Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all inclusive holidays worth it?

266 replies

Blueisthecolour1 · 25/02/2023 18:03

Just throwing it out there - I got excited and went online to book an all-inclusive holiday in Corfu next May half-term. Spent ages looking at various hotels - it's a once in a decade thing, for us so a really one-off opportunity. BUT:

Can't find many AI hotels that offer a family room with adequate space or number of rooms. Don't want to spend thousands of pounds to sleep in the same room as my two children for a week (ages 9 and 5.) I've got a better set up at home - i.e. at least one or two doors between me and them at bedtime!

Trip Advisor reviews - they really freak me out. Especially as every hotel has bad ones it would seem, which is to be expected I suppose however, a pattern of comments around the buffet-type food halls which in general, people seem to dislike after day 3 - one person describing them as cattle-sheds! Lots of complaints in general about food being under-cooked, and lots of queuing for the buffet. Clearly, you get great reviews as well but there does seem to be a theme to some of the concerns.

Lots of reviews complaining about other people - their mess, their noise, again, the queuing and overcrowding of certain favourite areas, like splash parks/play areas.

For the money, is it worth it? I know there's always a mix of opinion on these things but themes do seem to crop up with the all-inclusive topic and it's made me nervous about booking something. Some of them seem absolutely huge in terms of their layout as well - does it get a bit tedious having to make the same journey to get a bite to eat in the morning with young children, then perhaps queuing for ages to get to the buffet table? Then again at lunch, and again at dinner - some people seem to wait ages to get seated at mealtimes by which time the kids are grumpy, overtired, fed up.

I looked on Booking.com to see what properties are available for the location we're interested in and you can get a lovely 3 or four bedroom flat right by the beach for half the price - self-catering obviously. But no kid's clubs, no fun splash park, and all the easy wonders of an all-inclusive environment - IF that's what it is!!! I just don't know!

What are other's experiences opinions on this?

OP posts:
CaptainJackSparrow85 · 04/08/2023 10:14

I’m sure the Ikos resorts are lovely but aren’t they about £10k for 4 people sharing a room in summer holidays?!

Fundays12 · 04/08/2023 09:28

I think from the perspective of lots of ice cream and drinks included in the price they are handy though I don't think necessarily cheaper now. I think unless you are a heavy drinker which we are not they are not worth the money and the food can be boring and lack taste.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 04/08/2023 09:23

For me, the main benefit is removing the mental load of planning what's going to be eaten by who when.

KatharinaRosalie · 04/08/2023 07:55

The food isn't as good as good restaurant's but the budget they provide it on is small - I've just booked a 5 ai for £700 per head including flights & private transfers, I need to be realistic what that can provide, it's not going to be Michelin starred food at the savoy!*

There are AIs with Michelin starred food as well, but yes those would be more than 700.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 07:50

Lincslady53 · 04/08/2023 07:39

I have been on 2 AI holidays. 1 in Spain for adults only, good hotel. Good food but overcrowded pool area. The other. Nana Beach (now Nana Golden Beach) in Crete was v good for families. Several pools, 2 large buffet restaurants, and in a good location. I read a TA review of a hotel we have just been to (not AI) complaining that the food didn't cater fir English tastes. This was in Spain, with a variety of nationalities, and we had found the food good. So, don't take too much notice about reviews, as long as the majority are ok, and you have a positive attitude, I am sure you will find what you want. I think th at although TA is very useful, it has turned loads of people into Hotel inspectors, looking for faults instead of enjoying their holiday.

Ha! Yes, the bad reviews of the AI place that we stayed in Spain mostly complained that there were too many Spanish people and that the restaurant had too much Spanish food instead of catering to British tastes. That was enough to persuade me to book it tbh!Grin

Roselilly36 · 04/08/2023 07:47

Pleased IKOS is getting some love. We loved AI when our children were little, took all the stress any from meal times, if they didn’t want lunch they could snack, get an ice cream a soft drink. They really enjoyed those holidays, with kids clubs, sports etc. when they got older we booked villas with private pool and ate most meals out. I am sure you will love it, enjoy your holiday.

gogomoto · 04/08/2023 07:45

Another you get what you pay for comment!

