Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it okay to leave a child in the car to pop into a shop?

167 replies

loveisanumber · 25/02/2023 19:47

Local mum.

She has a baby/toddler who's recently celebrated her 1st birthday.

I've noticed on a few occasions now that she leaves the baby in the car whilst she pops into the chemist for prescriptions, pops into the little Tesco for a few bits etc.

Most of the time she's roughly a few minutes but the reason I'm starting this thread is because today she was talking to me whilst waiting for a prescription. We were standing there for a good 15 minutes before her name was called because mine was called just before

When I was walking by me said bye again, she opened the car door to get in and was saying 'It's okay darling, I'm back' and I heard the baby crying

AIBU to think it's wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whatafustercluck · 27/02/2023 08:00

I've done this when mine have been soundly asleep. Always local/ small shop or petrol station when I could see them. Never on a sunny/ warm day. And never to do the weekly shop or anything that took more than a few mins.

I currently have no choice but to leave my 6yo in the car for a few mins as I cannot get her to wear anything other than a dressing gown (SEN).

gogohmm · 27/02/2023 07:46

I wouldn't generally but did for fuel (pay at the pump wasn't available widely then)

InWalksBarberalla · 27/02/2023 07:23

Problem is that people underestimate how hot it needs to be for the car to get dangerously hot, and overestimate how long it takes for a baby or child to be in danger. As the UK heats up you'll have more and more days when this is unsafe.

Nobody means to leave their child in a too hot car to die. Sometimes they underestimate the impacts (thinking it's not that hot), sometimes the kids get into the car without anyone noticing, and sometimes they tragically forget the child is still in the car. Normalising leaving children unattended in cars is poor behaviour.

swapcicles · 27/02/2023 07:03

Very dangerous if the child can get out,not so much being one but if mobile still possible.
A few years ago I spotted a 3/4 year old get out of a car parked on the side of a road and went to cross the road. I spoke to him for a few minutes to distract him but had I not been there he could have easily been run over (narrow but busy road, the boy would not easily have been seen)or I could also not been a nice person too and taken him.
Turns out his grandma was getting a prescription from a chemist across the road and hadn't thought this could happen.

rowanoak · 27/02/2023 06:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

crimsonpeak · 27/02/2023 06:02

ohjeesus · 25/02/2023 19:59

Mind your own business, concentrate on your own life! Leave people do as they see fit ffs

This is bs. Safeguarding is everyone’s responsibility. Standing by while children are at risk of harm because ‘it’s an adults right to do whatever they want’ is a dick move. Leaving a child (of this tender age especially) in a car to pop into a shop is neglectful at worst at stupid at best.

maddy68 · 27/02/2023 05:28

It's fine. If the car is outside of the door and you can see it and teh temperature is ok.

It's not neglect!!!! If she was in a bedroom of a house it would be the same distance away.

Mind your own business

ireallyliketheboy · 27/02/2023 05:05

I live in a small sleepy town with a marketplace.

If I can park immediately outside the pharmacy then I may run in, with one eye on the car.

I would never pop into a supermarket with a little one in the car on their own!

SardineStitches · 26/02/2023 21:01

It's illegal where I live to leave a child unattended in car

Same. Animals too. Around here the police would be called if there was a kid or dog locked in a car with no parent/owner in sight and also photos posted on the local Facebook pages so the rest of the community can throw in their outrage too.

I never left my kids in the car when I went to a shop but I did when paying for petrol. Don't think I would these days though with the post I see on fb when someone sees you do it and the police being called instantly the minute someone notices.

Grantanow · 26/02/2023 09:29

I suspect many, many parents have done it without fully understanding the risks.

Cosyblankets · 26/02/2023 09:24

How have you noticed on a few occasions?

NameChangeFor2023 · 26/02/2023 09:23

.

Is it okay to leave a child in the car to pop into a shop?
CorsicaDreaming · 26/02/2023 09:22

www.vets-now.com/summer/dogs-in-hot-cars/

CorsicaDreaming · 26/02/2023 09:21

@Norwen - agreed that it's an unlikely scenario in Feb in UK, but car temperature fluctuates very quickly as it's basically a glass and metal box. The temperature will drop to potentially very cold outside temperatures very quickly - and in direct sun even on a relatively cool summer day can get dangerously hot surprisingly quickly - and dogs can and do die or become unwell with heatstroke in hot cars, so a child strapped into a highly insulated car seat, etc is also at risk - even in 15 minutes, even just a quick pop to the shops, when the risk may genuinely not be obvious to the parent.

static.vets-now.com/uploads/sites/3/2017/08/VEN2550D-Heat-Stroke-Infographic-A1-PRbleed21.pdf

autienotnaughty · 26/02/2023 03:48

Definitely not someone could hit the car, try to steal the car, car could get overheated. It's a risk assessment and personally I think it's not worth the risk

LadyJ2023 · 26/02/2023 01:52

No way is it ok I would never do it with our 4 to many stories car being thieved child in car, child dies in car etc etc defo a no no from me

WinterMusings · 26/02/2023 01:14

Jobalons · 25/02/2023 20:00

No tales seconds to break into a car, it takes seconds for a parked car to be hit, it takes only minit s for a car fire to start.

You get my drift, it's always the freak accidents and situations you never even considered.

Oh you missed alien abduction.

Bepis · 26/02/2023 01:11

@AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair It was in relation to leaving something valuable and precious in a car unattended and in view of everyone.

Norwen · 26/02/2023 00:40

@WandaWonder I agree with this. Why not instead think empathetically about the reasons that mother may have taken that decision. Instead of "lazy" or uncaring. Maybe her daughter screams during car journeys, and had finally fallen asleep. Perhaps getting her out of the car seat would cause her to wake and cry inconsolably for a long time, so that on balance leaving her in the car caused her (or was likely to cause her) to cry less than waking her. Perhaps she did not realise it would take so long to collect her prescription, and didn't track the time because she's exhausted. Perhaps she would never normally leave her baby on the car for any length of time, but today was exceptional because of x, y, z.

Mojoyoyo · 26/02/2023 00:34

@Jobalons
“Mad risks, yes leave an underaged child in a locked metal flammable container, full of fuel”

Wow…
Maybe we should stop driving lol 😆

WandaWonder · 26/02/2023 00:31

I don't remember ever doing it but what do you want from this?

To you need to feel you are right? Do you want to say something to them? Report them? Need permission to feel better that you don't do it?

Sure topics of all sorts come up but when you pick on something of someone you know it feels like someone wants permission to judge (in general)

Norwen · 26/02/2023 00:27

@CorsicaDreamingapologies, I'm not the person you were replying to but wanted to answer. That poor child (heaven forbid, what a terrible thing to happen) was accidentally left in a car for something like 8-9 hours in 22C. I personally don't think it is reasonable to extrapolate that to leaving a baby in a car for 15 minutes in the UK in February. I also think it is unfair to assume that the mum wouldn't behave differently on a hot day.

Better to deal with the actual risks of what actually happened and was observed. It may not be ideal parenting but the actual risks of what actually happened were minimal, not substantially different to countless infants screaming in their cots for 15 minutes while their harangued parents try to get a hold of their sanity - no doubt something that is happening all over the country right now as we have this discussion.

I believe there is a significant gap between ideal parenting and parenting that is so concerning it needs to be acted upon. This clearly doesn't meet the threshold for the latter in my opinion. Farfetched what-if scenarios (not that you personally have necessarily proposed any of these, I haven't followed the entire thread) could happen to any of us at virtually any time and aren't helpful for making decisions. In a discussion about safety, substantial, plausible and clearly avoidable risks are what matter. Eg I would say that extended rear facing car seats avoid/greatly reduce a plausible risk yet I would never "report" a parent who doesn't use them, not only because such a report would be completely futile but also because the risk actually isn't substantial enough (though it's much higher eg than a lunatic breaking into your car to abduct your children at the petrol station)

CorsicaDreaming · 25/02/2023 23:52

@Rellywobble - this was in France. Only 22C.
Most of July was 22C or well above in the UK last year. The RSPCA run campaigns about not even leaving dogs in hot cars because of how quickly they heat up. If this mum is doing it now, I doubt she will think "oh it's the summer, better stop now"

Don't tell people to "get a grip" when you don't know what you're talking about...

metro.co.uk/2022/07/23/baby-dies-in-hot-car-after-dad-forgets-to-drop-them-off-at-nursery-17056338/

Pallisers · 25/02/2023 23:37

parents don’t watch their child every single minute at home

Yeah they kind of do. If your 18 month old is mobile and interested in everything then you either corral her in a place she can't do any harm or you watch her.

I find it funny that people on MN think it fine that a baby could cry for 15 minutes and that is fine if mum needed to run to the pharmacy but if you suggested sleep training, you'd be the devil incarnate

hmrcwoes · 25/02/2023 23:35

GettingItOutThere · 25/02/2023 22:37

honestly no. never. I do not see the point when it takes 30 seconds to get them in and out the car and keep them safer with you?

Just lazy neglectful parent in the OP that you have seen

Could you explain what witchcraft you do to get a child in/out of a car in 30 seconds!?