back to change the outcome. Complex grief is always harder to get over (if you ever do) as it's harder to process. It's the ruminating that gets to you of what should I have done differently, then "If Only"s.

All our friendship groups are as kind and sympathetic to my friends as they are to me. So luckily I haven't seen any unkindness. Obvs everyone is even more mindful and thoughtful over a longer period of time to the friend who lost her young adult son to OD bc that was her son. She hasn't said if there has been any judgement from any individuals. I can imagine she'd make short shrift of anyone being dismissive as would all of us, as our hearts go out to her same as if any other illness took him. None of it is fair.

Turnipworkharder · 26/02/2023 13:26

As I always say to any people who judge.
Do you really think that person chose to become an addict to drugs/alcohol and normally end up homeless on the streets ?

Never judge others as you could easily be next, given the right circumstances.

So very sorry for you OP and all others who's lives are blighted by addiction.

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 26/02/2023 13:19

I'm so sorry for your loss @Azurehawker

It is traumatic. You know why he struggled with addiction , what his childhood was like and empathised with him

He's still your brother and his death affects you same as if he died any other route. I wouldn't share how he died with other people I'd you find most people are judgy. The fact is he died and you miss him. Some people do drugs and alcohol to escape painful feelings. It's never as simple as " choosing to be an addict"

Yanbu to feel angry at the world having lost your DBro
It's a normal part of grief complicated by the fact he may have died of an accidental overdose. The coroner may give you a different cause of death eg heart or organ failure (that may be related to drug misuse) and maybe that's ultimately what you tell people going forward without the drug part. That's your DBros private business you don't have to over explain to random people

Of course he didn't deserve to die. And his loss is a tragedy. He was too young and it was before his time.

glittereyelash · 26/02/2023 09:24

I'm so sorry. Death is hard no matter what the circumstances are. Hope you have lots of support

Boringcookingquestion · 26/02/2023 09:02

Addiction is an illness and, like many illnesses, the chance of recovery depends on many factors that the sufferer can’t control.

Your brother didn’t recover and that is tragic. I’m so so sorry for your loss Flowers

pollykitty · 26/02/2023 08:59

Both my brothers were drug addicts for portions of their life. They are now both clean. Similar to yours, they always had jobs and supported themselves. Were kind and caring through their drug use, although I didn’t speak to them for long periods of time because they just wouldn’t talk to family members. One brother really had a hard time quitting but he did it. I’m really proud of both of them. You have my deepest sympathies.

dottiedodah · 26/02/2023 08:53

I find it astonishing how so many people can just write off a life ,because the person died of something else than the "permitted route"of illness or accident.I feel your loss .A relation took their own life a couple of years ago ,and people didnt understand .He was depressed with many issues.People can be very cruel. Drugs are very difficult to move away from .

OurChristmasMiracle · 26/02/2023 08:43

I read it as he was a victim of a county lives drug syndicate and as a result they got him addicted to a drug so that they had control over him as they would have been his source of supply meaning getting out of that situation would have been very very difficult. They had targeted him because he had a bad childhood and wasn’t doing well at school.

to me he was a victim and heroin was his own way of dealing with his demons. You have every right to mourn his death and my heart goes out to you and to him.

ClairDeLaLune · 26/02/2023 08:37

No-one would choose that life for themselves. Your dear brother was a tragic victim of awful circumstances. I’m sorry for your loss OP and for your ongoing grief Flowers

inkblink · 26/02/2023 07:03

I'm very sorry OP. My brother died of a heroin overdose aged 21. I felt like that then allowed people to judge him as just a junkie (including the police, and coroner and some of my so called friends) rather than the funny, outrageous, kind, loving person that he was. He didn't in any way deserve to die, and neither did your brother. Thinking of you x

kateandme · 26/02/2023 06:46

hope you ok today op. just wanted to check in and say thinking of you at this time.

givemeanother · 26/02/2023 04:23

Your brother absolutely didn't deserve to die. I too lost my brother to addiction in his 40s and it is a damn complicated grief wishing he'd been able to recover, and not knowing what to tell people about it. My heart goes out to you, but hopefully what you can see from this thread is that many people know someone affected by addiction, it's just not talked about enough.