For the most part they offer value for money if your requirements are pool, entertainment and plenty of food washed down with plenty of drink, even more basic hotels. At the more expensive end you get a choice of hotels, multiple pools, entertainment value choice etc - and whatever star it will be less than eating out 3 meals a day if that would be the alternative (I'm not one for cooking on holiday!)

The food isn't as good as good restaurant's but the budget they provide it on is small - I've just booked a 5* ai for £700 per head including flights & private transfers, I need to be realistic what that can provide, it's not going to be Michelin starred food at the savoy!

Lincslady53 · 04/08/2023 07:39

I have been on 2 AI holidays. 1 in Spain for adults only, good hotel. Good food but overcrowded pool area. The other. Nana Beach (now Nana Golden Beach) in Crete was v good for families. Several pools, 2 large buffet restaurants, and in a good location. I read a TA review of a hotel we have just been to (not AI) complaining that the food didn't cater fir English tastes. This was in Spain, with a variety of nationalities, and we had found the food good. So, don't take too much notice about reviews, as long as the majority are ok, and you have a positive attitude, I am sure you will find what you want. I think th at although TA is very useful, it has turned loads of people into Hotel inspectors, looking for faults instead of enjoying their holiday.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/08/2023 07:37

Our experience of AI has always been excellent BUT to some extent I think you get what you pay for and we are fortunate enough to be able to pay a bit more than the minimum. If I was on a very tight budget, I wouldn't go AI personally.

I also spend hours researching the destination and hotel before booking, and I am extremely fussy about reviews and won't even look at anywhere rated less than around 4.5 on Trip Advisor. The place we're going this year has well over 10,000 reviews and less than 80 of them are 1 or 2 stars while 97% have 4 or 5 stars (mostly 5). That gives me confidence but I tend to read through every single bad or mediocre review anyway to see what patterns emerge. In the case of the place where we're going this year, the main complaint seems to be patchy Internet coverage which isn't really a massive concern for me because we don't spend a lot of time online when we're on holiday anyway. Even the bad ones are pretty positive about the food, cleanliness etc, so overall, I reckon it will be OK. I have ruled out many hotels over the years because of bad reviews though... even when it's only a minority complaining, there is sometimes a pattern that I don't want to risk ignoring. Your descriptions from the reviews of the hotel that you are looking at would be raising red flags for me.

Whether AI is the right option for you will also depend on what you want from your holiday. I have never minded sharing a room with my dc in the slightest - we co-slept for years in any case! - but the idea of self-catering on holiday is my worst nightmare and I absolutely wouldn't contemplate it. Other people will have different priorities so it's important to know what you want. We like the ease and relaxed vibe of good AI hotels, being able to get drinks and snacks etc without worrying about cost. We usually choose places with more than 1 dining option - the one we're going to this year has 4 a la carte restaurants that we can use once each week as part of the AI package alongside the main buffet one, so there is some variety. We also don't stay in the AI resort all day and we will likely eat a couple of meals out when we travel further - we will get a "packed lunch" from the hotel on those days but find local restaurants for dinner. Again, it helps when the budget is not so tight that you feel like you have to eat in the hotel every night because it's already paid for...I would find that too restrictive personally, because I don't go on holiday to just sit in a resort all day!

DivineLillith · 04/08/2023 07:27

I don’t like using buffets because of how grim some peoples habits are. I did see the worst clip of buffet grossness on SM recently of a guy tasting sauce using the ladle and putting it straight back in to the pot.

So that’s not strictly AI.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 04/08/2023 07:06

We did AI for the first time this year, with two kids (3 and 1) and I’ll admit to having been a bit snobby about AI in my pre-parent life. But it was a revelation with young children. The buffet was really great - I hate taking my children to traditional restaurants because my youngest won’t wait nicely for food and my oldest decides he hates something between ordering and its arrival at the table.

We were able to travel outside school holidays and get somewhere 5* that would have been really pricey in school holidays though.

TicketEnforcement · 04/08/2023 07:06

I recommend Olympic Lagoon Hotel Phaphos the AI food choice is amazing & excellent quality
More than one restaurant
Next to beach
30 mins walk to the town

Jodh · 04/08/2023 06:40

What’s the name of the hotel please?

maddy68 · 28/02/2023 19:34

I hate an AI. I live wandering round and finding a nice restaurant. Waiter service. Not queing for a buffet the greed too (me included !)

