Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people don’t have a ‘support network’?

168 replies

Moonicorn · 25/02/2023 21:07

Just something I’ve noticed on here. There seems to be a belief that most women have a ‘support network’ of available family and friends ready to jump in if they ever need help, but this isn’t my experience?
Most of the women I know have some support, but more ‘somebody to phone for a moan now and then’ or ‘ask for a favour in an emergency’ rather than the ‘pop in and watch my kids/clean my house/be there for me 24/7’ type expected on here.

OP posts:
Callmyfluff · 26/02/2023 14:34

This falls into a birds of a feather situation imo.

As on the flip side to your post I don’t know one person who doesn’t have a support network, large ones at that.

Im lucky I have 30 odd people who would be there for me and the DC at a drop of a hat, this is normal for my friends, co workers and general acquaintances as well.

doublethelove · 26/02/2023 14:34

redskydelight · 26/02/2023 14:26

@doublethelove I was talking about taking school age children to school, not pre-school children to nursery. Entirely different scenario.

Totally understand. I'm hoping it will be different when my children start school. I feel like I've come across as some weird isolated hermit haha. I'm actually quite chatty and sociable and would help anybody out in a time of need. It's been a culture shock moving here and I had expected to spend a lot more time with my partners old friends but for whatever reason that hasn't happened. People also seem to keep themselves to themselves a LOT more than where I'm from.

redskydelight · 26/02/2023 14:26

@doublethelove I was talking about taking school age children to school, not pre-school children to nursery. Entirely different scenario.

doublethelove · 26/02/2023 13:55

redskydelight · 26/02/2023 13:43

So. I have no support network. The day that DH and I were both so ill that we couldn't get out of bed we had to physically muddle through and somehow care for a baby. No one to call on.

But just taking a child to school, especially if you are taking your own child anyway? Unless you live in a completely different direction to every other parent (unlikely even for rural schools), then asking the parent of one of your DC's friends, or someone who lives locally to you just to take your child to school isn't really having a support network. It's something that 99% of parents would do as a one off without even thinking twice. So, it is confusing if you genuinely can't find someone to do this. So I think most people presume that there probably are people but you don't like to ask.

Do you never talk to another parent at school? Is there no class Whatsapp/Facebook group? Does your child never go to playdates or parties? Would you not so much as say "good morning" and exchange small talk with someone who lived near you with a child at the same school? If the answer to all of those is genuinely "no", then perhaps it's worth you considering whether having such an isolated life is really a good thing for you or your child.

Replied to myself by accident!

Sorry, to answer your other questions. In the 18 months my children have been at nursery, there have been no parties or playdates. There is no WhatsApp or other chat group that I'm aware of. I only moved to this area shortly before they started at nursery. My partner is from here. But I wouldn't have had anybody in my previous area either. But I do suspect people would have been more social in my old town. They're not as chatty or friendly here.

doublethelove · 26/02/2023 13:54

doublethelove · 26/02/2023 13:52

No, I don't know any other parents at my child's nursery. Its very much a drop off and pick up situation and very seldom any social type events where parents go along. Usually there are only a couple of other parents around if any at all. They aren't school age yet so maybe that might change but at the moment no. Nor do I know anybody who lives locally who could take them or collect them from nursery. Partially because it's not possible to walk to their nursery. But even if it was, I can't think of anybody I know or who I could ask.

Sorry to answer your other questions. In the 18 months my children have been at nursery, there have been no parties or playdates. There is no WhatsApp or other chat group that I'm aware of. I only moved to this area shortly before they started at nursery. My partner is from here. But I wouldn't have had anybody in my previous area either. But I do suspect people would have been more social in my old town. They're not as chatty or friendly here.

doublethelove · 26/02/2023 13:52

redskydelight · 26/02/2023 13:43

So. I have no support network. The day that DH and I were both so ill that we couldn't get out of bed we had to physically muddle through and somehow care for a baby. No one to call on.