My own brothers addiction was exacerbated by covid lockdowns and I'm sure he wasn't alone in that. I try to remember him for the positives of how he influenced me growing up, but hard to shake the unfairness of the life he was dealt Flowers

user1496262496 · 26/02/2023 02:21

He didn’t deserve to die. It sounds like he was failed massively by society. Failed by healthcare, didn’t get the help he needed.

You should be proud of him and remember him for his achievements and the love you shared. Sod what those ignorant people say. They are part of the problem.

OldFan · 26/02/2023 02:19

It feels wrong for anyone to die at 41 @Azurehawker . So sorry for your loss. x

DFAMA · 26/02/2023 02:11

Yanbu at all! I'm so sorry for your loss. I can't imagine how difficult it must have been to watch him spiral while being utterly powerless to do anything, all while knowing what had led him there. To then have to deal with judgemental people belittling his life and making you feel that your grief is less valid because of his "choices" is appalling.

Your brother was so much more than the labels put on him by judgy people. It is utterly tragic that he was taken in that way, so young and having fought against the tide for so long. Take no notice of the narrow minded idiots, however much they might like to cling on to their misguided sense of superiority, they have absolutely no clue about the people they judge so easily and their ignorance is repulsive to anyone who has half a brain

PatsysBeehive · 26/02/2023 01:47

I haven't read the whole thread, but I'm so sorry.
I saw at the bottom of page one someone mentioned rehabs. Ime, which is limited, rehab is definitely not a fix and cure for all.

what did your brother like? Do you want to talk about him?

My hearts with you and your family tonight, I can't imagine what you've been through.

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 26/02/2023 01:21

I’m so sorry for your loss. For every one person who would judge the situation, there are a dozen who would not, and give you a hug. Nobody sets out to be an addict. A childhood friend was addicted for about 15 years, clean for 6/7 years and died from the damage heroin had caused her lungs and heart. It was so tragic at her funeral, many school friends turned up, and you couldn’t help compare the way her life had been different to theirs. I cry when I remember the the schoolgirl she was, and the way things turned out. I hope she rests in peace, just as I hope your brother does. Sending you a hug to help ease some of your pain.

Foronenightonly22 · 26/02/2023 01:00

I am so very sorry for your loss and for your poor darling brothers tragic life. He deserved more. Your post brought tears to my eye. Take care.

kateandme · 26/02/2023 00:53

it was a loss like any other op.
he basically died of an illness like any other.
would anyone choose to be so unhappy this was the choices the had left to cope?
would anyone choose to be an addict and all the horridic details that come with that?
no they wouldnt.
this was acceptable.this wasnt his future.this wasnt going to happen.this wasnt predictable. this was a death.and a loss like any other from somrthing actually rwally fucking traumatic that he had to live and fitht against every day and every second of his life. to do that took bravery. to live that life take sooo much bravery.becasue that life of an addict is terrifying and agonsiing.
it wasnt a choice.
im so sorry for your loss.its ok to feel like you do.
he was your brother and all the kind things you know of him was still your brother.and like a pysical illness chages that persons body this one changed his mind.made it very poorly.
im sure if he could have clicked his fingers,for you,for himself he woud have to get well. to be happy.to have a life away from addiction.
dont listen to people op.they really have no idea.

Coyoacan · 26/02/2023 00:46

I lost a few friends to heroin so I won't judge. Actually most of my friends had had happy childhoods, but were foolish enough to try heroin.

I imagine heroin is like the most wonderful beautiful dream that it is hard to give up once you have a taste of it, so I don't blame your brother at all, at all.

Namechange10101010 · 26/02/2023 00:40

OP maybe it would help to write down his story.

Many years ago I was gifted a book by a charity of their users and their story's.

Very powerful.

I can't think of a single naysayer who wouldn't have been moved by it as without exception it talked of choices made by children, that blighted their lives as adults. Some recovered, some didn't.

Since when did our world evolve into a place where a childs mistakes can't be learnt from and fixed and how do we fix it has long been on my mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread