Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with DSS being a brat

61 replies

Mavis93 · 25/02/2023 21:05

So back story I have a DS who is 10 with a January birthday so often has no ideas for presents so often wants money to put away and get things during the year. DSD has a June birthday so often has ideas for presents so while has money no where near as much as DS (they all get the same set budget). DSS also has broken one and lost a switch so wanted new ones of our his money during the years which has taken a good chunk of his money.
today DS decided he wanted to buy a PS5 with his own money- all fine that’s his money and he paid for it. DSS has stropped and moaned all day, ringing his mum who has now kicked off that we are being unfair on her child. We have explained to both we didn’t pay and he is welcome to save up but we won’t buy it- DSS has been a brat about it all day being nasty to my DSS and sat glaring at me while on the phone to his mum.
DH says to ignore but I feel his rude behaviour deserves consequences AIBU for thinking this or is DH right

OP posts:
DaveyJonesLocker · 26/02/2023 07:49

You're doing a bloody good job of setting boundaries and protecting your DS. Stick to your guns. You know you're right. DSS and his mum can throw all the tantrums they want. He could have bought himself a PS5 but bought other stuff instead, that was his choice. Remind him that if he looked after his stuff he wouldn't have to keep replacing them and would have been able to buy a PS5 himself.

Maybe this is the moment he needs to realise that things have value and you should be more careful with your money and property.

Mavis93 · 26/02/2023 07:36

My other son also didn’t get a PS5 as he is not a saver and he was not bought a PS5 and we do not have the money to buy 3 PS5s so they all have the same as it would also be majorly unfair to buy my other DS one and my DSS and expect my youngest DS to pay himself. It would also show them all bad behaviour gets rewarded which I am not willing to do.
I tried talking to DSS about the savings for bigger items when wanted and even showed him the paper from my sons money wallet showing how he saved to be glared at ignored so I gave up. His mim
settled on get DSS his own controller so he can play it when he wants- I told her no my DS bought this item it was not a household purchase to share so he doesn’t get to use it without DS permission.

OP posts:
musingsinmidlife · 26/02/2023 06:24

Sit down with him and show him how he has 850 pounds worth of possessions and DS has 850 in cash but none of the types of things that DSS owns that he bought with the cash. They are 10. Show him how he has hundreds of pounds worth of games and toys and whatever else he spent it on and DS has none of that since he saved all this money. Pre PS5 purchase, they had an 850 pound disparity in belongings and possessions. That is a lot of stuff! Ten year olds dont fully understand finances or money management. A lot of adults don’t!

You have to show in practical ways how their two styles differ.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 26/02/2023 03:48

so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

Nope.

Thepossibility · 26/02/2023 03:46

jimmyjammy001 · 26/02/2023 00:41

I Couldn't agree more, you get involved with someone who allready has children, this is exactly the tyres of things you have to deal with, kids don't understand fair, so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

Absolutely not this.
Giving children everything they demand is terrible parenting.

sashh · 26/02/2023 03:36

Pubesofsoberness · 26/02/2023 01:29

And ops ds is in the same position! He may be jealous but he's had the same opportunity to save up

Op I think half the problem is his mum by the sounds of it

I agree, you have a mum problem.

If it was the other way round and your son was behaving like a brat what would the consequences be?

Pubesofsoberness · 26/02/2023 01:29

HazyDragon · 26/02/2023 01:08

He's only 10. He has had a difficult up bringing with his parents separating and having to navigate life as part of a step family.

My own 10yo hasn't had to do any of that, is level headed and not 'bratty'. She would still be very jealous if her sibling managed to save up and buy an expensive, sort after PS5. And that's without adding the extra layer of step-sibling jealousy.

I'm not saying he's behaving well, but he's jealous and a child. Give him a break.

And ops ds is in the same position! He may be jealous but he's had the same opportunity to save up

Op I think half the problem is his mum by the sounds of it

WickedStepmomNOT · 26/02/2023 01:23

kids don't understand fair No, can't agree with this - in my experience most kids have a hyper sense of fairness. DSS needs to have it explained once again and then if it comes up again remind him of the discussion and shut it down. Every time.

Blablablanamechangagain · 26/02/2023 01:15

jimmyjammy001 · 26/02/2023 00:41

I Couldn't agree more, you get involved with someone who allready has children, this is exactly the tyres of things you have to deal with, kids don't understand fair, so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

Eh?

Some fucked up logic there 🤣🤣

If they were siblings and one saved and the other didn't...you'd reward the one who didn't by funding them more? Course not. It's no different.

Really weird take on family set up.

HazyDragon · 26/02/2023 01:08

He's only 10. He has had a difficult up bringing with his parents separating and having to navigate life as part of a step family.

My own 10yo hasn't had to do any of that, is level headed and not 'bratty'. She would still be very jealous if her sibling managed to save up and buy an expensive, sort after PS5. And that's without adding the extra layer of step-sibling jealousy.

I'm not saying he's behaving well, but he's jealous and a child. Give him a break.

DoughnutDreams · 26/02/2023 01:06

This is such a shame to be ruining your son's lovely experience. He deserves to be excited about something he's saved for.

Liorae · 26/02/2023 01:00

jimmyjammy001 · 26/02/2023 00:41

I Couldn't agree more, you get involved with someone who allready has children, this is exactly the tyres of things you have to deal with, kids don't understand fair, so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

You are incredibly wrong. It's time to teach your kids what fair actually means.

hourbyhour101 · 26/02/2023 00:51

@jimmyjammy001 Couldn't agree more, you get involved with someone who allready has children, this is exactly the tyres of things you have to deal with, kids don't understand fair, so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

Erm no you do exactly what would happen in a nuclear family and one of the siblings is a saver and one is a spender. You would do sorry x saved up his money and you had exactly the same and spent it.

Just because you date someone with kids doesn't mean you turn into a doormat and have to shell out money just because. I would probably have more sympathy if the kid hasn't broken/lost 3 switches and showed some type of care for his belongings.

Really weird thought process to me here tbh 😵‍💫

jimmyjammy001 · 26/02/2023 00:41

HorseyMel · 25/02/2023 21:13

One of the complications of raising other people's kids, I guess.

I Couldn't agree more, you get involved with someone who allready has children, this is exactly the tyres of things you have to deal with, kids don't understand fair, so you will need to treat them the same even if one has saved up and the other hasn't

LakieLady · 25/02/2023 23:47

I'm in awe of your son for being such a good saver at 10!

And DSS is behaving like a little git. He needs to take a leaf out of your DS's book, and learn to save for things he wants. He might take more care of them if he bought them out of his savings.

takealettermsjones · 25/02/2023 23:27

It's definitely not unfair in the slightest and his mum sounds like hard work.

But... saving doesn't come naturally to everyone and children need to be actively taught about this stuff. Yes he is 10 now but you said this was three years' worth of savings for your DS. If he's naturally more of a spender than a saver, your DSS probably didn't have the foresight at 7 to realise that he could have a PS5 in three years' time if he saved up.

I'm not excusing breaking the Switches, not looking after his belongings, etc. He needs to understand this isn't okay and I absolutely agree with your rule about not replacing things.

But you could use this as a starting point for teaching him about savings and budgeting. E.g. ask him if he'd like some help in setting up regular savings, working out how long it would take to save up for X, etc.

ItchyBillco · 25/02/2023 22:40

Your little son sounds like a savvy saver. Good for him. I hope his spoilt step brother hasn’t ruined his big purchase.

ThereIbledit · 25/02/2023 22:03

To her - tough titty.

To the DSS he can sit there with a sour face all he likes.

Mavis93 · 25/02/2023 22:00

His mother has clearly been told that this is years of saving from birthdays and minimal spending by DSS hence why my other son want not bought one and neither was a second controller as it was a sole purchase by my DSS and apart from driving him to the shop was solely completed by him- she feels regardless it’s unfair for DSS to see my DS gets something like that and not get the same

OP posts:
evtheria · 25/02/2023 21:57

Three switches?!! Wow.

Mavis93 · 25/02/2023 21:57

I actually already keep paper in there money and write money in and money out after a last year him insisting he had more money then was in his wallet- so he can see exactly what he has spent money on.
As both me and DH work in half decent jobs and his ex doesn’t (her partner does) she thinks we should fund/ buy everything regardless and this is a constant on going battle

OP posts:
Tangelablue · 25/02/2023 21:56

I think your DH is right, you have explained that Ds bought it with his own money so just don't engage with him. If he starts going on about it, change the subject, blank him, walk out the room. If mum wants him to have one, she can buy him one.
Your Ds sounds very sensible, hopefully DSS will manage his money better in the future.

Changechangechanging · 25/02/2023 21:54

It’s absolutely disgraceful that his mother is reinforcing his feelings!

It is probably fair to say mum hasn't been told either the full truth or full story.

monomatapea · 25/02/2023 21:51

Going forward I would get them one of those ledger books each then they can see exactly how much they had been given for birthdays and where they are spending it

monomatapea · 25/02/2023 21:50

His mum is encouraging him.

Just look at the long game. Your kid will know fairness , hers will just have a sense of entitlement