But just taking a child to school, especially if you are taking your own child anyway? Unless you live in a completely different direction to every other parent (unlikely even for rural schools), then asking the parent of one of your DC's friends, or someone who lives locally to you just to take your child to school isn't really having a support network. It's something that 99% of parents would do as a one off without even thinking twice. So, it is confusing if you genuinely can't find someone to do this. So I think most people presume that there probably are people but you don't like to ask.

Do you never talk to another parent at school? Is there no class Whatsapp/Facebook group? Does your child never go to playdates or parties? Would you not so much as say "good morning" and exchange small talk with someone who lived near you with a child at the same school? If the answer to all of those is genuinely "no", then perhaps it's worth you considering whether having such an isolated life is really a good thing for you or your child.

No, I don't know any other parents at my child's nursery. Its very much a drop off and pick up situation and very seldom any social type events where parents go along. Usually there are only a couple of other parents around if any at all. They aren't school age yet so maybe that might change but at the moment no. Nor do I know anybody who lives locally who could take them or collect them from nursery. Partially because it's not possible to walk to their nursery. But even if it was, I can't think of anybody I know or who I could ask.

redskydelight · 26/02/2023 13:43

doublethelove · 25/02/2023 22:33

This. Entirely this. They are so weirdly confused by it!

So. I have no support network. The day that DH and I were both so ill that we couldn't get out of bed we had to physically muddle through and somehow care for a baby. No one to call on.

But just taking a child to school, especially if you are taking your own child anyway? Unless you live in a completely different direction to every other parent (unlikely even for rural schools), then asking the parent of one of your DC's friends, or someone who lives locally to you just to take your child to school isn't really having a support network. It's something that 99% of parents would do as a one off without even thinking twice. So, it is confusing if you genuinely can't find someone to do this. So I think most people presume that there probably are people but you don't like to ask.

Do you never talk to another parent at school? Is there no class Whatsapp/Facebook group? Does your child never go to playdates or parties? Would you not so much as say "good morning" and exchange small talk with someone who lived near you with a child at the same school? If the answer to all of those is genuinely "no", then perhaps it's worth you considering whether having such an isolated life is really a good thing for you or your child.

MRex · 26/02/2023 13:07

Commah · 26/02/2023 11:48

If you're a normal adult, why would you need someone to come and clean your house and be there for you 24/7?
My friend is a teacher. Her workload is so heavy that she doesn’t have time for anything else. Her own mum cleans and does laundry for her while she’s at work, and often preps meals too. If she didn’t have that support she’d be unable to continue teaching, the workload is just too heavy.

That's just ridiculous. Clearly you have no idea how many hours most other professions put in. She could also get a cleaner. Making a meal isn't an arduous task surgery unless you choose to make it one.

MRex · 26/02/2023 13:05

leafittome · 26/02/2023 09:23

Do people actually ask for help when needed though? They might be surprised how willing people are to help - they don't always have to be family and best friends.
I have children with additional needs so I can't offer practical help that often however whenever I can help I do. So if someone wants to borrow something in particular and they post in a WhatsApp group I'll offer a loan if I can. If I can offer a lift or childcare I will but it's reliant on people reaching out and asking. My school whatsapp groups are very supportive so I'm confident in an emergency someone would help me. I've had offers of help which I haven't taken up so know it's there. Mostly I think people help when they can. I don't expect regular/long term favours though. I don't expect others to emotionally support me for hours on end either.

People regularly help people who are virtually strangers in our local community. WhatsApp groups for neighbours, school classes and friends help to connect people and form support networks.

This is a very good point. I'd be happy to take any child from DS's class for a night if there was an issue for the parents; I'd worry more about the one with physical additional needs, but we'd make it work. Drop-off or pick-up for a neighbour is also fine and we are emergency contact when the dad is unwell (the kid knows he can come here or a couple of other neighbours for help), but I wouldn't commit to have him every week, just an occasional few hours. So that is still just emergency cover, which goes to OP's point; most people don't have regular ongoing support in place unless they pay for it.

Valentina12 · 26/02/2023 11:50

Commah · 26/02/2023 11:48

If you're a normal adult, why would you need someone to come and clean your house and be there for you 24/7?
My friend is a teacher. Her workload is so heavy that she doesn’t have time for anything else. Her own mum cleans and does laundry for her while she’s at work, and often preps meals too. If she didn’t have that support she’d be unable to continue teaching, the workload is just too heavy.

Oh ffs 🙄

how do you think the junior doctors, lawyers and accountants fit it all in? They don’t have 13 weeks off a year either…

Commah · 26/02/2023 11:48

If you're a normal adult, why would you need someone to come and clean your house and be there for you 24/7?
My friend is a teacher. Her workload is so heavy that she doesn’t have time for anything else. Her own mum cleans and does laundry for her while she’s at work, and often preps meals too. If she didn’t have that support she’d be unable to continue teaching, the workload is just too heavy.

Valentina12 · 26/02/2023 11:35

There’s a happy medium. I know people with no support network and I also know people who literally could not function without their parents involved. Which I’ll be honest I think is a bit pathetic when you’re pushing 40…

Arthurflecksfacepaint · 26/02/2023 11:30

I have no one. Only dh.

Which means I go through all the shit alone. I’m being told some bad news on Tuesday, the latest on a long line, this time it’s when my consultant thinks I will go blind. But I have to go alone, just like everything else that I’ve had that’s been shit as dh has to look after the children.

I’ve never had a close circle of friends, I was bullied at school, never went to university, moved around, got divorced and had to move again.

In a totally new area now, again. In laws don’t like me and to be honest l, wouldn’t trust them with a hamster, let alone my children anyway. My mum has been dead since I was a child, my dad is in a care home out of his mind with dementia. No siblings.

I have no one to call for a chat, no one to lean on.

The mums at the school gate here are wildly different people to me, I take my toddler to groups but I am 20 years older than the other mums so have little in common. It’s really hard.

WorryMcGee · 26/02/2023 11:21

I have one made up of my friends and neighbours, but my family are next to useless. The problem with that is, the majority of my friends don’t have children so if I need help last minute with my 10 month old that can be a bit difficult. I think when she’s older it’ll be easier (I’m not a baby person and had barely held one before I had my own so I don’t blame them of being scared of having her for more than a brief period!) help with the dogs or the house or anything NOT baby related I’m sorted 😂

I did feel sad about it a month or so ago when my parents let me down for a really stupid reason on a morning I was supposed to be at the chemo suite for blood tests and a line flush. All my friends who would have DD were at work, DH couldn’t get home from work quick enough for my appointment, I had absolutely no one. I had to take her there (in tears). Obv children aren’t allowed in the chemo area but thankfully two of the wonderful office staff looked after her in there - not their job, they could prob have got in trouble for it and would have been totally within their rights to say no. I don’t know what I would have done if they did say no as I needed that appointment. That made me feel really envious of people who can leave their DC with family whenever/wherever.

pizzaHeart · 26/02/2023 11:17

Well it depends on your circumstances doesn’t it?
If you have time to get involved in things and build connections and friendships, then you have a support network. Or if you have living family, you have a support network.
If you don’t have that time or that family, then you don’t.
The ironic thing is that probably the people who most need the support network, don’t have the time or resources to build it.

100% this^

AngeloMysterioso · 26/02/2023 11:13

On the flip side I feel expectations of others can be unrealistically high and there’s an element of ‘don’t ask dont get’. Quite a few responses about nobody offering to do X or Y in times of crisis, but I wonder if those posters actually asked?

A lot of people, for whatever reason, find it difficult enough to ask for help when they’re not in crisis, and you want them to to do it when their lives have been turned upside down?

thymee · 26/02/2023 11:13

Most of the women I know have some support, but more ‘somebody to phone for a moan now and then’ or ‘ask for a favour in an emergency’ rather than the ‘pop in and watch my kids/clean my house/be there for me 24/7’ type expected on here.

I don't really understand why people would need the latter on a regular basis, unless they have a chronic illness/ disability etc. If you're a normal adult, why would you need someone to come and clean your house and be there for you 24/7?

I don't offer or receive that sort of support because I'm a functioning adult and I/ most of my friends just don't need it.

If someone I care about became ill and needed that level of help, then I would certainly help them as much as I could/ help them to find the support they needed.

But I really don't think that's a normal level of support for a friend/ 'support network' to give.

5128gap · 26/02/2023 11:12

You get out what you put in isn't necessarily true at an individual level. It's more at a societal level where there has undeniably been a shift to a more insular way of life. Of course there are people out there who try very hard to build links, but unless the people around you are equally on board with it, it will be a one way street. There are bound to be generous inclusive people who end up without support themselves, because there's not enough of them.

LeFeu · 26/02/2023 11:10

Also people saying they don’t want to ask for help - do! I never used to but actually struggling on isn’t helpful and you might find people are more than willing. Vulnerability is ok. The first time maybe just get them something or make sure you follow up with childcare as a thank you and it can grow into more!

LeFeu · 26/02/2023 11:08

We don’t live near parents and so over time have found friends who are our network, but it has taken time and effort. But last week I was unwell and a couple of people offered to take my kids out to give me a break, and when I had to go into A&E we had people to call to look after the kids etc. but definitely not friends who come and clean my house lol, maybe water my plants when I’m away!

You do have to be willing to help others out too, I think. People don’t want to be taken advantage of and if you’re obviously there for childcare the friendships won’t feel genuine.

Bauhausstolemyhair · 26/02/2023 10:58

I don't have as much support as I'd like. Its just me and DD. My parents will have DD if I pay them. We were technically homeless a few years back and I paid for emergency accommodation for weeks. I had to either use a laundrette or pay to use my mum's machine. I'd not have dreamed at asking any school mum friends for help as I'd have been hurt if they said no.

I do however do favours gladly such as giving random lifts, bars of choc if a friend is feeling down or childcare. These favours never translate into anything reciprocal. I'm just used to paying and being my own support network.

Stompythedinosaur · 26/02/2023 10:35

I think a support network is more people who would help in a real emergency.

I definitely have one - both dm and dmil are within reach, and various friends with similar age dc.

I think it is a real disadvantage for families who don't have this and that it must make life much harder. Not having people to call on would definitely have effected my career.

icountallthebeans · 26/02/2023 10:35

I have a support network, but I'm loathe to use it.

I would never ask my friends for practical help (unless I was truly desperate) but they would give it if I asked. There are enough who Iive near enough and care enough about me to work out a rota if I had some kind of emergency situation.

I suppose the issue isn't so much about knowing enough people, it's about feeling like you can ask. Which I think probably comes down to how you value yourself, or don't.

SpinningFloppa · 26/02/2023 10:33

I also don't agree you get out what you put in. I had my nephew for my sister all the time. I had him whilst she worked, I picked him up from school, I took him on days out, I've had him whilst she went on holiday for a week!, whilst she studied, when she went on nights out. When I had my own children did she ever return the favour? Nope she's never had mine not once, she's a teacher now and told me she spends all week with kids so doesn't want to be around them outside of work?! so much for you get out what you put in.

JaninaDuszejko · 26/02/2023 10:33

I don't think it's as simple as 'you get out what you put in'.

In a traditional society there is a load of unpaid caring that is done by women who are denied the opportunities for education and career that exist here. I suppose the UK is in a transition stage where some of us have moved away from home and don't have mothers nearby to provide unpaid care but others do. And we see fictional tightly knit communities all the time so the expectation is we are suppose to have someone who can babysit at the drop of a hat.

My MIL kept telling us to set up a babysitting circle and she would tell us very jolly stories about complete strangers turning up to look after the DC so they could go out to a dinner party. I asked how she knew they were trustworthy and she said 'oh, they all worked at the university'. I think our awareness of child abuse makes us more wary these days as well, can't imagine being happy with a random bloke from DH's work turning up to look after our DC.

Swipe left for the next trending thread