Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people don’t have a ‘support network’?

168 replies

Moonicorn · 25/02/2023 21:07

Just something I’ve noticed on here. There seems to be a belief that most women have a ‘support network’ of available family and friends ready to jump in if they ever need help, but this isn’t my experience?
Most of the women I know have some support, but more ‘somebody to phone for a moan now and then’ or ‘ask for a favour in an emergency’ rather than the ‘pop in and watch my kids/clean my house/be there for me 24/7’ type expected on here.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 26/02/2023 09:16

Oblomov23 · 26/02/2023 08:49

@neverbeenskiing
Oh come on. Take it to the extreme.

It's not unheard of, Many people know other mums even vaguely through school pick up, dance classes, brownies or cubs, or some way. and know that a child in their year has a older sibling, say 17 year old sister who does babysitting.

I'm not taking anything to the extreme. You literally suggested getting a "young teen" to babysit and you specifically mentioned finding them on Facebook. Now you're taking about a 17 year old who is already known to the family which is quite different to your original suggestion.

megletthesecond · 26/02/2023 09:15

Yanbu. I'm a lone parent and work park time. my youngest child can't cope with social visits and has ruined the house so her older sibling could never have play dates over. I can't reciprocate favours so never ended up with a support network.

Franticbutterfly · 26/02/2023 09:15

I don't. My mum will help in an emergency if she "has to".

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 26/02/2023 09:12

One of the sources of a support network used to be the Church. When I was young, pretty much everyone went to a church, not necessarily COE but ‘chapel ‘ , the various Non conformist faiths. Even if a lot of the attenders were not deeply religious , they contributed to and made use of all the associated ‘networks’ : the Sunday Schools, The Mothers Union ( yes , I know, but they actually encouraged non mothers of a suitable age to join in) the Men’s Circle… the churches ran the Youth Clubs , they provided the hall for the Scouts and the Brownies. The bell ringers, the flower arrangers, the cleaners, the choir, the Parish Magazine, the notice board , were all organisations which supported the parish but also provided networks for the Parishioners.

That has largely gone, although in areas where the churches still operate, they are still sources of help for others, not necessarily people who were part of the congregation.
Of course it wasn’t perfect, and some of those organisations were riven with strife, because people are human and fallible. But they supplied a framework for community.

Nuevabegin · 26/02/2023 09:11

@Oblomov23 do you have family who can help ? Would you let a 14-16 year old look after small dcs for long periods of time ? The support that parents (who have none ) often struggle with is ad hoc care , help when sick or in hospital, maybe they’ve been asked to a wedding where they can’t bring dcs . I’ve had teenage babysitters , they are fine /ok for a few hours in the evening but honestly I wouldn’t leave small , multiple dcs with a teenager for long periods and the people suggesting this usually are the ones who’ve never had to. Also I rarely come across older babysitters whatsoever.
The fact that our only back up would be a teenager is also kindof depressing tbh and not at all a confident place to be .
Again we have made lots of wonderful friends , they might be able to help in an emergency, made friends with our neighbours and help where we can , it’s still not at all normal to ask for help . In fact when I had my third dc I asked my neighbour and paid them to watch my other dcs and they were definitely taken aback I didn’t have any support and tbh have been a bit distant ever since , maybe a message to not rely on them or something, they have lots of family support. But still there’s a constant assertion that those without support just aren’t trying hard enough..

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/02/2023 09:06

I think you are partially right OP. It depends in part what you mean by “support network”.

I’m a single parent and I have a good network of local friends, consciously and deliberately built over time. I always feel supported and there’s always someone I can reach on the phone or for a cup of coffee if I need to talk through a problem.

But I don’t have people who will drop everything to look after my kid at short notice in the way this is often portrayed in TV soaps. I don’t have family locally. Looking after my kid unscheduled and without warning just isn’t workable for my friends, the vast majority of whom are working parents. Apart from a few odd favours here and there I basically pay for all of my childcare.

It’s a trade-off though isn’t it? I wouldn’t want to live in a very close-knit small community. I would find it stifling and restrictive and would hate the feeling of being beholden to people and people knowing all your business. So for me I accept that paying for most childcare is the price of a lifestyle which suits me and I am lucky enough to be able to afford this. For other people this would not work and they would find that closeness supportive.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/02/2023 08:57

redpatternedquilt · 25/02/2023 21:34

I have no idea if having or not having a support network is the norm in the uk.
I think it's a negative consequence of societal change which has forced both parents to work full time while bringing up children. This, alongside many people moving away from their local area and consequently from their families, means that a support network is not readily available for many.

You are portraying this as an unambiguous negative but actually having the whole household dependent on one income is not necessarily a panacea, because it creates huge financial dependency for one partner on the other (almost always the woman).

Families where both parents work may struggle more with logistics and stress but at least both parties have a degree of financial autonomy.

Dancingcactus · 26/02/2023 08:56

We have family around us who can go and get things for us etc but noone who could look after our severely disabled 16 year old.

Oblomov23 · 26/02/2023 08:51

3 of ds2's friends have older siblings and their mum had mentioned the girls offering babysitting, on our local Facebook group. I've never needed to use them, but I know that some mature teens do offer babysitting services.

Oblomov23 · 26/02/2023 08:49

@neverbeenskiing
Oh come on. Take it to the extreme.

It's not unheard of, Many people know other mums even vaguely through school pick up, dance classes, brownies or cubs, or some way. and know that a child in their year has a older sibling, say 17 year old sister who does babysitting.

VinoPleaseforOne · 26/02/2023 08:41

UsingChangeofName · 25/02/2023 21:33

I don't think it is rare at all.
I am part of several communities who support people all the time.

Well that’s fabulous for you.

People often will show up but genuinely decent people rarely stay. I have seen it many times - not only with myself but with others many times too.

My support system is very tight and very small because I trust so few. That’s largely to do with me though and I recognise that.

Commah · 26/02/2023 08:40

A lot of grandparents are either “too old to babysit because we had kids late”, or “too young to babysit because we had kids early”. We have one of each. My mum is too elderly to babysit, while DH’s mum still works full time and is busy running around with her latest boyfriend. DH’s siblings moved to a large city 2hrs away so we can’t call them either.

We don’t have a support network of other school parents either, because most of them rely on THEIR support network to cope. I can’t ring them and ask them to look after DC for a bit after school, because they’re at work and their own kids are being picked up by grandparents.

neverbeenskiing · 26/02/2023 08:23

You could arrange/ advertise through school, or local Facebook group for your town, to meet someone either elderly, or a young teen, and they can then, once you are comfortable, babysit for you once your dc had met them.

Does anyone actually do this? I can just imagine the flaming someone would get on here if they posted saying they'd let a 14 year old they'd met on FB babysit their child and something had gone wrong.

Oblomov23 · 26/02/2023 08:14

There are a ways and means round most of these though. Not all, but most if you put your mind to it.
It make time to set up, or organisation, but it is possible.

The babysitting one could be arranged. You could arrange/ advertise through school, or local Facebook group for your town, to meet someone either elderly, or a young teen, and they can then, once you are comfortable, babysit for you once your dc had met them.

At some schools they advertise in the newsletter that any Working mum / anyone with no one to call on, can log their phone number and over time make arrangements so that it's sorted/arranged should they ever need an emergency, eg, for someone to pick up their child in an emergency, and you could return the favour in a different way, whatever you are capable of.

adomizo · 26/02/2023 07:57

JaninaDuszejko · 25/02/2023 21:39

I think if you live in the same community you grew up in then you will have a support network of family and old friends who will do this. If you live in a big city you will have a support network of friends who are all equally far away from family and support each other.

DH and I both live far away from family but in a town where most people are local. It can feel lonely at times because everyone else has family who can do babysitting etc but we don't have that. We can't build up favours because nobody else needs them. We're basically waiting for our eldest to turn 16 so we have a babysitter.

Yes I can really resonate with this!

Dubbydoodoubter · 26/02/2023 07:55

Well it depends on your circumstances doesn’t it?

If you have time to get involved in things and build connections and friendships, then you have a support network. Or if you have living family, you have a support network.

If you don’t have that time or that family, then you don’t.

The ironic thing is that probably the people who most need the support network, don’t have the time or resources to build it.

tuvamoodyson · 26/02/2023 07:53

statetrooperstacey · 25/02/2023 21:53

I do , I have a a couple of really close friends and several good friends, nice funny lively helpful colleagues who I have a good relationship with, also a large helpful and kind family.

However, I would always answer my door at any time of day or night even if I wasn’t expecting anybody, I would go out of my way to help anybody with anything I could , I don’t go lc or nc at the drop of a hat, I don’t take offence easily , I wouldn’t start a thread complaining that I’d only been invited to an evening wedding reception or that my baby wasn’t invited, or that people didn’t talk to me much at the school gates, or someone glared at me , or a man beeped at me going round a roundabout and shook his fist or my kid didn’t get invited to a party I thought they should have been invited to, or a teacher did or possibly didn’t say something that may or may not have been a bit sarcastic or any of the other bollocks that so many people get het up about. A lot of people ( mainly on here) seem to very unforgiving and intolerant of others, which they can dress up as ‘ strong boundaries’ . I can see how that can leave some people with no support network!! You get out what you put in in my opinion.

Yes! x 100,000,000!

Nuevabegin · 26/02/2023 07:38

@SpinningFloppa 100 percent

Nuevabegin · 26/02/2023 07:35

I live in Ireland and it’s normal for most parents to have amazing support networks and actually most people on mn seem to also.
I can’t stand it when others don’t get that it’s not like this for everyone. I’ve made wonderful friends here and although they prob would help in an emergency they don’t need reciprocal support or childcare swaps etc as they all have that with their families so it’s not at all the norm to reach out and although I always offer help if they are stuck etc the dynamic isn’t there to all help each other as they have families for that …. All the friends I know have had financial support, help with childcare and emotional support. For whatever reason my family are completely hands off , always been this way ( lots of lovely messages but always distance ), no invites really , very detached.. When my dcs were small I was very isolated , it didn’t matter if I was sick , sleep deprived ( chronically for years ) nothing induced an offer of help . My dhs family have loads of issues and are really dysfunctional so absolutely no support there , in fact they would cause work and take money given the chance.
We’ve accepted this a long time ago , there’s nothing that we can do about it , I’d love if my mum wanted to spend time with me and my dcs like in a playground or something but she never did and doesn’t.
My dh are a real team but actually are quite isolated and it’s not something we feel we can talk about , also I think because of our complete lack of support we can be embarrassed or I image others assume there’s been some big issue or why we don’t ever have family at our house or events etc . We have tried.
Of course it’s a first world problem.
I just hate the assumption you can build your own support , I’ve lovely friends but they all have family for this , it isn’t at all the norm where I am 🤷🏻‍♀️

MRex · 26/02/2023 07:20

We have a lot of emergency options from family or nearby parent friends; old friends are further away but would turn up if asked. Even the neighbours, a whole bunch of them on the end of a WhatsApp, are the type to step up if asked. If we needed a school pick-up / food dropped to hospital / borrow a thing, then it wouldn't matter who couldn't help because there are a lot of options. A lot of support offered with a recent bereavement too, though I only needed the emotional support of going out for a chat and the practical support of choosing some funeral arrangements (the religious friend).

Like OP though, we rarely ask for help and don't ask nor expect anyone to turn up regularly to help out or babysit. The idea of that is quite alien to me, and I also find those comments jarring to see, though we do have a cleaner so I guess it's just outsourced. We wouldn't get much regular help even if we did expect it.

whiteroseredrose · 26/02/2023 07:14

TheaBrandt · 26/02/2023 06:06

I do. Amazing local group of friends when kids little we had each others back for emergency childcare if I were running late there were at least 4 mums I could ring. Since then only one person has needed support one friend became chronically ill as a group we did care package and we ensure always one of us there to meet up when she’s reaches out that she’s up to it and wants company etc.

Same here. School gate mums. We did a mum's Deliveroo when one person's DH had a brain problem, some helped with ironing etc. Even now when we see less of each other people are there in an emergency.

CoalCraft · 26/02/2023 06:31

I have an "emergency" support network, I suppose. If I suddenly needed to go to hospital there are people I could call to come and sit with the kids. I don't have day to day options though, at least not for anything more than folks to rant to. If the kids are poorly one of us has to take a day off as no nearby family willing to take them, etc.

TheaBrandt · 26/02/2023 06:06

I do. Amazing local group of friends when kids little we had each others back for emergency childcare if I were running late there were at least 4 mums I could ring. Since then only one person has needed support one friend became chronically ill as a group we did care package and we ensure always one of us there to meet up when she’s reaches out that she’s up to it and wants company etc.

Theunordinary · 26/02/2023 06:02

I started a thread about this very thing yesterday in relationships and you commented on it OP at 20:58 then started this thread about ten mins later. I think it’s a very individual thing and it’s all relative. For me I feel like I have nobody as I’ve had nobody to call for a recent event and nobody to ask for childcare help for my Sen child and it’s been hard.

I did assume that the majority of people have a least one person they could call for a chat/cry in hard times. I have a dh but don’t want to over burden him and sometimes i do wish I could call my mum / sister but can’t due to past trauma.

ASimpleLampoon · 26/02/2023 05:49

Yanbu. I see some people in here expressing disbelief that anyone could be isolated because THEY have people they can turn to.

yeah try being disabled with a disabled child and see how fast that "village" disappears!