Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think alcohol should be made illegal or drugs made legal?

119 replies

ineverforgot · 25/02/2023 19:44

I was on a training course recently and was told that alcohol is the biggest killer out of allll drugs. Also cocaine (which is now widely accepted) kills on average the same amount of people as heroin - note the prejudice differences between the two.

But my question is - someone has a few drinks = violence, aggression etc (not all obviously)

Someone smokes a joint = eats food, laughs, chills.

Now I'm not stupid, I know that they say that weed causes mental health issues. As does alcohol!! Also if someone has a mental health problem and smokes a lot of weed, then there's a problem as weed triggers the mental illness. However, weed doesn't cause the mental illness.

Much the same as alcohol.

So my questions are -

Number 1 - it is physically impossible to overdose on weed. Weed is not physically addictive. The opposite is true for alcohol.

  • cocaine and heroin kills the same amount of people - however a massive stigma related to heroin users. Why? Cocaine is cheap these days as sectioned into 'council' 'prop' etc.

Why don't the government make it all legal? All taxable?

OP posts:
raguragu · 25/02/2023 22:22

Whilst weed may not be addictive, it's generally smoked with tobacco. I don't need to explain what's wrong with thay

Its a gateway drug

JoonT · 25/02/2023 22:20

I absolutely hate alcohol. For me, it's the single most overrated thing in the world. Professor David Nutt said that if it were invented tomorrow, it would not only be illegal but would be classed alongside heroin. It's bad for your health, makes anxiety and depression worse, and turns mild people into screeching idiots or violent thugs. Countless lives have been ruined by this disgusting drug.

I would much, much rather make alcohol illegal, but have MDMA, ecstasy and mushrooms available in specialist shops. Obviously there should be warnings attached (no drug is harmless), but society would be vastly happier.

WandaWonder · 25/02/2023 22:14

I think the push should be more personal responsibility that seems to be eroding as time goes on

Some people can have a few glasse of wine/beer occasionally with no issues other people cannot.

Or whatever if people have issues with whatever they are taking then they need to address this and yes there is the full on addicted heroin users, I am speaking of the more average users like the people who think the music is so bad at music festivals or their friends are so boring they need party drugs to enjoy themselves

Quveas · 25/02/2023 22:12

Prohibition - of anything - has never worked and still doesn't. All it does is put the profits in the hands of criminals. Always has. Always will. We need more rational and sensible methods of managing the intake of drugs, whatever poison people choose.

ohjeesus · 25/02/2023 22:08

Ps im my opinion weed triggers mental illness quicker than alcohol

ohjeesus · 25/02/2023 22:05

My son smashed up the house smoking weed, my daughter ended up in all sorts of trouble, paranoid and unstable..... alcohol isnt great but give me that any day of the week

Hope551 · 25/02/2023 22:02

Yes alcohol is pretty much as bad a drug as any. You leave someone withdrawing from heroin in a room, come back next day they are alive... alcohol they are dead.

I knew a guy who died from a seizure from not topping up with alcohol enough :/

Problem is society thinks it's normal. Government gain a lot of money from it. Besides they tried banning it once and people started making it illegally and it ended up very lethal and a lot of people died and cant remember the history but it was an utter disaster.

Needs to be more moderated perhaps, more education. Not sure as to the solution. But it kills so many people, and long term health issues is horrendous. In my 20's I was a party goer binge drinker... it gave me fatty liver 😬 all fixed now 😅 but I don't touch it anymore.

Indigoshift · 25/02/2023 21:58

ohjeesus · 25/02/2023 21:53

As a mother of two kids now both in their 20's id prefer them to drink than smoke weed! Seen them both smoking weed they turned into monsters, both more likable drunk

See I had the opposite with my ex husband.
That is the issue I guess people react differently.

ohjeesus · 25/02/2023 21:53

As a mother of two kids now both in their 20's id prefer them to drink than smoke weed! Seen them both smoking weed they turned into monsters, both more likable drunk

Mac9999 · 25/02/2023 21:46

Againstmachine · 25/02/2023 19:47

Alcohol is going to the biggest killer as it's most widely available.

If coke and heroin were as available they would kill plenty more.

This! YABVU

Lovetotravel123 · 25/02/2023 21:36

The research by Professor Nutt supports this idea. There is also a really interesting book on the drug side of things called Chasing the Scream by Johann Hari. People mostly just don’t want to give up alcohol so ignore the research.

Clarissa111 · 25/02/2023 21:21

Has the op got any personal experience of drugs/alcohism? Especially drug induced psychosis?

I have in all 3. Family members.

And weed being seen as a soft drug is so wrong. It can cause mental health issues. And is a gateway to harder drugs.

Alcohol is a drug yes. And I have seen alcohism in a close family member. It killed him in the end. Although was dry, the health issues couldn't be reversed.
But Alcohol is used by most. And most are ok with it.
I drink. I wouldnt touch even weed from what I've lived with my family.

Hawkins003 · 25/02/2023 21:20

So basically alcohol is considered the most harmful to society, but due to e.g. £, and the e.g. Prohibition era, it's not likely to be going down the drains. ?

Jobalons · 25/02/2023 21:18

If you want to smoke weed in your home I have no issue, but what I have an issue is the smell and the antisocial behaviours it brings to my neighbour hood, two wrongs don't make a right.

I don't take drugs never have and drink only on special occasions sorry I don't need a crutch to enjoy myself.

Smoking joints bloody well stink out your neighbours, disgusting habit. My neighbours drinks on moderation never affects me but the scruffy junky I had renting next door stunk my house out with week and brought all manner of issues to the street.

HorseyMel · 25/02/2023 21:11

Iam12andThisIsDeep

Rosebel · 25/02/2023 21:11

Anyone who thinks heroin should be legalised has never seen an addict. Or seen an addict withdrawing from heroin.
Very few herion or cocaine users begin on those drugs. They begin on weed and move up.
There are enough problems with alcohol let's not increase the problems by making drugs legal too.

theworldhasgoneinsane · 25/02/2023 21:11

Balloonsandroses · 25/02/2023 20:30

@ineverforgot I think you’re reading that link wrong. Cannabis use increases incidence of psychosis in those who are genetically susceptible anyway, I can’t see anywhere that it says they’d inevitably have developed psychosis with or without cannabis exposure.

Yes exactly this. I don't think OP gets what the article is saying

strivingtosucceed · 25/02/2023 21:10

I hate the smell of weed and the fact that largely you have no choice but to inhale it when people smoke around you, at least other drugs have the decency to only affect the people taking them. It's also obviously not as bad as Class A drugs but there are obvious links to mental illness, especially when starting young. I don't think it should be legal, vapes are horrendous for your health and now so many kids are doing it because they think it's cool and "healthier than cigarettes".

Realistically though, there's a very big difference between heroin, cocaine (and other drugs) and alcohol. The fact that many are highly addictive means that people who are curious but would never have made the effort/taken the risk to do it illegaly could easily take it once and be hooked. Look at the downward spiral people on meth go on after just one hit. In fact there was a big think about weed being laced by harder drugs and people becoming addicted to it that way.

RancidOldHag · 25/02/2023 21:08

People who are blase about the effects of cannabis on MH are probably thinking of the sort of weed that was around in the 60/70/80s. Which is hard to come by these days. The damage done since skunk drove out the less harmful forms of weed is immense.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 25/02/2023 21:05

Weed is vile!! The stench of it is awful and can affect so many neighbours who have to sit in their homes and smell it. Alcohol doesn't do the same.

Weed is as immoral in use as other drugs, given the slave trade and abuse it is linked to. Users of Weed deserve to be in prison for being complicit to this abuse.

Legalising may remove that, but ugh, imagine the stink around estates!! It's bad enough now 🤢

AlbertaWildRose · 25/02/2023 21:02

I live in Canada, and here marijuana is legal. It is also legal in some US states.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 25/02/2023 21:02

I can only speak for myself but one toke of a joint turns me into a gibbering, paranoid wreck with an overwhelming sense of Doom. Horrible stuff. I have friends who work in mental health who have seen first hand the damage it does. Surely it's OK for some people but it really isn't as harmless as people like to make.
According to people who know me, I'm pleasant enough after a drink, I don't drink to excess or to the point of a hangover.
Now mushrooms however I did have a fabulous experience on, but then I know people who had a bad time on them.
Not sure what my point is but the whole drugs and alcohol thing is a very complex issue.
I do hate the way supermarkets have the booze offers right as you go in- you should have to get to the end of the supermarket to see it so that people trying to abstain aren't tempted, same as with cigarettes.
But then I also support a ban on advertising for gambling and alcohol.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 25/02/2023 21:01

Erm, However, weed doesn't cause the mental illness.

No, actually, it can be a factor in the development of mental illness.

Weed is not physically addictive. - based on what?

I actually in favour of everything being legal, so it is safer to use and obtain and contributes to the tax base. I dont think it would cause more addiction problems, but would solve a lot of other issues. But I am sick of hearing marijuana downplayed - some people may use it perfectly fine, others will not be able to.

TwoMonthsOff · 25/02/2023 20:59

Can you imagine how the French would react
‘you can’t make champagne anymore’

Suzi888 · 25/02/2023 20:58

theworldhasgoneinsane · 25/02/2023 20:09

@ineverforgot 'the psychosis would have happened anyway'

What are you basing this on and how would you know?

^ This

It simply isn’t true. Alcohol is damaging but I don’t think you can compare it to heroin….