I honestly don't think it's that much cheaper either. Provided you budget !

FoodieToo · 28/02/2023 19:12

Ikos is wonderful for AI and avoids almost all the concerns that people have . Beautiful food in various a la carte restaurants . Just amazing !
You really need to go top end for AI in my opinion.

Umbrio · 28/02/2023 18:52

Apollonia1 · 28/02/2023 08:15

Hi @Umbrio , do you mind saying the name of the small modern hotel in Greece with the great breakfasts?

I'll pm you.

Funkyslippers · 28/02/2023 14:27

Aqualand ismn Corfu is great, 1 bed apartments right next to a waterpark. We used to go for the first and last hour of the day when it's quiet. This year though we're going to Barut B Suites in Turkey but as the kids are older we're going for 2 X 1 bedroom apartments. A bit of privacy for everyone! Great reviews too. Ticked every box for us

GettingStuffed · 28/02/2023 13:09

I wouldn't do all inclusive in Greece , they kill local communities as they tend not to use local labour, except for the very low paid staff and take trade away from the bars & restaurants that were set up when most people went B&B or self-catering.

We've done AI in Tunisia and the DR both of these were set up as AI from the start so haven't damaged local infrastructure.

Next year we're looking at a big family holiday AI in either Mexico or the DR and they're cheaper than the Med

Cornelious2011 · 28/02/2023 12:40

We did several of the holiday villages when dc was younger. Rhodes and menorca were fab. Menorca we had a 1 bed apartment. When dc are small it's such an easy holiday. Kids clubs, several pools, several restaurants, night entertainment (that ends at 11.30 so not noisy).

Nolongera · 28/02/2023 12:34

Love AI in Spain, bingo, chips, kids club and karaoke, but not in Greece, would rather have a "normal" holiday.

Wish I had discovered Greece sooner.

Mayonaiseislife · 28/02/2023 12:04

We really love them, family of 5 with 3 young DCs.

We dont drink alot of alcohol but for the food, snacks and general convenience of it we really enjoy them.

I must note we only book 4 or 5 star. I look for ones that have a la carte restaurants also so its mixed up a bit and we probably eat out around 2 - 3 times also.

Have a look at the First Choice holiday Villages, we went to them Pre covid, specifically the cyprus one and absolutely loved it. The 1 bed apartments in the fishing village part are huge.

LlynTegid · 28/02/2023 11:23

Would never do one myself, but I can understand the attraction of never having to find somewhere else to eat and knowing your spend with certainty.

budgiegirl · 28/02/2023 11:08

I found they were particularly good when I had teenage boys with their constant need for food. At an AI hotel they could graze, drink and eat ice cream all day (and still make the most of restaurant).
Plus they are entertained by wall to wall sports and activities

We've done a mix of all-inclusive and villa/apartment self catering over the years. On the whole, we found that self-catering worked best when the kids were younger, with breakfast and lunch in, then evening meal out. And days just pottering about on the beach. But our children were alway fairly easy to take out for dinner, even as small children. Then we could sit by the pool/on the balcony with a glass of wine while the kids slept later in the evening.

But once they were teenagers, and ate everything in sight, then all-inclusive was definitely the way to go.

DuvetDownn · 28/02/2023 10:56

I like them
and only pick ones with a few different restaurants. We like to go out every other day and have a lunch out.
I love being able to try different cocktails and if I’ve been on a big day out can just have a quick meal at the buffet rather than paying out for a meal.

MissAmbrosia · 28/02/2023 10:22

Much prefer S/C as I am not a huge one for breakfast and hate having to be up and dressed. Would rather mooch about on a terrace with a coffee. On holidays normally we would have an "out" day with sight seeing and nice lunch and then come back and chill out. Or a beach/pool day and then get showered and go out to eat. I don't ever do much cooking - maybe if we picked something up nice from the market / bit of a BBQ sort of thing. Or get takeaway. The idea of a buffet fills me with horror. I want to be waited on and choose from a menu. When dd was younger and wanted all the pools and entertainment we did Eurocamp - 2 bed 2 bath mobiles with large terrace and air conditioning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread