Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think is meant by 'overprotective?'

155 replies

Smugglers · 25/02/2023 19:00

I had mental health problems at 18 - long story as to the cause - but my mum one day thought this was a result of her having been overprotective as a parent. I wish I'd questioned her more on what exactly she meant by this now - as she seemed to see this as the root cause of all my difficulties.

Anyway , when I was on holiday aged 13 my mum coerced me harshly into a friendship with another kid at the hotel - "your father and I want you to make friends". This frankly made me feel shit. When I mentioned this to my Dad year later - he said she was trying to protect me. I was surprised as I thought it's not 'protecting' a child surely if you push them into a relationship they don't want? I would say quite the opposite - surely it's exposing them to a bad situation? Again I didn't question this at the time but has anyone got any thoughts on this?

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 26/02/2023 07:25

When I was 20 - when my friend was with me in her car - mum was giving us both a lift to an evening class - she said she had to take the car to the garage as they car had a headache' I mean wtf?! We were 20!!

Sorry I don't get this at all. You and your friend at 20 were getting a lift from your mum, your mum was taking her own car to the garage, the way she described it=over protective?!

Nimbostratus100 · 26/02/2023 07:23

donttellmehesalive · 26/02/2023 07:19

This one isolated incident doesn't tell us enough about them op. Who amongst us can say we have got every decision right with our kids? When they get to adulthood, most of our kids will remember one thing - probably more than one thing - we got wrong.

exactly - one of the worst things we can do for our children is be "perfect" parents! most of us do our best, and our children grow up to recognise that, and the many mistakes we make along the way are all just part of a happy, balanced family life

donttellmehesalive · 26/02/2023 07:22

And if she wanted you to go to play with the other kids so she could have a break, have half an hour to herself, or to talk to your dad or to enjoy a cocktail, or just looked at the other kids playing and thought you might enjoy it if you tried it, that in itself doesn't make her a bad parent.

TheaBrandt · 26/02/2023 07:22

The nursery rhymes and the comment about the car?! If those are the worst things your mum has done she’s doing pretty well I think.

Smugglers · 26/02/2023 07:21

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/02/2023 07:17

Overprotective could mean interfering too much in the child's choices. For example forcing a 13 year old to "play" with a "friend" rather than leaving them in peace.

Many overprotective parents do it for selfish reasons, be that because they like to control, or because it's a way to deal with their own anxieties, or because they want their children to remain dependent on them. It's not good parenting

Thank you. I think you're absolutely spot on

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 26/02/2023 07:20

God I hope my children when adults don’t look back over their entire childhoods and pick out events they didn’t like to beat me over the head with. Are you 100% perfect all the time and never make the wrong call? Most parents are doing their best

donttellmehesalive · 26/02/2023 07:19

This one isolated incident doesn't tell us enough about them op. Who amongst us can say we have got every decision right with our kids? When they get to adulthood, most of our kids will remember one thing - probably more than one thing - we got wrong.

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/02/2023 07:17

Overprotective could mean interfering too much in the child's choices. For example forcing a 13 year old to "play" with a "friend" rather than leaving them in peace.

Many overprotective parents do it for selfish reasons, be that because they like to control, or because it's a way to deal with their own anxieties, or because they want their children to remain dependent on them. It's not good parenting

donttellmehesalive · 26/02/2023 07:16

MessyJ · 26/02/2023 07:09

It sound like they are using the world wrong. Maybe they just use ‘overprotective’ as a way to excuse their behaviour?

I am wondering whether they were indeed overprotective just because op remembers the one time she was pushed to leave her comfort zone so acutely.

Anaemiafog · 26/02/2023 07:16

Did your mum have overprotective parents? Maybe she thought she was attempting to ensure this didn’t happen to you.

donttellmehesalive · 26/02/2023 07:13

To me, overprotective means not allowing or encouraging a child to take risks or leave their comfort zone. It means removing all obstacles from their path, never allowing them to experience - or learn from - age-appropriate worries and struggles, not allowing them to solve problems for themselves, leaping to their defence at all times instead of trusting them to manage a situation.

I'm sure parents who do this have the best intentions but it often results in children who can't cope with challenge effectively, who have no resilience or faith in their own abilities.

The holiday friendship and other things you highlight don't seem like big deals to me though. All parents are just muddling along and trying to do their best, sometimes imperfect, sometimes getting things wrong despite best intentions.

Smugglers · 26/02/2023 07:12

MessyJ · 26/02/2023 07:09

It sound like they are using the world wrong. Maybe they just use ‘overprotective’ as a way to excuse their behaviour?

Yes. I've often wondered exactly this

OP posts:
Swiftswatch · 26/02/2023 07:11

It sound like you blame your mother far too much for anything wrong with your life as an adult.
These are really not stand out examples of awful, damaging parenting and yet you clearly can’t let them go.

MessyJ · 26/02/2023 07:09

It sound like they are using the world wrong. Maybe they just use ‘overprotective’ as a way to excuse their behaviour?

Nimbostratus100 · 26/02/2023 07:02

It is difficult for me to see here anything that is seriously damaging, is there a big drip feed coming?

LolaSmiles · 26/02/2023 07:00

Overprotective to me is someone who is overbearingly worried about small things in daily life and is reluctant to allow age-appropriate independence due to a fear of what would happen. Eg. Not allowing their 4 year old go play supervised in a ln empty play area, insisting their teenager can't get the bus or walk more than 2 houses away.

There's a related behaviour where an adult might do the above, but for control/power, to feel like they're still wanted or needed, or to have the child remain dependent on them as they like the control. Eg Refusing to allow age-appropriate grooming, babying the child, telling the child they can't go somewhere or be friends with someone one day but when it suits the adult it's fine.

gettingalifttothestation · 26/02/2023 06:54

Dwelling on the past is pointless. You need to focus on the future

PuttingDownRoots · 26/02/2023 06:49

Nursery rhymes etc sound like infantalising rather than overprotective (similar threass on MN about not being allowed to take a bus at 15)- not being able to accept you aren't a small kid

Overprotective is is never letting the child out of their sight. Like shadowing around a quiet playpark at 5, or driving a 13yo to school when its half a mile walk... Or tracking their moves constantly by phone.

Both can be damaging.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 26/02/2023 06:41

Maybe your father meant "overprotective" in that your mother was choosing your friend instead of letting you go out and make friends on your own -- as most teenagers would.

WombatsAndGumTrees · 26/02/2023 06:15

JudgeRudy · 26/02/2023 03:05

Yes, thats exactly as I'd see it. Often someone who is over protective says they're doing it for the other person but it often serves a more sinister purpose. It makes the 'carer' feel powerful because you must obey them because you need them.

Or because the carer has an anxiety disorder about something happening to you in the big bad world.

WombatsAndGumTrees · 26/02/2023 06:14

Over protective to me means not allowing your children to take calculated risks that might be important to their development, shielding them from the world beyond what is fair and reasonable, not allowing them to fail.

My parents were crazy overprotective to the point it socially isolated me.

JudgeRudy · 26/02/2023 03:05

OnaBegonia · 25/02/2023 19:17

Overprotective to me is not encouraging independence and allowing a child to make choices and assess risk.

Yes, thats exactly as I'd see it. Often someone who is over protective says they're doing it for the other person but it often serves a more sinister purpose. It makes the 'carer' feel powerful because you must obey them because you need them.

Smugglers · 26/02/2023 02:45

LIZS · 25/02/2023 22:00

Did your dm have mh issues of her own?

Yes

OP posts:
LIZS · 25/02/2023 22:00

Did your dm have mh issues of her own?

Smugglers · 25/02/2023 19:28

LIZS · 25/02/2023 19:26

I doubt one holiday friendship had that effect on its own. Do you have other examples?

She played nursery rhymes at my 10th birthday

When I was 20 - when my friend was with me in her car - mum was giving us both a lift to an evening class - she said she had to take the car to the garage as they car had a headache' I mean wtf?! We were 20!!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread