Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL for lunch tomorrow?

337 replies

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 15:23

I will say I do like my MIL generally. PIL died about 8 months ago so I feel mean about resenting her coming for Sunday lunch - but this will be the 5th time since Christmas. Everytime we have a free Sunday DH invites her over. Dh has said he will cook so really I have nothing to worry about. Dd and I were looking forward to a chill day tomorrow though. I'm just a bit sick of it. We are also quite skint - all PILs assets went to MIL but she never brings anything not even a bottle of wine.

Just a bit bored with it tbh.

OP posts:
TheHillsAreAliveWithTheSoundOfMystery · 25/02/2023 17:15

Pizza for lunch for an 80 year old lol.

What's wrong with pizza? @girlfriend44 ageist much?

OP include her a bit more, ask her what she's been watching and find something you and DD can watch with her while DH cooks, it could become a regular thing that you all enjoy together.

Sunsetintheeast · 25/02/2023 17:13

Liorae · 25/02/2023 15:59

You expect a widow in her 80s to pay for her son's family for lunch? Seriously?

Some old folk are fucking minted, you do know that right?

Liorae · 25/02/2023 17:12

Blossomtoes · 25/02/2023 17:07

Why not? If we have Sunday lunch out with our adult kids we always pay. She’s clearly got more money than they have.

There is nothing clear about that at all. Surprisingly for Mumsnet, the dil has provided no details of her mils finances except that she alone inherited from her husband. That could be 100 quid for all we know.

Movinghouseatlast · 25/02/2023 17:11

Switch it round and put yourself in her shoes. Imagine you are a widow and grieving. Imagine your daughters husband in your case really not wanting you round. How would you feel do you think?

Nimo12 · 25/02/2023 17:11

Oh my god. I'd honestly be furious if my partner was feeling resentful of my mum coming over once a week for Sunday dinner, less than a year since her husband died. And I'd never expect her to "bring something".

Moveoverdarlin · 25/02/2023 17:08

Get tomorrow out of the way and say to your husband that can you want to keep the next 5 or 6 Sundays free as with his Mum and your brother it’s been a bit much.

AngelinaFibres · 25/02/2023 17:08

Sunday is a difficult day when you are alone / single/ divorced/ bereaved. I hated Sundays when I was a single parent. People are doing family stuff that you don't want to invade but if you go out there are 'happy' families everywhere and it just emphasises what you have lost. My mother didn't really get it but when my father died 6 years ago she realised how awfully lonely Sunday feels and apologised for not being kinder ( my children were young and noisy and her cats hated our visits so they didnt happen that often) I only live up the road from her now and she came for lots and lots of Sundays in the beginning.She just wanted a distraction . Once Monday came she was off and out again with her groups and friends. That may be you one day Op . If you have sons their wives may feel the same about you.

Sunsetintheeast · 25/02/2023 17:07

Bernadinetta · 25/02/2023 15:46

So what if she would hate it? It’s your house? If you want to chill in your PJs and watch a film then do it, whether she’s there or not. Obviously she doesn’t have to wear her PJs but she could watch a film with you or she could sit in kitchen and chat to DH while he cooks.

I agree, she falls in with family life!

my DMum and FIL are on their own and although I make a bit of effort if they come, it’s more a self help situation! My DC make cups of tea and help a bit, but otherwise it’s take us as you find us.

Gymnopedie · 25/02/2023 17:07

It doesn't help that my brother has been extremely ill so I've been looking after him during the week.

OP nobody has so far picked you up on this. If the reason you're so knackered and want a leisurely Sunday is because your time is taken up by looking after your brother, then yes YABveryU. Why don't you cut down on those responsibilities rather than putting it all on an 80yo recent widow?

However I don't think it would be unreasonable of you to try to avoid it becoming every other Sunday for evermore. That really limits what you can do with the DCs, not just in your own house but if you wanted to take them out somewhere too.

justasking111 · 25/02/2023 17:07

@Moonphantom is DH an only child?

Blossomtoes · 25/02/2023 17:07

Liorae · 25/02/2023 15:59

You expect a widow in her 80s to pay for her son's family for lunch? Seriously?

Why not? If we have Sunday lunch out with our adult kids we always pay. She’s clearly got more money than they have.

Passthechocolatesplease · 25/02/2023 17:06

It seems to be working out as roughly every other week OP so you do have some free weekends, but I can see you not wanting to get into too much of a routine, that can be a danger as it’s hard to change things later, perhaps slowly just stretch the gaps apart a little.
it is lovely though that your OH is caring for his Mum she will be feeling very alone.
I’m not sure about joining in clubs, if you’ve never done that she’s unlikely to want start now.
To be honest I wouldn’t have expected my Mum to bring anything to contribute a meal.
I think it’s completely selfish for posters on here to suggest you virtually leave her to your OH, how would that make her feel, she’s a human being and she’s grieving the last thing she needs is to made to feel like a burden.
Would it be possible to occasionally go out for meal on a Saturday, that would leave you free for your Sunday chill out time.

Pottedpalm · 25/02/2023 17:05

Triffid1 · 25/02/2023 17:01

You need to.cbamge the dynamic. She's now .spending.more time with you all as she is lonely. Fine. But the dynamic.cant stay the same. Start to introduce the concept of her being there but as a member of the family and not a guest. So.sure, have a nice lunch but everyone can wander off after to do whatever they like. You and dd can go upstairs and watch TV on a computer or tablet or disappear for a walk or whatever.

Spot on. She doesn’t need to be guest. She is a family member there for lunch. Maybe she would be happy to sit with a cup of tea and have family buzzing round the house. Great company. She must feel very lonely.

AtleastitsnotMonday · 25/02/2023 17:03

No that really wasn't what I was saying

Liorae · 25/02/2023 17:02

AtleastitsnotMonday · 25/02/2023 16:59

She's lonely. It's sad. I don't think you've said how long she stays. If she lives near buy could you just say "we'll be eating at 6 this week, shall we pick you up at 3?"
Or when dh invites her say "we're off out at 3 we could drop you home on the way to x'

Does MIL now money's tight? She might offer to contribute more if she realises. Just drop a few hints.
"I've heard the George and Dragon do a great roast, we'll have to get saving to afford it though".
"We won't be having a roast this week, the price of the food shop is going through the roof so we're really having to tighten our belts".

Also, i think you have to think of her a bit differently now she's coming more often. I make more effort for people who only come once or twice a year. The more people come, the less showy I get. You really don't need to change your plans. She has become a closer member of extended family, so think of her as that. Wear what you like, eat what you would normally, her preference might be a roast but that won't be the only thing she'd enjoy. Watch Netflix, don't most elderly people fall asleep after a roast anyway?

Just be honest and hang a sign on your front door saying "hand over the inheritance before we feed you again".

Pottedpalm · 25/02/2023 17:01

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 25/02/2023 15:39

In fact op doesn't even have to be there.
If I wer her I'd book a night with a close friend or a hotel with my daughter. Places like Mal Maison do a girls night in package etc.
Once op is not there the lunches every Sunday would soon whittle away I imagine.

OP says money is tight, a trip to Malmaison? Really?

Triffid1 · 25/02/2023 17:01

You need to.cbamge the dynamic. She's now .spending.more time with you all as she is lonely. Fine. But the dynamic.cant stay the same. Start to introduce the concept of her being there but as a member of the family and not a guest. So.sure, have a nice lunch but everyone can wander off after to do whatever they like. You and dd can go upstairs and watch TV on a computer or tablet or disappear for a walk or whatever.

Pandorapitstop · 25/02/2023 17:00

Very odd to go to someone’s house for lunch and not take anything, eg a bottle of wine or flowers, or to offer to make pudding for example and to take along.

Puppers · 25/02/2023 17:00

Having her round for a meal a couple of times a month to support her while she acclimatises to the hugely traumatic and life changing experience of losing her spouse is really not a big ask of close family. I'd be absolutely gutted if my DH couldn't put his desire to watch Netflix in his PJs to one side for a few hours every fortnight to accommodate this for my mum. It would be very out of keeping with the generous and caring spirit I love him for as well.

It's important that you have private down time but unless you are extremely busy (unusually so) then there's no reason you can't find a bit of time to support MIL in this way and carve out time for yourself every weekend.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 25/02/2023 17:00

Jesus, have some compassion,it's only been 8 months! Imagine if you lost your dh,actually think about it properly.

AtleastitsnotMonday · 25/02/2023 16:59

She's lonely. It's sad. I don't think you've said how long she stays. If she lives near buy could you just say "we'll be eating at 6 this week, shall we pick you up at 3?"
Or when dh invites her say "we're off out at 3 we could drop you home on the way to x'

Does MIL now money's tight? She might offer to contribute more if she realises. Just drop a few hints.
"I've heard the George and Dragon do a great roast, we'll have to get saving to afford it though".
"We won't be having a roast this week, the price of the food shop is going through the roof so we're really having to tighten our belts".

Also, i think you have to think of her a bit differently now she's coming more often. I make more effort for people who only come once or twice a year. The more people come, the less showy I get. You really don't need to change your plans. She has become a closer member of extended family, so think of her as that. Wear what you like, eat what you would normally, her preference might be a roast but that won't be the only thing she'd enjoy. Watch Netflix, don't most elderly people fall asleep after a roast anyway?

SealHouse · 25/02/2023 16:59

ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 25/02/2023 15:57

I would really resent my husband if he was as petty and heartless towards my widowed parent as you are OP. You mention money an awful lot too, and I would not be surprised if your MIL senses your graspy little hands waiting there. Poor woman.

Yes, the money thing struck me too. You sound nasty OP. Your poor MIL. Let's hope any future dil's treat you with a little more compassion.

Dishwashersaurous · 25/02/2023 16:59

And definitely crack on do baking etc. Do what you'd do if she wasn't there and just involve her ìn the conversation

Crunchymum · 25/02/2023 16:58

Given you get along okay and she isn't a horror I think it's actually pretty shit you begrudge her a fortnightly visit.

Does she stay all day? Can your DH to ask her to grab dessert or a bottle of wine? Can you arrange for some downtime on Saturday instead?

Weallhaveavoice · 25/02/2023 16:57

Think we all need a bit of family time alone.
No matter how much we get on with family I still feel more relaxed without visitors.
I totally get where you are coming from
You have every right to this especially as you visit during the week and your dh 3 times a week.

A compromise is needed
For every MIL Sunday visit there should be a weekend without MIL. Maybe it’s a once a month thing. Then. Everyone gets used to the new routine and isn’t constantly expecting Sunday at yours and youre not getting upset about it.